OVERALL: 5.4/10 (Yelp Converted Score: 2.7/5). Advice: Not actual, authentic Japanese food, by any account. If you want sushi, go to Kashiba. If you want any other dish, this place is not close to the top ten of Japanese places you should try.
Honestly, I'm shocked to be giving this place a 3 stars (what with rounding), but I guess this is what happens when you have a review system that forces you to rate things based on whole numbers.
1) VARIETY/SELECTION: 8/10. They had quite a number of pages on the menu. I don't know if this speaks to "upscale Japanese establishment" or "a typical Asian fusion joint", but I lean more to the latter than the former. The menu sections included: appetizer, soup, grills, fry, saute/wok, sushi bar, sashimi/nigiri, special roll, maki. It was quite overwhelming, but... maybe a lot of selection isn't the best thing.
2) FRESHNESS: 5/10. Each of the dishes were underwhelming in their own unique way.
The sushi roll's rice was undercooked, salmon was at least marginally fresh, but I wasn't "wowed" by the sushi. Overall, it definitely had an inconsistent temperature (the fish versus the seaweed versus the rice versus the other fillings). This likely points to some combination between chef inexperience and lack of ingredient freshness.
The black cod was tender, but lacked any flavour. The garnishes weren't tasteful either; while the cod was at least somewhat moist, my partner commented at how greasy it was (that's when I noticed it too). The upside? It was at least warm-ish cod.
The sukiyaki came with a lightly poached egg on it (NOT AUTHENTIC). The vegetables included *maybe* had 6-8 different ones, maximum, but nothing that would qualify being in an authentic Japanese sukiyaki dish. There was a very thin layer of mostly overcooked (supposedly angus-quality) beef, as well as noodles. The small assortment (not much variety, it's like when non-Asian businesses try to add veggies to something to call it "Asian") of vegetables (cabbage, carrot, onion, normal mushrooms) at least had a few of each within the wide, but not deep bowl.
3) VALUE FOR MONEY: 4/10. We ordered three items:
- Beautiful Alaska Roll ($18) - overpriced; cost should take more than $10/roll, including labour and ingredients.
- Grilled Saikyo Black Cod ($20) - also overpriced. The fish was slightly greasy, moist, but not very flavourful.
- Beef Sukiyaki ($25) - way overpriced (although the portion size looks good at first glance).
I'm shocked this cost over $50 - given the portion size, quality, and general plating of each dish. It didn't come across as "upscale", it came across as overpriced.
4) SERVICE: 5/10. Our experience should have been relatively quick, since the restaurant claimed 25% capacity maximum, and were maybe 10% full when we arrived (without a reservation).
The sushi roll took around 15 minutes to come out. The Alaskan cod came next ($20 for this one), around 15-20 minutes later. So far this experience isn't something I'd come back for.
Did I mention that the service is EXTREMELY SLOW. and this is with limited capacity - I can't imagine what would happen if this place was at full capacity. We waited roughly an hour (after sitting down and ordering) for all of our food.
The sukiyaki arrived last, about 45-50 minutes after we arrived.
Water refills were prompt (twice), but without food, we're not really having a reason to drink water.
5) CONSISTENCY / FIRST IMPRESSION: 5/10. I wouldn't recommend this place for anyone looking for a true upscale Japanese restaurant experience - there are many better places elsewhere in Seattle. You'd be doing yourself a disservice by going here, if you hadn't tried any of the actual great ones already (Kashiba being the incumbent #1). read more