I love to find a good thrift store. However, this one did not impress me very much. There were some…read moregood finds, but the environment causes my trip to come up short. The floors are highly dirty with trash lying all over, not to include the distasteful music playing over the loud speakers. To each their own - Not my cup of tea. Prices are also decent, but questionable when finding the same item with different prices marked down. The staff is very friendly, but seems to be unable to answer any questions without calling a manager or higher-up.

Very happy to discover this thrift store while driving through York and surprised it never made it…read moreto Yelp before now. Now that I know of it's existence I'll be coming on the regular. Walking in I wasn't expecting much. The retail area is very nondescript and unmemorable. Very basic layout with rows of clothing separated by item/color, and some racks but not many by size. Shoes and purses lined the one wall, mens and children's were on the other side and housewares in the back. Some furniture items were showcased in the front with lesser quality pieces in the back. Little or no display or props other than furniture which is just there. At first glance I wasn't sure if I wanted to take the time to go thru the racks, after all I had hubby in the car (his choice) on a hot summer day. But once I dove in I couldn't stop. The brands and quality were some of the best. I saw Michael Kors over and over. Many items were like new or with tags. In about 15 minutes time I had an entire cart of items to try on. With my recent weight gain I'm finding less and less that fit (damn you covid!!) so I'm having to constantly shop to replenish my closet. I will say that the prices were higher than average for thrift and more in line with consignment, which normally I would bulk at given the retail space is so blah. But the quality was exceptional and I found several key pieces that are great additions to my wardrobe so it was worth the extra money. If I find the time I'll post some of the great items I bought. Just an example of pricing: tee shirts are in the $3.99 - $7.99 range, purses $9.99, jeans and shorts $7.99-$11.99, some blazers, coats and dresses were $19.99 They do have offers if you sign up for their email and I was able to score 5% just for asking to sign up (and mentioning the current discount the customer in front of me used). The staff were happy to give it to me without question and also to tell me how many people my purchase today fed ( a whooping 23!). It's shopping you can feel good about and also very worthy of your sell-able donations. Worth mentioning: no Sunday hours, easy to find BEHIND the Weis on 462 in East York beside the Petco.

Great service, organized and clean!! Good prices. Easy to find. good selection. I enjoyed going…read morethere.

We visit in this area at least annually and always seek out the Mount Joy Gift and Thrift. On our…read morelast visit we were pleasantly surprised to find this shop in a new location and facility which is also more directly accessible. The store lives up to its name in that offerings are more on display vs resembling a garage or yard sale manner--more organized with space surrounding the houseware items. Clothes are neatly hung appear clean. I especially like viewing the donated China sets , gardening supplies and seasonal figurines. The prices range from reasonable to real bargains. Music adds to the relaxing browsing experience. Overall one of my favorite thrift stores!

What a great place to donate to . I donated a beautiful 12 place setting china set with matching…read moreserving dishes .. also a lot of my clothing some new and other clothing also .. I've purchased everything from jeans and tops to nice going out to dinner or church clothing . They have household items also .. jewelry.. shoes .. The profits go to our community!! So u are helping the different needs of our community. Just look at their beautiful window displays.... It will entice u to go inside to see more !!!

I am going to go ahead and give this thrift shop 5 stars simply because whenever I am in town, if I…read morecan't get in there I know I'm missing something. This is a thrift shop but does not carry furniture or large items. Most of the store is women's clothing in all sizes from Petite to Plus. There are small children's and men's clothing areas. There are also children's toys, books, purses, jewelry, shoes and some accessories. There are also several small areas with linens, collectibles, small appliances and kitchen wares. One negative is a Keurig I purchased with a tag that it works, but it didn't. It turned on but that was it. I imagine they checked it came on and assumed someone would not donate a non working item. But I paid $15 and consider it a donation to their charitable contributions. OK so the clothes are pretty much exclusively in very good condition or new. They do mark up designer brands and new items with tags. I paid $25 for a Michael Kors dress with tags, and $8 for a new child's outfit. They have easily accessed dressing rooms and a speedy check out process. They offer a frequent buyer card with $10 off when filled. The store is crowded but very well organized. Clothes are hung by type, size and color. So if I am looking for a white long sleeved shirt size small, they are all hung in one place. One positive/negative is their amazing store window displays. They decorate the windows seasonally with the best of what is donated. It is incredibly enticing to see all the wonderful items that might be available inside. The catch is that NOTHING in the window is available for purchase until after the season is over. The Christmas windows items will be available January 9th at 10 am with the line forming early. So if something you have been wanting appears in that window display you will need to be on hand at a very specific date and time, like an estate sale or auction. Because I don't even live in the area, I pretty much don't even look at the windows since I can't buy anything there. I see from other reviews the store windows cause lots of angst for shoppers and for staff apparently. But since I know the deal I just accept it. One review from 2019 talks about a children's play area. I have been shopping here 10 years at least, and there is no children's play area. There is an area of toys for sale. When I was in last week 3 small children were tearing up the toys in there and screaming into a Frozen karaoke machine. When they put it down for a minute I scooped it up and bought it for my granddaughter. Yes, it is an alcove but every toy, book and game is priced so obviously for sale. Who in the world leaves a 2 and 4 year old unsupervised in a thrift shop toy sales area? So consider that if you read it below and wondered about it.

Everyone was pleasant and selections are unprecedented…read more I've been a customer for many years and will continue for many more. I always find something new and recommend Carriage House to anyone interested in better clothing at lower prices.

Beautiful tucked away gem of a consignment shop. Service is awesome and they'll give you a quick…read moretour when you arrive if you've never been there. Outstanding selection big brand names for great prices. Scored still with tags chicos slacks.

Are the low ratings just to keep this place to yourselves? Every time I come here I find…read moresomething(s) very cool, great variety of vendors and the best part is things are usually priced as if the vendors WANT to sell them and aren't just putting them on display! Edit: I read the other reviews: things must've changed in the past few years-- no staff followed me around, they actually gave us good recommendations of where to eat, and prices were good! (Maybe vendors just didn't raise them w inflation? Lol whatever works!)

I found a lot of cool little things, but I could've spent at least another hour in there. So much…read moreselection on multiple levels. Displays are well organized, in my opinion.

I thought this store was pretty good. Great prices. Clothing for men and women. The lady at the…read morefront desk was nice. They have a rewards program. If you like thrifting and like Carlisle you should definitely check it out. I got some silver plated grapefruit spoons which is part of the reason I love thrifting. Never know what you might find. The store next door was a good stop too.

The owners are great people! They even donated a piece for my craft project! I have gotten a lot of…read moregreat blazers and jackets from here. They also have local artists crafts to sell.

I had added this business and for some reason they decided that what I entered was not true and…read morecombined this store with another. There are in fact four total stores, and I can assure that this one is the location in South York. If this reverts back to that actual York location, in downtown, know that I did not visit there and that was definitely not the location I went to. I was not in downtown York, I was in a plaza in South York. In fact, this was an old Tuesday Morning location before they moved in. LifePath is what I would call this areas Goodwill. A thrift store that benefits the area and the work this organization does. I can't speak to all the locations, I can just speak to this one. This location was well organized and had a ton of items. I didn't come in here for anything in particular, I just came in here to browse. I went through the clothes and peaked at the furniture. But I was drawn to the electronics section as I always am. I went up and down the aisles and found one item in particular that caught my eye. Something that I had been toying with getting, but just never found one at a decent price. I walked by it several times and eventually picked it up. I had wanted a hot air popcorn maker for a while, just didn't want to pay the price for a brand new one. Eventually I would get around to it, but not a priority. This thing was basically brand new, didn't even look like it was used once. I saw the price and decided that at $6 now was the time to snag it. Went to pay, had a great transaction with the employees in here. Paid and was out the door. When I got home, I did my due diligence with cleaning the pieces that should be cleaned. It may have looked brand new, but didn't want to take any chances. Plugged that thing in and made myself some of the best popcorn I had in a while. Definitely a diamond in the rough here.

Exceptionally friendly and helpful staff. Good selection of items, fair prices. Found what we were…read morelooking for quickly. Staff reached out to help us. We were on a mission to find unique bric-a-brac for wedding decorations and were not disappointed! Open aisles, not cluttered & clean. Good selection of Hawaiian shirts. No real selection of depression / carnival glass, but that is getting harder to find anyway.

The Middletown Interfaith Senior Services Thrift Shop is a great little store who proceeds benefit…read morethe local community of Middletown. They have great prices and a good selection of clothing, small household goods, and books.

Love this thrift store! It is small but the prices are better than the VOA, Salvation Army,…read moreGoodwill, or any consignment shop. They almost always have a sale, i.e. buy 1 women's shirt, get 1 free or buy 1 kids item, get 1 free. They list the deals on the front door. This is a great place to get games; unlike some other thrift stores they verify the pieces are there and rubber band the box closed. Cash only, but there's a bank across the street with an ATM if you need it.