Unfortunately this place fell flat for me. We took a trip during the week after someone recommended it and I'm not sure we'll be back for anything other than the drinks, the plantains and the sautéed crab appetizer. The coconut curry shrimp lacked the depth and really any flavor you'd expect for something curried, the jerk wings lacked that quintessential smoke flavor and smell and at opening when we went they said we're out of rice and peas and substituted it for overcooked jasmine rice and the pineapple upside down cake was also unavailable. Again, maybe a place for appetizers and drinks only. read more

See all

The food is out of this world you cannot go wrong, the drink are awesome, the staff and owners are awesome.

The food was amazing, the potions were good, and the service was fantastic. I YELP the restaurant to find something different. It was worth the find. read more

Montego Bay Grille - I shrimp linguine - Caribbean Near Me - Hobart, Indiana

Crazy good man! Us three guys dropped in after a dunes day. Quite hungry though hesitant to try fish in the Midwest, when one has tasted any gulf restaurant catch of the day, shows what the stuff should taste like, becomes difficult to live so far from the Atlantic. But the high reviews lured us in. And boy! This place has it all albeit quite small portions. A great date spot I bet. Fun little tiki inspired bar surrounded by quaint tables, we perched up and soon had the great staff bringing us a bloody Mary, painkiller, and mojito. Again what a win, I now have the ideal Bloody Mary skewered with bacon and a burnt chicken wing to judge all other breakfast cocktails by. The others enjoyed theirs as well. We went basic with jerk chicken, salmon, and shrimp curry. Curry was quite a small plate, surprising compared to the large jerk chicken pile. Quickly forgot. Any complaints trying the rice, so good! Whatever magical chef skills go down here I want to learn. Even with our range of restaurants between us three the rice was something new and exciting, who knew rice could do that. Cheesecake for the end was tiny. Sad cup looked funny with three spoons round it. Small matter, come try the rice, we were excited to make up for the overpriced below average coffee in Hobart with this place, can easily recommend Montego! read more

See all

Dinner, salmon and mahi, old fashioned, Bloody Mary, all great!! Friendly service in the small town setting! read more

Montego Bay Grille - Jerk salmon and mahi! Salmon is wild caught not porpoise-killing Faroe Islands salmon!! - Caribbean Near Me - Hobart, Indiana

First time here! Cute place, Our server Erin, was amazing. My Husband has a lot of food allergies, so when we were ordering, she was on top of it. Food was beyond Delicious! Out of all the restaurants we have been in lately, this one is hands down the best and had a unique menu! read more

See all

Waited long for mid food (unseasoned) and overpriced, spent $100 on 2 meals and appetizer and one beer. None of which was good. Worst jerk wings I've had and Mac and cheese tasted like craft. I usually wouldn't rate a small business this low just because but the restaurant being rated 4.7 is actually insane. #YTPF think the fish was better if you dare venture read more

My wife and I ate here last Wednesday. The food is excellent. But the service was SLOW ! It took nearly an hour to get the appetizers. The place wasn't busy (maybe 4 other people in the restaurant) so the long long delay can't be blamed on the volume of customers. The only reason I didn't walk out was fear of having an argument with my wife. Kudos on the food... but the speed of service will keep me from becoming a regular customer. read more

I ordered the jerk salmon & the mango marg. Both were delish! Servers were extremely helpful. Love the Jamaican decor

My wife and I hosted our Children for their anniversary and Christmas celebration here. We had a GREAT time. The owner stopped by the table to say hello and congratulations. What a gentleman. The meal was great. I had the steak. Cooked perfect and well presented. I added the crab cake, wonderful as well. My Wife had a salad and half my crab cake... loved it. The upside down cake for desert was excellent. The quality/value was outstanding. We will definitely be back the next time I. Hobart. read more

The food was amazing ordered the jerk chicken and rice which was very delicious, the shrimp tacos and crab cake, were also very delicious. The staff were very friendly and the atmosphere was warm. We will definitely be back to try other items on the menu. read more

Great dinner, I had the jerk salmon and I was able to add just the right amount of heat, the salmon was cooked to perfection. My wife had the jerk chicken and it was tender and moist with a crisp skin. The servers were very accommodating and mixed a cocktail not on their menu. For dessert we had the key lime cheesecake which was just the right size for two, creamy, and not too sweet. Although the restaurant has been open eight years, it still has a clean new feel. read more

This is my second time coming to this restaurant but this time I brought my brother and sister in law with me. And they had their crab cakes in stock !! And they were great! They were well seasoned and the sauce that was served with them was delicious! The jerk chicken was good and the sauce served with it brought the heat. The Cajun chicken and shrimp with linguine was creamy but had no heat/flavor. But the Jerk Mahi Mahi was once again fantastic !! They only had one dessert left, so that went to my brother. All in all a great meal. read more

Montego Bay Grille - Signature Jerk Style - Caribbean Near Me - Hobart, Indiana

See all

This place never disappoints. The food is consistently good, and I love how clean and well-maintained the restaurant is. Service is fast and friendly, making it a great spot for a quick lunch or dinner. read more

Montego Bay Grille - Caribbean Near Me - Hobart, Indiana

First time. My Dad wanted Jerk Chicken, which was phenomenal. So much food. I had the Jerk pork. It comes with vegetables and rice and beans. And let me tell you about these rice and beans. Wow! So good. The pork was so juicy and tender. The jerk spice isn't crazy spicy but does pack some heat. The vegetables were equally tasty and delectable. They were tender and had such good flavor. We also had the Jerk Salmon. Hands down the best salmon I've had in a long time. It's a decent portion size and so tasty. We ate every last bite!!! It was super cozy inside. Great service. Decent prizes for the high quality of food you get. This is no fast food place. They put care in presentation and preparation. The food is hot and fresh. read more

Montego Bay Grille - Jerk Pork with rice and beans and vegetables - Caribbean Near Me - Hobart, Indiana

My husband and I visited the restaurant for the first time and thoroughly enjoyed our meal. We were informed that there would be approximately a 30-minute wait, but considering that waiting is typical for places serving jerk cuisine, we didn't mind. The chef even came out to apologize for the delay, which we appreciated. Our waitress was exceptionally pleasant. I usually order strawberry daiquiris, but they weren't listed on the drink menu. However, she went the extra mile and made me a strawberry margarita instead, using a puree that gave it a daiquiri-like flavor. It was delicious, and I gave it two thumbs up. The ambiance of the place gave off a strong Jamaican vibe, which we found very appealing. We will definitely be returning for another visit. read more

What a nice surprise in Hobart Indiana! The food was amazing and the servers were very accommodating. I will definitely be back to enjoy another tasty meal read more

The service was great even though I placed an order through Uber eats. I tried to place an order through door dash but it wouldn't let me. So I called and they informed me they were on Uber eats so I placed my order there. The meal I wanted wasn't on there so I called and they changed it and advised me there may be an up charge. So I was under the impression this was authentic Jamaican food. So when the food arrived it was still warm and it looked really good. However, it is missing Jamaican flavor, taste, seasoning and spices. I should've known when I didn't have oxtails on the menu and offered crab cakes. The food isn't nasty but it's not real Caribbean food. The cakes was pretty good but it was missing a cherry. read more

See all

Been a long time since I have been there. Menu has a much better verity of choices than I remember. All the dishes we ordered were very good. Only slight hiccup was that they were out of Modelo Negra. read more

I really love their crabcakes , Their Jerk chicken raps, food is just delicious, very nice and clean now that's important for me to eat there read more

Thank you for bringing this fantastic food to Hobart! Great food and service Teddian! I love listening to the music on open mic night too!

Delicious food, attentive wait staff, personable chef. My mom and I went to dinner here after seeing favorable reviews and we're not disappointed. We got the crab cake (so delish, especially with the spicy avocado sauce), the jerk salmon, and the lobster ravioli. In addition we ordered a few coconut and mango margaritas that we really enjoyed. We ate on the lakeside patio as the day was really beautiful and absolutely enjoyed ourselves. This was our first stop in Indiana for food and it left a really good taste in our mouths read more

Montego Bay Grille - Coconut margarita - Caribbean Near Me - Hobart, Indiana

This place is so good and the customer service is top tier. I'll definitely be visiting this place again. I ordered two dinners to go! read more

Montego Bay Grille - The jerk chicken and mixed vegetables was amazing! The chicken is well seasoned and not over cooked. - Caribbean Near Me - Hobart, Indiana

See all

Great food and service. Been a few times and it never disappoints. The drinks are great too!!

Absolutely love this place. The food is always incredible and the staff/owners are amazing and kind! Feels good to support a business like this one. Shrimp tacos are absolutely incredible but I have forced myself to try other options and every time is great! Highly recommend for so many reasons! read more

No vegan options on the menu as of 09/2020 but I opted for the Jerk Chicken wrap minus chicken. Great meal! Chef added extra veggies in there and that jerk sauce is fire. The potato wedges are the bomb. read more

Montego Bay Grille - Jerk Chicken Wrap (minus chicken) Grilled veggies, jerk sauce, mangoes, beans and rice and potato wedges and that jerk sauce! So good! - Caribbean Near Me - Hobart, Indiana

My boyfriend and I stopped here for dinner one night after a visit to the dunes and they did not disappoint! Definitely recommend the jerk wings and the dessert! read more

This place seems like a little dive place. It's bigger than you think. The server was actualy one of the owners and she was realy pleasant, her name was Josie. The atmosphere was very laid back and the food was great. Will definitely be back for more. read more

Great food! Everything was fresh, the chicken was flavorful and juicy, and the shrimp tacos were perfect. Nice atmosphere, great service, and very pleasant and friendly staff. They also had a live DJ on the patio, very nice touch . Will gladly go out of my way to eat here anyday I'm craving Caribbean Food. read more

See all

This place is great! We stumbled on it after a comedy show. The food is absolutely delicious! The drinks great! Definitely not fast food, but worth the wait. It was very busy yet the servers were very attentive. read more

Best place to eat Jamaican style food and the service is terrific. I highly recommend this place. read more

Montego Bay Grille - the front of the restaurant - Caribbean Near Me - Hobart, Indiana

ABSOLUTELY PERFECT! Definitely a hidden gem! We just closed on a new home only 5 minutes from this restaurant & we couldnt be more thrilled bc we will be regulars here. This quaint little place had a perfect menu, especially if you are a sea food lover. Our waitress was pleasant & very knowledgeable. She was extremely respectful when she approached the table, waiting until we were done with our conversations before she spoke. I ordered the Mahi Mahi. It was a generous portion and so beautifully plated. It was perfectly cooked and the sauce was delicious. I also had 2 peach martinis & they were dynamite! My husband ordered the Coconut Shrimp Curry. He said it was the best rice & beans he has ever had and the shrimp were deliciously outstanding! All in all I give a well deserved 5 stars & I cannot wait to visit again! read more

Montego Bay Grille - The most perfect Mahi Mahi dish around! - Caribbean Near Me - Hobart, Indiana

The food here is AUTHENTIC! The Rum punch tastes like the one I had in Jamaica. Will come back. read more

Montego Bay Grille - Rum punch! - Caribbean Near Me - Hobart, Indiana

See all

We almost left before we even walked inside. It appears to be very small with limited seating, however leaving would have been a huge mistake. The food (scallops, mahi mahi, and coconut shrimp curry) was amazing. The drinks were strong and refreshing... Get the strawberry margarita... We'll definitely be back. read more

Food was very flavorful and fresh. Small intimate restaurant. Owner and workers are very pleasant. Food is cooked to order, worth the wait. I HIGHLY recommend this restaurant if you are looking for some home cooked Jamaican food read more

Great food and the owners are always so welcoming. I love the salad with chicken and pecans in it

I absolutely love this place. Chef Teddian has an amazing jerk sauce that you can buy to take home! The spice is just right! There hasn't been anything on the menu that I didn't love! Drinks are tasty and the atmosphere is cozy! The staff is always wonderful and quick. I will suggest staying for a dessert! They are all phenomenal. read more

Walking in downtown Hobart led us to this small but mighty Jamaican style restaurant. The menu was quite small, but we definitely found a few items that caught our eye. We tried their 3 appetizer options: the shrimp tacos, crab cakes, and the jerk wings. The wings had great flavor and were very meaty! The tacos were good, use the jerk sauce with it! And the crab cakes were probably our favorite of the three; full lump cakes with a nice crunch, that paired well with the spicy avocado sauce. The only thing we weren't a huge fan of was the interior of the restaurant itself. I believe there's a back patio, but it was raining so we didn't get a chance to try it out.. we will next time! read more

See all

WHOA !!! This place is truly a gem in the heart of downtown Hobart. The star of the show is owner Tedian who has endless personality. His restaurant is small, clean, and nicely decorated with Jamaican flair. I ordered Fried Plantains and they were easily the best I've ever had. Tedian then mixed a fantastic drink which was one of his specialties, and it was nothing short of phenomenal. Montego Bay Grille is now my most anticipated stops whenever I'm in town. If I lived in Hobart, Tedian might have a difficult time getting me out of the place !!! read more

Montego Bay Grille - Caribbean Near Me - Hobart, Indiana

See all

Just had lunch there today. My hubby had the jerk chicken sandwich with a side salad and my daughter and I had the jerk shrimp tacos and fried plantains. Everything was delicious. We will definitely be returning. read more

See all