I've taken my VW here for a few things, and have been generally happy. They will use your parts if you provide them, which is nice to cut down on the marked up prices you'll pay if your mechanic provides the parts.
Last week, I brought my VW in to check on a few things: water ingress in the trunk, pooling in the side storage bin above the wheel, an oil leak and slow wipers. Now, I told Nal's that I had replaced the taillight after being hit by another car, and that I thought that was the source of the water leak. I also told them that I'd replaced the valve cover a few times but had noticed oil wetness on the top of the engine, at the side near the pollen filter. Dropped the car off at 9 a.m. as scheduled, and waited for a call. Late in the afternoon, Nal's called and said they couldn't find where the water was coming in and couldn't find an oil leak. I explained exactly where the oil leak was and talked about where the water was pooling and where to look. Keep in mind that the oil leak is visible on the engine; there is a wet spot on the engine head on the side closest to the cabin filter, which is probably a cam tensioner seal going bad. Nal's said they'd look again at both issues, but that they'd need the car another day.
The next day, they said they couldn't find where the water was coming in. Now, I had about two inches of water in the trunk side storage bin where the jack is stored that I had bailed out earlier in the week, and the carpet was still wet. They said they checked the tail light and even retightened it so the seal was flush and tight. They diagnosed the oil leak as a timing belt tensioner gasket, which at the front of the engine, and which is no where near where the visible wet spots are at the back of the engine. For the wipers, they said the transmission that actually moves the wipers had seized up and couldn't be service and would require replacement. I paid about $120 for the diagnosis and an oil change. They also told me that my hood latch, which had been working before I dropped off the car, was broken, and that a brake light was out, which they could replace for $2.50 for the bulb and $10 for labor. It takes a minute to swap out a bulb, so I declined.
Today, I had a chance to look over the work and was very dismayed to find that they hardly did anything over the two days they had my car. First, just looking at the tail light, I could see a half inch gap between the seal and the car, which would easily allow water to come in. All that was required to spot the source of the leak was to remove the bulb assembly, which just requires pinching the plastic assembly to release the two plastic latches and pull the bulb assembly out. I have no idea how they could have missed the gab between the tail light lens cover and the car body, or failed to notice it when they supposedly retightened so it was supposedly flush to the body. The only explanation I can come up with is that they never looked at it in the first place.
I also fixed the hood latch myself. Those are poorly designed and prone to breaking, which is why I had a spare on hand. But I'm annoyed because it was working before I brought the car in, and then it wasn't.
I appreciate Nal's patience in explaining things, but what they've said just doesn't reflect the reality of the work they should have performed. I'll update this with a picture of the oil leak to show just how obvious it should be, especially since I already told them where to look. I should have taken a picture of the tail light to show how wide the gap was and how hard it would be to overlook, but I just removed the three screws that hold the tail light cover on, realigned it so the seal would be flush with the body, and tightened it down. That took 10 minutes, most of which was simply going back into the house to find the right sized socket.
If your mechanic is going to lie to you about the little things like checking that a tail light cover is properly installed, or that they can't find an oil leak even though you tell them where to look, how are they going to handle the big ticket items? I won't bring my car back to Nal's. If you choose them, be sure to check over their work to make sure they actually did the work. Or go somewhere else.
I stand by this review and would be happy to answer any questions about it. Feel free to contact me.
Tom read more