Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Muddy Toe’s Cafe

    4.5 (6 reviews)
    Closed • 11:00 am - 3:00 pm, 5:00 PM - 7:00 PM

    Muddy Toe’s Cafe Photos

    More like Muddy Toe’s Cafe

    Recommended Reviews - Muddy Toe’s Cafe

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    1 year ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 1
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    It was a lovely cafe and good food but overpriced with small portions. Owner is nice and has a nice gift shop across the street.

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Muddy Toe’s Cafe

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Amarin Coffee USA - Couple of coffees and pastries . Amazing place with great people

    Amarin Coffee USA

    4.7(294 reviews)
    34.8 mi
    •$

    From the moment you step in the door at Amarin, you're immersed in the cozy comforting aroma of:…read morebutter. You can literally smell the pastries in the air, which is maybe even better than seeing them waiting for you in the bakery case. On a recent weekend morning we opted for the blueberry cheese Danish, which was perfectly executed, with plenty of juice berries and lush cream cheese filling on top of a flaky, crisp and yes buttery Danish dough. Perfection. I'd love to come back and try a croissant, which look amazing on top of being HUGE. For drinks we opted for the Vietnamese milk coffee, which was just the right balance of sweet, bitter and creamy. It's a distinct experience on Chincoteague but holds its own against plenty of bakeries on the mainland!

    Fantastic coffee. Fantastic staff. Fantastic pastries (read: croissants). My family and I visited…read moreChincoteague last weekend and decided to try this place after seeing all of the great reviews and boy were we glad to have visited. This place became a staple for us for just the few days we were in Chincoteague and there are no regrets. Coffee: Both myself and my partner ordered the Vietnamese iced milk coffee and it was out of this world delicious. This drink was a bit strong but that didn't deter me at all from ordering it every day we visited the coffee shop because it was that good. Pastries: my family ordered the butter and chocolate croissants and they were fantastic! Huge, buttery and chewy inside and flaky on the outside, the perfect combo! We also ordered their chocolate chip cookies on a whim and were pleasantly surprised at how tasty they were. Normally coffee shops aren't know for their cookies but these were the perfect chocolate chip cookies - thick, the right amount of chocolate and not too sweet. We also ordered their peach and pineapple slushie and it was super tasty. I'm not a fan of slushies as they taste pretty watered down but this drink was fresh and had the perfect balance of tart and sweetness! This place is a MUST if you're visiting Chincoteague!

    Photos
    Amarin Coffee USA - Expect to wait in line during high season

    Expect to wait in line during high season

    Amarin Coffee USA - Chocolate croissant and coffees

    Chocolate croissant and coffees

    Amarin Coffee USA - Outdoor covered seating

    See all

    Outdoor covered seating

    Clove and Cedar Coffeebar - Store front!

    Clove and Cedar Coffeebar

    4.9(36 reviews)
    70.3 mi

    Clove and Cedar is an absolute gem!!! I stopped in after shopping at the Bethany farmers market…read morewith 4 elementary school boys (not my kids) who, unbeknownst to me, knew exactly how to order at a coffee shop. They ordered strawberry shortcake matchas and iced vanilla milks and specified for the woman taking their orders exactly how many vanilla pumps they wanted and what type of milk alternatives to request. The barrista took their orders like they were adults (while eying me to make sure this was all ok). We also got 2 pastries to split. We got some kind of coffee cake and a chocolate chip muffin. I didn't get to try either as the boys wolfed them down and left a mess of crumbs bc they aren't actually as bougie as their orders. (sorry about the crumbs if you are reading this, Clove and Cedar). The little boys said it was the best matcha they ever had - and apparently they are experts. hahahaha. I am in Lower DE every week and had completely given up trying to find a decent matcha here bc every place I've tried just sucked. When I saw the color of the dark green matcha at Clove and Cedar, I knew immediately it was going to taste great. I got the Ube Vanilla Matcha and it was perfecto!!! Honestly, I can't even explain how excited I am that I found this great place. I wish it was closer to Dewey or Rehoboth as there is nothing up here like it. I def will make the drive again to Bethany soon!!!

    Cute little coffee shop. Was really packed when we went but they handle the crowd well. I took off…read moreone star based off of the matcha. They have multiple matcha drinks on their menu but I did not really like the strawberry matcha I got. It tasted very watered down. My friend and husband also agreed. I make matcha at home and thoroughly enjoy a matcha at other cafes but this one didn't do it for me. The mint mocha was really good but didn't really taste like mint. I loved the coffee cake!!

    Photos
    Clove and Cedar Coffeebar - Bar seating while you wait for your order

    Bar seating while you wait for your order

    Clove and Cedar Coffeebar - Yum!!

    Yum!!

    Clove and Cedar Coffeebar - Seats for waiting

    See all

    Seats for waiting

    Lorraine's Snack Bar - Hush puppies

    Lorraine's Snack Bar

    4.1(48 reviews)
    0.2 mi
    •$$

    I was expecting an epic crab cake since crabbing is listed as a main economic source for the…read moreisland. But the sandwich had zero lump meat and little seasoning. I didn't even taste Old Bay which should be a staple ingredient used by all eating establishments on the Chesapeake. It was busy and the staff was hustling so we could make our ferry trip home but the fries we ordered didn't get done in time. Any restaurant first and foremost needs delicious food. If Lorraine's could leverage their crab industry to serve outstanding crab dishes such as crab imperial, au gratin, crab bombs, then it could become a destination worth visiting and retuning to.

    We came to the Island on a Saturday afternoon. We stopped in a gift shop that gave us a tip to eat…read moreNOW at Lorraine's before the next ferry came in. I am glad we listened to the tip. We were sat immediately but soon after it 100% was full. Service was friendly and quick. We started with Crab Dip and hush puppies. Both were delicious. Lots of crab in the dip and a perfect dip to bread ratio. So important! Menu is of course heavy on seafood with a few other options and they had specials. I got the Coconut Shrimp special and the rest got flounder bites, Garlic Shrimp Special and a BBQ sandwich. The food itself was good. The Coconut Shrimp was perfectly fried and soooo good. I got a salad as a side and it was a generous portion with lots of fresh veggies. I tasted the macaroni salad and it was way to sweet for my taste. But the Garlic Shrimp was good and so were the Flounder Bites. Fortunately my friends shared. Don't wait on your check - go right up to the register. There is a bathroom and AC. Simply decorated and friendly service. It was a good 1st stop because then we walked off the lunch.

    Photos
    Lorraine's Snack Bar - Crab Cake and Soft Shell Crab Combo with Sweet Potato Fries

    Crab Cake and Soft Shell Crab Combo with Sweet Potato Fries

    Lorraine's Snack Bar - Scott's Crab Fries

    Scott's Crab Fries

    Lorraine's Snack Bar - Cream of Crab Soup

    See all

    Cream of Crab Soup

    Muddy Toe’s Cafe - sandwiches - Updated October 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...