BEST PIZZA IN BUTLER. PERIOD. Simple menu perfectly executed with expertise and fresh ingredients. My go to is the meat lovers calzone with mushrooms. Staff is always friendly & prices are reasonable. Love it here - or to go! read more

I was staying across the street for the night and didn't expect much, I was pleasantly surprised at the thin crust and well balanced ingredients. I ordered a to go 'captain' pizza it was ready on time and the crust was perfect. This is a true pizza shop so don't expect to eat onsite. The counter guys were courteous and helpful. read more

Mac's Brick Oven Pizza - Captain pizza - Pizza Near Me - Butler, Pennsylvania

See all

I wish I could rate it higher because not only was the food good but the staff made our experience soar! We haven't had service like that in forever, they loved their jobs and wanted us to be happy with their product. They let my son watch them put the pizza together and in the oven and it meant a lot that they took the time to do that. The pizza is made from scratch start to finish in front of you so it's really fun to watch. The place has a couple tables inside and a chair to sit and wait for take out. We were so happy with our entire experience! read more

Mac's Brick Oven Pizza - Chicken bacon ranch and Philly cheesesteak pizzas. - Pizza Near Me - Butler, Pennsylvania

See all

Pizzas are great, but a little costly for the size. You do get what you pay for, but It's still a tad high, but delicious! read more

Delicious pizzas! Thin crust, amazing flavors, wood fired to perfection. We ordered the Philly Cheese Steak pizza and it was fantastic, white pizza and added mushrooms very yummy!! read more

Great brick oven pizza. All ingredients are fresh and although we were warned that it can take a little to create your pizza, I didn't think the 25 minute wait was all that bad. Service is fantastic and very attentive. It's also BYOB which was a plus since all the bars in town seem to be closed on Mondays. What a great find across from my hotel! read more

Mac's Brick Oven Pizza - Meat Lovers Pizza. Bigger than I expected. - Pizza Near Me - Butler, Pennsylvania

Their pizza is great ! We got a pepperoni , Philly and some garlic bites and they were very good . The cook was very friendly and went out of his way to make sure it was exactly the way we wanted it . Macs is just off the main drag and little rough to find parking up the street , but when you do it is worth it . Very clean and updated . read more

Excellent pizza will be back again to try the calzone! Cody makes a great pizza! Couldn't believe the pizza was cooked in 3.5mins Very pleased! Got a new customer for life! read more

Mac's Brick Oven Pizza - Classic pepperioni - Pizza Near Me - Butler, Pennsylvania

Friendly service and outstanding pizzas! We had the meatball pizza and the espresso pizza and both were delicious. Will definitely be back!

The pizza was delicious! Crispy on the outside and soft and chewy on the inside. Toppings were just right. Staff was friendly, courteous and knowledgeable. Clean and open space so you can watch your pizza being made. read more

Mac's Brick Oven Pizza - The Captain pizza - Pizza Near Me - Butler, Pennsylvania

Beware they use BAD water here they explained was bad and confirmed the local water is bad for ones health. Luckily I didn't want a bottle of soda to go with my pricey pizza and just wanted a cup of water. They explained they won't serve Butler tap water as it is bad and unhealthy. I assume the use water to make their dough as well as wash dishes, etc so I hope I don't get food poisoning, plus I'm now concerned for all the Butler residents and other restaurants. In this case, I hope and pray I was being lied to for the sake of everyone's health. To me, asa customer I hate being lied to, so either way, bad unhealthy water or a lie to my face, I will never return. Perhaps I'll call the Butler Water Authority and express my concern read more

Absolute perfection. I'm traveling here in town for a wedding. I've had pizza all over the world. This is by far the most perfect pizza I've had in the USA! Sauce perfectly no acidic or overly sweet, just perfect. Crust firm, crisp where it's suppose to be and delicious flavor. The toppings were perfect as well, fresh basil, fresh burrata cheese, and pepperoni. Wonderful service as well! Thank you for the great service and friendly greeting! read more

See all

Espresso dust on pizza? Are you kidding me? It's perhaps the best pizza I've ever tasted. It's about an hour from where I live and I'll drive there just to get that pizza again. Wonderful salads too. The ingredients are all high quality and very fresh. And the staff, especially Patrick, are very kind and welcoming. My only complaint is that they are not in my neighborhood. What a great find! read more

Mac's Brick Oven Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Butler, Pennsylvania

See all

My nephews said it was the best pizza they have ever had. Looking forward to taking them back when I am in town next month.

This place was amazing today delicious fresh food and the brick oven pizza hit the spot the place is clean and spacious and the services was great definitely top pizza place in butler. BOP BOP BRICK OVEN PIZZA. read more

See all

This is the best pizza I have ever eaten. The crust is perfect not to thick or chewy, just right. Toppings were delicious . Get the bruschetta/caprese salad - it is one of a kind fantastic and you don't want to miss it. read more

Amazing experience, again. Butler is finally showing its love to the pizza fan. And the salad was one of the best I have experienced. Oh Captain, my Captain. A must experience if you appreciate a great pie!!! read more

See all

THE best pizza in town! Great service from the team behind the counter. I would highly recommend

Just arrived into town (first timer) and needed a late lunch/early dinner. Online ordering could not have been easier. Added a few items to one on the menu and it was FABULOUS! Would definitely go there again when I am back in the area. Great, friendly service as well! read more

The food and service were both excellent! We visited on a Saturday around 11:30am with a group of 8. The staff was super accommodating and friendly. We ordered a pepperoni pizza, a margherita pizza, and a burrata caprese salad. Everyone was in agreement that it was some of the best pizza they have ever had. The burrata caprese salad was split as a side between 2 people and was so good! The crostini that it came with was delicious!! Highly recommend everything that we got! We will definitely be coming back next time we are in the area! read more

Absolutely amazing service and food always I have always had great service and amazingly good food every time I go there

Pizza was excellent. I am from New Jersey and we have great pizza. This is probably one of best I have ever had.

Tried this place for the first time. I ordered to go and when I picked up my order. The nice young man that cashed me out ask if I've ever tried their pizza before. "No this is my first time" I said. He says " You will not be disappointed". I hate it when people especially younger people try to tell me what to do. So I already made up my mind that it wasn't going to be that good. Well try as I may, I found this pizza to be delicious. Crust was perfect, ingredients tasted fresh and of good quality. I will be a regular customer in the future. Sometimes I don't mind being proved wrong even more so when it comes to pizza pie ( I am very serious about my pie). Nice work Mac! read more

Excellent pizza! I ordered online and saved $2. The dough is perfect, the sauce is delicious and the cheese is luscious! I hope we come through the area another time so we can order again. Well done! read more

Mac's Brick Oven Pizza - Meatball pizza - Pizza Near Me - Butler, Pennsylvania

The interior of the building is nothing special if you plan on dining in. There is nothing wrong with it, it's just sparse. The food is very good. My friend and I bought two different pizza's and they were both very good. read more

Incredible pizza, the employees here are super friendly, good people. I drove an hour out of my way to pick this pizza up, passing dozens of pizza places along the way. I would happily do it again. read more

Pretty decent brick oven pizza with some interesting combinations. I went with the Captain which was prosciutto, hot peppers and onions. I felt the amount of toppings were perfect while the crust had a nice char and mouthfeel. My only issue was there was way too much cheese for my liking and it pretty much slid off each slice making it difficult to enjoy. read more

My buddy comes from North Jersey and I am from Philly. We are pizza fanatics. Anyway we were stopping over in Butler. We wanted pizza and we read the reviews. This pizza was every bit as good as the reviews. The staff is friendly and great and really dedicated to pizza. Highly recommend. read more

Great first time experience! Tried Supreme and Meat Lovers pizza. Both were fantastic. Best pizza that I've had in a very long time!

Surprisingly good Za! Four stars for the pizza, but the menu is limited. Still, if in the area, give it a whirl!

We have been going to Mac's restaurants for years. The service, prices, variety, and service have always been great. Their Breakfasts are fantastic. read more

One of the best pizzas we ever had. The barrata margarita. A flavor carnival with every bite. House salad with chicken with house Italian dressing. You cant go wrong. Outstanding. read more

Pizza was delicious! Wood-fired crust and tasty sauce too. Garlic knots also done in the pizza oven - got a big thumbs up from my hungry teenage son. Staff willingly accommodated request for no cheese on my veggie pizza. Fresh basil was the perfect topper. Enjoyable and easy dinner out! read more

Mac's Brick Oven Pizza - Triple parmesan meatball and a veggie with fresh basil on top. - Pizza Near Me - Butler, Pennsylvania

Ordered takeout. Misquoted the time a bit, but there's a small waiting area and WiFi. Pizzas are 12" and cut into 8 pieces. The brick oven produces a nice char on the bottom crust and the lovely dough bubbles on top. I opted for the Margherita and it was excellent. Toppings and sauce were layered perfectly so that they don't slide off of your slice with each bite. I got a side salad which wasn't listed on the menu. The salad greens were garden fresh. My only complaint is that the salad container was barely filled to halfway. Local business for the win! read more

See all

Absolutely love this place. We order pizza from here a few times per month, and each family member has their favorite go-to order. My favorite is the white pizza, with onion and tomato... sooo good. The service is always super friendly and speedy. Thankful to have such a great brick over pizza place in my little hometown:):):) read more

These guys were so nice! I stopped in from out of town wanting something fast. They accommodated my quick reply. For $10 and in 10 minutes I had a delicious pie in my hand. Being from New York and also having been to Italy the pizza is a perfect combo of a NY pizza with an Italian flare. So thrilled to have found this little gem in Butler. Thanks guys I'll be back read more

Stopped by while driving thru this little town in PA. The town was nice but the pizza was outstanding!! My wife liked the gluten-free pizza w/ espresso dusting. Must try their Captain pizza too. read more

Came here for lunch with my family when they opened today. There was only one worker and he was very good and friendly. Our pizzas were fantastic! Overall great pizza place. read more

Mac's Brick Oven Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Butler, Pennsylvania

I love their pizza. Order ahead and skip the wait. I haven't seen a lot of people dine in. Most people order pick up. The espresso pizza is worth a try, if you're into unique flavor combinations. read more

Tried a pepperoni pie from Mac's last night and it was pretty good. You can tell the ingredients are quality and they were able to get the order out quick in about 20 minutes. I'd give them another try again in the future as they have a good selection and decent prices. They only offer one size though, but that's common for a brick oven style pizza joint. read more