Unfortunately, this restaurant is permanently closed .. They had the BEST steak you'd ever want to eat. The rest of your dinner would have been just as good. Thank you for the years you were open. read more

Everything went well! Service was friendly and warm. Ambiance very nice. Clean, well lit, and easy to hear the person/people at your table. Food was tasty, warm, and served quickly. Will be going back. read more

Soup AND Salad WITH Bread, in addition to your meal ... in one word, YUM! Upon entry, we felt like we were stepping into a different dimension and simpler times. Candlelit tables and dim sconces on the walls provided a warm, inviting vibe. Surprisingly, the server who greeted us knew us by name and warmly welcomed us to the National Hotel. Our server was knowledgeable, friendly and had a great sense of humor. The meal was coursed out perfectly and we enjoyed every bite. Stuffed mushrooms to start were piping hot and flavorful in a ramekin of butter. The hottest thing in Cuylerville was the freshly baked bread-in-a-bag! Perfect to get every morsel of mushroom soup out of our bowls. Usually you have to choose between soup OR salad, not here! We got a fresh greens garden salad following the soup! Our main entrées of steak were perfectly cooked to temp and tasted great with the red wine. The mashed potatoes were fluffy, flavorful and satisfying. Peanut butter and chocolate pie brought our experience to a close. To wrap up the evening, we got to thank the chef and her husband for an amazing dining experience. This is one of a kind gem and we look forward to our next visit. Bring a loved one, go for a special date night or just stop in to treat yourself. You will not be disappointed. read more

National Hotel - Short rib and mashed potatoes - American Near Me - Leicester, New York

It's been many years since my husband and I have been here and since we've heard such rave reviews recently, we decided to invite friends to join us for a nice dinner out. I made our reservations with ease a few days in advance. We arrived for dinner the day of and were seated fairly quickly. From there, it took a turn - the service was awful and s-l-o-w! The food though - DELICIOUS! Once our food arrived and we enjoyed the meal, we asked about dessert, but were told we couldn't eat it there and would have to get it to go because they needed our table for other guests. I get it, but seriously?! Not our fault service was slow and our food didn't arrive timely, but to be quickly rushed off was just rude! Then there's the parking fiasco. Who parks 3 rows and blocks people in? Needless to say, we won't be heading back too soon. The current owner told us he's selling the business at the end of the year and we can take up complaints with the new owner! Unbelievable! read more

My husband and I wanted to celebrate our 50th Anniversary so my children and grandchildren dined at the National in Cuylerville New York. I hadn't had lobster in a while and really was looking forward to it So I ordered the twin lobster tails. My son also ordered it. Neither of us could eat it because it was spongy and had a foul taste to it. I really tried because I wanted nothing to go wrong that evening. The lobster tails were $65 per each of the two dinners They still charged us the $65 each the lobster for lobsters that two of us could not eat.That is outrageous! How petty of them! We will never go back there again! They have certainly gone downhill! read more

This was an unexpected surprise! The service was great, the food was amazing. I never expected it to be great so far from the beaten path! I had veal french over broccoli (my choice). So delicious. They also give soup, salad and bread with every meal. I had French onion and it was so good. My husband had seafood creole and a seafood bisque as his soup. He wanted to like the creole bowl lol but didn't! The dessert list sounded scrumptious but we are not indulging right now. read more

National Hotel - a man sitting at a table reading a menu - American Near Me - Leicester, New York

Post-COVID reopening: The place was booming but our server Sarah kept up with us and our orders and requests on a timely basis. The food was good -- many delicious scallops in my order and the beef barley soup that came eith all our dinners was the best I have ever tasted-- clearly home-made and with actual pie es of beef, all served at the perfect temperature. The stencilled dining room was as pretty as ever and as always, extraordinarily noisy. Conversation among the 4 of us was dufficultThe restaurant and restrooms are definitely handicap accessible, despite being in a historic building. Happy to have this nice place as a dining option again. I have only given 4 stars because of the noise factor, which limits who you dine with and what interaction you can have. But especially compared to other local options, the National is a winner. Reserve early. read more

This is an aging beauty in Livingston County - a traditional menu and setting. Food is well-prepared and fresh - many sauces, dressings, and desserts made on-site. Service is top-notch and the atmosphere is cozy, warm, and inviting, especially in the winter with the fireplace and candles lit everywhere. Going to the National is like coming home to a good friend. Family-owned and operated by Art and Violet Allen since 1994 - I'm hoping this hidden treasure will continue to operate for many years to come. read more

My wife and I had dinner tonight at the National Hotel. I suggested it based on a recommendation from a coworker. Although the night started off a little rough with some confusion over which server was assigned our table, it got progressively better. We decided to go with their Saturday night special, 2 meals for $58. You had a choice of 3 entrees all of which included soup & salad, choice of side, and dessert. We both went with the 12 oz prime rib and a baked potato for our side. All of the food was excellent and a tremendous value. The soup was home made, the salad was perfect, the prime rib was an excellent cut of meat, and the desserts were incredible. We also had a great bottle of red wine with dinner for just $19. Overall we really enjoyed our evening and will definitely return! read more

Unbelievable service, fastasic meal. If anything too large so I had to take a dessert to go. Love the old building. But wish I'd have thought to ask if the rest of the rooms were available for viewing. Short drive from letchworth state park and worth the trip read more

The National is a hidden gem! The owners are very friendly and the food is awesome!! I've never had a bad meal here. I'm a seafood lover and the Haddock Oscar is phenomenal! Stop in the bar to visit with Art... He has the best stories! Old historic building with candles on the tables and the bar. Meals include a cup of soup and salad... You won't leave hungry . read more

What a hidden gem this is!! Took the family on Saturday nite. I was pleasantly surprised by the atmosphere, service, quality and quantity of food!! Our server Ari was very attentive and knowledgeable. You get soup,(fresh and homemade) salad,bread (garlic, hot and fresh) and main course( huge portion). And the deserts, well you will be very surprised!! Let me just say MOUNDS CAKE!!!! So please if you are in the area make it a point to stop by. You will certainly be very happy you did. read more

This was our first time at the National Hotel. Our meals were delicious! The heavenly herbed garlic bread came to our table fresh out of the oven and pipping hot. Both soup AND salad were included with the meal, we both had the seafood bisque and would order it again if it's a choice on our next visit. My husband was very happy with the surf and turf he ordered and I had the black and blue filet which was one of the specials for the day. My filet was cooked perfectly and so tender that you could literally cut it with a fork! Unfortunately we had no room for desserts but did squeeze in an after dinner drink at the bar where we got to meet bartender and owner who entertained us with stories about this historic building and family business. read more

Had one of their specials; broiled chicken breast topped with crab, asparagus and hollandaise sauce-delicious! Service was quick and hostess very friendly. Better than expected even though other reviews were vg! read more

This is one of our favorite places to eat when we go out for a romantic evening. The atmosphere is so intimate, and rustic country, and the history so deep that even if the food WAS bad (which it isn't) it would make it worthwhile. We've eaten here several times, and never have we been even close to disappointed. A drink at the bar afterwards, and a discussion with the owner will reveal some true treasures! read more

Great historic site where you know what you want and what your going to get. If your looking for classically prepared dishes, perfect steak and seafood temperatures, and overall consistency this is a good spot! Its an old building with rustic charm that was at one point a stop on the underground railroad. Homemade soups and sauces, fresh desserts and timely service. The drink selection is a bit limited but has a good overall base. Very intimate setting and a good place to go if your looking for conversation with dinner as it is not a noisy atmosphere. read more

A very old place, so it has an old feel to it. Also reflected in the clientele. Dining area is dark, and quiet though the tables are closely packed. Hands down, the best French onion soup in the area. Prime rib is excellent and always prepared well. This has been our go-to place for a long time. Nice, sit-down, relaxing dining! read more

I don't know if you realize but we have a REAL TREASURE here in Livingston County and her name is VIOLET ALLEN she and her husband Art own the National Hotel in Leicester,NY.......... And if you want a fine meal that is prepared by VIOLET she not only cooks your steaks she makes the soups and desserts too!!! So do yourself a favor and check out the National Hotel you won't be sorry!!! Kimberlee Williamson read more