I LOVE MR PIZZA SLICE And to that end, I was surprised by the reviews. Mr Pizza Slice is one of two viable pizzas in Red Bank, the other being Giannis. The others? Well its New Jersey so they aren't going to be complete garbage but by local standards they are. To those who warmly reminisced of the "old" Mr Pizza Slice under the old owners, I say to you: HA! HA HA! The old Mr Pizza slice is the dump of which you speak. I went to the old Mr Pizza Slice years ago and asked for a pepperoni slice. They cut a plain slice off, took out a bag of Hormel pepperoni slices, and put those slices on top of the plain slice. Like wow that's the secret to how it all comes together huh!? Also, that WAS the fanciest slice you could get. There were no specialty slices, good sandwiches, or any of that. THAT place was the dump. Then this guy who wears a "legalize marinara" t-shirt comes in and changes all that. He brought the good pizza, the specialty pies. He brought amazing sandwiches to the menu. Seriously, have you tried their sandwiches? They might be the best in Red Bank. He brought the delivery. I once ordered Mr Pizza Slice from my couch and it came 8 minutes later and it was also the best pizza I'd ever had from there. I'm still figuring that out. I'd probably agree that the place could use a regular schedule for someone to actually check the dining area to see if needs to be wiped down. Like, seriously I know you guys like making pizzas but I also don't like sitting waist deep in crumbs that fell out of someone's mouth. I haven't posted a review in a while, but when I think criticism or praised is deserved, I bring it. Try Mr Pizza. Start with a plain pie and tell me it's not one of the best in the area. If you don't think so get the hell out of Red Bank! read more

After a visit in Red Bank, I stopped by this pizza place, for some appetizers to go. Although I did not try their pizza, which may be good, this review is based on only these 3 items I tried. The mozzarella sicks, chicken tenders, and garlic knots. I was not that impressed with these apps. The chicken tenders with the honey mustard sauce was the best of them all. I enjoyed them. Second I would rank the mozzarella sticks ; as just average. Not that bad but not that good. And the garlic knots weren't good in my opinion. Very bland and dry, even with the marinara sauce. Overall, this was just average pizza appetizers. It got the job done of satisfying hunger, but not my favorite place. Maybe next time I'll try their pizza, and see if it stands out more. read more

See all

Really really awful service. No one cared that there was a problem with the food. Owner must just throw anybody on schedule to staff the place. Some of the worst food, really upsetting to waste almost $40. We threw all of the food in the garbage after tasting it, it was that bad. read more

I have been going to Mr Pizza Slice for 54 years. Steve - the previous owner was a zen master pizza of the Jersey slice pizza - minimal cheese perfect amount of sauce, crust thinness that had depth in every bite . I often told Steve , " it's the best pizza in NJ " Mic Drop! I've been going to the rebooted re-ownership of Mr Pizza slice since it was taken over. I am sorry to report the quality has been steadily declining since Steve sold the place. Initially they had his pizza recipe on the menu and their own recipe. They phased out Steve's recipe eventually. Mistake. Today Plain slices can't stand up folded in half lengthwise - this is pizza 101. Epic fail - my last 4 visits. The pizza Fold fail is one thing, cheese and sauce avalanche off the pie itself- upon lifting - worse than Fold Fail. I'm feeling generous with 3 star review - if I could - I'd give it 2.25 stars. Bring back Steve read more

Excellent pizza and reasonably priced. If you want a quick slice of za, this is the place.

Best DAMN PIZZA IN NJ! The classic small town pizza joint everyone flicks to! Great menu! Great prices! The kind of place kids would go to after school and at lunchtime and be able to afford pizza and a soda and still have change left. This place has to be a national landmark. It's been here since I was a little kid. The prices haven't changed that much it seems too it's very affordable and the quality is incredible. Family owned and operated, real pizza chefs. Thank you Mr. Pizza Slice. read more

Mr Pizza Slice - Pizza, sausage subs, burgers and more pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Red Bank, New Jersey

See all

Very solid pizza place. Came here on an afternoon on the weekend and certainly enjoyed the pizza and garlic knots quite a bit! Price point is pretty par for the course and the specialtslice I had was really excellent. My friends and I really enjoyed our time here and I super enjoyed the marinara sauce for dipping, very tasty! read more

Mr Pizza Slice - Pizza Near Me - Red Bank, New Jersey

Wow. Low grade everything! Cheese sauce crust below average and not even worth the seemingly value pricing. Amazing how this place survives in NJ!! read more

Terrible customer service was just told our order was cancelled cause they did not have a guy to make a cheesesteak so pizza order was cancelled as well .. no phone call. Second disappointment with this company we will no longer order here. read more

One of the worst pizza slices I've ever had in my life. Not even my 6 year old daughter had a second bite of hers. It was cardboard and tasteless. Ownership must improve its recipe and presentation. Front door was open and the restaurant was cold to where my daughter qas shivering. We left after 1-2 bites. Please put some money into the bathroom, which wasn't sanitary, has a 15+ year old toliet seat, dark, tasteless. Come on ownership, you guys gotta improve as Red Bank is a great town but Mr. Pizza Slice does not deliver outside of your loyal contingent. read more

Ordered a pie with my contractor on thursday... The absolute worse Pizza I ever tasted in My Life.. It was delivered cold and like eating cardboard....got with half sausage...all of the sausage was off the pie into the corner of the Box........I have photos .....terrible... Will never ever order from them ever again.. read more

Mr Pizza Slice - a whole pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Red Bank, New Jersey

What a dump. Every table was filthy. It was around 6:00 on a Friday night. Only one other table was occupied. Pizza was tasteless and extremely thin. Probably the worst pizza I have ever had. We were pressed with time and a guy from yestercades recommended this pizza place because it was right around the corner. read more

Mr Pizza Slice - Plain - Pizza Near Me - Red Bank, New Jersey

They have huge pizzas that are really quite good and a great value (20 inches!). If that wasn't enough, they have some of the best chicken wings in the area. Their french fries are more akin to thick potato chips, very unique and worth getting as well. Always quick delivery, worth a shot! read more

Just moved to the area and received a flyer for this establishment in the mail. We were very excited about ordering dinner!! Well the person taking the order was So Very rude that I was flabbergasted!!! I ended up Not ordering anything from them. There's plenty of places to choose from. So if you call them, expect a Very rude conversation. Only wish I had gotten his name. read more

Hello Nick, I wanted to let you know about an issue I had with an order. I emailed with no response. I ordered on-line via your website-order number 5374247. After I placed the order I was called in about 10 minutes to inform me that your store was out of the fried Sicilian slices and if I wanted something else. I agreed to fried ravioli. After waiting a while about 40-50 mins I was delivered a chicken parm sandwich, buffalo wings, garlic knots, and the fried ravioli. I asked where the 2 pizza I ordered were and the driver looked confused. He told me they didn't give him any pizza. He told me that they forgot the pizza at the store. He said he would go get it and be back. After the driver left I called the store to tell them they forgot the soda. After about 20 mins the driver returned with 1 cold round pizza and the soda. I said where is the other pizza. The sicilian one. He said there was only one. I then called the store back and asked where the pizza was and the mozzarella sticks. The person I spoke to told me that he informed me when he called that they were out of mozzarella sticks and that I would be refunded. I said that was not true and I don't recall that conversation. I than asked where the other pizza was and they had no idea. I was told that I would get some store credit for the pizza. I asked for a refund. I was then told that they can't refund the pizza because they couldn't just refund one item. He said if I refunded you the pizza it would mean that I would be getting free food. I then asked if he couldn't refund my pizza the how was he going to refund my money for the mozzarella sticks. He didn't really have an answer because it seems like they never were going to do anything. I said I wanted to speak with a manager and I was told there was no one there who was a manager. I then asked for the owner and in about 10 mins I was finally given a number to call 732-618-XX77. In that time I looked on the website and found that nick was the owner and I said can you tell nick what happened because I am now asking for a full refund. The reason was because all the food is now cold and I still don't have my order and I was offered no real solution. It seems like they had a hard time fixing an issue. Please see the attached receipt. Please refund me 81.72 as this was a terrible experience and I did not get what I ordered. Please give me a call if you would like, Anthony read more

The pizza slice I had was very bad. No tase at all. The place is dirty inside. All tables and chairs are sticky (ieeeee) ...come on guys to clean up the tables is not difficult. No toilet paper in the bathroom!!!!!!! Really???? And please repairs your bathroom lock ...once you go inside and you lock the door it's very hard to unlock it. It's broken!? read more

There hot dogs and fries are on point!" I come here everytime I come down to help out work at carlos bakery right around the corner...

Memories, that's what Mr. Pizza Slice has for me. I went to RBC, and we would sneak off campus at lunch for a hot slice and a plate of round fries. Oh yes, the round fries - heavenly memories. I returned here with my teenager this summer. I raved abut the authentic Mr. pizza slice, and insisted he needed to try the authentic jersey shore pizza experience! Nothing changed (except me). It's a rude experience, as you stand at the counter and wonder if the man behind the counter news you're there (he does). You better know what you want - and speak up. Find a table, and clean it off. The slice was marginal, but the fries just as wonderful as I remembered! My son wasn't impressed with the cardboard slice, but loved the crispy coin fries. 2 slices, 2 fries and 2 cokes = $20, served with a bunch of grumpy regardless if ordered! Go for the fries! read more

Mr Pizza Slice - Their signature round fries = YUM! - Pizza Near Me - Red Bank, New Jersey

See all

Terrible service my son and I walk in, ignored. Standing waiting as a group of teenage girls walk in behind us, they service them and ignore us. Like WTF? What kind of business ignores its clients? read more

$3.25 for a slice of pepperoni when a whole pie costs $1.60 to make. Dough is different every person that makes it and either cracker crust or doughy. No yeast flavor that goes with aging. Dead in the water no other joints on Broad Street so you are left with expensive mediocre pizza. read more

Best fucking pizza in New Jersey I'd sell my newborn for this place. I love you mr pizza slice

Change the name. A disgrace to the once great Mr. Pizza Slice. One of the worst slices I've ever had.

Very good. No flop. Couldn't ask for a better few slices and some knots on a random day. Def will be back when in Red Bank

I was lured by the view of pizza varieties from the sidewalk window and the fact that I was starving.. so it was a by chance visit and I will not be chancing it again. They have good variety, but the slices were tired by 6pm. I selected the ziti pizza after asking if it was dried out, and my instincts were right; dried out lunch leftovers for $5 a slice. While waiting for my slice I went to the bathroom and noticed there was no soap which means every employee in the place didn't wash their hands, because like the pizza, it was bone dry. When the pizza did arrive at the table, the ziti fell off and on to the dirty table and the slice ripped into two. I would have given them two stars, but there is no way this place would pass a health inspection. read more

I'm sorry but u can't call it a rutgers fat cat if the ingredients are nothing like a true rutgers fat cat. Maybe call it a red bank fat cat. Rutgers fat cat has 2 burgers, french fries lettuce tomato onion and ketchup. Other than that the selection of food looked great. read more

Worst two slices of pizza that I have ever eaten. Terrible sauce and cheese. The crust was nice and thin but horribly burned. read more

Visited here back in 2018 while getting an autograph from Kevin Smith at Jay and Silent Bobs secret stash. The folks that worked at the stash told me and the family to visit for great pizza and they were right. All their mixes of pizza with different things are delicious. I will be back next time I'm around the area. read more

Its amazing to be how much garlic was in there tomato sauce. If it were up to me, I would rename the place Mr. Garlic Slice. I got a Margherita slice and a chicken farm slice for 7.75. Upon my first bite, I was overwhelmed with garlic. If you like garlic this is definitely the place, if not - theres plenty of other options. read more

Solid 4 Stars. Been coming here for years. Some of my first memories were eating a few bites of their good pizza and large hot dogs. I go with two slices and a hot dog when I am in town. My favorite pizza in the area is Pete and Elda's in Eatontown. Followed by Federic's in Freehold. read more

Mr Pizza Slice - Jumbo sized Hot Dog, frosty shaved ice coke and a slice of thin crust pizza-Perfect! - Pizza Near Me - Red Bank, New Jersey

I was really happy the first time, although the pie was a bit undercooked. So I ordered again as I love the arrivals pie. This time I ordered it well done. Sadly still undercooked and a lot less arugala then the first time. The onion rings were also really soggy. read more

They should change the name. It's not even close to the same Mr. Pizza Slice anymore. The Italian hot dog at the old MPS was outstanding. I wanted to cry when I tried the new one. So sad. read more

This place literally went from the best pizza in Monmouth County to the worst. As far as I'm concerned, when Steve sold the business, Mr Pizza Slice died. The food is simply not good anymore. I'm gave 2 stars only because they did a nice job with renovations. But, ANY pizzeria has better food. I'm not joking. I always hope all small businesses will succeed. But, Me Pizza Slice will never see another dollar from me again. read more

First time - Last time! I stopped by before shopping for groceries at a nearby food store. And I observed the preparation as the person in charge of preparing the food came out from rear of store with no gloves holding a cell phone and proceeded to check his phone paging through information in front of me. The phone was placed on the preparation board as you would a food implement contaminating that area. The entire food handling was done without any hand washing nor the use of gloves protecting the food about to go in my mouth and no regard to my safety preventing any pathogens from contaminating food. The meat was handled with bare hands on the flat grill as was the cheese, garnishes and bread from start to finish. I would expect this blatant disregard and affront to clientele in a remote one horse town but never in Red Bank! The Red Bank Health Dept needs to show these restaurant workers about proper and safe aseptic food handling to these people. One can't help imagine what goes on in the back of store away from watchful eyes! I am sure Gordon Ramsay would turn livid! read more

one word...BANGIN'! the chicken balsamic sandwich is drool-inducingly delicious and the homemade bread that it's on is top-notch, the pizza was super good as well...and apart from the fries being thee coolest thang I've ever seen, they are also SOOOOO great tasting! We will definitely be back the next time that we're in town! read more

Has taken a major step backwards. Pizza was good I'll add. However went in at 645 on a friday night to order a few slices and was told "we have no plain slices". Ok so I asked if they will be making anymore and was told at least 35 minutes. Mind you, not 1 person in the place. When I said never mind I was told to wait and miraculously 4 plain slices appeared. Still a solid place but the imbeciles that work there will certainly put the place out of business. read more

I went here when visiting my family in Red Bank. I went to RBC, so this was a go to place after school. It doesn't seem any different, so perhaps this is just nostalgia to me. Good place for a slice in the old neighborhood. read more

Great pizza!!! I'm an Italian Red Bank local and I go there every week never duapions. Fanula! Pizza is bossin

Mr. Pizza Slice deserves more credit as one of the best pizza places in the Monmouth county area. I have been coming here since I was a kid and it never disappoints. My man Steve has got that thin crust pie down to an art. As with many other classic pizza joints, this place is all about the pie, and nothing else! The sauce is what makes this pizza, truly one of the best I've ever had. Very flavorful, with never too much cheese covering it up. Best part of the slice is at the top, little cheese, little sauce, and the crust with the perfect amount of char to it. This is a locals spot, with one of the best pies in the area. The regulars know that for sure! read more

Thank you Nick and Erica fabulous and delicious Italian buffet lunch you catered for our office. Everyone enjoyed it and raves how great everything tasted. So much food we had left overs for lunch the next day. Will definitely call upon your services again real soon. Diana FHO read more

Customers paid good money for the Red Bank Food and Wine Walk this past Sunday and Mr. Pizza Slice was not ready for their customers at start time. Yes, sounds like a small matter but if they are being paid for their service and they don't provide the agreed upon service, then they are not a well run business. If the food walk starts at 2 pm, don't turn customers away stating you are not read - to come back in 15 minutes. Shame on you. We had a party of 10 and you lost us as potential customers. read more