This pizza is all that! Charming hole in the wall place. Fast friendly service! Thin is very crispy throughout. Fresh delicious toppings. Great pizza experience! read more

Michael Anthonys Pizza - Tony's Special (14" Pizza) - Pizza Near Me - Villa Park, Illinois

I haven't had Michael Anthony's in years and was craving the club pizza with lettuce tomato onion and lettuce. Got my order and it was missing pickles and onions (UGH). The real issue here is it looks like someone's living in the restaurant. I mean the booth is full of garbage old food backpacks crafts etc. horrible atmosphere for a restaurant! Wow. Won't be coming back. And a reply to the owner's response below, the kid was in the restaurant without shoes eating with their hands but i was not going to include them in the photo/review. Also, when I called I was told that you still carried the pizza that i ordered. Family-owned businesses that care about their employees is great, but there should be boundaries. Thanks, read more

Michael Anthonys Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Villa Park, Illinois

1-star because they cannot follow simple directions They do no know what a vegan is that is not okay they are food service at extortion prices I asked for a kid's pizza no cheese and loaded with veggies Well I went to pick it up and it had cheese and it was a small not a kids That would be 3 meals for me So I asked them to remake it with no cheese and it set me back $20 for bread, veggies and the grossest tomato canned concentrate one could imagine Pizza is always good not here read more

Always perfect. A Christmas Eve tradition for years. St Christopher pizza is required. read more

See all

Had been wanting to try the pizza here for quite some time. Pretty disappointed... the pizza is super thin, like fingernail thin which made it very floppy. Gave me vibes of a frozen pizza. I wouldn't order again. read more

Best pizza. Hands down! Not overly greasy. Crust is just right and the flavor is on point. Jaime made the best pizza by far!

Great food and service. My local favorite. Great pizza, beef and ribs. Excellent staff.

Well, one thing's for sure: you won't need to worry about vampires after eating this pizza. There was so much garlic in the sauce, it oozed out my pores for days! The search continues... read more

Just a little hole in the wall setting, mom n pop restaurant, not anything for ambience. But food is excellent, generous portions, good prices. Love it when Tony is there, he makes you feel so welcome and appreciated. The only problem we had is that server also takes all phone orders, this can interfere with table service. They need more help with phone orders so in house customers get 100% attention. read more

Great food, great service, we use them for our regular pizza orders, as well as catering for our family events. We love the beef and mostaccioli, especially the chop salad. Awesome homemade ranch and Italian dressings. Love the cozy dining room. read more

We've always ordered our pizza from Michael Anthony's (love the stuffed crust!) but wanted chicken parmesan for a gathering of 12 friends. I ordered from the catering menu and got the chicken and a Caesar salad for 8-10. It was ready on time when we came to pick it up and the chicken parmesan was delicious! I really liked the Caesar dressing that we got with the salad and the quantity of salad was spot on. I had time to make my own side pasta and garlic bread but I'm sure they'd be just as tasty as what we ordered. read more

This place is a go-to spot to pick up pizza whenever I am visiting my dad in the area. Some of the best thin crust pizza I've had. I also ordered their beef sandwich and that was good too. Beef had nice flavor and was sliced super thin. read more

Michael Anthonys Pizza - Half sausage & half pepperoni (ordered well done) - Pizza Near Me - Villa Park, Illinois

Pizza with garlic sauce is amazing service is great will definitely be coming back here a must try hidden Jem ! read more

Great customer service and delicious pizza. everyone is always friendly and the food is affordable.

Great pizza. Very small, but it wasn't very crowded. Broccoli cheese puffs were a great start. Highly recommend the creamy garlic salad dressing. Two of us could only eat half of the pizza, so plenty of leftovers. Pepsi products to drink. read more

Michael Anthonys Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Villa Park, Illinois

Meh! Thin and crispy cracker crust. Just Ok pizza. It's hard to find a great pizza place in the burbs. read more

Definitely good pizza. Nice menu with a wide variety of choices among pizza, sandwiches, burgers, and Italian plates. I almost got the baked lasagna, which sounded amazing, but really wanted to try the pizza. I ordered the St. Christopher, which has Italian beef, pepperoni, mozzarella and ricotta. It was very good, and I got about 3/4 of a 12" pie down by myself with little problem. The only issue is the pizza also has giardiniera peppers on it, and they really make the pizza pop. If you don't like spicy stuff, you had best order the pizza minus the peppers. They offer thin crust, pan and stuffed. The one I got was thin crust. Not your typical Chicagoland choice, and if you're expecting Giordano's or Lou Malnati's, I don't know that this place does pizza like that. Who knows, they might. As for atmosphere, this is a typical family owned, small shop. Plenty of seating later in the evening. They seem to do a lot of carryout business. I sat down and pretty quickly got the feeling the place doesn't really do a lot of table service, although a server did eventually come out. But I think this is more of an order-at-the-counter kind of joint, which is fine. I hope the place thrives and continues to be around a long while. I enjoyed it and would like to come back and try other menu items. read more

Michael Anthonys Pizza - St. Christopher - Italian beef, pepperoni, mozzarella, ricotta, and giardiniera peppers. - Pizza Near Me - Villa Park, Illinois

This is the best pizza in the area, although Gulliver's and Aurelio's give it some competition. The crust is superb, and the cheese blend is perfect. Our go-to order is 1/2 sausage, half pepperoni and mushroom. That gives us a nice sampling of our two favorites. read more

If you are a fan of thin crust pizza, you have found a great place at Michael Anthony's!! I am a huge fan of thin crust pizza that is well done (extra crispy,) and this pizza did not disappoint!! read more

This is one of our go to pizza spots. We always get the 18 inch sausage pizza. The crust, sauce, and sausage on their pizza is absolutely delicious! They have a nice dining room with booths and tables. The staff is always friendly and welcoming. The food quality is great and prices are fair. We would definitely Michael Anthony's! read more

See all

I usually love this place! Everything is so delicious. Ordered for delivery and I found so many hairs on my garlic bread it was not edible, half of them even buried in. Gross gross. read more

Michael Anthonys Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Villa Park, Illinois

A 12 inch pizza took an hour and a half. Barely anyone in the restaurant which I don't understand.

Two siblings, myself and our spouses searched on Yelp to find a place to eat pizza and salad and after checking the reviews decided on Michael Anthonys in Villa Park , IL . We're kind of snobs when it comes to pizza but we all agreed that this thin and crispy pizza was really good . I read one review mentioned the sauce as flavorful, check , the thin and crispy crust rated high with us as well and the toppings all first rate . Those who ordered the salads were very pleased . Service was great , servers friendly and with good attitudes. Place wasn't very big but we appreciated that it was quiet and able to hear our conversation over a good meal ! read more

The times I have been there the pizza was always good beer cold. I would recommend this restaurant as an enjoyably good time

Amazing pizza but it's hit or miss on accuracy. We repeatedly order the thin crust "extra well done" , both via phone ordering and online ordering and 3x now have received a pizza that was super soft, not extra well done and far from crispy and crunchy how we like it. One time we ordered sausage, onions & peppers and received just sausage on the pizza. Another time we received a neighbor's order. The first time or two wasn't a big deal as mistakes happen and they refunded us but it's now getting to be an expensive game of "what will be wrong with the order this time?" and it's super disappointing because my family adores the pizza here and I hate having to play Karen. read more

See all

I was looking to take a bite of nostalgia, and a thin crust pizza as well. The neon 'Pizza' sign out front sends a beacon of light that immediately attracts you attention. It has that vintage appeal much like the interior of the Pizzeria; four tables, three booths, red checkered table cloths and an open kitchen for your viewing pleasure. A neighborhood style pizza joint that offers a believable 60's retro look. Places like this remain tempting; oversized booths are a natural attraction while the only missing pieces are pitchers of beer and a cigarette machine. As for the pizza, Michael Anthony has no problem offering an independent style thin crust pie. The cheese and sauce are different, and I found no reason to pin-point why. Fresh shrooms are available for those in the know, but a can opener remains on stand-by. The pizza is 'lite' and crispy, but not so much that it might float away. A post meal nap is highly unlikely; especially notable for those taking an exercise pit-stop from the adjacent prairie path. No booze available, so I opted for the Grab-N-Go. read more

Michael Anthonys Pizza - Cool Neon - Pizza Near Me - Villa Park, Illinois

See all

Staff was very friendly. Pizza was great, wish the sauce had a bit more flavor. The garlic bread was very average/crunchy. read more

Michael Anthonys Pizza - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Villa Park, Illinois

Been coming here since HS and like to make a stop when I come back home. Italian beef pizza, enough said, so good!

Pizza is just okay, could use more toppings. I did like the thin crust, it reminds me of Nancy's pizza

Order shrimp dinner, no cocktail sauce. Called and they said just come back and get it, I said no you bring it to me. She apologized and just said we hired a bunch of new people, well I said you have to teach them to check the orders to go, that's all read more

thanks for the lettuce n cheese.. I'm not asking for much in a small side salad but, c'mon. and the "dipped" beef?... Never have I had a drier beef sandwich in 40 yrs in the Chicagoland area. Like, I don't even know how one would go about getting beef that dry..cheese sticks weren't bad. congratulations on ordering those from somewhere else and dropping them in hot oil.. read more

Michael Anthonys Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Villa Park, Illinois

Very good pizza. I was very impressed with how good the sauce was. It was very tasty. I liked the slight char on the cheese as well.

Cross another great tavern style thin crust off my list. The crust on their pizza is the same no matter where you grab from. Everything I enjoy about a tavern style thin crust is at this place. Would highly recommend and will definitely try again! read more

See all

This place is amazing! Let's start by saying the appraiser broccoli cheese puffs are heaven in a bite. Also the best thin crust pizza in the burbs and get this at a reasonable price!!!! The red gravy sauce doesn't give me any acid reflex please note that this does have meat in it BUT the red marinara doesn't have meat in it and is just as amazing!! Omar recommends all of the best pizza toppings ask to speak with him and you'll be set!!! Also don't leave without getting a homemade breadsticks PS ask to speak with Omar of you want your pizza to be cooked the best read more

Love love LOVE! This place is great, pizzas great but honestly love all their dishes just as much! Half the time we don't even order pizza. The works salad is amazing, love the Philly beef, and their fire wings are my favorite! Of course with their homemade ranch:) They make almost everything homemade, you can't beat it! read more

Great pizza and an awesome owner! Can't wait to try some of the non pizza offerings!

I'm not sure why they open at 4pm on Sunday. I'd order more often if they open earlier. I forgot how amazing this pizza is. Today I ordered a large thin crust with; extra sauce, pepperoni on the whole pizza, half sausage, half Italian beef (baked well done) & I have to say this pizza was perfect! The customer service was also perfect. They made sure to read back my order before sending it through. I absolutely love this place. That being said, the parking sucks. So be ready to park away when ordering. read more

Updating review after the owner provided nice feedback. The food we were able to eat was very good and delivery-while it said would take over an hour, actually arrived well before that. If you have dietary restrictions though, I would make it a point to note that when ordering or call ahead as not all ingredients are listed. read more

Good local pizza place that mostly caters to deliveries and carry-outs although they do have a few tables if you'd like to eat there. They have a pretty extensive menu although we've only had their pizza and wings. The thin crust pizza is good and made with fresh ingredients. I really liked the pizza sauce and sausage. The wings were OK but a bit overdone. read more

While I might order pizza when other people come to visit, I rarely order pizza alone. Well, I did and it was invigorating eating pizza and binge watching 7 episodes of GoT. (Don't worry, I've seen them all, I just wanted to re-watch them.) I ended up ordering the St. Christopher's (Italian beef, pepperoni, giardinara, mozzarella and ricotta) Sounds great, right? There just seemed to be something lacking in this. It wasn't bad, but I wish I would have just ordered my typical sausage with garlic and spinach. I also asked for double dough because I didn't know how thin their thin crust was going to be but I felt like that maybe that was the reason why my pizza didn't feel like it had enough toppings on it. I also ordered their broccoli bites because you know, nothing says healthy like fried stuffed battered broccoli. It was delicious! I plan on being "healthy" again next time and ordering more broccoli bites. I'll try Michael Anthony's one more time but I wasn't impressed with the pizza I ordered. read more

Michael Anthonys Pizza - Double dough St. Christopher pizza- Italian beef, pepperoni, giardiniera, ricotta and mozz. Also broccoli bites... because why not - Pizza Near Me - Villa Park, Illinois