Last night our high school volleyball team finished an away game late, around 7:30pm in Dennis. I called Mr Gs just before they were closing to place a large order. The gentleman there was fine taking a large last minute order just before closing! No attitude either! He also had a great attitude when the bus pulled up with 40 players to get their pizzasssssssss. To top it all off........... They said the pizza was delicious, some said it was the best pizza they ever had. Thank you Mr. G. read more

Saw some of the reviews weren't very favorable, but we were in an AirBNB about 2 miles away and this place was the most convenient option so we gave it a shot. I ordered a pizzas at 6pm on their website and chose the well done option. The automated confirmation said it would be ready in 30 minutes. I showed up in 25 minutes fully expecting to be waiting based on the other reviews, but the order was ready, the people working there were incredibly pleasant, and the pizzas were cooked perfectly. Will definitely be back. read more

Good food & friendly service. Order was ready for pickup on time. Very clean. Very convenient location because you don't have to cross the bridge onto the Cape! read more

Meh. Pick up always takes longer than stated when ordering and when busy the pizza always seems to be undercooked. Which is too bad because the dough was a strength. read more

Concerned about previous reviews and trying to avoid a hangry family after a long drive- I order a large crispy chicken parmigiana calzone. It was ready when we got there. Staff was friendly and quick. We were pleasantly surprised at how good the calzone was. We have passed this place for years and never tried it because of the bad reviews. Next camping trip we will try the pizza read more

Apparently they don't know what Buffalo sauce is or don't carry it anymore. I have ordered a wrap with Buffalo chicken three times now and each time it comes without the Buffalo sauce. Even after repeating the order and having it repeated back it still comes without the Buffalo sauce. I know it's easy enough to add to it at home but the point is that I'm paying for something specific and expect to receive what I've ordered. Will no longer be ordering from here which is sad because we've been long time supporters of this business. read more

We bought our cottage here in Sagamore Beach 10 years ago. (2014) Our first celebratory get together, I ordered takeout from Mr. G's for my whole family and was so excited we all loved it. It was a bonus knowing we lucked out with a great pizza place so close to us. However, it got sold a few years ago, then Covid hit us and I'm sorry to say we haven't been happy with anything we order here since. First of all, their hours do not coincide with our neighborhood. What pizza place closes at 8pm on a Friday night? And if you call to place an order after 7:30pm, you'll be extremely lucky that someone answers your call! I recently ordered a cheeseburger sub and it had a lot of gristle in the beef. There was no TLC in it at all. I for one miss the old owners. read more

I have eaten here twice during the pandemic, including here at home and a quick bite with my mom in the car. I give the heads up to the meal I had here, but the difficulty with that was I had to heat the sandwich myself not a big deal at all but in comparison to THEIR heating of the sandwich it was like night and day. The meat volume was great, it was a solid Italian sub but heated by Mr G's it was not all that great. Considering it was a quick turn around I expected better. The sweet potato fries were undercooked as well, not a very good move. I am always looking for the great oven roasted Italian sub so will keep it going. There really are just too many places to eat to give Mr G's another chance I give them great remarks for keeping the place super clean, it looked fantastic. read more

Mr G's Pizza - open sign on building - Pizza Near Me - Sagamore Beach, Massachusetts

See all

Standard pizza and sub shop. My husband had a steak and cheese that was satisfying and I had a gyro(also tasty). Kids were happy with their pizza. Thought it satisfied a large group and we needed a place that had no shellfish due to an allergy. It was nearby one of the beaches we were at, so able to go by and pick up. read more

Just ordered sub from here busy day and had no time to eat. It was one of the worst subs messy missing ketchup and just yuck. Do people just not give a shit anymore? And I tipped which I'm over doing when not necessary. Don't bother with this place, explains why it was empty. read more

Food is always ok for a quick meal, but last two times I have been given the wrong order. When they realize it they call but fat lot of good that does I'm already back at work. Let it go first time but will not be among my picks in the future read more

4 of the best subs to get when visiting Mr Gs 474 Lowell Street Peabody. Come in and try one... you'll be back in for another one for sure. read more

See all

The pizza here is amazing! I haven't tried many other items but I didn't think much of anything that's fried like chicken strips or fries. The chicken bacon pizza is our favorite and we order a few times a month. The staff is always helpful and the owner is really good to his workers. I've seen them interact many times with kindness and laughter. Looks like a nice place for a young adult to work. read more

First time trying Mr.G's and very happy with the service and the food. Placed a to go order over the phone and the girl who took the order was super sweet. Food was ready quickly and very fresh and extremely delicious! The chicken salad was definitely fresh and prepared there not some pre maid stuff like typical pizza/sub shops have. The pizza was hot and delicious as well. I got a slice for my son and definitely shared a couple more bites than he was happy about. Great experience will be definitely be back! read more

Mr G's Pizza - Chicken salad wheat wrap and slice of cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sagamore Beach, Massachusetts

It's a good place to come there much to do in this area so I normally don't think to come here They area accommodating the food is cooked fresh if you down at the beach and hungry I have had the pizza chicken Parma and the Italian sub and they we're all good read more

Went by Mr G's yesterday to grab a sub. Very clean and spacious inside. Friendly staff as well. I spoke to the new owner Rob Lawrence while there. He recently purchased the store last December. He has added new equipment including new grill, pizza station and fridge. But enough about that. The sub I chose was a steak and cheese recommended by Rob. The ingredients were fresh and the steak was awesome!! This time I got the small and I was wishing I got a large after it was gone! I look forward to getting the pizza when I am back in the area. I 100% recommend if you are on your way to the cape or down by the bridge to stop in and get a sub. read more

We stopped by to get subs for lunch because we like the eat-in setting. The service was good and so were the sandwiches. Quality here has been uneven over the years as help changes. They are not the fastest but it's still a good place to eat- whether pizza or sandwiches- take out too. read more

Mr G's Pizza - Turkey wrap - Pizza Near Me - Sagamore Beach, Massachusetts

Excellent pizza super thin crust like asked, amazing cheese you could actually taste and a super sauce that was just right!!! It was amazing and had I lived in mass this would easily be my go to pizza place!!! I craved pizza and this pizza was amazing Fried ravioli was also good!!! read more

I see you took the option to review of Facebook. We just got run of the mill everything.... I can see why. Going across the bridge next time. No flavor. 'broccoli poppers' were full of flavorless cheese - not mentioned on the menu - and there was a 'hint' of broccoli in them.. I think. They were all the same shape - scary. For $8? Pizza was pretty 'raw' even though we asked for well done. Tasteless too. Wow. When we camp at Scusset we'll be going elsewhere for sure. read more

Mr G's Pizza - Supposed 'brocolli bites'... with unmentioned cheese in the menu and there MAY have been some brocolli in them! For $8? Wow. Never again. - Pizza Near Me - Sagamore Beach, Massachusetts

OVERPRICED!! I had never tried in the 2+ years I have lived and worked in the area so I figured I would give it a shot. 2 wraps (add chicken in miniscule amounts at $3.50 for $.50 worth of chicken) and fries. $28.00!! That is insane. I have NO problem paying a heftier price for convenience food, as long as there is value there. Save your money and go someplace else. (The one and ONLY redeeming thing was that the girl up front was very pleasant.) read more

Whenever we need a quick bite rather than other fast food chain options, that's what we go for..pizzas n subs. Tonite, that's what I craved. We came here before we headed to the canal for the boat parade. This place serves up very much the same as any pizza joint. It's always a hit or miss when we blindly go into anywhere for pizza (for once, I didn't yelp beforehand). However,this one's a homerun for us! Yummy pizza...you can taste the freshness,a little greasy, but hey...just blotted it up with napkin n we're good! We also shared a chix parm sub...oozing with cheese n saucy...again, very fresh! read more

See all

What a disappointment! We called an order at 7:15 and we were told 20 min. 8p still no food! This has happened multiple times. I'm a patient guy but when your in the establishment and there's not a rush of phone orders and a staff of four, it's the unknown of why it's not ready. read more

Didn't order pizza, maybe that was our mistake.. ordered a sub and girlfriend got a salad with grilled chicken. Found ourselves continually inspecting the chicken because it looked gross. The staff seemed confused and so were we with our decision to try the place. Plenty of better options in the area. read more

I don't even want to leave one star. I was informed tonight that they refuse to deliver to my house after years of being a customer because my elderly mother who is legally blind was unable to leave a tip on the credit card slip on Christmas Eve. When I told the girl on the phone that she is legally blind and can't see the slip she called back to the manager "The old woman who lives there couldn't see the slip" I'm sorry what? I was beyond angry. They lost my business. Rose and Vikki in Plymouth from now on. read more

Great subs, but pizza is hit or Miss, seems like the food quality all depends on who's working at the facility.

Twice I've seen the usual female cashier in the kitchen area in a tank top. This is a health violation!

Waited 50 minutes to takeout two cold items. Tried delivery to see if it would be better, homeboy dropped my pizza box and fries all over my front steps read more

I feel bad for the people at Sagamore Beach if this is there only pozza/sub place. Been there three times. First time I ordered a veggie melt and got a black olive melt with a mushroom. Soggy mess. Second time slice of pizza that was edible. Third time I ordered a BLT. Left without it after 20 minutes. Cooks were way to busy chit chatting than getting food made. BTW there was no one in the place. Not going back. But I'm sure they don't care.... read more

We came in and asked for four slices and they said they only have those ones left there were three slices there from this morning and it is currently three o'clock they are so lazy here don't recommend it here . read more

This place is great! The pizza here is outstanding and the restaurant is very cozy. I got a large pizza with bacon, pepperoni, garlic, and linguicia with extra thick crust. The pizza was hot, the cheese was gooey, and the sauce was very flavorful. The service was also fast and friendly. The dining room table set-up makes this a great place to stop on the way home from the beach. I wish I discovered this place sooner and will be regularly stopping here for all future trips to the Cape. read more

Maybe if they get young people instead an old man and a man who looks like he smokes cigs everyday all day the service would be better. I ordered a small COLD Italian sub. Small. Cold, meaning nothing has to be cooked. Took 30 mins. For what. They weren't doing deliveries so it wasn't slow and i asked the girl up front if they were busy and she said no. The men cooking he food looked like he was in no hurry and didn't care if there was a line. Highly disappointed. Had to ask for my money back. Put a lil pep in your step men and maybe you wouldn't have ppl walking out the doors. read more

Great pizza grabbed some slices for the road for a quick stop as we are driving out of town.

Can't get an order correct I have given them six tries for them they couldn't get my order right no dressing on salad no extras on subs I will never go back here read more

great food, everything prepared fresh. Great hardworking staff with good service. Awesome little place to eat.

Called last night around 7:20 PM to order 7 pizzas and was told that because we didn't call a day in advance that they could not make them for us due to a lack of dough. I thought I called a pizza place but I guess I was wrong. read more

Whoever rated this place highly is delusion. Pizza's terrible along with every other food item they sell. I live within 0.5 miles of them and they wouldn't deliver over the bridge because "sometimes they don't go to certain places on 4th of July." No traffic might I add. Its good though, ill starve. read more

Prices are a little high, but the pizza is well above average. Take out, hands down one of the best to check out. Dining area is large. They hire a lot of young people, but the service have let me down. read more

i love mr.g's. had an issue 1 x in over 2 years but was quickly fixed gota say no lie best pizza n subs i ever had i recomend them 100%... read more

Mr G's Pizza - This is a neapolitan...?? Cold n dry n omg yuck.. - Pizza Near Me - Sagamore Beach, Massachusetts

Steak tip dinner all fries hardly any steak for 15$. Steak tip salad, all lettuce hardly any steak! Italian sub hardly any meat mostly just a bread roll read more

I just paid way too much for one large Neopolitan pizza delivered from Mr. G's. It was disgusting! Paper thin, dried up, burnt - it was like eating a scab! There was no mozzerella, just parmesan cheese and that is not at all clear on their menu. It tastes awful. I live less than 5 minutes from there but I will never order that overpriced crap again! I called to complain and the guy seemed like he was happy about it, like he gets those calls everyday. He didnt appologize and didnt offer to fix it. read more

Mr G's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sagamore Beach, Massachusetts