Cancel

Open app

Search

Mythical Pizza

4.4 (56 reviews)
Closed • 11:30 am - 10:00 pm

Order Mythical Pizza Takeout or Delivery

Mythical Pizza Photos

MYTHICAL PIZZA ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Casual
Touristy
Dogs allowed

You might also consider

More like Mythical Pizza

Recommended Reviews - Mythical Pizza

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Anthony F.

What a fun pizza shop to visit. Good pizza along with a ton of Bigfoot memorabilia. I'm a huge Bigfoot fan so this was a lot of fun. Staff was friendly and there's a good amount of parking. The dining area is like a Bigfoot museum so it's a fun atmosphere.

Close Encounters (Of The Veggie Kind)
Emily L.

I was so hungry my first night in Berkeley Springs and didn't feel like cooking. Luckily, I found a Mythical Pizza on DoorDash. I ordered the veggie man's vegan roll and the close encounters of the veggie kind pizza,, both with vegan cheese. They were delicious! The prices were also super reasonable. I will definitely order from them again and highly recommend.

Rachel R.

We love this place! We are from out of town and vacationing with a toddler. Finding a resturant that is family friendly and cool is hard. But yet, here is mythical pizza. We had so much fun! The staff was so nice and brought my son his own pizza slices. If you have ever seen "goofy movie" you know how delicious cheese slices can look - the pizza slice my son got looked just like that! See below

Storefront
Arcadia S.

Even before you step into Mythical Pizza, you will catch the vibe. Royal Purple exterior with illustrated cryptids beckoning from the windows and doors. The enticing aroma of smoke from real pizza ovens in the air as you park your car. Then you enter and, honestly they had me at 5-stars on aesthetics alone. My husband said, "I hope the pizza is even a tenth as good as their branding!" And it WAS!!! Actually it was 100% as good. Absolutely delicious vegan pizza done right! And the veggie man vegan roll... Yum Yum Yum! Surprisingly affordable too. YEZ: vegan friendly YEZ: family friendly

Entrance
Javier M.

We're from out of town and recently bought a property in Berkeley Springs, so we've been working our way through the local restaurants. Honestly, most have been underwhelming, with only a few exceptions. Mythical Pizza was a very welcome plot twist. We happened to drive by and pulled in on a whim. Even from the outside, the place has personality. Inside, we were greeted warmly by who I think was either the owner or manager. She explained how everything worked, gave great recommendations, and immediately made the place feel welcoming. The decor is quirky in the best way: Bigfoot, aliens, cryptids, paranormal touches, and a little gift shop. It sounds like it could be too much, but somehow it works. If a pizza place and a roadside folklore museum had a charming baby, this would be it. The menu is surprisingly broad, with pizzas, specialty crusts, pastas, salads, folded breads, strombolis, wings, desserts, and more. Since there were too many interesting pizzas to choose from, I ordered the "Flight of the Squonks," three 5 inch signature pizzas. We tried "The Alabama White Thang," "Attack of the 50' Meatball," and "Sprout Man and the Masters of the Pizzeria." All three were genuinely very good, creative without being weird for the sake of weird, and the crust was excellent. We also had barbecue wings. The wings themselves were juicy, meaty, and well cooked. The barbecue sauce was fine, though next time I'd probably ask for sauce on the side and try another flavor. The place was packed, which felt like a good sign, and the energy matched the food: fun, unpretentious, and better than expected. After a disappointing meal elsewhere the day before, where the price point really wasn't justified by the food, Mythical Pizza felt like a small-town restaurant win. Great vibe, warm service, creative menu, and very solid food. Definitely coming back.

This was soooo I good I ate it allllll, it was a bacon, pineapple, ricotta, cheese, spinach 10" pizza.

Very great staff! The staff was very nice and the young gentleman passing out the pizzas was very friendly and helpful. Thank you so much for the wonderful experience!

Nick C.

This is a creative, cool and interesting pizza place. The staff is kind and chill. They make pizza at higher quality than fast food but our 3 pizzas did take 15 minutes(worth the wait!). It provides a good family meal, not super cheap, but not expensive with very customizable offerings for all different types of Pizza. The store is very cool with a lot of knickknacks and merchandise for the brand of the store which are cute, silly and fun to look at! The store even has some arcade games that you can put coins into and play. It is definitely a family friendly restaurant and a cool place to hang out when you wait for your pizza or eat your creative pizza. We had 3 different pizzas. They were all amazing and eaten quickly! They were all well roasted, toasted, cheesy and yummy but one was better than the other two. One of them was super delicious with: corn, jalapeño peppers and barbecue sauce; A great USA style pizza. The other one was a vegetable lovers pizza, but it was kind of a letdown because while the screen you order on showed a bunch of vegetables on the vegetable lovers pizza, the only vegetable actually on the pizza we got was brussels sprouts. The last one was a super rich pesto cheese pizza which lived up to its cheeseolicous expectations. While we were there the workers seem very preoccupied with some drama(dramatic dialogue, jokes, and running around, the manager apologized for the hectic vibes) which was a little frustrating considering many of the tables had crumbs on them and weren't the most suitable to eat on. Still overall a good experience, with decently priced food and amazing tasting pizza, cool customizable options and a unique store, so I do recommend for families!

We came here last summer and she suggested adding a plain seltzer, called Squonk tears... wow - here it is!!!

Great fun - good food, hilarious and tasty drinks inspired by cryptids. I had Bigfoot birch beer

Decor on the wall
DeAndre J.

You know Planet Pizza in Toy Story and the Pixar movies? This place kind of reminded me of that! We came here during our Retreat to get a treat. Two of my friends on properties in the area and we were craving pizza. This place was close by and seemed interesting to us. We entered and were greeted with welcoming service and cool decor of mythical beasts and gift items. They also have ordering tablets as well for placing your order. The gentleman who helped us explained some of the different options and then we placed our order. We each got a few different types of pizza and they're known for their cool names and unique toppings. In addition to the cool Decor they also have a few arcade games that you are able to play while waiting for your pizza. I hopped on one of them with a buddy of mine who we were with and we got to game for a few. There were also some kids that were playing nearby and once we were done jumped on the arcade games and other activities. This place was clean and neatly organized. They also had a gift section wall that featured unique gifts including doctor squish House of dragons soaps which are hard to come by if you don't order directly from their website. We got our pizza in a timely fashion and check some out at the nearby clean tables inside. Once we were done inspecting the pizzas we headed back home but this was a cool spot to visit and I liked that they had many options to choose from. The pizza was also pretty dang good in my personal opinion but the seeming sold us on this place! I give it a 5 out of 5

Mythical Pizza! Parking lot in front, several spots for picnic up orders.

See all

Reviews are largely positive. People highlight the creative pizza menu, friendly staff, and quirky themed atmosphere, with vegan and gluten-friendly options.

Read the full review summary in the app

2 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Antonio B.

Antonio B.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Monika M.
80
12
23

4 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Antonio B.

Antonio B.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of R C.
15
27
1

3 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Antonio B.

Antonio B.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Antonio B.

Antonio B.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of S E.
0
6
2

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Antonio B.

Antonio B.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Antonio B.

Antonio B.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 1

4 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Antonio B.

Antonio B.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Antonio B.

Antonio B.

Helpful 4
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Antonio B.

Antonio B.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Antonio B.

Antonio B.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Antonio B.

Antonio B.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Antonio B.

Antonio B.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Antonio B.

Antonio B.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 2 of 2

Ask the Community - Mythical Pizza

Buddy Lou's Eats Drinks & Antiques - Ice Cream

Buddy Lou's Eats Drinks & Antiques

3.9(476 reviews)
7.4 mi
•$$

We stopped on Monday around 2PM for a late lunch. Had to wait a few minutes for a table outside,…read moreafter getting our drinks it began to rain so the waitress bussed a table on the covered patio for us to sit. Just had four delicious appetizers and a Buddy Lou Root Beer and it was just over $30 (BTW- for all the people complaining about the price, it is printed next to the meal on the menu) Another great visit to Buddy Lou's!

When we were walking in some people walking out felt the need to inform us that service was super…read moreslow and you'd wait a long time for food. We told them we were okay with that since we were relaxing...and they weren't lying. Some of the worst table service and food speed I've experienced. We ordered some apple jalapeño Cole slaw and sweet potato rounds for appetizers...they brought out the Cole slaw with my meal and then we told them to skip the rounds but they brought them anyway. It was 50 minutes from the time we placed our order until we got any food. Only 20 minutes to get seated and there were a ton of open tables...they are quite obviously understaffed out front and in the kitchen. Oh...and the potato rounds were just warm, not hot...so they'd been sitting awhile. I got the pork belly BLT and it was pretty good. The pork belly was tender and full of flavor. Big sandwich bun and avocado as one of the toppings. I'd get it again. The girlfriend got the smoked pork nachos since it was one of the gluten-free options. She would have given it 5 stars if it was hot. By the time it was given to us all the cheese had hardened, it wasn't even warm. We did bring this up with the server and she pretty much told us if we sent it back that it might be another hour before we got a replacement. With that being said we didn't want to order dessert. When she brought the check everything was discounted 50% so I think they acknowledged their error of bringing us cold food an hour after ordering. It would have been about $46 for the meal but we got it for $23 and even at that price it was too much for what we got. I'm sure they might have just had a bad day. I would give them another chance and update my review if I was ever in the area. The food had potential and was great tasting...the execution wasn't poor which is a reflection of mismanagement. We really liked the vibe here and all the eclectic items and unique tables. The "thrift store" part of the restaurant is worth walking through as is the downstairs outside area...but after doing it once you won't need to do it again and it takes less than five minutes. Perfect for checking out while waiting on your order.

Photos
Buddy Lou's Eats Drinks & Antiques
Buddy Lou's Eats Drinks & Antiques
Buddy Lou's Eats Drinks & Antiques - Quirky and lively outdoor setting

See all

Quirky and lively outdoor setting

Wingstop

Wingstop

2.4(58 reviews)
17.0 mi
•$$

We were driving through town and decided to place a carry out order (our only option due to…read moreCOVID-19) since we had never eaten at a Wing Stop. We used the online app, which was user friendly. The order confirmation said our order would be ready in 16-20 minutes. Approximately 15 minutes later I walked in and they were packaging up our order. They almost forgot to place one of our items in the bag, but they stopped me before I walked out. We're frequent BWW goers and I will say that these boneless wings were probably better! The breading wasn't thick and the chicken was meaty, juicy white meat. I was surprised at the limited sauce flavors - approximately a dozen options. For this place to specialize in wings I would have expected a LARGE selection of sauce flavors. We tried 3 different flavors: hot, Cajun, and the hickory smoked BBQ. The sauces were good but there wasn't a huge difference between the flavor of the Hot and the Cajun, which was a bit disappointing. After dinner we both commented on how thirsty we were and how salty the sauces seemed to be. However, they were pretty good and I liked the fact that the breading wasn't thick. I've read other reviews about the poor attitudes and disinterest of the staff. While I didn't necessarily experience that (since I ordered and paid online) I will say that everyone behind the counter/in the kitchen seemed VERY young (high school age). No one was rude but it was VERY obvious that this was just a job to earn spending money. Overall, we were very satisfied with our food. I would order here again for a carry out order but I would still choose BWW for dine in because of the sports atmosphere and full bar

People are harder on chains, and that is not always fair. I like Wingstop. The wings are always…read morecooked perfectly and I have a weird hatred of "Frankenwings" ie wings that are all malshaped and odd looking. I just can't eat them. That is a weird me thing. I'm aware of that. I always get perfect wings at Wingstop with no frankenwings. The sauces and rubs are always good and they actually have wings with some heat and flavor. The hottest local wing joints top out at "hot" which is "Franks," which is not hot. Franks is mild. Atomic at Wingstop is perfect. 6 Atomic is a perfect burn that doesn't last too long. Wingstop is cooked perfectly, delivered quickly, flavored perfectly, and the employees are lovely. Blows all the local places with their wimpy Franks Red Hot Frankenwings to shame. Solid 5. Local joints. Up your game and please give me something with some spice and flavor.

Photos
Wingstop
Wingstop
Wingstop

See all

Mythical Pizza - pizza - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...