If you call it pork roll, we can still be friends... but just know you're wrong. This is a Taylor ham, egg, and cheese on a plain bagel. New Jersey breakfast royalty, mounted on a carb throne. Salt and pepper? Nah. Just ketchup. This little bagel sammich is a certified banger. The Taylor ham is salty and crispy, the egg is good, and the cheese melts into everything. And that plain bagel? Soft on the inside, just enough chew on the outside, holding together a greasy masterpiece like a true professional. It's the kind of sandwich that requires two hands, extra napkins, and zero self respect. People here are super chill, the place is clean, and they crank these out fast because they know nobody's here to socialize, we're here to eat. There is seating, but heads up, the foot traffic is heavy and the tables are basically in the splash zone. If people walking inches from your face while you eat bugs you, grab it to go. Personally, I don't love being shoulder checked mid bite. Parking? A pain when it's packed, but what are you gonna do. Bottom line: one of the best spots for a Taylor ham, egg, and cheese. read more

My Bagel Heaven - Delis Near Me - Pequannock, New Jersey

BEWARE!!! Ask about price before you order. They charge you more then the prices listed on menu. I ordered a sausage and cheese bagel, which menu states is $6.50. Was charged $7.95 for meat, egg, and cheese. I told woman menu says meat and cheese is $6.50. I was then told the menu prices are not right. Told her they need to fix it. Then looked at my receipt and instead of being charged for chocolate milk, I was charged for a vitamin water. Very sketchy. Won't be back here again. read more

My go-to spot for my everything bagel, with bacon, egg, and cheese. The proportions are excellent. Bagels are excellent too! Highly recommended. read more

I come once or twice a week and love the bagel and coffee. I had a muffin one time an it was good too.

Please tell your store staff to toast the bagel before they put on the cream cheese! Mine was dripping all over the place not happy

Very disappointed in this place!!!! Use to be our family's go to spot for breakfast & more & has truly gone down hill since they expanded location. Horrible sandwiches nothing's fresh no attention to detail on what we request when we order our sandwich. Had to go back multiple times for them to fix it now all of their sandwiches are little of nothing for meat as far as Taylor ham sausage one slice of cheese pathetic excuse for a NJ bagel place!! read more

My Bagel Heaven - Pathetic excuse for NJ bagel spot especially Taylor ham - Delis Near Me - Pequannock, New Jersey

Bagels here are average for the area. On any weekend, You will be greeted by a super disorganized staff that trips over each other and gets easy orders wrong. Frustrating experience all around. Felt like a bagel nightmare read more

Such a joke.... one piece of cheese and taylor ham.... what are we doing? Quality has gone way down. Instead of paying for remodeling you need to do better with the food! read more

My Bagel Heaven - A joke of a THEC sandwich. - Delis Near Me - Pequannock, New Jersey

Horrible service. Overpriced. Counter staff answer phones before making a simple bagel. All very confused Bad experience read more

MBH is my favorite hometown bagel shop. The bagels are great, the service is good and they take pride in the way the store looks. The parking isn't always ideal but I'll come back in a little while and find a spot. The family loves their bagels too! Say hello to Alphonso when you order a sandwich from the grill! read more

So I've been going here on and off for years it's a hit or miss most of the time it's a mess and I'll tell you why I own a bagel store for 10 years I know a fresh bagels are and I know with Yesterdays day old bagels are on a few different occasions I have received or yesterday's bagels. I just ordered a salt bagel this morning. I'm in town I want to keep local businesses together and here if it only happens once or even twice I might let it slip but it happens multiple times and I've already tried the other places and never hit or miss because they don't make bagels. This store has no excuses. It's poor service Total chaos they have two paper signs one says pick up or delivery. No one knows what's going on they all walk around like who's next we don't know who's next people are standing in there with frustrated faces. It's it's really ridiculous and I'm sure the owner knows nothing and if you do as an owner, you should be ashamed of yourself, and that's just how it goes. I hope they get their stuff together. read more

My Bagel Heaven - A hockey puck day old bagel - Delis Near Me - Pequannock, New Jersey

Great, doughy bagels and coffee! The place is usually pretty crowded on weekend mornings but they keep it moving. Try the typical taylor ham, egg and cheese bagel, you won't be disappointed! Don't park in the front lot as it is very tight and people with large pick up trucks like the block the way. Park on the street, it's much easier to get in and out. read more

I came here on a Saturday morning and they were busy. However, I didn't have to wait that long for my order. I ordered an everything bagel toasted with butter and an everything bagel with taylor ham, eggs, and cheese. Everything came out exactly how we ordered it. I also ordered two iced coffees. There is a little bar area for you to make your coffee the way you want it. They have different flavor creamers and sugars to choose from which impressed me. The bagels are pretty average and generic. I give them four stars because they sell iced coffee some places don't and it's an inconvenience to me. read more

Don't order sliced lox, or if you do ask for extra they charge you $$$ but give you a singular slice of lox.... Service is okay, music is too loud in my opinion. Bagels were good it's the only reason I'd come back. read more

I went into bagel heaven as I always do and never had a problem yesterday I went in to order what I normally order an everything bagel not toasted with extra butter the cost is normally under 2.00 yesterday I got charged over 3.00 so I questioned it and the girl said they charge 1.00 more now for extra butter that is rediculous I probably won't be going in there again and I will go back to Kings kid across the street also I will spread the new news so knowone else gets ripped off. read more

Something has changed here. The dough is not the same and the bagels are puffy! Not Jewish style water bagels anymore. Used to put two eggs on the egg sandwiches today only one egg! If your business has problems don't cut corners and change the product! I'll have to find a new spot, sorry you had to go and change a good thing! read more

Stopped in for the first time in awhile and was disappointed to find this establishment has gone downhill significantly. Two thin slices of taylor ham are all you're getting on a THEC sandwich. I understand that it's difficult times for businesses everywhere (let's go Brandon!), but honestly I would rather you raise your prices than serve me an inferior product. Walk across the street to Kings Kid for a breakfast sandwich that is head and shoulders above this place. read more

My Bagel heaven is an ok bagel shop. If it were in Tulsa Oklahoma that would be great. Unfortunately it is in northern NJ, an area populated by many very good bagel purveyors. The staff might be friendly and helpfull......I can't tell, as they seem half asleep whenever I stop in. Fast food retailers who plan to serve breakfast should try to sleep at night, not on the job. Sleepy, grumpy people always seem rude to me. The bagels and hot breakfast sandwiches are rather good. Everything seems fresh. I am concerned that I see things that should be kept cold in warm areas, ( i.e. butter and cream cheese) and things that should be kept hot languishing at room temp. I am surprised these sort of food handling lapses pass inspection. All in all it's just passable. read more

they have the best bagels around, no one is even close. and the staff is always courteous and quick. In truth, only go there on weekends, so not sure about the weekdays, not sure if the same people or not. But they are correct on the name, it is a Bagel Heaven. Only reason not 5 stars is a bit pricey, but that's the only complaint. read more

Damn good bagels. Got a cinnamon raisin bagel with cream cheese and a lox cream cheese whole wheat bagel. Only issue I had was there credit card machine wasn't working and I was on time restraints. read more

Really good bagels and service here! The short, tan man-child making my sandwich gave me the heebie-jeebies just looking at him. As soon as I walk through the door, I can feel his dark and sinister presence. I'm positive that if we made eye contact, my soul would shatter. The taste of the Pequannock panic is unmatched. The women at the front are always super helpful and speedy. This bagel place is by far my favorite to go to in my busy mornings. read more

Great place to get some quick bagels, it's clean and got plenty of drinks to choose from & candy. Very clean and many choice of bagels. The parking isn't the best when it's busy but definitely a good place to get a bagel. read more

Never disappointing. I've tried the Cloud 9, bagels and flat bagels, always delicious. Try the tacos! OMG the tacos!

I just started going here since I work in the area. I always thought my area had the best bagels but these are amazing! The staff is fast & friendly. They have a great array of options and cream cheese in different flavors. My new go to place! read more

Like others I experienced the unsanitary practices here. I ordered the chicken salad. The cook had to smell it twice before he decided to put it on my bagel. I then went and looked at it. It must have been a week old along with the egg salad which just looked terrible. I ended up throwing it away and going somewhere else. I won't be going back. To bad; used to be a good place. read more

Great breakfast bagel sandwiches. I've never had a problem with customer service and never waited more than 15 minutes for my order. Love this place read more

Had a random desire to eat tacos the other day and was slightly desperate to find a taco place near my job that wasn't Taco Bell. Came about this place through my coworkers' recommendations. Such a strange thing to offer at a bagel shop! But their tacos are actually pretty decent for a quick lunch break! Nice size for a decent price! Knocked a star off for lack of variety. Really wish they had Al pastor as an option read more

This bagel place is my favorite out of all in North Jersey. Amazing staff. So friendly. Their bagels are delicious and so is everything on their lunch menu and tacos! And the coffee is good too!!!! read more

I don't know what just happened, but we just had the worst service in a while. Girls didn't understand our order and we got one bagel with three fourths of a bagel. Hope things get better. read more

never had anything bad here.. I call I'n the morning and pick up... really good Taylor ham and egg sandwiches... good scallion and veggie cream cheese. read more

I'm between 4 and 3 stars. I love Bagel Heaven Bagels! The staff is alright.. some of them seem grumpy. I usually get an everything bagel and the last few times I got a bagel with barley any seeds on it. :( I've been having to ask and make sure they give me one with enough seeds. ..Sometimes the guy will ignore me and take other customers first. Bagels and Coffee = Awesome usually. Service = Depends who you talk to. The ladies are nice! :) read more

l was going to My Bagel Heaven for years. It looks like they are under new management now. The new management is much to be desired. You walk in there and they are constantly playing a channel from their own country that no one else watches or wants to watch, but them. There's always a language problem w/these people. They don't want to learn English any better than the little they know now. They think they can run a business w/the little English they know and just get by with whatever problems that occurs because of it. I've always gone in there for a taylor ham, egg, & cheese on a seeded rye bagel. There's this one taller man who can never learn what "seeded rye" is. Month after month, he just can't learn. There's a woman who works on the register that always has to pick out the right bagel for him. When you watch him, he just gives this head shrug (duh) and then either asks someone else for what they want or stands around, instead of learning his trade. You'd figure he would have learned after a few months. No! You'd also figure that management would want to know what's going on. No way! He doesn't care. Nobody is minding the store. Last week, I went in and asked for a taylor ham, egg, & cheese on a seeded rye but make it a double. Again, this guy doesn't know what it is. After all the trouble of someone showing him what it is, they they made a single. It was $8.00. It was a single. I asked - "This is a double?" They had to make it over again. Today, I went in there for my usual single taylor ham, egg, & cheese on a seeded rye. This same guy again didn't know what again and held up a 1/2 loaf of toast (looking like an idiot) LOL!. I shook my head - "No, that's not a seeded rye bagel. I need a seeded rye, seeded rye". Well, they messed up and made a double. The price was $7.10. When I asked the girl why this 'double' (which I didn't order) is $7.10 and last weeks double which I ordered was $8.00, then all of a sudden, the cook (who I never spoke to before) came over and called me a F'ing A hole. That's the last thing you do instead of asking the customer what the problem is. I was going to tell the cook what he told me but I kept my cool and asked him why am I being charged a different price for a double, which I didn't order, and last weeks double was $8.00. He didn't know what to say. He gave me $3.00 back. There were no apologies. Another words, to make a mistake is human, to forgive is not my policy! What farm did they pick these clowns off of? What a bunch of low lives! I'll be spreading the word about this place. Hopefully, they will go out of business. You don't treat your customers like crap especially when it's your fault to begin with! Learn English! Watch what goes on in your own business instead of being A hole's yourselves! read more

Good bagels but very slow service. Food items not as fresh as they used to be. Good example is the lox spread. Old!!

Absolutely the best bagel place in town, and I have tried at least five other locations. Friendly, quick as long as it isn't too busy, and delicious bagels that are chewy, the way they're supposed to be. Highly recommended! read more

I agree with the other two reviewers, that there is good and bad here. Yes the staff is less friendly then at King's Kid across the street but the bagels are much better. My biggest issue is the prices, I got a bagel with cream cheese and a pint of OJ for $5.xx, this seems very expensive. The parking stinks! read more

Best bagels around. The everything bagels have seeds on both sides unlike most other bagel shops and are my favorite. Egg sandwhiches here are always delicious and so is the cream cheese. Service here is always good and the workers always are friendly! read more

Love slidin' a sweet bagel onto my enormous beef machine. It's all day fun, roddy doddy doo!