Everyone was great and there were many choices. Unfortunately, we couldn't finish the ice cream…read more Neither of us enjoyed the... consistency? Flavor? It was different than we've had before. Too sweet? We can't put our finger on it but we wouldn't go back. It was consistently busy and they have great reviews so it must be more due to preferences. We just happen to leave disappointed.

This place is really awesome. The staff was really friendly and knowledgeable of the ice cream…read morethey have. They took time to answer questions about the flavors and the portions where gene

I have been a fan of Herrell's my entire life! Before and after renovation and all! They always…read morehave a great assortment of flavors and I always love to look for their most unique options! They cater to all types of dietary issues and have dairy free and sorbets. Even their cookie and cake selection usually has at least one GF item. Their board also displays if any flavor has wheat, nuts, or eggs in it, which is much appreciated! The staff is always knowledgeable and friendly. The line can be out the door at times, but the staff work diligently to keep it moving. The seating can be tight but it's a nice place to hang out if they have the space. Fun wall hangings and always their signature bears keeping us all company! The only downside to this place is that it is so well frequented, as it should be, that some flavors sell out quickly. It will be there one day and then not the next, so get it while you can. Or alternatively, you can email them and special order a flavor you love that you keep missing. I love that they do this! It takes time, so plan ahead, but it is so worth it! And although I want people to keep this business running, I.e. keep the money flowing so they keep in business... I have to also say, don't forget to come in and get your free birthday sundae!! Maybe just bring a friend who will purchase their own item.

Good selection of flavors. The cookie dough vanilla base was really good but there was to much…read morecookie dough for me it was overpowering. They have ice cream cakes and a selection of baked goods here too. Indoor seating available. Employees are very nice here.

The workers are always so friendly. The ice cream is so creamy and there are tons of flavors to…read morechoose from. The farm is nice to eat your ice cream at. There's so much space and the line goes by quick.

Staff were very friendly. Ice cream was super creamy with a lot of brownies. We also had the…read morewatermelon Italian ice that was also delicious. This is our go to ice cream place.

I recently visited an ice cream shop and was disappointed. The ice cream wasn't very tasty and…read moremelted extremely fast. Additionally, the prices were quite high for what you get. I wouldn't recommend it if you're looking for quality.

Absolute dump! Absent owner, outside the place looked abandoned, attracting tons of trash, nope,…read morenever again. This place is going to close, seriously.

Was cutting through town and stopped for an ice cream before my evening plans…read more Line at the time wasn't terribly long but can get long quickly. I ordered a blueberry milkshake which was gone in a blink of an eye. Took a bit to get though, there were a couple large groups a head of me and by the time I got mine the line behind me turned into a bottleneck as registers kept taking orders but couldn't push the ice cream out. Early season rust maybe? Overall, lots of flavors to choose from, worth the stop and wait.

One of my favorite local ice cream spots in the area. Always a large selection of flavors to…read morechoose from. Excellent seasonal service, friendly staff, along with good fresh homemade and quality always.

I love the ice cream here--tasty and well-made…read more Recently, had my birthday and was craving their ice cream. Decided to call first before I made a visit; you could not make a call for mailbox was full. So, I did an email and was told the flavors I wanted were available. I go there and the ice cream section is closed, Then, go to the other part--see ice cream flavors --NONE WERE THE FLAVORS I WANTED, Asked the woman when the ice cream section would open--said she can't open due to no water. I asked if she had idea when she would--said she had been waiting almost 6 weeks and had no idea when they would be there. First, if your ice cream section is closed-you should have a message that states this and have no time table for when you will be opened. Secondly. there is more than 1 plumber in this area, so why didn't they find another. I know they are frustrated losing money, but they must consider letting customers know they are not open.

Love the variety of flavors!! Delicious ice cream. Generous portions. Everything you'd want!read more

Been coming here for years and I'm happy to say the experience is still pretty much the same. Great…read moreviews, an actual working farm, and you can still buy fresh raw milk and beef cuts inside. One change since my last visit is that you now order the ice cream outside instead of inside. The line was long but it moved surprisingly fast. I do wish they offered samples and this time they were missing some of the more unique flavors that I like to try. Kiddo and Wifey got the Orange Pineapple, and they both loved it. The best part was that it wasn't overly sweet. It was light, fruity, refreshing, and the pineapple pieces throughout gave it great texture. My mom got half raspberry and half pineapple from the non dairy sorbet options and really enjoyed both. I went with the Black Raspberry Chip and it was so good. This is that old-school ice cream I grew up with. If you've had it before, you know exactly what I mean. That said, after trying another place just three minutes away, I do think that other ice cream is creamier. I personally prefer a creamier texture, while my wife likes a firmer scoop, so it really comes down to preference. One thing to know before ordering: when they say "one scoop" they really mean one scoop. Don't expect an oversized serving. There are chickens and cows roaming around the farm, which adds to the experience. The animals looked happy, and while seating is limited, there are both indoor and outdoor places to sit and enjoy your ice cream. Overall, this is still a great stop and one I've enjoyed for years. This place is well worth visiting for the farm atmosphere, beautiful views, and classic homemade ice cream.

Flayvors of Cook Farm is a farm-based ice cream shop that combines homemade ice cream with a…read morerelaxed countryside setting. We walked up to a spot where the experience feels different from a typical ice cream stop because you are surrounded by farmland, open views, and even the cows that contribute to the farm's products. The environment is just as much a part of the visit as the dessert itself, with picnic tables scattered across the grass and a view of the fields stretching out beyond the parking area. The biggest highlight for us was the ice cream itself. The texture is creamy and rich without feeling overly heavy, and there is a good balance between classic flavors and more unique seasonal options. We tried a few of the creative flavors and found them to be what makes the shop stand out, with choices that you would not normally find at a standard ice cream shop. The more unusual options were interesting to sample, while the traditional flavors were still strong enough to keep coming back for. The portions were generous, and the quality of the ice cream felt consistent across the different scoops we ordered. The farm setting adds another layer to the experience. Sitting outside and enjoying ice cream while looking out over the fields makes it feel more like a destination rather than just grabbing dessert. We noticed families settling in at the picnic tables, kids running around the grass, and a general sense of calm that you do not get at a typical scoop shop. It is also a nice spot for families since there is more to see than just the ice cream counter, with the farm animals and open space giving the visit a fuller feel. The main thing to consider is that it can get busy, especially during warmer weather and peak dessert hours. The lines move at a reasonable pace, but the popularity means it may take longer during the busiest times. Parking and seating can also become more limited when the farm is crowded, so arriving earlier or visiting on a weekday can make the experience smoother. Flayvors of Cook Farm is one of those places where the location, atmosphere, and food all work together. The ice cream is the main reason to visit, but the farm setting makes the experience feel more memorable than a regular dessert stop. It is the kind of place that fits naturally into a warm afternoon outing, offering a treat that feels rooted in its surroundings.

Sold on location and the fact that they have muffin tops. I've driven past here hundreds of times…read moreand never pulled in. Came in for ice cream tonight and instead I bought a cider slushy and a blackberry muffin top with cream cheese which didn't stand a chance. Only place knew that sold them was Rice Fruit Farm in Wilbraham and I have boycotted them. There was live music which was nice as well as some animals and a play place. Extra parking in the back. Ice little gift shop. Definitely a place for everyone.

I had a feeling this would happen, and it did. When Rice's bought The Apple Place they brought…read moretheir cheap frozen Sysco food service pies with them, and slapped a premium price on them. I ordered two pies this year for Thanksgiving, and they were not the same pies that I had the year before. It's a shame. No goddamn way am I paying like $40 for two cheap mass produced pies again. I think Atkins actually makes their own.