The stuffed spinach pizza was really good, a lot of yummy bright green spinach and gooey cheese…read more The crust was tasty too, good texture and cooked all the way through. I would just caution, it's a LOT. Do not get greedy while ordering. I shoulda got the small, but no, I got greedy and ordered the medium. I literally ate pizza for days.

Delicious pizza. The sauce is sweeter and I love it. Highly recommend. We dine here at least once…read moreper month. It is the Pizza we crave the most.

Simply perfect. We…read moretried the London Timmy with extra sausage, and it was the best surprise of the night. The fenugreek added an incredible depth of flavor, tying everything together beautifully, and the sausage was absolutely delicious. Our second pizza was The Puff Formerly Known As, which was equally impressive. The hint of lemon zest made every flavor pop without overpowering the pizza. The dough deserves a special mention: light, beautifully fermented, and made with Caputo flour, resulting in the perfect texture and bite. I have to admit--I never expected to find one of the top three pizzerias of my life in Eureka, but I did. A huge thank you to Bob for welcoming us into your beautiful and authentic restaurant.

The most adorable place with phenomenal food. The pizza is excellent!! It is nicer but not too…read morefancy. A perfect date night or dinner out!! When passing through Eureka, please stop here. You won't regret it!!

Not Even 1 star. Laziest group of 'workers' I've ever seen. My group was told (on a Tuesday) that…read morethere would be a 45 minute wait for food. Another friend of mine was told similar on a different occasion. I understand that this place does carry out orders too, but there was literally only 2 other tables the night my group was informed of the 45 minute wait???

Went there on a Tuesday and no worker in sight, we eventually left thinking their was just gonna be…read moreno service, but turned out the other table near us with "customers" was the bartender talking to her friends. Lame she saw us and had dark brown hair. Boyfriend ripped a bunch of a## while we were waiting so hope she got that linger.

This was flagged as one of the best pizza places in all of Illinois so it's been on my to try list…read morefor a while. Located on Seminary Street, cute shops surround and on street parking available. Unassuming from the outside and purely historic, refurbished, recycled everything inside. Jazz and classic rock was playing on a record player. Staff was lovely and helpful with questions. Order at the counter and take a seat. Glasses are chilled, no ice. Canned sodas, water, alcoholic beverages available. Pizza has 4 sizes, specials and make your own. Sandwiches, salads. I chose the goat cheese and herb pizza and it was sooooo good. Chewy yet crunchy, the crust is perfection. Takes 20-30 minutes when not just. Worth the wait. Will definitely come back when we are in the area.

I called first to see if they had something handheld as I'm traveling through town. The employee…read morethat answered the phone was very polite and helpful and also willing to explain specials and ingredients. I decided to go in and make my choice. Both employees working were so kind and helpful. The sandwich was delicious! And liked the kindness showed when the employee that checked me out got me more napkins upon my request and offered to grab the door for me on the way out. While the food speaks for itself (so good and a fantastic price for a healthy lunch!), politeness goes a long way! Highly recommend!

Service was great, and there was live music on Friday when we went. The pizza was delicious but…read moredid take a bit to get out to the table. They must only be able to to do a few pizzas at a time in the oven because we ordered three and only two came out at first and then one several minutes later. Was nice to try something different in the area and were pleasantly surprised by this little gem.

We hired Rubi's for a Teacher Appreciation Week luncheon and they were wonderful! the pizzas were…read moreall hot and delicious and the afternoon went without a single glitch! Michelle is a great communicator and her and the rest of the staff were friendly and courteous! they were also cheaper to hire than the other food trucks we priced out. Definitely recommend!

Only because it won't let me post zero stars. The place is filthy all over, but the bathrooms are…read moredisgusting and I am a guy who lived in a fraternity house with a military style (no stalls, just five open toilets next to each other) with 70 other guys in college. On our worst, everyone was drunk and puking and pooping all day (most home football Saturdays), it never got as bad as this Casey's. Avoid like the plague.

has to be worst Casey's around! ordered Taco pizza and not ONE chip!! notta!!! have been on hold…read morefor 36 mins waiting for someone to answer the damn phone. NOT HAPPY. want a total refund !! if it didn't cost 20$ for a medium pizza,, I would have let it go!

Overpriced, mid-tier pizza. Can't believe paid 66$ for a pizza, beef roll, and a dozen boneless…read morewings. Prefaced with I've never been to Illinois till earlier this week, ergo unaware of quality and what restaurants people will keep going through patronage, I have spent the last few days checking out restaurants on Yelp. Noticed this was a surprisingly highly rated spot, even though the photos didn't look that great. Through ordering online , placed an order for a small pan pizza , not realizing (isn't listed on their website) that adding any toppings is 1.25$ more each; like a 23$ small pizza. It appears the pizza had its toppings put after the sauce, and cheese on top, leaving an unsatisfying appearance and feeling I would've needed to order "extra cheese" to get a normal pizza. The exterior of the crust was hard, like baked too high of a temp for too long, and crunched like a cracker with the dough being dense and flavorless. The "beef roll" appeared to be their small dough folded over into a 12"x8" rectangle and cut into 1"x3" long pieces , and dusted with an Italian seasoning. Thin shaved beef inside, opted for pepperoni in it too. It was alright, again the crust put me off, the au jous that comes with it was watery and bland, and for 20.50$, felt like an overpay. Personally I like getting boneless wings with pizza, so opted for a dozen of those for us. Limited flavors , went with "hot", which was no hotter than Franks red hot. If they were fried, they steamed inside their foil and styrofoam container, and were received soggy and soft. Nothing noteworthy on taste or experience there.. beyond the 16.75$ charge, making each quarter-sized piece like 1.40$ each All in all impression: overpriced. I wouldn't go back, and if this is the best rated pizza in town, think I won't be going out for pizza around here the duration of my trip, least it be overpriced for mediocre food again.

I think they closed, we both got food poisoning. Won't let me leave NO STARS, or I would.read more

this place is deadass dogshit. pizza was so mid, service was the worst for ever had, manager was…read morevery inconsiderate, first 0/10 ive ever had at a restaurant. fuck ass restaurant

Stopped in last night for dinner... We went for just a basic sausage and cheese pizza and an order…read moreof cheese bread.... It was all fabulous. I do believe the pizza was the best I've had in forever! Thanks for the great meal

Giving this 3 stars for the price! I think pizza hut has gotten overpriced the last few years! $26…read morefor a large veggie pizza? We got a free breadsticks coupon but still ended up paying $65 for the whole meal!! We got a 2 ranch and 2 marinara sauces, a cookie pie and a liter of soda along with drivers delivery fee and tip!! The food was good and hot and they didn't forget anything but I can easily spend $20 on a great pizza and quality at Mollys pizza in town! It was just really disappointing these days for the price wow!

My bother was in town. I ordered a large thin with pepperoni,mushrooms,and sausage at Pizza Hut…read more For carry out. Went to go pick it up and brought it home. Opened the box the biz when I got home and they pizza looked burned and not a lot of tops on it looked like no cheese was add. Took a bit if the pizza and did not taste any sauce in fact did not taste anything but card board crust. Nobody bets the hut. Pizza Hut you need to fix this. Nobody is betting the hut right now.