Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Mid Continental Gems

    4.4 (7 reviews)
    Closed Closed

    Services - Mid Continental Gems

    Jewelry repair

    Mid Continental Gems Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Mid Continental Gems

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Kristin K.

    Heather is literally amazing!!! I could literally cry right now when looking at this stunning ring and I CANNOT believe it is mine. I showed my fiancé a ring that I thought was way out of our price range -- a dream ring. Tonight I was surprised with a ring beyond my wildest imaginations -- like the picture but so much better. If you're in the MKE area and you're looking for a ring you HAVE to go to Heather.

    Ring in it's original state, before "repair".

    See all

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Mid Continental Gems

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Jewelry 1,614 times last month within 20 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Gold Creations

    Gold Creations

    (19 reviews)

    I was in the area for lunch and I was getting pet food in this strip mall so I decided to stop by…read moreto have a link removed from my watch so it fits better. The place is in the very back side of the mall. It's a very nice store with a nice variety of items. The man who helped me was very friendly and serviced me quickly. Overall it was a quick pleasant experience.

    I am very unhappy with my recent experiences with Gold Creations. There are no warranties,…read moreguarantees, and they totally nickel and dime you if you need any work on the jewelry you purchased at their store. Nothing is free. You want your white gold bridal bands rhodium dipped, you will pay per ring. So the way to get this cheaper is to solder them together, which you will pay for. By the way, because they don't tell you this, when you solder them together they may not fit. You should consider getting them resized. Oh and they charge for that too. You want your appraisal updated, it's not free. Over the past year I have apparently chipped three diamonds. I did not know diamonds chipped, apparently that's a thing. I understand paying for them, but find it funny that I have had these rings for several years and never had an issue until recently. I have another ring from a mall jeweler and they stand by all the work. I lost a diamond and they replaced it for free. They rhodium dip my ring for free. Recently they resized it for free. They also reinforced the back of the band that I thought was thining for free. I am supposed to get this ring checked every six months for the warranty to be valid and have not because I have not been wearing it, it just sits in my jewelry box. That's okay, they recently checked it and re-validated the warranty. I have also purchased jewelry at Kessler's. Kessler's is amazing! They have a great warranty and stand behind their work and all your purchases. If I need anything done in the future I will be going to Kessler's. We will never go back to Gold Creations. They have lost our business. I used to tell everyone to go there I will now be telling everyone NOT to go there! Word of mouth is a great marketing tool!

    Scott's Jewelry Shop

    Scott's Jewelry Shop

    (27 reviews)

    $$

    Went in to visit Scott with a broken prong on a marquis-styled ring and with some drawings and…read moreideas for a pendant redesign. It's hard to find or trust a jeweler and Scott easily earned my business for life! Scott is patient, caring, and sincere, and truly loves his job. He looked at my ring and explained what needed to be done for repair. He also alerted me that the stone had damage-cracks but he would do his best. When he received the parts he started working on the ring and during the process broke the stone. He called me immediately and told me the unfortunate news and said that he had another stone on order at his expense. When I got the ring back it was perfect, and the stone is of much better quality than I previously had. Scott and I looked in books and online for ideas for the pendant I want to redesign. Even though I had my heart set on some designs he told me the honest truth about the flaws in the designs and produced a design that will not only be beautiful, it will last for years, and it will be reasonable! He added higher quality stones at a discount & gave me a very good price on old/unworn jewelry. Even though I haven't presented the payment yet and the project is on hold, I'm very excited to get the piece completed. I can't wait to work with Scott again! Take all your jewelry to Scott, you won't have regrets!

    Scott resized rings for both my husband and me. He did a perfect job! Also, it was done in a timely…read moremanner at a fair price. Yes, I'd recommend him!

    Kesslers Diamonds - Add a caption

    Kesslers Diamonds

    (25 reviews)

    $$$

    I've been a Kessler's customer for 30 years now. When my fiance and I first went to choose a…read moresetting I had no idea what I would like. Grandma Carol (now happily retired) walked me through a variety of styles taking note each time of what I liked and didn't until she presented me with a set that combined all the elements that had made my face light up. With my part done my fiance went back and looked through the loose diamonds until he found the perfect center stone. They serviced my ring repeatedly over the years. Sizing it up while I was pregnant and back down after my babies were born. They repaired a shank that cracked because I wore my ring to the gym while lifting weights and repaired a prong that I snagged and bent. For our 20th anniversary we had a custom enhancement made that made me fall in love with my ring all over again. I have other pieces from Kessler's as well: earrings, several chains and my favorite cross necklace. I hadn't needed anything in several years, but am now looking for another piece of bling. I showed up at the Brookfield store and was greeted by Ari who was able to read my mind and guide me to the perfect ring for me. She ordered one brought over from another store and has done some incredible logistical coordination setting a loose diamond into a Kessler's setting. There are a few extra costs when the center stone isn't purchased from them (cost to set the stone and an appraisal fee), but that seems logical to me. They are and will continue to be my jeweler!! I've never had a bad experience at a Kessler's store!!

    Kesslers was absolutely phenomenal for my fiancé and I when we went engagement ring shopping. Ari…read morewas a WONDERFUL consultant that was patient and so kind and could tell when my face lit up while looking at a ring. Since getting engaged I have been in every time and if Ari is working she goes out of her way to say hi, ask about our wedding, and go above and beyond to make us feel like family at Kesslers. As a girl who isn't super high maintenance and doesn't wear a lot of jewelry, this has been HUGE for me. We can't wait to buy all our future diamonds from kesslers and continue to work with Ari! She's simply the best!!!

    Sullivan Jewelers

    Sullivan Jewelers

    (11 reviews)

    $$

    I went to Sullivan Jewelers to purchase a watch battery- they are only 5 dollars (and some change)…read more I've never seen prices so low but was super happy with the quick and professional service. When I showed my watch to one of the associates, he admired how unique the bezel looked and commented on it. You can tell the employees here are passionate about jewelry and watches. While I was waiting for my watch battery to be replaced, I took a quick look at all the gorgeous pieces that they have at the store. I noticed unique antique pieces as well as gemstones and diamonds. A gorgeous pink tourmaline piece caught my eye and I fell in love with how unique it looked. The next day I found out that the ring had a spot on the metal and I brought it back where the amazing jewelers fixed it up! I will definitely be returning to Sullivan and I'm really glad small businesses like this exist! It's about care, selection, and the quality of the pieces. Thanks again!

    I discovered Sullivan through a friend of a friend. They mentioned that we should check out this…read moresmall shop before going anywhere because they were the best. The recommendation did not disappoint. Buying local is important to me. I compared their rings to many other big-box stores and I found that at Sullivan's, you could customize the bands and it would be more cost effective. More importantly, you wouldn't be getting something that EVERYONE else has. The service was great. Over the course of a couple visits, we had a few people help us, including the owner Jeff. Jeff was friendly and personable in our experience. He even polished up my partner's old ring at no charge after we purchased our new ones. I'm surprised there aren't any reviews yet for this shop. I definitely recommend checking it out before going to department store.

    Paul's Jewelers

    Paul's Jewelers

    (15 reviews)

    $$

    Fast and professional service that you don't find a the national chain stores…read more When I dropped my ring off to be resized they said it would be about a week. Two days later I received a call saying it was ready and it fits great. Looks great too!

    Update: I spoke to Mitch and explained to him that it is illegal to add on services and charge the…read morecustomer without the customers knowledge and permission. (Wis Stat 100.18 bans false or deceptive sales claims. Wis Stat 100.20 empowers the state to enforce fair-dealing in commerce) Note that if a business charges more than the estimate without prior notification and approval - or overcharges beyond posted price- YOU have the right to a refund of the overcharge and in service contexts- potentially double damages in small claims court. He is now well informed so I expect this practice to stop immediately. If they break your jewelry while attempting to make a repair YOU have the right to tell them to stop and give you all the pieces so you can take it elsewhere if that is your desire. At minimum, they must call you and tell you what needs to be done, how much it will cost and get your approval before doing anything else. Mitch, maybe you should give me a call tomorrow, or now if you'd like, and you can discuss this with me professionally. I needed my wedding set sized down. It was uncomfortably too big. I was quoted $135 and a 3week wait at one place. Paul's jewelers quoted me $100 and a week turnaround at most. I go to pick-up my ring and I'm blinded by the shine! But not blinded enough because I definitely saw the $190 price on the card reader. I pushed back and the lady proceeds to say $100 for the sizing, yes. The rest is for the cleaning. I know that standard cleaning comes with jewelry repair because jewelry gets very dirty during repairs. So why am I being charged nearly double? She says it's the Rhodium coating, to make it shiny! I didn't ask for anything more than a sizing and the cleaning that comes with it. She did me a favor and gave me a discount Seriously?! So I'm not familiar with this special cleaning they did and look it up. Google ai says " Rhodium Plating: Commonly used on white gold and silver, this process involves plating the jewelry with a thin layer of rhodium--a rare, white precious metal. This gives the jewelry a bright, silvery-white look and provides a protective coating that prevents tarnish and scratches." Did I mention my ring is YELLOW GOLD? So why would someone just naturally assume to plate my yellow gold ring?! Will never step foot back there again. I'll bet Paul's spinning in his grave that this is how his business is being run! They are crooks and I'm certain that too many people fall for their BS!!

    Mid Continental Gems - jewelry - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...