Over about 2 decades, and 2 dogs, Dorothy has been an absolute light in the dark. I grew up with dogs, and thought I knew what I was doing, but through my older family members, inherited an admittedly outdated system of dog education.
This changed when my wife and I first met Dorothy during the classes for my/our first dog of 'our own' (a 3 mo old German Shepherd). As many have recognized, obedience training classes is more about the owners being trained, not the dogs. And, man, did we learn a lot about dog training--which is mostly quite simple, as far as I can tell:
1) be consistent; most owners are, by human nature, horrible at this--this is why we need a trainer, and we need to practice (your once-a-week class alone ain't gonna do it)!
2) you can be firm without being mean; simply insist on your dog performing the appropriate behaviour by putting them in that position; no yelling or threatening required!
3) praise is the most important motivator; sure your dog may like liver treats more than praise, but is that really the type of relationship you want to be fostering? I know lots of people who can call their dog (along with 100 other random dogs) back at the park, so long as there's a treat in their hands. But my dogs always come running back (even away from your treats)--praise IS that GOOD!!
Many years later and multiple international/inter-city moves later, we landed back in Toronto and my second dog (a 9wk old golden mutt) joined the family. Once again (and fortunately) we tracked Dorothy down to initiate the new pup into the family system. As a testament to her motivation for taking the time to train us noobs--the price for classes was exactly the same in 2017 as it was in 2003!
Anyway, I can say that both dogs we've had were model citizens, and we frequently would hear the whole "wow, your dog is so smart/so good!". In reality, it is neither--both dogs are as different in personalities as they come, but both are identically 'obedient', and we (dogs and humans) have a simple but wonderful relationship. Both dogs were CKC level 1 and level 2 certified with the school. Both extensively travel(ed) with the family and are easily controlled off-leash. Consistent training means they understand what we want them to do (mostly, just 'follow me, and be cool/be chill')--no confusion, no stress.
My opinion of dog-human relationships/training is that there is no single 'right' way, but I think Dorothy's method is simple, kind, but also firm.
Even a dog that isn't 'mean' will roll over you, if you let them--it's in their nature (to take charge when someone else won't). Leadership is not about being mean, it's about being consistent--dogs (all animals?) like predictability.
As for some of the negative reviews--people are certainly entitled to their opinions (and there are different scenarios/issues of consideration beyond basic obedience; i.e. if you have adopted a dog with a history), but it seems like some of the comments are like "this method won't work because my dog is small". I think that 'small' dog behaviour is more of a reflection of the owners who think (or make excuses) that expectations are somehow different for 'small' dogs. There are analogous issues with 'big' dogs and the personalities of some of their owners too (certain human personalities apparently are attracted to certain types of dogs). Bottom line is that untrained dogs are a menace, regardless of size (we've all seen small dogs bite--not cool especially, when these are kids).
I've heard many people say: "well my dog is pretty obedient except if/when....". Well, if there's an "if/when" condition, that is literally the opposite of 'trained'. People often forget dogs aren't people/your kids. Baby-talking your dog in a purse is not helpful (at least to the dog), and feeding them your leftovers is not necessarily love. Again, YOUR dog, so YOUR choice on those matters....
.....BUT to live in a world/community with other people/dogs, ALL dogs need to be trained as well as loved. Your dog is not allowed to be an a$$hole!
FYI, a Martingale collar is not a choke collar, unless (as Dorothy explained) you are using it incorrectly (or wrong size). It is there to give your dog instantaneous signals (most humans are way too slow to do so! That's why the little poke to the side works; you don't do it hard, just do it swiftly!)--it is PSYCH 101. Now (as Dorothy promised), my voice acts like the 'click' in the collar--off leash dog walks are nearly the same as on-leash.
Sure, you might have better luck with another school (and largely this will be fine), but I think every dog-person agrees, that the point is that ANY training is better than none, and 'your own common sense' and YouTube is no replacement for pro advice! read more