Tasty pie and friendly staff! I tried butterscotch pie for the first time--good and not overly sweet. Very large though! The parking lot and building itself are a little awkward. There isn't much space to park in the lot or much space to stand inside. I did see indoor seating, but that room also looked like it was holding supplies, so I sat outside, which was nice. I wouldn't have enjoyed sitting inside. They also have offering beyond pies that sound good, but I haven't tried those yet. read more

See all

Stopped in to check out this small pie shop in Kentucky and so glad we did ! They make homemade pies from scratch . The space is very compact , the counter is right in front of you filled with yummy pies , while behind the counter pies are being prepared . They make pies both for the public and also for several of Ramsey's Diner's located in the area. They even make quiches , pot pies and soups ! We purchased a slice of good old fashioned apple and pecan pie to go .Both were outrageously delicious! The pies were not overly sweet , they had plenty of filling and the crust was nice and flaky . Sooooo good ! read more

See all

Did the butterscotch pie recipe change? I used to love this, it always tasted just like my grandma used to make; but the last two times that I have ordered-it's been a MISS! The custard is dry and thick, almost fudge consistency, the flavor is lack luster- the crust and the merengue were just like they always have been-, PLEASE BRING BACK THE OLD SMOOTH CUSTARD! I just threw an $8 slice of pie in the garbage. read more

Missy's Pie - Butterscotch Pie - Bakeries Near Me - Lexington, Kentucky

Amazing pie, friendly service! Could have gone daily on our trip to Lex! Too bad we didn't discover it till the 3rd to last day. We had apple, cherry, French Silk, Mayday, and Snickerdoodle. The mayday was a strong favorite! Crust is perfection! read more

Missy's Pie - Mayday pie! Yum! Perfection! - Bakeries Near Me - Lexington, Kentucky

Stopped here in early morning on the way somewhere else. Open early and ready. We bought a whole pecan pie to take with us as I've heard having pie for breakfast is taboo lol. When we ate it, it was more than I'd imagined. This was easily the best pecan pie I've ever tasted! And this was without whipped cream lol. So if you find yourself in the neighborhood, please stop by even if you're going to eat it later. read more

Tried this place on a late Saturday afternoon and unfortunately they were already out of all of my first picks, but the staff were very friendly. Went with the Butterscotch Pie and the Chocolate Creme. Also tried their pimento cheese and bleu cheese. The butterscotch pie was pretty good. Sweet, creamy and decadent. The chocolate creme was overwhelmingly sweet, too rich and was not our favorite. The pimento was really, really good. It consisted of bigger cheese pieces and less of a cream-like texture than others I've had, which was a nice change. There was no hint of any heat, which I also appreciated. Bleu cheese was also flavorful. I later had a piece of the may day pie from a restaurant that served Missy's Pie and that by far, is my favorite. Pecans and chocolate chips, their take on the Derby pie. read more

Just give it a try! Last year's chess pie and pecan butter were a hit. Trying pecan this year. Locally owned, small business, a tradition - need more of this type of place! So, go getcha some pie. They also have gift certificates! read more

These pies are incredible! We got two to share, coconut cream and silk pie. They both were amazing

We literally live down the street and have driven/walked past this place dozens of times. Today i was on a mission to find a peace offering for my boss who had mentioned how much he loved the black bottom banana pie. Lucky for me they had all the pies available so i got a piece. Hopefully it softens the blow out between my boss and myself if not I'll eat the pie myself (kidding or maybe not). When i arrived there were no other customers so i could take my time and slpbher over the mile high meringue i saw on one of the pies. They also offer a lunch menu which id definitely go back for at another time Where they bake it's an open air space so you can watch them work which i always find fascinating since I'm an avid baker myself. Although these days I'm leaning more towards homemade marshmallow making. Nevertheless the man who i dealt with was nice and accommodating as could be while I checked out the other pies just in case I wanted to grab a treat for myself. read more

Excellent pies always consistent fresh and delicious! I no longer live in Lexington and was visiting recently. The seasonal peach pie was a hostess gift. Everyone totally enjoyed it. read more

Brownie pie was bland, but the crust had no flavor at all. Here is a pro tip, use a cookie crust (maybe Oreo crust) to add flavor, texture and substance to the pie. Add some whole chocolate chips and some walnuts, and maybe a thin layer of vanilla frosting to top it off. You're welcome. read more

I learned about Missy's Pies at Ramsay's like most folks. I've tried several of them over the years, and they are all good! Brownie is the family favorite. This year, I was lazy at Thanksgiving, and instead of cooking, I ordered a pie. I called the first week of November to pick up a pie the day before Thanksgiving. I chose a pick-up time and got a confirmation number. On Wednesday, I rolled in and picked up my pie curbside. They had 2 drive thru lanes so you could pick up your pie, pay, and keep on traveling! Pie was great. Pick-up was easy! Pro tip: Pop a piece the brownie pie in the microwave for 20 seconds and add some Greater's Vanilla Bean ice cream drizzle with a bit a chocolate sauce and caramel and you have an elevated treat! read more

Amazing service! Pies are phenomenal, highly highly recommend! Best pecan pie I've ever had

Found out about Missy's Pies from Ramsey's Diner. Ordered a slice of strawberry rhubarb and chocolate crème. Both were good and portions were generous. The crust was not delicate or flakey for my taste. Chocolate crème: If hot cocoa and chocolate silk pie had a baby, this would be it, but it was a tad too sweet. The meringue top helped to cut the sweetness of the chocolate crème filling which had a rich chocolate taste reminiscent of hot cocoa. Parts of the crust were soggy. Strawberry rhubarb: Filling was firm, sweetness was just right and there was some tartness from the rhubarb. Crust was average. read more

Missy's Pie - Half eaten chocolate crème pie with merengue topping. - Bakeries Near Me - Lexington, Kentucky

See all

Walking into this little store front you get the sensation that you'll be eating a damn good pie. It's all hustle and bustle, early morning prepping to stock their shelves and store orders. Great selections await you, cream, fruit, brownie, and cheesecakes. I ordered two slices and they happily finished my pie before slicing it. Can't get much fresher than that!!! Black bottom banana cream is a fabulous choice. Everything about it is perfectly balanced! Crust is homemade and can be tasted in every bite. Wish I lived closer so I could enjoy every pie option they serve. read more

Buy all my holiday pies from here.. The banana creme pie is the best!!! May day make it to all my holidays!!

The most delicious pies ever, especially the pumpkin pie. It's addictive . I can't get enough of the pumpkin pie

YES! Their food is FUCKING YUMMY. Mmmmmmmm! Like damn! Coconut pie was making me lick my lips! Lady serving me was a total cutie too!

We ordered the sugar free 5 berry pie and it was amazing. Service was easy and great. Highly recommend!

Hello do you have a fresh Butterscotch pie available? Yes we do , I purchased it took it home to serve for after dinner. Pie was tasteless, filing was a paste consistency. I could not serve this pie to anyone. I contacted Missys , information given, offered to return the pie. They said no need our office will reach out to you. It's been a month, that did not happen . Now i know it's about the money and quantity and not about the customer or quality. read more

At Missy's you can order a pie a few days ahead and pick up your fresh, delicious circle of heaven. I ordered a Dutch apple pie ( not on their menu) that was as good as my mom's and made my cry tears of joy. How I miss her, but eating Missy's pies is a comfort. Their key lime and brownie bottom pies are family favorites. We love this place. read more

Absolutely delicious! There are so many options for you to choose from. The warm pie with icecream on top is just phenomenal! I highly recommend Ramsey's beforehand! read more

Missy's Pie - a plate of ice cream - Bakeries Near Me - Lexington, Kentucky

Stumbled on Missy's pies while shopping in downtown Lexington and got a piece of the pear-blueberry crumble pie and the mayday pie. Both were amazing! The pear-blueberry reminded me of my grandmother's pear pie. I ended up going back 2 days later and taking 2 whole pies back to Nashville with me! read more

If you have a dream about pie, here is your place. It's in a great spot in the city with plenty of parking because it's on a corner. This place has plenty of home made pies. I went down and picked out a chocolate pie. It was hard to choose with all the choices. Below is the list of all the pies. Just click. http://missyspieshop.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/01/img20171204_15202502.jpg read more

Amazing! The pies are all fresh. The chicken in dumplings were so yummy! Great place to get things to go!

Best cheesecake in the city! Don't have a pic of the New York style but it is excellent. Just got a chocolate chip cheesecake and we were very impressed. Can't wait to try a pie. They now serve lunch. We bought a pint of pimento cheese. Very good. read more

Missy's Pie - Choco chip cheesecake. Couldn't wait to eat before taking a pic. - Bakeries Near Me - Lexington, Kentucky

Paul and I were wanting a post dinner sweet treat, so we gave Missy's a try. I had the combination pie, which was a chocolate peanut butter combo. It was good. The peanut butter portion was light, which complemented the somewhat dense chocolate layer. The crust was flakey and buttery as pie crust should be. Paul has the butterscotch pie. I took one bite and nearly spit it out. I have a powerful sweet tooth, but that pie was cloyingly, knock you on your butt, sweet. On a brighter note, the meringue was good. Service was quick but not particularly friendly. The young woman at the counter seemed annoyed, as though we were keeping her from something important, and came across as condescending. In sum, try the combination pie, avoid the butterscotch, and do not expect service with a smile. read more

I have a weakness for pie. It's a shame I don't have more pie-themed clothes & jewelry to showcase my love of pie. Anyway...when I'm craving pie, Missy's is the place to go. There are so many freshly baked options to choose from. My favorite is the May Day Pie -- Missy's version of Derby Pie -- warm, ooey, gooey, chocolatey awesomeness. The portion sizes are humongous and if you order your pie a la mode, you'll get a soft-ball-sized scoop of ice cream, too. Definitely get your pie to go, though. There are a couple of tables available for seating, but they're not comfortable and they're located in a storage area. read more

Missy's Pie - Mayday pie (their version of Derby pie), warmed & with ice cream. - Bakeries Near Me - Lexington, Kentucky

See all

The pie just isn't that good. The peanut butter one is decent and the only reason I am giving them two stars. It helps that the crust on that one is different than the others because their regular crust is somewhat soggy and bland. They ought to have crust down to an art form after all these years. Also, anything with meringue is a hard no. Again, that would seem to be a necessary skill in the pie business, but it's not even close to acceptable. They have been around forever, and no matter how long I wait before trying it again (about 20 years before this last attempt), I am always shocked they are so below average. They're not cheap either. There is much better pie to be found in this town. Actually, I just tend to order pie through GoldBelly. I'd rather pay more and get something divine. read more

What can I say, except for this is the best place around for pie. The variety is perfect, fruity pies, sweet pies, I have tried many and not been disappointed. You can get their pies at Ramsey's, but also here. It's worth a trip to just have - slice of pie. They also have a small, but tasty catering menu. I recommend the chicken salad. read more

Love the variety of pies here. The wonderful scent of sweet buttery goodness greets you when you walk into the shop. I wish I hadn't already had a huge lunch next door at Ramseys so I could try a bunch of the different varieties. I had the combo which was the brownie bottom with a peanut butter/cream cheese filling on top. So thick, rich & creamy.....I always judge how good a pie shop is by their pie crust & this crust was a perfect combination of flaky,salty. I wish I could have tried the butterscotch meringue, banana black bottom & classic apple. $4.65/slice or apprx $18 for a whole pie. The gal who baked the pies was so nice too! read more

Missy's Pie - Butterscotch pie with meringue & key lime. - Bakeries Near Me - Lexington, Kentucky

Amazing derby pie! The slice of pie was HUGE too! I wish I could have had more but it was so filling I could only eat one piece! This will be my go to place when I'm back in Kentucky! read more

I LOVE pie! I usually make my own but every now and then I just want to try something different. I have gotten pies from Missy's for years but I have to say the last several times I wasn't impressed. The crusts are very soggy and the filling was old and cracked (peanut butter pie). The sugar-free cherry was no better than canned. I'm not sure why they are slipping but it's gone from a solid standby to I think I'll pass. Other reviewers have posted that the shop was unclean and I have to say I agree. I hope the managers/owners take heed and make some necessary adjustments. read more

I special ordered a peach pie. If it had been any better, Jesus would have taken it with him!

My favorite pie for the first Saturday in May is named May Day Pie at Missy's. It is most certainly Derby Pie and the best I've ever eaten. A while back someone trademarked their version as the 'Derby Pie' and they have been known to sue for trademark infringement if someone else uses that name. The proprietor would be outclassed by Missy's version. read more

I agree with person that's says, meh. That are mediocre pies at best. Ordered 2 for this Thanksgiving, a pumpkin and pecan. Pumpkin tasted no better than one from Kroger or Fresh Market, which would be around $7-$8. The pecan pie was so runny you couldn't cut it. I'm from the south, pecan pie should not be runny. My point to all this is for $56 for two pies, they should be spot on and the best damn pie I've ever eaten. These were $5-$8 pies. Just ate a coconut crème from Pie Peddler for $14 and it was so much better than these by 10x. Sorry, but I will not be ordering any more pies from Missy's. read more

Really great pie and cute atmosphere! However there is not much seating available. The woman who was working gave useful information on pie recommendations for me! read more

Amazing pie and amazing service. From Chicago so had to take some back with me. Mayday and the combination pie is a must have.

Missy's has the BEST pies around. After living in Lex for 6 years, I moved away in 2016. I still miss these pies and crave them occasionally. They are so good, and the wide variety is sure to please everyone. If you're debating stopping, do it. read more

We had the chocolate brownie pie. It is very thick not super rich or overwhelming sweet. We asked for it warmed with scoop ice cream if you gonna get pie why skimp on the ice cream! read more

Missy's Pie - Go ahead get desert before dinner! - Bakeries Near Me - Lexington, Kentucky