Danielle was amazing and my food was great. Cute little pizzeria in a quiet neighborhood. Lots of different types of pizzas to choose from. One line big screen tv in the bar area playing football. Fairly impressive selection of alcoholic beverages. My brother and mom got the rustic pizza with half pepperoni and half anchovies. The only reason for a minus star was because the crust was very disappointing for them. It seemed to be overcooked and very hard to cut and eat. They said it tasted good but the bottom was burned. My eyes were bigger than my stomach and I should have asked for a description of the stuffed pizza. They had one small one with cheese which said serving for 1-2 people. It came out and I said holy cow that is massive! I barely made a dent in it haha. It was very tasty but was thinking it would be a small personal pizza size. Nope! Was still good. The service was great, I would probably get a thin pizza next time. Thanks! read more

See all

Let me just start with Kimberly! She is an amazing bartender, and server who was very attentive. She was also very, very polite! Always a plus. The place isn't much inside, but it isn't bad either. Plenty of room for partys, and you won't feel crowded at all. OK, the food. I had a side Caesar salad which was delicious! Then came the pizza. I ordered a small chicago deep dish with meatball, and green peppers. I only got through two pieces, but it was pretty good. My only issue is that there was not nearly enough meat in my pizza, but plenty of green peppers. I would suggest meat choices only to go with the tons of cheese, and sauce. I'll still be going back when I'm in the mood, because even though it isn't Lou's, or Giordano's, it's pretty scrumptious. read more

See all

Awesome food and service! Definitely recommend! A bit pricey, but very, very tasty. Plus, they're super friendly!

The service was good and the stuffed pizza was delicious. We also ordered wings which I thought were pretty good as well. They have a small parking lot. We went on a Sunday evening and we were the only people in the establishment. Which was nice. The service was good. Our waitress was very friendly. They have a pretty cool bar area if you wanted to watch the game. The price of pizza was a little high. But it was definitely worth it and I would definitely go back again. I suggest if you're going to get the stuffed pizza that you eat it at the restaurant. I hear a lot of people who have had issues with the pizza when transporting it. read more

See all

July 25th 2026 **Very Disappointing Experience at Nancy's Pizza in Springfield** I normally don't take the time to write negative reviews, but our experience with Nancy's Pizza in Springfield was extremely disappointing. We had just got done traveling a **12-hour drive day**. We stopped because we simply wanted to grab a pizza, after a long and tiring day with 2 very hungry kiddos. Unfortunately, we were given the **wrong pizza**. We didn't realize it was the wrong pizza until after we had already eaten a piece. Once we discovered the mistake, we contacted the restaurant expecting a simple solution. Kids only wanted cheese not a meat pizza., Instead, we were told that we had to **drive all the way back to the restaurant (15 minute trip 1 way) and return the pizza we had already taken home and started eating** before they would give us the correct pizza. We made the trip back, returned the pizza, and then had to wait for and pick up the replacement. What made this even more frustrating was the complete lack of concern for the situation. We tried calling and reaching out, and we didn't feel like anyone was taking responsibility for the inconvenience. We explained my mom took a piece, and kids won't eat cheese and two hungry kids, yet there was very little effort to make the situation right in a reasonable way. They eventually offered us a **free pizza for another visit**, but we don't live in the area, so that really wasn't helpful. We didn't want a free pizza another time -- **we simply wanted the pizza we had ordered that day.** there was no compensation for thier mistake, no concern for our drive back (15 minutes each way) There is also a food-safety concern with being instructed to bring back food that had already been delivered to and handled by a customer. Illinois has adopted the FDA Food Code, and Section 3-306.14 addresses returned food and states that food that has been served or sold and has been in the possession of a consumer generally cannot be offered again for human consumption. Illinois inspection guidance also specifically lists the proper disposition of returned, previously served, reconditioned and unsafe food as a food-safety requirement. ([Illinois Department of Public Health][1]) That makes it especially concerning that we were specifically instructed to bring back a pizza that had already been taken home and eaten from. Mistakes happen. We completely understand that. **What matters is how a business handles the mistake.** In our case, we were inconvenienced multiple times, had to make an unnecessary trip back, had hungry children waiting, and felt like our situation simply wasn't important to the staff. They should have given compensation for all the drive back and fourth! For us, this wasn't about getting something free. It was about receiving the correct order and having the restaurant take responsibility for its mistake. Unfortunately, based on this experience, we would not return to Nancy's Pizza Springfield. read more

We caught them on a busy night; placed an order to go ... there was a bit of a wait but it was WELL worth it. The food was awesome and the service was stellar; friendly and attentive read more

I loved this pizza. And guess what? Deep dish pizza takes time to cook because it's not mass-cooked ahead of time. Our custom made deep dish pizza was hot and fresh and very tasty! Be a decent customer and understand that it takes time. It was not an excessively long wait. It was a very reasonable wait. I'd go here again if I lived in the area. It's great deep dish! And the skillet cookie was yummy! read more

See all

Super friendly service. Nice atmosphere, with a full bar and the game going on on the screen behind it. The pizza was good, not great in my opinion but decent...The thin crust was more of a hand tossed, but the taste was good and still had some crisp. Most importantly I could tell it was homemade dough and not some frozen disc. The deep dish was good, we tried both. Overall decent pizza, we'd go back. Especially when in Springfield, where actual high quality homemade pizza is hard to come by. read more

Nancy's Pizza Springfield - 9" Small Original Stuffed Pizza w/sausage 12" Medium Classic Thin Crust Pizza w/sausage - Pizza Near Me - Springfield, Illinois

Gave it three shots. Just got worse each time. The deep dish was horrible. Ordered a pepperoni and sausage deep dish. We literally had four pieces of sausage and a few pepperonis. Way too much cheese. The waitress took the order, brought it to the table, and we never saw her again. She spent the whole time chatting to the bar tender. One of the employees noticed her non attentiveness, brought to her attention and brought the check. Bad food plus bad service equals won't be back. read more

Good pizza! Lots of options. A bit pricey though. You start with a cheese pizza. Each topping is and $3.50 each.

I order a lot of food for the office and I just used Nancy's pizza for the first time for this purpose. Two key reasons: they offer GF crust; they will deliver to downtown Springfield. A huge pizza order was placed the other day - 6 pizzas total. One deep dish, 3 thin crust, a couple GF. Everything arrived on time; all our food was hot when we received it; ordering over the phone (preferred) was a breeze with the help of a friendly employee there. My co-workers were happy, and full from our pizza order. Thank you, Nancy's Pizza!!! read more

Nancy's pizza is amazing. Not only was the food delicious, but they were super attentive to our group- we had over 30 people. Celena and everyone else working went above and beyond to make sure our group was never without. Come for the good pizza, stay for the amazing service. read more

This is one of my favorite pizza spots in Springfield.. I really don't like any other pizza. Mostly because it reminds me of Chicago pizza..What I enjoy most is the consistency. I can always expect the food to taste the same. I've never experienced bad customer service. They send coupons and have a loyalty incentive discount, as in been a customer for years and sometimes get a few dollars off.. not sure if this is only a location thing. Today I ordered the largest family size thin crust pepperoni and sausage pizza which ran me about $31. Of course I'll be back! They have indoor seating and servers. It's a comfortable dining space that is separate from the cash registers. I've come with party of 6. Not sure if the dining is open due to Covid at this time. Mandatory face covering in order to enter. read more

Nancy's Pizza Springfield - Thin Family Size Pizza - Pepperoni & Sausage - Pizza Near Me - Springfield, Illinois

Ordered for a takeaway for 100th birthday party, all the pizzas were fantastic along with the salads too. You guys do great food! Everyone liked and complimented the food. Thankst so much read more

Really good service. Easygoing yet attentive. Good selection of drinks of all sorts. Food came out hot and fresh. REALLY great wings no lie best I've had in awhile. Laidback atmosphere. Regulars definitely come here read more

See all

Great pizza & great service! You can tell the owner takes pride in her business. Clean restaurant, friendly servers. Kimberly took great care of us. Our last night in town for a funeral, looking for some good deep dish Chicago style pizza. We thought it was better than Lou's!! Thanks again! read more

We loved this place so much! Was recommended to us by a friend. And it was amazing. Kim was our server and she made it the best time for my mom's bday. We will be back read more

Very friendly service and pizza very good. Had 2 pizzas with rustic crust on both. Chicago beef with giadiniera on side and a cheese with black olives and shrooms. Both were cooked excellent and the crust was perfect. Recommend. read more

Nancy's Pizza Springfield - Chicago beef with Giardiniera on side, rustic crust - Pizza Near Me - Springfield, Illinois

See all

I ate here while on business, looking forward to trying the Chicago-style deep dish pizza which I've never had. A local remarked I've still never had it since I ordered a deep dish pizza and not a Chicago style pizza from their menu. Now I'm confused, but the pizza I did order was good except for the crust which lacked flavor and texture. The blueberry salad was amazing though! read more

See all

The deep-dish personal pizza (pepperoni, bacon, Italian beef, and garlic) was great. I got food poisoning from a famous place in Chicago and was scared to try deep-dish again, but this place saved the whole cuisine. They have a unique cooking method for their deep-dish pizzas. The manager (or owner of the franchise?) told me they have some sort of contraption they put over top of the pie that cooks the pizza all the way through - this is great in my book, as that lessens the probability of food borne illness. The place that starts with a G in Chicago does not, making this cooking method pretty unique. The buffalo cheese waffle fries I had were bomb, and I found myself licking the plate! I almost wanted to keep it to dip my pie in it. The meal all in all was around $20 and well-worth it. But the real gems besides the food are the staff. They were so friendly, welcoming, knowledgeable, and took their time to recommend me the unique Springfield eats that I can't get anywhere else; horseshoes are looking to be on the menu tomorrow! My favorite part of traveling for work is meeting nice people such as the people at Nancy's. The place was very clean and modern. It's also conveniently next to a Krispy Kreme and a McDonald's; I got my fix for a donut and coffee in the same parking lot. read more

Nancy's Pizza Springfield - Deep dish pizza - Pizza Near Me - Springfield, Illinois

Great service and food. The server was very attentive and the thin crust pizza was very good. We don't go there as often as we'd like.

I love their pizza. At be least once a month I get my pizza fix. Service is always great

Veggie deep dish was so goood. The service is great and it was a perfect dinner. Great food and service. Unfortunately Nancy died in February but the legend lives on with this great food. Highly recommended read more

It had been years since we'd had deep dish Chicago style pizza. We tried it from another chain here in town: the crust was soggy and the flavors were bland. Not at Nancy's! This is the best deep dish pizza around. read more

Nancy's Pizza Springfield - Deep dish Stuffed Deep Dish Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Springfield, Illinois

Okay regular crust pizza, a little pricey for Springfield but worth trying if you want switch things up.

I had to try a Chicago style pizza. Well, it was great and filling and could only get 1 1/2 slices done lol. read more

Nancy's Pizza Springfield - Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Springfield, Illinois

Had a flyer in the hotel room for 10% off so I decided to give it a try. Ordered a large stuff cheese. About $28 which is understandable for stuffed. It arrived all slid over to one side and a big mess. Called and told them. The woman said she would tell the manager and have him call me but they never did. I'd order from them again. Really good pizza. I just wouldn't order the stuffed. A little too much money to have a big mess. read more

Nancy's Pizza Springfield - Large stuffed Cheese. - Pizza Near Me - Springfield, Illinois

Great pizza sauce flavor, good crust, fast service (for deep dish: be patient and reasonable) and a pleasant atmosphere.

I grew up on deep dish pizza in the Chicago area. I LOVED Lou Malnati pizza, the buttery crust and all those amazing toppings and tons of gooey mozarella cheese. So I was really looking forward to my first deep dish pizza from Nancy's Pizza in Springfield. I ordered a large pepperoni, Italian sausage and black olive. This pizza cost me $32. THERE WAS NO ITALIAN SAUSAGE ON MY PIZZA and there was barely any pepperoni on my pizza. So for $32 I got mostly black olives and cheese on my pizza. What a COMPLETE DISAPPOINTMENT. I WILL NEVER ORDER FROM THIS PLACE AGAIN. WHAT A COMPLETE RIP OFF!!!!!!! SHAME ON YOU NANCY'S PIZZA. read more

Overpriced garbage - I had heard this place was good and i ordered to go, we ordered a thin crust pizza with just a few toppings, the entire crust was stuck to the bottom of the box, we also ordered some cheese sticks, which were completely uncooked. I had to warm them up in the air fryer upon returning home, trust me and go to Pizza Man also here in town and much, much better. read more

The evil manager no longer works here. I hadn't gone back for 4 months because of her. To my pleasant surprise the new Manager puts the customers satisfaction above all else. Brandon was short staffed when I went in and still took the time to come to the table and ensure what we wanted was perfect. He personally took the order and made our pizza. It was back to the excellence we haves come to expect from Nancy's. Bravo Brandon! And thank you! read more

Stuffed pizza was amazing! Fettuccini Alfredo and Caesar salad were also super good. The staff were all fantastic and we had phenomenal service from start to finish. read more

Nancy's Pizza Springfield - Uncle Tony's and a sausage. Both mediums and huge! - Pizza Near Me - Springfield, Illinois

Always fast and tasty too eat food!! Is close to me and frequently go there Great pizza read more

*I'll start this by saying I spoke with a manager after the dinner rush by phone who was apologetic and gave a full $62.xx refund. Much appreciated resolution! Was looking forward to carry-out deep dish treat all week on payday, and I've had Nancy's pizza at a different location and it was delicious. It rivaled Giordanos' from Chicago. I Ordered from the Springfield IL store, a large supreme deep dish cooked "well done" and a small veggie deep dish with double spinach (apparently didn't come with spinach originally) totaling $62.xx. The supreme lacked product inside the o Lt thing I could taste was sauce and onion. The crust was undercooked despite ordering well done and a bit doughy. The veggie didn't have any spinach that I noticed and there was so much cheese it balled up in my mouth like chewing a wad of gum. I used to run a pizza shop and know proper specs on toppings, this failed miserably I'd say the food this time was mediocre at best. Not horrible, just for $62 I expected a WOW factor. I've had better pan pizza from Dominos, not kidding. read more

Ordered carry out, and it was ready exactly when they said it would be, 1 hour. Anyone complaining about how long it takes hasn't had good deep dish. Pretty good pizza but not really on par with deep dish from Chicago. I ordered a medium with green peppers, spinach and tomatoes, uncut. It was pretty deep, the cheese was thick and good, sauce a little too tangy. The crust was too thick and not crispy like a good chicago pizza. I'll be going again, but not nearly as good as chicago. Also wish they delivered. read more

Nancy's Pizza Springfield - Looked great! Was decent. Medium, spinach, tomato, and green pepper - Pizza Near Me - Springfield, Illinois

I love Nancy's Pizza! I'm from Chicago and grew up ordering from Nancy's, I was SOOO excited when one opened up in Springfield... HOWEVER... Their restaurant (although beautiful) lacks quality service and their mozzarella sticks SUCK! They bake them, which leaves them tasting like hot cheese wrapped in sticky dough which is just GROSS! And if you complain, there's only a "Sorry, yes they're baked." No offer to take them back and remake them the right way. Do they NOT have a deep fryer back there? They have great deep dish tho. Their pizza is just like the original Nancy's in Chicago! I highly recommend ordering for pick up or delivery, skip the dining in. Worst wait staff ever. read more

Nancy's Pizza Springfield - Pizza Near Me - Springfield, Illinois

See all

The place is clean and the staff are friendly. The deep dish pizza was like 3.5 out of 5 stars. They're good to have in Springfield for sure. They don't skimp on the toppings, so that is a plus. read more

Nancy's Pizza Springfield - Deep Dish personal pizzas - Pizza Near Me - Springfield, Illinois

See all

While staying in town we ordered some pizza for delivery. The GF selection is absolutely WONDERFUL. The staff we dealt with we very professional and friendly, I would highly recommend them. read more

The best pasta & pizza in town! They have a full bar and great service. The restaurant is always clean and fresh. The kitchen staff is great & fast. Cassidy is the best. read more

Best pizza around! Delicious and plenty of toppings! Pricey but right now everything is!