After visiting Living Treasures our party of five searched for a place to eat and came across Mr Pizza. The large pizza was quite good and I am still amazed by how inexpensive the bill was. Large drinks with refills $1.27. Pizza pricing from what seems like the good old days. The menu was quite diverse with equally impressive pricing. Also the service was quite fast. Be sure to visit and you will say "I'll be back". read more

We ordered 4 pizzas here on my birthday, Sept. 12. 1 wth no cheese. They were terrible, almost uncooked. Ruined the get together. 7 adults, 9 PCs of pizza are. I will never go there againm read more

Very well know spot around town and have excellent deals! On Monday's they have $5 - 8 cuts which is awesome. Recently I had their tuna fish sub and it was really good and only like $4.50. Their Italian subs are really good too. Sometimes if you order a pizza though in transfer if it slides it bunches up on one side. Make sure it's level. Everyone there always seems really friendly. And if you decide to sit inside it's really original and a nice little spot along a main road to have lunch. read more

Best pizza and prices in New Castle. Daily specials Monday through Saturday. Great owner and friendly staff.

You always can get a good deal at Mr. Pizza. Everything on the menu is delicious. If you like hot sandwiches, they frequently have deals on them. Their pizza is terrific, it's New York style. Recommended. read more

Best pizza, soup and subs in New castle! they've been open for as long as they have been for a reason, always consistent and great. read more

Mr Pizza - Pizza - Italian Near Me - New Castle, Pennsylvania

See all

Honestly. This is the worst pizza in town. They let it set out all day and heat the slices when ordered. No sauce taste, it was very dry and crust was like cardboard. Now I haven't had any of their other menu items so cannot comment on that. Back in the 90's their pizza was really good. This place needs better management. read more

A "hidden gem"! Definitely get your moneys worth, the portions are large, the price is affordable. Staff is helpful and friendly. Quick service also. Great all Around. read more

While their crust is amazing but they have screwed up my order the last three times. This last time they screwed it up twice. First had the wrong toppings and was barely baked and the replacement was raw in the center. We called to talk to a manager and we could hear someone in the kitchen "what's wrong with that one?" when they found out they were talking to us again. They did offer a refund for the pizza the screwed up twice but I didn't feel like waiting for them to come back again to pick it up. If they got their act together they would be amazing but as it stands it is time for us to find a new pizza place. read more

The meatball sub and the pizza is always delicious. The employees are always polite and friendly. Overall there's nothing to complain about about this place. Plus the food isn't that expensive either. an 8 cut pizza or a meatball sub is less than 16 bucks. read more

I ordered my sandwich extra crispy, it was delivered burnt-out the point the bread was black. I called and talked to the manager on 5/18/2024 around 11pm. The MANAGER told me that I ordered is extra crispy and that was a fine line between crispy and burnt. The manager was so arrogant, rude and dismissive that I just said...I guess I will not order again. Unbelievably rude, bad food and terrible service. It was very sad since this used to be a great place. The service is worse than the food. An apology can go a long way, just a suggestion. read more

the handmade pizza is one of my family's favorites. our 20 y/o daughter has been a very selective eater since birth, so her range of pizza references is very broad. she will choose mr. pizza first from a list of the many pizza places located in new castle. we are fairly equal in the amount of times that we eat in or have it delivered. we really do not have a preference as the service and environment is friendly & clean to eat in and the timing of delivery is very fast. the portion sizes are generous and the variety of menu options covers just about all areas generally associated with a 'pizza place'. the pizza slices are larger than most other places, but not overwhelming. the variety of soups offered throughout the week will cover just about anyone's taste (i order one of the soups every time). read more

Pretty solid pizza. I would say it's one of the better tasting pizzas in the city of New Castle. Not real cheesy, but the sauce is incredible and it tastes great. They have a nice dining area. read more

Brought my pizza out to me, was happy that it was 10 minutes less than what they said, only to find out that they had literally taken it out of the oven, threw it in a box, and walked it out to me. This isn't a good thing when you place the pizza in the passenger seat and realize all of the toppings are sliding off of the pizza and pool in the corners of the box. read more

I love this place one of the best pizza places in town I love to pick up orders here from door dash and I like to pick up a few slices for myself or a big pizza for my family. Also I believe they have a picture of my dog on their advertisement board. read more

Good NY style pizza and subs. Always pleasant and on time with you order. It has a nice seating area big enough for a large family and cozy enough for a quick bite. read more

Respectfully, this shit busting down thotiana. Straight gas package every time. Always fire.

the pizza and experience was laughably bad. we ordered a large cheese pizza w/ half pepperoni, they told us it would be 30 minutes before it's ready. we arrived 31 minutes later, and then waited 30 more minutes in the parking lot just to receive an abomination of a pizza. the pizza was not even sliced fully, it was shaped like an oval, soggy and soaking wet, essentially a huge clump of cheese, undercooked, the pizza could not have been tossed, toppings (sauce included) slid off immediately. "New York Style Pizza" more like "New Employees Made This Pizza Style" Mr. Pizza used to never miss, what happened to this place hahahaha read more

Mr Pizza - a person taking a slice of pizza - Italian Near Me - New Castle, Pennsylvania

See all

Love this NY Style Za! Consistently made and friendly staff.

Average at it's very best. Has potential. Yelp wants me to write more but I just cant muster anymore about this place. 1 bite everyone knows the rules..... 4.3 read more

Love this place! They have not only saved my lost kid but every pizza is heavy topped, super yum ...and I don't really love pizza! ( fam does) Also? The soups are incredible and nicest people work there! read more

Mr. Pizza is the bee's knees, The Wednesday special of Meat Ball Hoagie and drink for 3.35 is possibly the best deal in New Castle. The pizza isn't going to make you a believer in God but it's still really good and for the price you almost feel like you should pay more. Downside is the cups they give you to drink are small and you have to constantly go back up to the counter if you want more pop and if you're like old Chappy you can knock down several medium size cups of Diet Pepsi. Chappy read more

Absolutely amazing food... service is really good... sometimes it's a long wait to get your deliveries but it's worth the wait... also if there is ever a mess up, mistake, or food comes cold they will do whatever they can to fix it read more

I promise, this review is worth the read and a warning to everyone. First of all, if there was a rating less than 1 star, they would get it!!! Recently, I had a Sandwich, no. 11 on their menu board (a takeout order). Now, I'd had this sandwich before as an eat-in item and it actually was one of the best sandwiches of its type I'd ever had. I know every ingredient on it and it features 3 different meats. When I got the sandwich home (takeout order), the only thing on it was one (1) meat and LOADS of lettuce. What's that about!!!!!! That was a RIPOFF because I know what was supposed to be on it. There have been times at some other Establishments, that you similarly get LESS food for a takeout order than you do when eating inside. THIS IS WRONG and I am SO irritated you can't believe it. I'd rather the person making the sandwich just tell me they're out of certain ingredients at that time and at least give me the chance to select another item, rather than making this "lesser version" of that sandwich and stuffing it in the bag for me to take. I don't like their pizza anyway...but several of their sandwiches are really good. Either way, I'LL NEVER EVER GO THERE AGAIN FOR ANYTHING after this RIPOFF experience!!!! read more

Really good pizza, and the drive-through pick up window makes picking up your order really convenient. It's New York style pizza, and they have specials every day posted on the marquis out front. They have an awesome special on Mondays, I think it's half off medium pizzas when you get them for carryout. The people who work there are pretty friendly. It is a casual pizza joint in town so don't be super offended if the guy working the pickup window chit chats with his buddy in the car ahead of you for what seems like forever while you patiently wait your turn, or if that same guy then spits out the window just before you pull your car up. If you can look past that kind of stuff and not expect anything fancy you might be really happy with the quality and price of the pizza. They get the fourth star for offering my dog some sliced turkey when I brought him with me in the drive-through once. I love places where people are cool to dogs. I haven't been there since i became vegan, but if they ever get vegan cheese I will totally go again. read more

We have ordered from Mr Pizza several times since our first experience here, two or three times being delivery. Our most recent call to Mr Pizza, they advised my husband that they don't deliver north of McDonalds in Neshannock. Unfortunately my husband did not challenge this statement considering they have delivered to our house before (which conveniently can be the next street AFTER McDonalds depending on which road you use to access our neighborhood). Very disappointing. read more

Mr. Pizza has very good pizza-- it's one of those hole in the wall gems. The prices and good, and they have very reasonable lunch specials. I wouldn't recommend eating in, the inside leaves much to be desired, but hey, the food is yummy and that's what's important! read more

Recently moved to the New Castle area and was looking for a good, go to pizza place. Tried this place and now don't need to try anywhere else. Pizza is always great and delivery is always fast. Great prices too. Order from here and you won't be disappointed. read more

Excellent pizza and subs, AND outstanding soups! Delivery and drive-through both valuable services! read more

Mr Pizza is a clean, well maintained restaurant. It looks like some past chain restaurant that's been converted. There are no tables, just booths. The tomato pie is pretty good, but really sweet. Their regular, plain cheese, slice was quite good. The crust had a good crunch and nice chew. One really surprising thing was the size of the soft drinks. Their large is what most fast food places call a small. I really appreciated the normal sizing. Pepsi brand product made a nice compliment too. read more

Pizza slices tasted like cardboard and service was really bad. Heard it was the best around so I might give them another chance.

Really great people.they alway have time for u as a person even when they are busy. to top it off their prices are so reasonable. I feel that when they cook your food.they are really enjoying it. The food is so good never have had a complaint read more

We where two families who arrived New Castle late after driving from Niagara and we found Mr Pizza coincidentally. We were met with a welcoming smile and a very helpful staff. They gave us advice on sizes and were able to meet our special requests. The pizzas where fantastic. Both the thin crust and the thick crust tasted absolutely fantastic. The choices of toppings are very well combined, not to many. You pick what you want from a menu. Real cheese perfectly prepared. The interior reminds you of a typical fastfood restaurant, but the food is far better It is also very low prices. Enjoy!! read more