I just moved here and wanted a pizza for dinner. I called to…read moreorder a build-your-own pizza and side salad. The order was ready in 25 minutes and when I arrived it was ready and aromatic! While there I added cannoli - oh my gosh were those good!!! The pizza was really delicious and just enough garlic! ;) The crust was just perfect I will be ordering again and again.....

Everything about this place is great, including the owner…read more Best, pizza in Butler. I have never had a complaint about my order or been disappointed. MMMMMMmmmmm

I don't think they are at this location now. Be sure to ask their location when you call. It was…read morealways good but it moved to somewhere else in Butler.

Great pizza, staff and atmosphere! Great for a quick lunch spot :) Daily lunch specials are not to…read morebig, perfect size! The pizza sauce was tasty and the crust was cooked to perfection! I was in and out in under an hour!

Pizza is excellent and so are dinner entrees. We ordered a lg pizza and the leftovers were great…read more Their Italian platter is wonderful.

Delivered wrong item, called to complain and was told oh well. This restaurant has been here…read moreforever and the locals like to sing it's praise but reality this is a sub par Italian restaurant. People of butler won't complain because it feels like a hit on the city. And actually they do not complain much of all. That's what has allowed the restaurant to continue. And it doesn't matter if you do because they will do nothing, not smart lossing a customer for a pizza. I was a cracker barrel general manager in the early 2000s. Management & customer service sure has changed.

I can't say enough about how grateful we were to the special employees at this pizza shop! The…read morenight before my sons birthday party, our original catering plan fell through. I called El Pizza plus and found that while they were not quite open at the start of his party, someone there was willing to show up early and prepare and even deliver all of the pizza for his birthday party. It was so clear to me that this woman loves her job and cared about making the pizza for the party. I had such a sense of gratitude and can see how this pizza shop goes above and beyond just the quality of their food. To that end, the quality of the pizza was outstanding! I can't wait to order it again!

Ordered food and they messed up. They offered to fix and took an hour, seen them deliver to across…read morestreet so called back to see what's happening and the girl toldme they busy and I'm not a priority right now!!!! Im super upset nothing was done and the girl working there didn't care at all cussed at me and had horrible attitude!!! HORRIBLE CUSTOMER SERVICE!!!!! So I paid $42 for 2 sandwiches and French fries and was told by the girl oh well!! Disgusting behavior!!!

Great food, but they take quite a while to make your food. Two separate occasions it took over 45…read moreminutes for just a hoagie. I'm not sure if they forget to check their online orders or what, but you can get one from Bon Aire in 1/3 the time.

From the owner: Here at Martins Pizzeria, between our hand tossed dough, homemade ranch, garlic sauce, and our menu…read morediversity, there's something for everyone! We carry the highest quality ingredients money can buy. Our food speaks for itself! Come try it out today :)

Ordered a pizza with all the toppings and just got a cheese pizza. Also was overcharged about $15…read morefor what I got. The online help for Slice disconnected when I complained. Never will I order from these morons again.

I called, got put on hold them hung up on (they said they disconnected) I called back, put on hold…read more15 minutes. call back, then immediately hung up on. I called 6 times each time being put on hold them either *disconnected* or hung up on. the 7th time I said *do not put me on hold* before I could get disconnected AGAIN. I got told *do Not speak to me like that* then when I said it was unacceptable being hung up in or disconnected 6 TIMES they told me to call corporate and hung up. I walked down there, and explained the situation (a bit heated but I was not violent in any way except I told the cashier to shut up because I didn't wanna deal with her after being disconnected 6 times. they threatened to cal the cops on me for this. HORRIBLE service, HORRIBLE attitude.

This location is the best!!! loyal employees and management they always make their customers feel…read moregreat!!! Kudo's!!!!

I'm always treated well by Randy. If there is a mistake they fix right away with no questions…read moreasked. Staff are all nice and friendly.

Took over 1an half hours an food was cold...quality was not there...I will not ever order there…read moreagain..

Ordered pizzas ahead of time. Went to pick them up, they were out of potatoes so they couldn't make…read moreour pierogi pizza. Owner said I can make you a medium instead of x-large. We said ok. He said I can have your order ready in 10 minutes. Thirty minutes later they had the pizzas ready. No apology. Called and talked to the owner, he said we did our best. I can understand when restaurants are short staffed but lack of communication and empathy for poor service is not acceptable.