they were out of regular pizza doug, ordered pesto wings, way too much pesto sauce, garlic k its were overcooked and way too much garlic butte, to top it off when the gal delivered my husbands wings she said" I dropped one of your wings so you only have 5 is that ok?" I kid you not! Just don't go! read more

Pizza arrived to hotel , tasted like pizza left out overnight and was ice cold! Do not order delivery from those place! Horrible pizza! Visitor from Fl read more

Great food and good atmosphere! Pizza was great, wings were amazing and my salad was excellent. Definitely will be back!!

The $18 medium pie had no ingredients As expected. We will never go there again there was very little sauce and less cheese for a supreme pie it was disappointing read more

Very good pizza and calzones best in area , Try to get there early for online and call in orders so u can get it just out of oven when it is nice & crisp read more

The pizza is really good and the garlic knots are ridiculously good! atmosphere and customer service is good too :)

Best Pizza in Dothan. Got the pies out fast. Good sauce. Thin crust was crispy and tasty.

Pizza was the best, by far, that I have had in Dothan. This was my first visit but is certain to be a future stop for pizza. Staff was very friendly and courteous. The casual atmosphere was just right for my state of mind. read more

They really didn't disappoint. A bit pricey but you really can't complain with fresh ingredients. Friendly employees, fresh food. Pizza turned out thin and crispy [marvelous]. Brick oven style pizza I believe [not wood burning ] wings weren't fried. Pretty sure they were baked. The buffalo is good and wings are fair in size to price sold. I would recommend this establishment in the future, for sure ! read more

See all

Best pizza around. Don't wimp out and go with the old standby cheese or pepperoni. Spice it up a bit and go out on a limb with something a little different. You can't go wrong with any of these: MY GREEK PiE: light pizza sauce, garlic, parmesan, feta, spinach, artichokes, roasted red peppers, red onions, kalamata olives, balsamic glaze PROSCIUTTO & ARUGULA: garlic & evoo, parmesan, goat cheese, prosciutto, arugula and fig jam drizzle PEAR-FECT PIE: garlic & evoo, parmesan, gorgonzola, fresh mozzarella, pears, caramelized onions, prosciutto, balsamic drizzle Neve fear, you can still go for the cheese pizza, meatball special, meat lover, Hawaiian or spicy BBQ. So many options to choose from. And if you are not in the mood for pizza, try a calzone or salad. read more

Had a wonderful experience here over the weekend. It was fun picking out our toppings and seeing our pizzas made. I eat GF and the cauliflower crust was excellent!! Staff was friendly, food of great! Highly recommend! read more

See all

If you understand what a real Margherita pizza tastes like, you will we terribly disappointed. If you like a decent frozen pizza from the grocery store, you'll like this. Price was low. Limited beer selection. read more

Waited 10 minutes and was never spoken to. They put orders ahead of us and still didn't acknowledge us. Highly disappointed.

We decided to try "the new place", I am so glad we did. My first experience was a good one. I ordered on line for curbside pickup since we are in the midst of this COVID mess. Everyone asks for a phone number but no one ever calls, I got a phone call from the person making my pizzas because I forgot to choose a cheese for one of my pizzas- they called just to verify - well of course I had wanted cheese lol so glad they chose to call. When I picked up my pizza they were hot and ready. This is probably now my favorite pizza in Dothan. Fresh toppings and friendly staff - hope to see delivery in the future! I also can't wait to eat inside which looked very cozy from what I got to see. read more

See all

Look! I have eaten pizza all over. I know pizza. Unfortunately, I am a diabetic and pizza and me have a love hate relationship these days, but then I ran across My Pie Pizza! Friendly service at a level 10! For me this is the greatest day ever! They got a cauliflower crust and even better than just having it, it taste amazing! New routine just started! Great pizza no matter who you are. You can't go wrong going with My Pie Pizza! read more

This pizza is the best in Dothan! It has the best gluten free crust I've found. They ask if I order gluten free due to allergies or preference. When I tell them it's allergies, they make it on a completely different surface. read more

This place is like a pizza subway. It is real good and fast. The kids loved it. The staff are real sweet. Give this place a try you won't regret it. read more

See all

The garlic knots are best!!! And the pizza cannot be beat. The service was good but takes a little time be be freshly prepared. The restaurant is a great place to dine! read more

This is an amazing establishment and I absolutely rave about it now. I love the staff, I didn't get my servers name but she was part of what made my visit so amazing. Her service was extraordinary. And the food is amazingly delicious, I chose Hawaiian and when I forgot to ask for no jalapeños she picked them off for me and was very nice about it. When we got our food it was still fresh and hot and the slices were perfect sizes and had a great amount of toppings on each slice. The wings were not to spicy and not to bland, it was the perfect medium. And I absolutely rave about the plating. Overall I loved the place and would come to eat it everyday if I could read more

My Pie Pizza - Dothan, AL - Two topping pizza and a Hot Hawaiian Pie - Pizza Near Me - Dothan, Alabama

Very good service, outstanding staff and the pizza was excellent. Family atmosphere and enjoyed just sitting back and relaxing

Excellent, excellent pizza. Thin crust, and just the right amount of toppings. Love the sauce. One pizza easily feeds two, maybe three people. Finally found a great pizza joint in Alabama. Reasonable prices. Moved from Conn 2 yrs ago and missed a decent pizza. There are one or two others but more expensive. read more

Don't wast your time or your money. I've trained to many restaurant servers to know how to treat customers. Waited 15 minutes in an empty line. I had to ask 3 different employees if we could order. I got ignored, told there were people in dinning room had been waiting longer than we had and of course the straight out "no". The pizza marginally better than the service. Limp and forgettable. read more

the food is great!!the the pizza is delicious we love the food here and the wings were great as well we have ordered here several times always delicious read more

I had an AMAZING cauliflower crust veggie pizza with Alfredo sauce instead of marinara. It was so flavorful. The cauliflower crust didn't take away from the usual "bready" flavor you'd expect from regular pizza. I ordered take-out. They do not currently offer curbside pick-up, so I went inside to pick up my order. Social distancing guidelines are in place. The employees wear masks, and their are hand sanitizer stations set up. The pizza was inside of a recyclable box, so that was a plus. I highly recommend people to visit My Pie Pizza if you want to be able to enjoy pizza in a vegetarian/vegan/gluten free way. read more

The best single person pizzas around the wiregrass! No one does it better than My Pie!

I ordered the chicken pesto pizza and my husband ordered calzone both of them were delicious. We would go again.

We have gotten my pie takeout 3 times now and we think it's the best pizza we have had in Dothan!!! Will def be back!

Okay first of I want to say the food is good but still the service in there was terrible 1. They burnt both our pizzas while they were on there phones 2. Even though they burnt out pizzas they charged us for 4 pizzas when we only got two 3. When they where giving us our drinks the girl just looked disgusted at I feel like was slightly judging us so just keep this in mind when you want to go to this place read more

Tried it a couple weeks after they first opened and it's became me and my fiancé's favorite pizza place. They have really good sized pizzas and calzones and you can't beat the price. I like the fact they also have cauliflower crust for anyone with gluten sensitivity. Hands down my favorite pizza place in Dothan!! read more

Just got the lunch special. Salad your way and a half of pizza of your choice. Absolutely delicious!!! Going back ASAP.

Ordered two pizzas for 7:50. Called before 7 and asked them to add something. They told us our pizzas were already done. Over an hour early. When we picked them up, the cashier said "oh they made these a while ago." We're aware sir. read more

This pizza is awesome and with Cauliflower crust and gluten fee it was perfect for me , the best pizza in town ! The staff is friendly and they have a good selection of beer and the only draw back there is a limit of 2 . Where are you Dothan this is at the top of the list ! read more

It is acceptable pizza. Not bad, not good, but average. Bit pricey when you consider that the pizzas are individually sized, but looking at it as a lunch, it is affordable (~11 for a pizza and drink). I wouldn't call it NY style, though. The ordering process was novel and kids in line behind us seemed to enjoy it. read more

We tried for first time. Pizza was good but the organization of pickup at the curb... well... there was nothing organized. I finally went in the store and paid and told them I was waiting. The APP shows my closest store is in Oklahoma??? When I sent a message to the company one of the boxes wanted me to select a location. My Dothan Alabama store was not listed. Actually there were only 8 stores to choose from ... all in other states. However, the website does show the Dothan store. So bottom line... Pizza was good. Takes a long time to get it so plan on 40 min or so. The curbside pickup is disorganized. The App can not be used to order if you live in Dothan. They need to take a look at Papa John's app. It is excellent! It tells you the on-going status of your order. They are also well organized for curbside pickup. Our last visit to PJs, I drove up and an employee came to my car within 3 minutes. The employee even called me by name. I hope My Pie gets there act together for the app and curbside pickups. If not, there is always PJs. read more

I decided to give my pie a second chance with a free pizza. It was sufficient for two people. I ordered mama meatza, expecting it to be loaded with meat, it was not. However, it was tasty. I put two pieces together and it made a nice size bite. The crust was thin and chewy. It was a little on the greasy side as my shirt can attest to. I was pleased all in all until later in the evening when my gut disagreed with my meal. Before I close I do want to say that they answered the phone promptly this time, courteously and professionally. I was given a pick up time and my food was ready when I got there. This is a big improvement over my first visit. I would have given them a 4 if there had been more meat on the pizza. All in all it's a pretty mediocre pizza place. That pizza by the way was a $10 pizza. I had four people to feed so obviously we were still hungry. So for 6 bucks I got a much bigger pizza, a lot more pepperoni and a nice crust at Little Caesars. We had pizza left over. read more

yo this place is so good at first i was like on the fence but like really in my heart of hearts this place is the best pizza place. i'm talking gluten free crust. i'm talking vegan cheese. i'm talking about the cauli. flower. crust. i wouldn't be disappointed to see this at the marriage supper of the lamb right next to the chick fil a nuggets read more

I have never ordered anything from this brand of restaurant before - so was skeptical. On top of it, we're restricted from eating in because of the pandemic. We ordered a medium pizza with pepperoni mushrooms and fresh tomatoes. It was the best I think I've had in years of pizza orders. Way better than the common chains around here. People were friendly. Glass separates you from the cook but let's you see exactly the ingredients you want. Great place. Nice folks. read more