We had such a great experience at Kaya! We brought in our fresh-caught mahi mahi for their…read morehook-and-cook, and they turned it into an incredible three-course meal for only $20 per person. Everything was flavorful and beautifully prepared--a really fun way to enjoy our catch. William, our server, was fantastic and truly added to the experience. He was attentive and thorough, explained everything, answered all of our questions, and even brought us a magazine to show us a review featuring the dish we were having. That extra attention made the evening feel special. Great food, an awesome hook-and-cook experience, and exceptional service from William. We would absolutely recommend Kaya!

After a long drive from Orlando, we were looking for something quick and easy off the beaten path…read morewith great reviews, and Kaya Island seemed like the perfect spot! The restaurant was nearly empty when we arrived, so we anticipated a pretty quick experience. Unfortunately, a large group arrived shortly after we were seated, and with what appeared to be only one waitress covering the area, service was much slower than expected. Between placing our orders and waiting for drinks, we honestly came close to getting up and leaving. But WOW, am I glad we stayed! This ended up being one of my favorite meals of our entire Key West trip! The fish tacos were seasoned to perfection, my cocktail absolutely hit the spot, and everyone in our group loved their food. The atmosphere was wonderful, and despite the slow service, the hospitality was warm, friendly, and genuine. By the end of the meal, with full bellies and happy faces, the wait was a distant memory. Sometimes good things really are worth waiting for! We'd absolutely return!

Loved food & excellent service! Ate here at least two times on each trip to Key West! The Key Lime…read morePie is a must!

Blue Heaven is one of those rare places that feels less like a restaurant and more like a second…read morehome you somehow never knew you'd been missing. The food is excellent--flavorful, thoughtfully prepared, and consistently satisfying--but what truly sets this place apart is the service, especially when you're seated at the bar. As a bar guest, I experienced something far above exceptional. It felt like walking into a place I already loved and being shown the very best of it by people who genuinely care. To the bartenders and staff who made every visit feel that way: Dairy-ah (I'm almost certainly butchering the spelling, but the pronunciation stuck with me), thank you for the warmth, the skill, and the way you made the bar feel welcoming every time. Lucy--always with the hat on backwards--you became my spirit animal the moment I realized how perfectly that energy matched the whole vibe of the place. Thank you for being exactly who you are behind that bar. Brittney, the chillest of them all: your calm, easy presence made everything feel lighter and better. Chelsea, I only got to have you serve me once, but that one time was enough to know how good you are at this. And to the Servers, Paul and Lola: even in our brief interactions while I was at the bar, both of you brought such strong, genuine personalities that it elevated the whole experience. Thank you for that. Blue Heaven is an amazing restaurant with great food and even greater service. But more than that, it's the people who make it feel like coming home and being shown the best time in a place you love the most. Thank you--truly--to all of you for making it feel that way. And to Henry, a longtime regular at the bar, who passed away during my visit. "His" presence was clearly part of the fabric of this place, and I'm grateful I got to share that space, however briefly, with the people who knew and cared for him. Thank You All, and sorry if I didn't list your name in this review because there were far more of you than I've mentioned, just Know my early mornings sitting at the Blue Heavens Bar, was the highlight of everyday I spent in Key West. Sincerely, Brian.. (or as my friends call me, "Jonesie")...

Ate here twice while in town. 10/10 jerk chicken is flavorful and juicy. Cleaned the bones dry and…read morecame back for more. Best plate in Key West hands down!!!! MUST TRY!

I was told by one of the locals to try the jerk. I was off and decided to try the jerk. I decided…read moreto try the jerk chicken wings with rice the service was awesome and I would definitely return. The ambiance was nice and the music was very eclectic and the live band was great. When you're in Key West, FL make your way to The Jerk. To all my Yelpers let's continue to eat our way through the world #foodie4life.

On the last night of our Key West trip, we wanted to find somewhere new with a little something for…read moreeveryone. We were looking for a funky vibe, but something a bit more low-key and off the beaten path. After browsing Yelp, we landed on Flaming Buoy! I'll admit, when we first pulled up, we were a little hesitant. The exterior wasn't particularly inviting, and we wondered if we'd made the right choice. But once we stepped inside, we were pleasantly surprised! We loved the eclectic decor, dim lighting, and laid-back atmosphere. The menu had so many unique options, and everything we ordered was absolutely delicious! Our waiter was also tending bar, but he didn't miss a beat. He was quick-witted, friendly, attentive, and clearly knew how to keep things moving. Food came out quickly, and the entire experience was just what we were hoping for. Such a fun little hidden gem and the perfect meal to wrap up a wonderful Key West vacation. So glad we gave it a chance!

The Flaming Buoy Filet Co was a great place for dinner, with great food and an interesting…read moreatmosphere inside. We went on a Thursday night, mid October. We sat at the bar and started with the grilled marinated key west pink shrimp appetizer with a spicy lime chutney. The shrimp was cooked nice and plump and the chutney (served on the side in a little funky bowl) spread on top gave it a bit a of kick. The spinach salad was a nice contrast of "greens" to have as an appetizer. For mains, the Key Lime Pasta with (I think) local spiny lobster was great and the Filet Co. Chili Cheese Coney with small beef dogs on a little buns was also good. For dessert, we enjoyed the hot banana honey. The bistro is decorated with Star Wars paraphernalia on the shelves over the bar and you have to check out the bathroom, which was pretty awesome with Star Wars scene complete with flashing lights. The atmosphere is dimly lit and kinda cool and a bit like a speak easy. I'd give The Flaming Buoy a very strong 4 and highly recommend it as one of the Key's coolest better food oriented restaurants. Good service even after it got busy.

While my husband and I were in town, we definitely had to try El Siboney! We have never been and as…read morea Cuban, I always like to try new places! And this place was GREAT! I was born and raised in Miami to a Cuban/Puerto Rican family so I am very familiar with this cuisine and how things should taste so I was super happy with this entire meal! When they brought over the toasted buttered cuban bread, I already knew we were going to do good haha. IYKYK. We ordered the Appetizer Sampler which came with tostones and sides of ropa vieja (shredded beef stew), avocado, pickled onion and pork, so you can build your own. It was delicious! Then for our entrees, my husband got the ropa vieja (SO good) and I got the palomilla. The steak I am used to is thinner and smaller, but I was not complaining! It was soooooooo good and I really really enjoyed it. It was pretty busy but our server did a great job of taking care of us. The restaurant is not that big so it can get a little loud in there. But if you're in a Cuban restaurant, it's never going to be quiet lol! It's part of the experience! Highly recommend for some legit Cuban food and will definitely be coming back next time we are in town!

This might have been our first meal in Key West. Drove over, parked in their lot, and ordered two…read morethings, but the most amount of food. Very generous portions. Our research told us that this would be a great meal and it truly was. I ordered the pork chunks, which were perfectly fried and so flavorful and tender on the inside. My wife ordered Ropa Vieja which was pulled beef, which wasn't as good, but still quite tasty. Had to bring food back home with us, which we ate for various snacks before we departed. Fast food and a nice hidden gem in the town. Glad we had this kick off our trip.

As we made our way through the streets of Key West, my husband and I decided to grab drinks and…read moregrub at Rams Head Southernmost. Here's the rundown. SPACE: Seriously I don't know what's not to love here. The patio is massive! There's tons of greenery and chickens roaming about. During our visit there was a musician playing some tunes under the modified airplane wing awning. They hav large fan throughout to ensure that air is circulating during the hot Florida days. SERVICE: Our server Mariquena was top notch. She answered all the questions we had about the menu items and made great recommendations. When our food came out, and I had stepped away, she even tilted my chair to ensure the chickens didn't sample my tacos before me. SIPS: The drinks were easily the most needed part of our visit. My husband opted for a gin and tonic and a local beer (Waterfront Lazy Way IPA) after; while I chose a coconut creamsicle blended cocktail. Yum! Totally worth the brain freeze. SUSTENANCE: After browsing the menu we both decided the blackened Mahi Mahi tacos sound just right. Let me tell you - they were bomb-dot-com! With pineapple slaw, queso fresco, chipotle aioli how could you go wrong? Rams Head Southernmost was the perfect lunch pit-stop during our Key West adventure!

We had a few hours to explore Key West from our cruise ship. After a couple hours of walking around…read morein a sweat bath we picked Rams Head for their reviews. Surprisingly everyone wanted to sit outside and we took a nice A/C break inside. Rylee was our server and such a sweet girl. Super friendly and always checking on us. Restaurants need more staff with her awesome customer service. We both snacked on the conch fritters and they were good. Just so much breading and wish there was more of a prevalent taste of the conch. I had the fish and chips and the fry on them was perfect. I enjoyed the fish but honestly like cod the most for a good ole fashioned fish and chips. My wife loved the tomato and watermelon salad.

Poolside bar is good. Great for a quick bite for lunch or snacks. Harbor View Restaurant was odd to…read moresay the least. We made a reservation for 1:00 on Monday 9/7 and arrived a few minutes before 1:00 to be told they were closed due to it not being busy enough to stay open. Breakfast the next day was sub par. Way overpriced for basic tasteless eggs and potatoes. Servers were pleasant and attentive but the food was just bland. We would not dine there again.

While staying at Pier House, our group of 10 decided to dine here on a whim. We were given a table…read moreon the veranda which was very nice. WHAT I TRIED: Blackened Hog Fish Tacos- fresh and perfectly cooked. Conch Fritters- also just right with the most delicious key lime mustard sauce! Strawberry Lime Lemonade- very nice with muddled strawberries. Not overly sweet. My friends ordered the caribbean cobb salad, the white conch chowder, and crab/spinach dip. Two enthusiastic thumbs up from everyone. Our waiter, I think his name was Alvaro, single-handedly tended to our table. He took the orders, filled our glasses, double checked the orders were correct, brought out our food and extra anything we requested all while remaining cool, calm, collected, respectful, and poised. So refreshing! BY. HIM. SELF. Great hire! He definitively brought the experience full circle. ALSO unlike other restaurants on the key (cough Firefly, cough Santiago's Bodega) he easily and efficiently split our bill into several ones without ANY hesitation. Easy peasy. What a concept! I will be back to try their dinner menu the next time I'm in town!

If you're looking for one of the best breakfast spots in the Florida Keys, Karlitas cafe is an…read moreabsolute must. This authentic Nicaraguan restaurant delivers big on flavor, comfort, and culture--especially in the mornings. Breakfast here is outstanding, with a wide variety of traditional options that are filling, fresh, and full of soul. From classic plates that showcase authentic Spanish and Nicaraguan flavors to perfectly cooked staples that feel homemade, every bite tastes like it came straight from abuela's kitchen. And the café con leche? Simply phenomenal. Smooth, rich, and perfectly balanced, it's easily one of the best you'll find in the Keys and the ideal way to start your day--especially when you're just steps from the beach. What really sets Karitas cafe apart is the authenticity. This isn't a watered-down tourist spot; it's real, honest Spanish cuisine served with heart. Whether you're a local or visiting the Keys, it's one of the best places to sit down, relax, and enjoy a true taste of Nicaraguan culture by the water. And the service reminds me of my aunt always making sure I'm ok and full Great breakfast, incredible café con leche, tons of options, and unbeatable authenticity--Karitas cafe is a Keys favorite for a reason. Here's my review Food 5/5 Service 5/5 Price 5/5 Location 5/5 The foodie ninja shall return

Food was decent. Nice people working there. Just wish food was a little better. There needed to be…read moresome seasoning or something. Just not great sorry.

Definitely lived up to the hype. The burger with beef was amazing. Really flavorful. Seems liked it…read morechanged every bite. The chicken pita pocket has the best damn creamy green sauce I've had.

Just found out about this hidden gem last week. Highly recommend this food truck ! Everything was…read moregood, exempt the plantains that were overcooked.