My favorite restaurant in Central PA hands down. I actually go through withdraws when I am away at school and don't get my Cowboy Crunch Fix. Speaking of that... The perfect burrito that has ever been created lives here. The Cowboy crunch starts off with a tortilla ( id recommend the jalapeno cheese) and then Cajun chicken, re-fried beans, rice, and barbecue sauce. Cheese is then added and melted on top. The typical toppings added on after that are lettuce, tomatoes, ranch, and crushed up tortilla chips. The burrito is then grilled to perfection and served. If you wanna add pico, verde, or their jalapeno feta salsa on top go for it. The atmosphere there is like hipsters paradise. Depending on your location you could either have records hanging on one wall and a giant buffalo head mounted on the next wall; or be sitting at a table that has a grass pattern printed on the table. You can also find some pretty cool less popular sodas. The employees are as strange as the decorations in the store, but I've never had a bad encounter with one. They always seem nice and give me advise on what I should get. Overall cant say anything bad about Neato at all. If you wanna send your tastebuds on a trip to flavortown and branch off from the typical chipotle burrito (I still love chipotle too) get a cowboy crunch and enjoy. read more

I have ordered here many times, often the order is incorrect in some way or the quality isn't consistent but I have never called in and complained. Tonight our order was made very incorrect, I called in and from the initial answer of the phone was met with attitude. When I tried to explain my burritos were incorrect I was told I was wrong and she was looking at the order. I tried to explain what was wrong, manager got on the phone and stated she mad the burritos and they were correct and I was wrong. I actually took my burritos back in and when they saw they were wrong I was told nothing can be done. ( no correctly made burrito, no refund, I was yelling at them at this point). I asked to speak to the manager, no luck, gave my phone number and requested a call, no luck. I will no longer support a business who treats a repeat customer so poorly. read more

Neato Burrito is pretty unique to the Harrisburg/Camp Hill area of PA it's a family owned chain that offers a great blend of unique large Burritos that are stuffed with great tasting ingredients! The places we visited in Lemoyne are always very clean and the staff are always pleasant and willing to answer your questions on the ingredients of your choice. I do recommend the Cowboy Crunch or the Gringo Authentico. Whatever you choose I think you will find their food delicious. read more

Neato Burrito - Mexican Near Me - New Cumberland, Pennsylvania

Food was great, service was terrible. They were not friendly whatsoever. We will not be coming back.

Food was horrible the heated up burrito was ice cold. Food did not taste fresh I won't be back horrible gave my husband an upset stomach.

Food is good , price is reasonable. Bring your hot sauces with you. There are no hot sauces out for customers. Staff friendly, facility is clean! We will be back. read more

This was neato for sure. We were in the area and saw the beautiful artwork so wanted to check this place out. The food was fresh and loved how varied the menu was. The service was great and restaurant super nice. Can't wait to try more of the grub here. read more

Neato Burrito - a close up of a bowl of food - Mexican Near Me - New Cumberland, Pennsylvania

There's nothing too crazy about this place's food. The bowl was solid but not packed with flavor (probably a more traditional-style way of cooking the chicken) and they have a good amount of things to throw in it. I don't love the pickled jalapenos and thought it was kinda funny that they would crumble chips on top. The ambiance is fun. From the outside, there's an intricate layer of graffiti that is draped over the entrance and the inside has a nice and clean industrial feel to it. For all of the lack of solid options in the area for a quick bite that isn't fast food, this might be one of your best bets. read more

Terrible! The food lacked any flavor. It's like they forgot to season the rice and beans. Also ordered a burrito with beans and cheese for my little guy and then they said it was a regular price and not a kid's meal. Wrong tortilla or something?? Ummm you can see how small it is in the photos... seriously? read more

Neato Burrito - My child's burrito compared to normal burrito but still charged full price and not as a kids burrito or kids meal. - Mexican Near Me - New Cumberland, Pennsylvania

The Cowboy Crunch is the real star of the show here, followed by my second favorite, "For Those About to Rock, We Cilantro". I don't see the need to try any other flavors besides those, though that doesn't seem to stop me. It's a fair portion, it's delicious, and the ingredients are quality. The decor is great and the music is fun. Free Parking is available in the lot right beside it. read more

Neato Burrito - X-mas decoration - Mexican Near Me - New Cumberland, Pennsylvania

This used to be outstanding. But the past year has been disappointing. The orders have been incorrect, the on line system has not worked. Even ordering in person has resulted in incorrect items (nasty orange cheese instead of pork) forgotten items, and no adjustment to the charge. Would not recommend this Neato Burrito. read more

Horrible customer service. I picked up my burrito and when I got home it literally had nothing on it except for chicken with literally a FEW tomatoes. I had paid for xtra cheese, pico de Gallo, and onions. So I called the restaurant and spoke with a manager named Heather who told me I was lying and I could bring my burrito in to show her but other than that there is nothing she can do. My husband and I live 15 minutes away and are regular customers there who have never made a complaint. Super disappointed in the burrito & the customer service. read more

Neato Burrito - a person holding a fork - Mexican Near Me - New Cumberland, Pennsylvania

Not for me, it's like subway for burritos is the best way I can describe it. It's super expensive but if money isn't an issue for you and you like to experiment with making a 5 pound burrito then you might like this place as I have met many who do and many who don't so I guess it's worth checking out for yourself. as far as the service went, it was overwhelming and I felt rushed but to be absolutely fair it was busy at the time. also you can't miss the place just look for the giant graffiti billboard of a building. read more

The food quality is very good but I struggle getting full portions of ingredients. Sometimes my burrito ends up looking more like an an egg roll. My burrito tech recently commented they were going to charge me for extra rice after I asked for more when most of the rice was still stuck in the scoop. read more

Absolute worst food let alone Mexican I have ever had. Got two cowboy crunches, chips and guac, and two sodas. Nothing was fresh, the guac was dark brown throughout, soda was flat. Can't believe they actually served us this. It was to go too so we didn't see any of it until we got home and it was too late. Honestly would rather have taco bell especially considering it was $32. Will never go back. Stick to Chipotle and avoid this place like the plague. read more

Love love love neato burrito! The cowboy crunch is so dang good!! Always have a good experience when I eat here.

The only disappointing thing about Neato Burrito is that it's not a national chain yet. Their cowboy crunch is the best burrito I've ever had and it's not even close. Always a must-visit place when back in Central PA! read more

This is a neat little restaurant. The nice part is that you get to have control over what gets tucked into your tortilla of choice. This New Cumberland location gets the prize for the best physical location of all of the Neato's. The other one's are small and are often filled to capacity at meal times so good luck getting a table. I do have a few complaints. 1) A lot of their food is lacking in spice - which might be a result of being in central PA where many people like their food to be mild and polite; 2) some of their staff have that smug "I'm too envio-artsy-liberal-retrohippy for the room" attitude that just makes some of us want to say "get over yourself"; 3) there's often a huge line at peak times which makes it a poor option if you have a limited amount of time for lunch; and 4) see item 1 - it really needs a kick other than from a bottle of hot sauce. read more

We liked it. We had the cowboy crunch and it was very good. Cool looking place. If you like to try new interesting places, this is the place for you. I couldn't finish my burrito and took it to work for lunch the new day. It saves well and tasted just as good the next day. The staff was nice. read more

The food I just got was absolutely terrible amongst a few other things like not getting asked which choice of meat I liked to a soggy quesadilla which I took home to cook myself in the oven I personally recommend eating here and the only reason I'm giving the two stars is because the building was cool. read more

A classic burrito used to be a staple in my diet at one time. I was excited to see Neato advertise a classic mission-style burrito. Growing up near San Francisco, my expectations were probably unreasonably high. I ordered the burrito of the day, which was a gringo authentico which had marinated flank steak. In my mind that means carne asada. I guess there is no grill here because it tasted more like dry roasted beef. It also included black beans and cilantro lime rice which I'm not opposed to but the rice was very limey and the whole thing lacked moisture. It did have their IPO (everyday salsa) but that was either absorbedby the rice or dry steak. That may have also contributed to the limeiness. I didn't taste any heat at all. Overall, you can tell that the ingredients were high quality, it just lacked the authenticity and taste of a Mission Burrito. I'm not sure if I'd put down $10 for another one. read more

While visiting friends in the area years ago, they took me to Neato Burrito. I'd been planning to visit with said friends while passing through town, and insisted on Neato Burrito. The Cowboy Crunch is still amazing, even if it loses just a bit in the translation to take out (understandable). A must when in the area for me! read more

Love the cowboy crunch! They are huge, so my husband and I usually share one. The burritos are consistently good - you always know what your experience will be. We especially love this location for it's proximity to the West Shore Theater. Makes for a great (cheap!) date night! read more

Every other week, usually on a Wednesday night, I have a craving for a Cowboy Crunch burrito from Neato Burrito. It's conveniently located within walking distance from my bungalow and in all honesty that is one of the main reasons I frequent this store in particular. It is definitely my least favorite of the three locations I've visited, but still serves a relatively consistent brick of a burrito, and the Cowboy Crunch burrito is a simmering pile of nom nom deliciousness with just the right amount of kick (with a jalapeno cheese tortilla). Sadly, the times I stray from the Cowboy Crunch formula, I am usually not well-rewarded. Creating my own mess from the options available usually ends in blandness as the ingredients lack spice and flavor. It also makes me mess my pants as the burritos usually drip with juices or spontaneously combust. Also, every now and then there's an "off-day" and I chomp into a few grains of uncooked rice, which feels exactly like losing a tooth. Cowboy Crunch = AWESOME! Everything else = eh... read more

No more ice cream (bummer) but I'm sticking with the four stars in spite of the whole one-bathroom thing. There are new faces behind the counter but I haven't run into any issues with quality in preparing my delicious burritos! read more

Amazing unique and delicious! If you're looking for a great burrito place this is it!

I'm happy to say that I have never had a bad experience at Neato, especially at the New Cumberland location (still my favorite one). The "made-to-order" style of menu is awesome for those looking to experiment with their burritos. It's one way to ensure never having a dull, run-of-the-mill burrito. I try to mix it up and try something different every time I'm there. A lot of people have their favorite "go to" combinations, and of course the famed Cowboy Crunch is a must, but my advice is to mix it up, try different sauces and combinations. It's always a new experience. read more

Went in here for lunch with coworkers. Anyway this place was awesome the food was great and they even offer complimentary water. We ordered 5 burritos I highly recommend them.We chose the beef pork and chicken options and it was delicious pulled tender beef not the cheap ground beef taco meat and the portion was definitely more than enough and it was only 8.75 per burrito! We were lucky and got seating but it did fill up rather quickly as we were leaving . Try them out you will not regret it and for 8.75 it's worth the chance :) read more

One of my favorite places to eat in this area. The food is amazing, the workers are always super friendly and they have a great selection on the menu. I highly recommend this place compared to anywhere else local like Chipotle, they're so much better. Keep up the great work, guys! read more

Got a Cowboy Crunch after everyone I talked to recommended it. It tasted really good. I am not a big meat eater so it did not concern me as much but the center of the large and thick burrito had maybe 1/2 to 1 cup if that of meat. The rest was rice. I thought it was more than enough for one eating as I saved 1/4th for later and others with me ate a slice. Was told the burritos are larger than what ours were. Would eat there again. A child's beef burrito was super filled with meat. The children's chicken burrito was also skimpy on meat. A regular beef burrito was very slim on meat. My husband who likes more meat than other things (Subway) would have preferred less beans and rice and more MEAT! read more

Neato Burrito - 1/2 of a Cowboy Crunch. (filled with rice, lacked chicken.) - Mexican Near Me - New Cumberland, Pennsylvania

Have been coming here for years. Love it! Cilantro tortilla is my favorite. Oh and the feta and jalapeno salsa = YES! Always consistent, which I appreciate. Love to bring friends from out of town. read more

VERY VERY VERY disappointing! Been forever since we had this and typically love Neato Burrito, but now? So we tried it thru door dash. I will say very fast! However, always get the burrito bowl. It's half the size it used to be with one tiny piece of meat in it. $13 for this, COVID or not is crap! Sad to see one of our favorite places sink to this terrible level! read more

I was first introduced to Neato Burrito back in 2005 and I am so glad that I was! I call it the "Subway" of burritos, as the burritos are made to order the way you like it. In all the years I have been going, the only item I ever order is the Cowboy Crunch with sour cream instead of Ranch dressing. (Best burrito I have ever had!) The employees are always so enthusiastic to serve you. The atmosphere is very welcoming. I have never had a bad experience at this location. And you will not leave hungry because the burritos are over a pound. For your convenience, you can fax in your order and then pick it up. Not a social butterfly? They allow you to fill out what you want on a blue card and they'll make your burrito. My only complaint is that the parking lot fills up quickly during lunch. Be prepared to walk if the surrounding businesses are busy. Other than that, I would highly recommend you try out Neato Burrito! read more

Top 3 reasons why I haven't moved to Hawaii: 1. Family 2. Hairstylist 3. Neato Burrito Not even kidding. I genuinely love Neato Burrito that much that when I think of moving out of state I'm like, "But Neato Burrito..." I've eaten at every burrito place I can find, and Neato is still my favorite. Their burritos are HUGE, and their ingredients taste the freshest. I also like that, unlike other burrito places, I can get a burrito without any spiciness. If you want super spicey, they have that too. I am an insanely picky eater (to the point where it's incredibly annoying), and I have zero complaints about Neato. It's actually in my top 3 favorite restaurants as well. Kudos Neato Burrito -- you're awesome. Now hurry up and become a national chain. But stay awesome. read more

Quick food, nice selection and cheap prices. It tastes pretty good too, can't beat it.

I am a huge fan of Neato burrito but today I went to the lemoyne shopping center location and was incredibly upset when I got my burrito. It tastes wonderful, but this location has decided to change the size of the wraps and thus the burrito is half the size yet the same price.i won't be going to this location again. read more

Love this place, love the food. This location is the coolest of the branches, very hip place. The food is customize to your taste, they have a Salsa of the day and it's different depending on the day of the week. Their website lists the info. http://neatoburrito.com/. I love the jalapeo feta, so those are the days I tend to go out. All locations have the same food quality which I love. I have eaten at 3 of the 4. New Cumberland is the best decor however in my opinion. Portions are huge, unless you are a hefty eater plan on leftovers, or at least being extremely stuffed. You can also fax in orders using the fax form on their website, great for pick-up orders when you have a bit of a drive. This is a must try this place at least once if nothing more for the awesome dcor, but the food totally ROCKS! read more

This was great local restaurant. It reminds me of a hipster chipotle. What I like most was all the choices for tortillas they had (spinach, tomato, wheat to name a few). I also like the option of getting the burrito grilled. A couple of things that were so so. The salsa seemed a bit. I had the black angus, which tasted a bit like rump roast. A great place for a quick bite. Tip, they do not take AMEX. read more

This place is so good. I've been going here since I was a kid (so about ten years) and the food has always been great. It's a make your own burrito joint with a really fun, retro atmosphere. read more

Perfect. My wife and I eat Neato Burrito about once every week or two. I actually get giddy to get my cowboy crunch burrito after work. Here's a recipe for a great night: Call order in to Neato Burrito. Pick up order on the way home from work. Go down the street and pick up a case of Troegs at the beer store (don't know its name). Go home to watch TV. Don't plan on moving from the couch for about 3 days. These burritos are like food-bricks that sit in your stomach for a while. read more