Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Mortimer's Pub

    3.2 (5 reviews)
    InexpensiveBars
    Thu 11:00 am - 2:00 AM (Next day)
    Fri 11:00 am - 2:00 AM (Next day)

    Mortimer's Pub Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Mortimer's Pub

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    11 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Steven T.
    244
    2286
    38724

    4 years ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    14 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Andy M.
    289
    2560
    34

    8 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Bars 4,775 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    The Tin Widow - Tin Window

    The Tin Widow

    4.7(107 reviews)
    4.4 miWalker's Point
    $$

    We stopped in on a whim after dinner out in the deer district. Driving home when I saw the holiday…read moreinflatables and I thought if I can find a parking spot, we are going in. I had heard about the Tin Widow's holiday pop up being one of the best area, the hype was not wrong. From the entrance to the ceiling and walks, this place is the definition of deck the halls. Unless you get here right when they open it early in the holiday season, I would expect a crowd. The drink menu is so fun with holiday themed drinks served in matching glassware. You can even purchase the glass/mug for an additional fee. A lot of the cocktails looked to be batched cocktails which help with the bartender's efficiency. Highly recommend making this place a holiday stop. I'm also curious to stop in after the holidays to experience it without all the holiday decor.

    Stopped in for their Miracle on 2nd St holiday pop-up. We only had to wait about 5-10min for a…read moretable, but it does get busy fast, especially on weekends. They had several seasonal cocktails in special festive cups, which you could also buy to take home. I got the Cheery Cherry Chocosaurus, which was good, but pricey for what it was. Almost all the seasonal drinks were $15 each and didn't seem too big. The venue itself is medium sized, but feels crammed quickly. There's more people let in at a time than there is seating, so you have to move fast to get a seat. I'll likely come back during the summer to try something else.

    Photos
    The Tin Widow - Interior

    Interior

    The Tin Widow
    The Tin Widow

    See all

    O'Brien's Pub

    O'Brien's Pub

    3.4(53 reviews)
    1.9 miWashington Heights
    $

    I stopped here for new restaurant of the week twice since the first time, the kitchen was closed on…read moremy first visit and my review had to wait until I had some food. The place does a good job with the decor of an Irish bar with the woods, stone fireplace, windows and light fixtures etc. I ordered a spicy Bloody Mary to start and I looked over the menu but I remembered from my first visit that they have a burger of what ever so I asked what it currently was and it's a Swiss patty melt on marbled rye with choice of side, onion straws is a personal favorite of mine so yes please. My food came quickly before I could even make a dent into my decent spicy Bloody Mary which had two olives as a garnish, weak presentation at best. The place wasn't busy at all and my server/bartender didn't do a great job at taking care of me and I waited 10 minutes at least for a box and a check after I was clearly done with my meal. The Swiss patty melt looked delicious with a cold pickle, onion straws and what looked like 1000 island dressing on the side. The pickle was a nice size with decent crunch wise. The onion straws were perfect with a light breading, tasty/thin cooked in relatively fresh oil. The Swiss patty melt was cooked perfectly rare with a char grill flavor, melty Swiss cheese, translucent onions with some crunch on perfectly toasted marble rye bread. Overall the service could have been better and yah I could have ordered an Irish staple but I was thoroughly satisfied with with the Bloody and burger of the month.

    We've come here a few times for trivia in the last several months, it's a somewhat central location…read morefor the members of our team and there is plentiful off-street parking available, which is nice. Service can be a bit spotty at times, though it's les for a lack of trying and more of a lack of enough staff that tends to drive any issues. Everyone that is here, though, is friendly, to both newbies and regulars alike. This is definitely a "townie bar," so it's not uncommon to see the same faces whenever you come. One highlight on the menu to consider is the Artichoke and Chicken pizza. Baked on a crust so thin it's almost invisible, it's a great size and value and heats up well the next day too! Or get the nachos and have food for five!

    Photos
    O'Brien's Pub
    O'Brien's Pub
    O'Brien's Pub - Swiss patty melt cooked perfectly rare

    See all

    Swiss patty melt cooked perfectly rare

    Kelly's Bleachers

    Kelly's Bleachers

    4.1(119 reviews)
    1.2 miStory Hill
    $$

    It had been years since we last stepped foot in Kelly's Bleachers on Bluemound, and it was nice to…read moresee how much it's been updated and renovated. The space feels refreshed while still keeping that classic sports bar vibe. We were invited to a birthday party that happened to fall on the same night as a Packers playoff game, so the place was absolutely packed. Parking was scarce, and we ended up parking several blocks away. That said, the setup for the party was great--we had our own area with plenty of TVs to watch the game and reserved tables facing the front of the bar. Pizza was served for the party (we didn't try it), but it looked good--cheesy with a thin crust. We ordered a patty melt and a cheese curd burger, and both were excellent and very large portions. Service was good, especially considering how extremely busy it was. I'd definitely come back on a calmer day or night to try more of the food. Overall, it has a cool sports ambiance with solid food and is a fun spot for game day--just be prepared for crowds during big events.

    Kelly's Bleachers is a great spot before and after Brewers games! The shuttle is quick and easy,…read morealthough because it is so popular, there are times you need to wait awhile when leaving the game. I wasn't able to make it to Brewers opening day this year, but I stopped into the bar shortly after the game had ended to join in on the fun. The bartenders were all kind and attentive even though it was packed full of people and chaotic!

    Photos
    Kelly's Bleachers
    Kelly's Bleachers - Go Brew Crew!

    Go Brew Crew!

    Kelly's Bleachers

    See all

    Colonel Hart's - The bar at Colonel Harts.

    Colonel Hart's

    3.5(70 reviews)
    1.4 mi
    $

    I stopped here for a couple beers and to grab some food because it was a bookmark. The place was…read morepretty empty at lunch time but it was a Monday. The place is a good kind of dive bar because it looks old with lots of wood. I would have a summer shanty and a third space for my beer options which were ok on a lazy Monday. The menu isn't large but it has all the usual suspects as far as bar food goes and I would get a burger that comes with frys. I ordered the Good A Burger rare which is bacon, jalapeños and Gouda cheese just because I have not seen that combination before. The burger looked good with lots of frys. The frys were hot cooked to order and seasoned nicely. The burger was good on a fresh toasted bun and as rare as you could get with the thin patty that was somewhat juicy. The beef had a nice grill flavor that complemented the bacon nicely but the jalapeños were can/jar and not fresh. Overall I can't complain about anything because the service was good and the food was fresh and hot on a lazy Monday afternoon.

    I've had Colonel Hart's plenty of times when my office has ordered food to go for lunch, but today…read morewas the first time I stopped there to dine in and I happened to have my family with me. My wife and I both ordered the turkey club sandwich, one kid got a cheeseburger and one got a grilled cheese. The kids like their meals. Yay. The problem is both my wife and I had mold on the bread for our club sandwiches. The bartender was super apologetic, said our meal was free, made a point to explain that they have more bread available downstairs, then asked if there was anything else we wanted. We both said no, assuming he meant something else while we waited for our food to be remade or a different item completely. Almost half an hour passed by and I got tired of waiting for our remade food, so I flagged the bartender down. Apparently he took us saying no as we didn't want anything at all because they never bothered to start remaking our food. Our kids were already done with theirs and were getting bored, so we just left even more frustrated and hungry than necessary. I was also super embarrassed because I talk up how good their food is and this experience makes neither of us want to stop back again. Guess I'll not be ordering the turkey club for work lunches anymore either now that it's clear they don't sell enough to turn over their supply of bread before it gets moldy.

    Photos
    Colonel Hart's
    Colonel Hart's
    Colonel Hart's - $8.50 dollars for short scotch  and seltzer!

    See all

    $8.50 dollars for short scotch and seltzer!

    Mortimer's Pub - bars - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...