I only eat brisket typically once a year, and I've been buying it from my local grocery store…read more Problem is the past few times and seems to be hit or miss as to whether or not it's tender or kind of like shoe leather. I was under the assumption that maybe I was doing something wrong, or perhaps my crock-pot was shot and overcooking things. So this year, having just heard of butcher boys I purchased a 3 and 1/2 lb tip. Crock-Pot for 7 hours and oh my gosh it was perfect. Now that I know this place exists and I've had a good experience, I'm going to head back over and try a few more things, like for example I see on their website that they have duck breast. That will absolutely be my next purchase.

My daughter spent $90 on this pick of fat! Stay away! Try to support a small biz and got burned!read more

Ok... let me tell you about myself.. I love good meat. I smoke competition grade meat or Iberian…read moreribs. I spent over 20 years as enlisted military member, and I still work for Uncle Sam. I said to myself one day I'm not going to eat crappy food anymore. I found Sam's butcher shop online, and I order 10 pounds of his meat. I've so far had some of his boneless ribs and sausage, and I'm a fan.

11-9-2021 Sam's apparently hasn't been in business for a few…read moreyears. As per the neighbors who I asked concerning the obviously vacant space,

Argh, Yelp, why do you insist on editing and entry based on the domain name of the URL? this is not…read moreReam Time Farms. It is Four Story Hill Farm. Yeesh, pay some attention! Anyways, let's not get my rant to ruin the review. Four Story Hill Farm is a very small operation but they bring some of the best raised meats to some of the higher end and distinguished restaurants in the country. Their beef is awesome and I recently tried a 110 day aged version. Talk about a unique flavor profile. Ever heard of milk fed poularde? Me neither but it looks like one of their breed has taken on to it like cattle do. Makes for interesting flavor profiles. Well raised animals, in a caring small operation, with the end product being tasty and flavorful

This place is amazing. Some of best chicken and veal I have ever had. I found out about them from…read moreThe French Laundry when it said that is where they procure their chickens. I called the owner, Slivia, and she has been great. I strongly recommend them

I was very disappointed in the 2 ribeyes I bought today. There was so much fat on them. The steak…read moreI had was about 45 percent fat. My wife's steak wasn't as bad but still had a lot. I had been buying steaks from them for over 10 yrs but I am not sure if they had an apprentice butchering the meats today (Sunday) this was almost half of my steak

Quality meat, chicken, pork and fish. Wish they were still in Scranton. I also like their salads.read more

I have read reviews from this shop. As I read the reviews, I understood the passion that this…read moreproprietor has for his work. As we entered the shop, the amount of different available items, was overwhelming. We looked over the cases, made some choices from the frozen meats, and told the lovely woman behind the counter, what we were looking for. She listened, and as soon as the butcher was finished with the prior customer, he prepped our fresh cut ribeyes. We chatted with him and he made a few suggestions, according to our choices. We were thinking the same thing! He seemed pleased that we were so tickled that he approved. This shop is a breath of fresh air. Someone who takes true pride in what they do!

Great service. Not sure of his name but the owner was so nice and we had a great chat and he even…read moregave me insight on the cut that I had and everything. Meat was amazing quality and I will be coming back every time I make the trip up to the Poconos. Lots of exotic meats, even had kobe ribeye which I did buy. Can't wait to come back!

I'm never disappointed ordered some food pigosh and the fish and Italian pasta all are delicious…read more I find something new every time I go there I love this place

I had an amazing chicketta sandwich on a hard roll. The chicketta had the perfect amount of spices…read moreand the relish was the perfect compliment! The roll was fresh - crusty on the outside and soft on the inside. As a side, I had the potato salad. This is one of the best potato salads I've ever had. Absolutely delicious! My compliments to the chef. So excited about this amazing market in Old Forge!!!!

Growing up Polish-AmerIcan in northeastern Pennsylvania, smoked kielbasa was on the dinner table…read morefor every major holiday, be it Easter, Thanksgiving, Christmas, and even some everyday dinners, just because. And, while there are many meat shops in the Scranton area, my family's choice for kielbasa has always been Schiff's even though it's about 20 miles from their home. Now, having moved away from Pennsylvania decades ago, I haven't been able to find kielbasa that is as good as that from Schiff's from my childhood memories. So, during a recent trip "back home", I stopped by Schiff's to stock up on kielbasa. Our daughter also requested that we pick up its necessary accompaniment, horseradish. My family loves both the regular white horseradish (spicier) and the red one that is prepared with beets. Schiff's also has an excellent selection of other meats: a deli with sliced meats, cheeses, and specialty salads; fresh fruits and vegetables; ethnic foods such as pirogies; and more.

I purchased 6 lobster tails from Schiffs for the holiday. It was quite expensive, but a family…read moretradition to have lobster for New Year's Eve. After cooking the tails, and beginning to eat them they had a strong ammonia smell. It was the most disappointing dinner experience. Luckily we did not eat enough to get sick.

They made excellent meat sticks made from my deer! A little pricey, but it is a time-consuming…read moreprocess.

Stopped by and picked up my smoked cheese and smoked spareribs.. The steaks looked excellent will…read moretry the next time I'm in the area.

Dropped off my first ever bear that dressed was 82 lbs. paid $165 to have it caped and very basic…read morecut. I asked for loins to be whole and one entire loin is missing! Very disappointed that it was "left out" of my box but how can I prove it now? They will just say it was in there. But it was not. Very disappointed.

I've been brining my deer Kevin at naugles deer cutting for seven years. I have been extremely…read morehappy with the excellent and quick service. He makes a huge variety of products from kielbasa to hot dogs to snack sticks. His shop is large well equipped and spotless. I have toured the entire shop several times and never seen anything dirty, I butcher my own deer but use Kevin to make the meat I don't use into great food. I usually have over 100 pounds of product done here annually. Last week I brought in 110 pounds of meat and had 190 pounds of finished product made. It was done in three days!,,, my advice try the cheddar cheese dogs and kielbasa .

I thought this place would be somewhere between Schiff's and Wegman's. Walking in, it struck me…read moremore as a local meat market than a place you'd go out of your way to visit. Just to give an example, the Meat Locker (long closed) had some creations that photographed well and were genuine specialties. Here, the name of the game seems to be ethnic tastes, namely special types of sausage. Main knock for me is that they sold me 3 choice filets at 26.99 per pound. I think this is outrageous considering Schiff's probably still sells the entire tenderloin for $16/lb or less. The cuts were low-end coming from what I call the "tail" of the tenderloin, actually with a vein of gristle. They also stock frozen local pierogis which I can't fault them on the quality of, but I cooked a dozen of them today and will note that they were a bit too bready and grainy for my taste. I also bought fresh kielbasa which I didn't get a chance to cook but looked great. There are tons of exceedingly positive reviews on another platform singing the praises of Bosak's, but I can't find many specifics and my experience puts it into more of an emergency/novelty category for those who live further downvalley.

Great place and friendly staff. Their meats are amazing . The homemade pierogies are to die for.read more