My husband and I just moved to the area and wanted to find a new pizza place so we tried Michelli's based on the good reviews. So glad we did! We tried it with a bunch of our family and got pepperoni pizza, these unbelievably awesome garlic rolls, and the house special calzone. All of it was great! We'll definitely be back! read more

First time visitor and love..love the Spaghetti and Meatballs my husband has pizza and the kids noodles were a hit. Absolutely Amazing!!

I'm from NC and decided I wanted stuffed shells. I can tell you I made the best choice. Waitress was awesome and very prompt to take our order(considering she was the only one waiting tables). Started with the garlic knots, as close as you can get to perfect. Ordered my shells and they were awesome. I will be back every time I come through from now on! read more

Great pizza! I don't get up there very often but when I am down in that area I try to make a point to go in a grab a slice. I've had their pizzas (all types) and their chicken parm roll, along with a few side items. Their garlic knots are fantastic, and their chiken parm roll hits the spot for me. Their pizza is fabulous, highly recommend! read more

Their pizza is quite good, as are their cheese steak sandwiches. But before I tell you about that, let me warn you: do not order their wings. Okay, now the details. Like I said, they have excellent pizza. I particularly like their Michelli's Special, which just simply rocks. They also have excellent white pizza, and their base pizza is quite nice, but doesn't reheat all that well. They make good cheese steak sandwiches, with a good amount of meat. Their lasagna is good, but not great. I'd give it a 3-star compared to the other food. So that brings me to their buffalo wings. Let me remind you that their other food is good before I continue. These are, quite simply, the worst buffalo wings I have ever had. I have had buffalo wings from Boston to LA, from Seattle to Palm Bay, and everywhere in between. I have had good buffalo wings. I have had bad buffalo wings. These are the worst. They are the absolute worst. Now, it's not even the chicken. This poor chicken wasn't rancid or turned or anything that would justify bad buffalo wings. This chicken was just cooked to an inch of its life, hardened by a cruel chef intent on taking out his or her shame of wing cookery when he or she could have been cooking real italiano. I want you to imagine the best wings you've ever had. Now, put that on a scale and compare that to the worst buffalo wings. Multiply the distance those two standards of quality are by, oh, say ten, and that's how much worse these wings are. These are lose-the-will-to-live buffalo wings. We're still going to get pizza from Michelli's, but we're never, ever, EVER going to get their wings. You, too, Dear Reader, should visit Michelli's and partake of their fine pizza. But do yourself, your future, and your willingness to see the next dawn a favor and never, EVER order their wings. EVER. read more

Michelli's has definitely the best pizza in town, Like NY style, they are a small mom and pop pizza place which also has a regular Italian menu. Not many tables to dine in, maybe 6 to 8 but they will try to accommodate you. Big take out/ delivery place. This place is been my go to place for years. The consistency of there food is always spot on. Aside from pizza, I have tried most of there dinners and like them all. Just an FYI, there served in tin to go containers even if you dine in. If your ok with that than try them, you won't be disappointed with their food. Most dinners come with tasty garlic knots and small salad. read more

Wow! Just WOW!!! We are relatively new to the area and have been looking for good pizza around here since late 2017. We still haven't found good pizza, we've found SUPERB pizza! Well worth the 1/2 hour drive for sure. The place was very busy but they sure do hustle! Our server, Wanda, was amazing. The food was equally as good as the service. The pizza had a delicious crust that passed the "fold test". The red sauce is delicious. The cheese was very fresh and just the right amount and flavor. My house salad was cold and unbelievably fresh with greens, olives, cucumber, a delicious tomato, red onions and a Greek pepper. The balsamic dressing is really good. Portions were very large, I had a single slice and the salad and couldn't finish it all. All that and a raspberry iced tea for $5.75 (one of the lunch specials). There is an extensive menu and we can't wait to eat our way through it all. Congratulations to Michelli's for achieving perfection! read more

This place not only has the best Italian in Palm Bay/Melbourne, they also have the best service. After my boyfriend and I were told by friends to check this place out, we've been back once a week ever since. Their dinner special for two (ziti or stuffed shells) is our usual, but their pizza is out of this world too. They have the best tomato sauce I've ever had, and their portions are very generous. They treat you like family and are always friendly and up beat. I highly recommend this place to anyone looking for delicious Italian food. read more

Probably my favorite pizzeria in Palm Bay area. Love their Wednesday special. My mom loves chicken wings and she just takes a plate from here and goes to town. Love that they are willing to mix sauces for the wings. We make a spicy bbq. Never ordered delivery, would usually order and pick up on my way home from work. read more

I just was on Yelp looking for something to eat and I saw that michellis has only 4 stars and that's ABSURD. This is 100X better than any Italian food I've had in Palm Bay. And really anywhere. Everything is great but as far as recommended menu items I'd say michellis favorite pizza, Stromboli, and cannolis are unbelievable. This place deserves all five stars. The owners are ALWAYS there so you know they're not letting anything slip. Grande cheese.. Yum read more

Garlic knots are very yummy! Pizza great! Stuffed shells great! Delivery people are on time!

Best Italian Food in Palm Bay/West Melbourne, hands down!!! Anything and everything on the menu is amazing!!

Awesome food and great service, the large Stromboli will feed a family of four! Garlic knots are big and flavorful. The Alfredo sauce is the best I've ever had. read more

Love this place! We try to get delivery every 1-2 weeks. Greek salad, garlic knots, mozzarella cheese sticks and single slice pizza is what we order. The garlic cheese bread is also phenomenal. Looking forward to our next order! read more

Amazing food and the owners are amazing. They know how to take care of you. This place is a staple for my family if we want Italian. Always will go here...guaranteed! read more

Family running the place treat mine like their own. Thanks guys. Oh and the food tastes awesome as well.Stayed open for my pick up order tonight. It does make a difference to your patrons. Thank You read more

I'm visiting my family in Palm Bay from the San Francisco Bay area. I grew up in an Italian neighborhood in upstate New York (the real Upstate, Rochester). Sadly, I haven't had good pizza since I left the East Coast, while I love California, the pizza there sucks. It's bad when your best pizza comes from Dominos or RoundTable. Then I read about Michelli's on Yelp and looked at the pictures. I placed an order and the woman that I spoke with was very friendly and helpful. This is the kind of pizza I remember from growing up in Rochester. Great crust, not too thin but not thick, with a wonderful texture, great sauce, a generous amount of cheese and tasty sausage and pepperoni yet not greasy. Definitely coming back here at least a couple of times before I head back to Cali. read more

We order from Michellis probably once a week or every other week. Food is usually on point. I'm not one to public shame but today I am. We ordered our food, we waited an hour it got here and half was missing. I call to tell them and their answer was they wouldn't charge me the $3 delivery fee. What BS ..no your girl was laughing the entire time i was placing my order screwing around. Instead of paying attention to her customer. Our order my not matter to you. But you have lost our business for good. We will never go to this place again nor recommend them as we have in the past. Extremely disappointed in this horrible customer service! read more

First visit here, had dinner on a weeknight, the original plan was carry out but we ended up eating there, the waitress quickly set up our table when we changed our minds. Got the Popeye pizza, spinach and cheese, etc. It was tasty, could have used a touch more salt and garlic in my opinion. Garlic knots were pretty good too. I look forward to trying other menu items. read more

For palm bay, the best. Friendly owners. I remember when they first opened and I would walk over every day for a slice of pizza. I would tell all my friends to give it a try and now this is the only place we will all go! I used them for my daughters 2cd bday..the eggplant pizza was good! If you are just having friends or family over...perfect place to order from. If you are having it delivered ..have cash. The stuffed shells are yummy! And pretty decent salads too. Just all around a nice place and great food. Priced fairly also. read more

Best Italian food in Palm Bay! Hands down!! Look forward to eating there! The homemade meatballs are outstanding!

Very good. Had the Meat Fest pizza and mozzarella sticks. Everyone at the table enjoyed the pizza; service was friendly & efficient.

I have eaten a lot of pizza in many different cities, Chicago, New York, Indianapolis, Raleigh etc but this is some of the BEST I have had! From the crust to the sauce to the meat EXCELLENT!! You HAVE to try the garlic knots... SUPERB!! read more

Attempted to order 12 pizzas for a party and it was like i was putting them out. Posted it on our activities board how I was treated and disrespected. Was told by numerous folks that they no longer support this business. read more

I ordered a large cheese pizza and a order of garlic knots.. It was my first time ordering there and was looking forward to a real NY style pizza.. It was a fri evening and I do understand its a busier night.. A hour and 40 min later it arrived.. The pizza was burnt on areas and room temp.. The garlic knots were refrigerator cold! I called to complain and was told the knots are made in the morning then packed up and put away till you order then it goes with your order.. REALLY?? I spoke with 2 different women and both acting like they didnt understand why I was upset! I didnt swear or even yell but did expect decent customer service! I own a business myself and would NEVER ignore a concern regarding my product! Will NEVER order again! read more

Last night my husband and I had pizza from Michelle's and to tell you the truth I like their pizza because they make the crust the way I like it thin. The pizza good my only problem is by the time it gets here it's not hot enough so I can only give it 4 1/2 stars. Sorry Diana Bellizzi delivery it hot and you'll get 5 stars. read more

2 hours and 20 min delivery. Very unprofessional, food horrible and cold. Never again! read more

Stopped in on a whim. Love the pizza size, quality of toppings, and the taste. Customer service was great too! Will be back.

Pretty good food for Florida. I was born and raised in Brooklyn NY so for me Florida sucks for food. I went in there and asked for broccoli raab, and a rice ball. Then I asked for spinach with garlic. They looked at me like they didn't know what I was talkin about..Thats what u get for Florida. A bunch of fake Italians. I need to get back to Brooklyn! read more

We LOVE Michelli's. The food is great, the owners are even better, and the service has always been incredible. The ONLY reason we stopped eating at Michelli's is because of the delivery wait times. I'd expect 30-45 minutes unless it's a holiday or normally busy dinner time. But no matter when I call, the wait is ALWAYS well over an hour. I would hope they would either invest into a new oven or new delivery person. If they would improve on the delivery times we would be back as it used to be our go-to treat when friends and family would visit from out of town. read more

Excellent food. Probably the best pizza in the Melbourne/Palm Bay area. Also has the best buffalo chicken sandwich (Ed's Favorite) I've ever had. The only reason I can't give it 5 stars is because the delivery wait time is typically 1 hour to 1:30 hours. They tell you this over the phone so it's not unexpected, but I'd order so much more often if it was 30-45 minutes like other places. read more

Amazing Pizza! You can tell the ingredients are made in house and not from a can. We stopped here on the way back from a road trip and it was the perfect lunch break. The customer service was they best. The staff was super nice and extremely attentive. I'm going to keep this place in mind for future road trips! read more

Best Italian food in town. Service is great, the owners are wonderful and the food is authentic.I won't go anywhere else for Italian, as there is no point when you already have the best. read more

Yep, still 5 stars. I just HAD to update that thier Popeye Pizza is absolutely fantastic. It includes: Ricotta, Spinach, tomato, garlic, and mozz. and it isn't the least bit greasy. Love love LOVE IT! read more

The garlic knots were dry, the pizza was ok but nothing special and as a bonus I got really sick a few hours later.

I went to eat here based on the reviews and what other people had told me about this place. Not bad not great. Have been here a few times and every time the food has been mediocre. Honestly I have had better pizza from the cafe at SAM's club. Every time I Ieave here I ask myself why I paid $6.00 for two bland paper thin slices of pizza.. read more

In town for a workshop, and was stuck at the hotel without a car. Found this place here on yelp. The pizza was amazing! I had pepperoni and Italian sausage and an order of the garlic rolls. All of it was so yummy! The service was great, the delivery driver was friendly and very sweet. Highly recommend this place! Wish there was one in Texas! read more

So good! Took a little bit of time for them to take my order but they were crazy busy. I got garlic knots which were excellent and a small pizza. Looked greasy but it actually wasn't! It was fantastic! Loved the fact they had regulars come in and they were talking to the owner catching up like old friends. :) I will definitely go back next time I drive thru this area. read more

Excellent pizza and great garlic teriyaki wings. The hardest part is waiting for time to past after you have placed the order.

This pizza is very authentic. The plain cheese was awesome. Also ordered the veggie. It was soggy because of too many toppings, but the next day, reheated directly on the oven rack it came out perfectly crispy and delicious. read more