Cancel

Open app

Search

Montauk Sushi

5.0 (2 reviews)

Montauk Sushi Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Montauk Sushi

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

3 months ago

was fresh and delicious. Would take out from them again . yelp is making n=me use "85 characters --stupid. i have nothing more to add

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

13 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

Verify this business for free

People searched for Sushi Bars 474 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

East Hampton Grill - Chocolate pot de creme and amazing!

East Hampton Grill

3.7(352 reviews)
6.9 km
$$$

Another visit to East Hampton Grill and another stellar meal and experience. Dinner at EHG last…read morenight... Service is always top notch Food quality is excellent Time from order to food being brought to table is great (quick) Highly recommended the spinach artichoke dip and chips and the spicy chicken sandwich. Consistently my go to in the Hamptons!

A classy, cozy inviting high end tavern with subdued lighting and a romantic setting. People will…read moreflock to great food and service - the East Hampton Grill has both. We started with two unusual and inexpensive appetizers- the heavenly biscuits (2 per order) for $5 served warm with Hampton's organic honey. These biscuits were delicious and I could have eaten a basket full of them. With a cold beer they had just the right amount of savory and honey sweetness. The deviled eggs (3 per order) with special relish for $12 were a perfect starter. Not to heavy - melt in your mouth. Onto the entrees: my triple cut brioche roll fried lobster po boy sandwich $48 was toasted with butter, tomato and lettuce and crispy tender lightly fried lobster pieces. With a Nice sandwich remoulade. A bit expensive, but it was a large sandwich full of lobster meat. A little hard to eat because of the height of the sandwich. My wife tasted my sandwich and thought the lobster should remain cooked but not breaded and fried. To each their own. The Nashville style hot chicken sandwich came on the same three cut brioche bread with the shiny top, perfectly toasted ($36). Here again - delicious tender chicken and a large meaty sandwich. Beer and wine service was spot on with a leisurely time pace between appetizer and entree. No room for the two offered desserts- but the key lime pie looked scrumptious.

Photos
East Hampton Grill
East Hampton Grill - Prime rib Prime Rib Roast

Prime rib Prime Rib Roast

East Hampton Grill - Prime Rib Roast

See all

Prime Rib Roast

Sunset Harbor at EHP Resort & Marina - Alaskan salmon roll

Sunset Harbor at EHP Resort & Marina

3.2(13 reviews)
6.8 km

We went here a couple weeks ago at 5pm on a friday night. We took the early resy as we were just…read morewanting to try Sunset Harbor. We were seated in the indoor patio area as they said the outdoor area was reserved for parties larger of 6 (except for the high tops). It was very hot in the indoor area I would recommend taking the high top if given the option. The service was great. Very fast and friendly, however I am unsure if this is a valid complaint but the service was almost too fast, we finished our meal in around an hour which just seemed a little rushed. We started off with the spicy tuna crispy rice and the spicy king crab crispy rice. Both were so good, but the tuna was slightly better as it usually is. I was told not to order the tacos as they come with little to no fish and that appeared true as the table next to me got them. We moved on to the glazed pork rib, yellowtail roll, california roll, and a salmon roll. The pork rib was tender but lacking flavor, however the rolls were really good. My favorite sushi in the hamptons is probably suki zuki, however, I don't think that any hamptons sushi is worth it as it is expensive and not great. This was some of the best I have had, better than sen in my opinion. The drinks were also very good. I dont know if I will be back as it is very far from me and bougie, but definetly great for a special occasion, if you sit outside.

5 stars for the staff and the vibes! Everyone who works here is so genuinely kind and it really…read moremade our experience more enjoyable. Beautiful views of the harbor - book for sunset. We came on a Saturday evening and they had dueling pianos all night which was so much fun. The performers were active with the crowd and everyone was involved. I suggest sitting away from the music if you are looking to talk because it is very loud. The food was good but not out of this world. We had the calamari, a spicy salmon roll, edamame and a salad. They were accommodating for a gluten allergy and it is fairly reasonably priced considering the location. A much cheaper option than Si Si which is also oh three mile harbor

Photos
Sunset Harbor at EHP Resort & Marina - Play room

Play room

Sunset Harbor at EHP Resort & Marina
Sunset Harbor at EHP Resort & Marina

See all

Montauk Sushi - sushi - Updated May 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...