Mickey's Tavern may be one of my new favorite spots in the Madison! Located on the eclectic Williamson Street, Mickey's is divey, local, welcoming with a tinge of new age and it works, really well. The exterior is quintessential old school dive bar from the worn paint to the old school PBR sign. When you walk in, you are quickly transported into a retro, yet new age space that features old school lighting and artwork mixed with new age neon's and a creative menu. Staff were excellent at the bar. They hooked it up and helped us choose just the right drink, and chatted us up for a while. Patrons were equally friendly, which was nice. With that, it has the vibe of Wisconsin from decor, menu, staff to patrons. We hung out in the main bar area for a while, and then discovered there was a whole other section with a pool table and more cozy style seating areas. They do offer your standard bar food, which looked and smelled good. However, we were there on a liquid diet, so cocktails is all we got, and we were not mad at it. Overall, absolutely in love with Mickey's Tavern. Will absolutely be back on my next visit to Madison! read more

See all

Mickey's is a proper local pub, right on Willy Street, Regardless of your sex/age/race, it's a great place to meet, We were told "you must try the food & sexy fries", We weren't disappointed, they weren't telling lies, So next time you're in the area, relax and follow your feet! read more

At first glance Mickey's looks like a dive bar, but once you get around the main corner there are the cutest little lunch spot. I was surprised that they had vegan options on the menu and even more surprised at how good the vegan sandwich was! Add it to your list! read more

Music is on point and a good volume for a Sunday pick me up! Add to it a really great Bloody Mary with all the fixin's and just the right kick. Suffering Fool is a gone mule with added brandy. Never knew how fine Brandy was until she met Gin! Bartenders work well together cleaning in between serving drinks. No food for a chunk of time in the afternoon, but with a chill vibe like this-- I could be here for house! read more

See all

When I found out that we were going to have brunch and a bar (you know, take the preggo to another bar) I guess that's only in Madison ha ha, I was a little disappointed. It's no fun to be around other people drinking when you can't. However, Mickey's definitely exceeded expectations. The food was really good. I had the scramble of the day which was bacon, chèvre, tomatoes, and sunflower sprouts. My son had a half order of biscuits and gravy. My scramble was so good-I ate every single bite. My son ate about half of his biscuits and gravy, so we took the rest home and shared it for breakfast the next day. I love that they do half portions of some items and that they have a bottomless coffee and tea bar. Our waitress was really friendly and it was a fun environment. I would definitely like to come back sometime when I am able to have a breakfast cocktail too! read more

See all

Fun spot to stop for live music, drinks, and food. Have visited a lot but never actually tried the food. Their Mac and cheese is probably in my top 5! Also loved the fries. Bartenders and staff are what makes Mickey's to great. They are wonderful and so friendly. Sitting on the patio is great in the summer, inside is a chill vibe too. Drinks are always great and strong. Not pictured is the Bloody Mary which is also one of my favorites in Madison. Comes with good amount of pickled veggies. Overall, I think everything is super reasonably priced for the great food it is. read more

See all

Bartender tried to shame my friend for not tipping on a $2.75 beer after tipping on the first one and charging the wrong price on my drink. Very rude behavior. read more

Wow! What a horrible experience. The staff was super mean and passive aggressive towards us. Definitely thought we were inconveniencing them so some reason. Would never go back! read more

A great duck off place. I go for the sexy fries!!! They give a very generous portion,and not because I'm their # 1FAN. Whether we sit and enjoy them there or get them to go for a car picnic they are always hot & fresh and the truffle oil sends them into the next atmosphere!!! It reminds you of when you were a kid and you went out for coke &fries, but now you're all grown up and it seltzer water and sexy fries read more

The boozy barista & the eggs benedict were unreal... amazing service and super cute spot! read more

Mickey's Tavern - Eggs Benedict - New American Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

A great place for sunday brunch! Bottomless coffee, loaded bloodies, and fuller than full portions. great atmosphere with fun bartenders and attentive servers. The weekend sunday brunch fish special was a table favorite! You can't visit Madison without stopping here:) read more

Mickey's is such a fun brunch spot! Hell - Mickey's is good any time of day! The food is always superb, no matter what you order it's gonna be great! Strong coffee, strong drinks if you wish & the best-lit patio in town! What are you waiting for, Mickey? lol Also very cozy & cool when it's winter or other inclement weather! GO NOW! You're gonna love it!!!! read more

This place was fun and unique with a good amount of seating options and drinks. Staff were super attentive and great. We went on a night there was live music we weren't aware of and it was a heavy metal band so super hard to hear anyone talking. Something to consider looking for before you go here- I know I would've had a great time without that live metal band read more

My girlfriend and I went for brunch last Sunday. They open at nine and we arrived at about 10:50 AM. They were completely packed already. We were about to leave and go somewhere else in the neighborhood, but then two stools opened up at the bar just as we're about to leave. We quickly swoop them up!. We were both very excited for bloody Mary's. I really did not like mine. I can't describe the flavor. I really wanted to like it, but there was just something about it I didn't care for. Fortunately my girlfriend really liked her bloody Mary so she took my second one. I had the champagne cocktail Instead, and it was very great old school style loved it.. I had the breakfast burrito with potatoes, which was very good and my girlfriend had the eggs Benedict with potatoes. We were happy with the meals. The atmosphere is amazing very old school. It is definitely a neighborhood bar with a hipster/old-school punk rock feel. Awesome and I super recommend if that is the vibe you were into.. read more

Suggest you STAY AWAY from Mickey's unless you want to wait TWO HOURS for your food!!! It was 30 minutes before they took our food order and then the food did not arrive for another 90 MINUTES!!! The waitress told us it would take 45 minutes for the food because they have a small, nothing kitchen, which sounded quite long by itself, but then it took 90 minutes, for a total of TWO HOURS to get our food!!! And of course the hamburgers were cold upon arrival, so what's the point???!!! The waitress did give us our drinks for free (we had three beers, so not that big of a concession I don't think), but I strongly urge others to not patronize this establishment... that is, if you want to eat there! (Drinks came on a timely basis). read more

My husband and I visited Mickey's Tavern for the first time yesterday and were pleasantly surprised with it! As we walked up to the door, there was a sign that said ''when you're here, you're not at Olive Garden''. We got a good laugh out of it and could tell this would be our type of place. I've heard good things about Mickey's Tavern from my aunt, but always assumed it was a dive bar. That was definitely not the case! The ambiance is really nice. It's dimly lit with neon lights, feminist signs (yes!!!), a cozy bar, a pool table in the back area. We love a good bar and this one was so cute and fun! I ordered a classic Wisconsin Old Fashioned to drink and we ordered ''Sexy Fries''. The fries were thin cut potato slices with truffle oil, Parmesan, crushed red pepper, and salt. They were so flavorful and crispy! We loved them and would definitely order them again. We can't wait to come back and try more things! read more

See all

Sweet spot to stop in for a quick bite. Old Madison meets New Madison. You can count on anything and everything on being delicious! Fabulous Reuben, sexy fries and slaw. They should have won the WORT chili cook off 2024 #rigged! Great bubbly staff! read more

From its eclectic look to great prices and very cool, pleasant customers and bartenders this old tavern is the place to be. Check out the jukebox! We didn't have food but the menu is bar food and I heard it's good. It's the 2nd oldest longstanding bar in Madison. A day of Arboretum and hotel stay in the city and dinner out made us happy and the short hike from Pewaukee was a mini vacation getaway. Don't miss it- they have weekend bands too! read more

I'm a fan of Mickey's Tavern, but it's mostly for the vibe. The location is great, especially if you're near willy street and looking for a casual place to eat and drink, or even just start/end your night. I will say though, outside of the vibe the food is just fine and same with the drinks. Nothing super wowed me, but the entire experience was still a 4 just for the entire once more, vibe that I experienced. Casual, inviting, and overall just a good place to catch up with friends. read more

Maddie, Maggie , Mattie, great bartender, real god squeakiest, great cook, some strange cat at bar he weird, great old time bar real great experience read more

I loved the atmosphere when I got into the bar, it was pretty busy but it was the regulars that ate there for happy hour. I just loved the feel of the atmosphere here. read more

See all

Popped in for breakfast on our way through Madison - it was such a pleasant surprise! It's like having breakfast in someone's Victorian home that also happens to have a sweet bar. Staff is super friendly and we took a few recommendations from our server for breakfast options. I wish I took more photos of everyone's food because it was so good. It was filling but didn't leave you with that heavy brunch feeling you can get sometimes after a big breakfast. Bloody Mary was super fresh tasting and was accompanied by a chaser. The pickle and pickled brussel sprout were particularly delicious. A few in our squad ordered the breakfast burrito and they loved it though all of us were jealous when a friends "Special" came out. It was just what we needed and we loved it. read more

See all

Best brunch & staff. Patio vibes immaculate. For the love of god, stock a bottle of cherry doctor for cherry bombs though :) read more

Stopped in for a late lunch. I ordered the Deluxe Grilled Cheese with cheese curds. My girlfriend ordered the Mickey Burger with sexy fries. We typically hit this spot for breakfast but, lunch did not disappoint! read more

See all

This was on our list of places to check out so we stopped in for dinner on a Saturday night after a Badger football game- off the beaten trail enough so no big post-game rush. We grabbed a couple stools at the bar, if it had been a bit warmer we would have sat in their big outdoor patio in back. The bar itself is really a great authentic piece of Wisconsin tavern history - love the vibe. We ordered a couple well made Old Fashions and then checked out the menu. They do give 10% off food items with the Bike Benefits program - another plus especially since they are right off one of the busier bike paths on the east side. Warning - another cash only place in this area of town... I ordered the beef brisket special - it was excellent, tender and flavorful without being too fatty. My wife ordered the World's Best Sandwich - it was pretty darn good. We will be back! read more

Mickey's Tavern - Brisket special- it's great! - New American Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

See all

So fun and cozy. Plus Adriane bartends here so obviously a rad place to hang :) Highly recommend read more

Was pretty excited to try the brunch, had heard it was spectacular! We sat down at 11:20, and ordered at 11:30. Our food came out at 1:15. It wasn't our waiters fault, and I'm sure they were short staffed or something, but we were starving. The food was pretty good, a standard Belgian waffle with bananas, strawberries, and blueberries. Friend said the biscuits and gravy were delicious. The food was decent. Outside there were a million flies, gnats, and other bugs, and normally I don't really notice them in outdoor restaurants, but every minute I had to swat a few off my leg and hand, which definitely also was not fun, but also not their fault. Would definitely go back, and the staff was super friendly, but there was a long wait and I would probably sit inside next time if possible. read more

Mickey's Tavern - Waffle - New American Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

See all

Super friendly server, must have been the owner. Huge portion of walleye on Friday night. BTW not on the menu I had to ask. Delicious beer. Just wish there was another option besides fries with the order. read more

Mickey's Tavern - Outdoor dining - New American Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

This is the quintessential Wisconsin tavern. Lots of old hippies and young students. Eggs Benedict are worth the visit. Include a stroll along the Yahara River for a pleasant taste of Madison. read more

I loved the bartenders and service. So kind and welcoming. They check in with you and make it an enjoyable hangout.

I can't get over how much I love Mickeys! I'm new to Madison, WI and I have found my spot! The food is incredible! Have tried the super sexy fries, flank steak sandwich, green chili pork appetizer, and Mickey burger....everything has been top notch. As for the ambience it is the perfect combination of dive bar charm but with cocktail class and service. Our server Gabby was sweet, funny, and super attentive! Bar tenders are great and the live music is the cherry on top! read more

Stopped in for a drink on a Saturday afternoon. Restaurant was packed but we found a little spot at the bar. Servers were nice enough. Went for the Bloody Mary and it was okay. Toppings were good, the mix had good flavor but it was very thick and highly seasoned. It was almost a little too much to drink. Not awful but probably wouldn't get it again. Not my style. FYI- cash only read more

Mickey's Tavern - Bloody Mary - New American Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

We've been here a few times now and it is definitely one of my favorite food spots in Madison. I haven't had anything bad here yet. The waiters/waitresses are very friendly and will give recommendations for what to try. Its also a really fun setup for the restaurant as there is a patio, bar area/restaurant, and more of a lounge area with a pool table. This time we ordered the Mickey burger and the lonestar. Their namesake burger is very flavorful and well balanced. On the lonestar the tofu had a great marinade and the bread was excellent, nice and soft. The highlight for me however was the cheesecurds. These are the best that I have had in Madison this far for stand alone cheesecurds. The sauce with it could maybe be upgraded, but the curds themselves had a thick enough breading that you could tell it was there and they weren't greasy! We will definitely order these again! read more

Mickey's Tavern - The lonestar - New American Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

See all

Food was ok. Not a lot of food that I would eat, to choose from. Bartenders ok. Took a minute to get drinks. Stuff to look on the walls okay. Probably won't go back though. read more

Super cute local spot with great bartenders and kind staff. We are in town from Chicago and enjoyed the chill ambiance on the patio with friends. My gin martini hit the spot! read more

I've never felt so at home without being at home. Go past the bar into the seating table area and you'll find yourself thinking you're not at a restaurant. Sofas, side tables, dinner tables, everything is fair game. The food was decent. The eggs Benedict was good but nothing that I can say sets it apart as being a signature dish. The biscuits and gravy were okay despite the huge portion of gravy (which I'm always okay with). It's a good place, but at the moment it's not one that I'd be dying to go back to. read more

Mickey's Tavern - Eggs Benedict - New American Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

See all

Food was very good. I had a burger here and really enjoyed it. Nothing crazy nice but worth the price.

The restaurant itself was cute and the server was very friendly. However, our food took over an hour to get to us after we ordered. It was room temperature and just tasted okay. It was our first time, and I'm sad to say we won't be back. read more

Dark bar with TCM playing, umm hell yes!! Food is fabulous, drinks are cheap and decor is cool. I wish I could remember our bartenders name because she was amazing however the alcohol has erased that memory from my brain! read more

Mickey's Tavern - New American Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

I really like Mickey's. It's a nice little spot that offers a creative (albeit limited) menu, drink specials, and a cool atmosphere. I've been in a handful of times now, and each time has been just fine. Last summer, I was in and had lunch here on a Sunday afternoon. We opted for the outdoor seating and it was wonderful! It's like a little secret garden back there. So cute. It was fairly busy but service was still on point. The food was delish and the drinks were refreshing. I was there again this past weekend for dinner. One bit of advice I would offer is, if you're coming in for dinner, sit in one of the back dining rooms. We took a table up front in the main bar area, and although the table itself was fine (a little chilly in front of a window) the dining room was super loud because of the bar. It was Sunday, after a Packer game, so I would imagine a lot of the patrons in there had been there a while, and they were loud, obnoxious even. It was our own fault for not choosing a spot outside of the bar area, but still annoying. Aside from that, service was good and the food was great! The chili was fantastic! It had HUGE chunks of the most tender, delicious beef. And they didn't skimp! The BBQ pork was very good, and the Sexy Fries were awesome as well. Overall, everything we had was spot on. The ambiance of the bar area is dark and divey, which is a stark difference from the other areas. They are clean and well lit, done in a sort of vintage-chic decor. There is a pool table in the back and lots of little seating through out the various rooms. Super cool place, all in all! read more

See all