This location is nicely situated along a quiet street. The outside is decorated and feels welcoming, and inside matches wonderfully. The place feels clean and the service is attentive and fast. I ordered a frozen raspberry margarita and it was delicious!! We also got the fresh guacamole for an appetizer...wow! They make it right at your table in a mortar bowl and it's delicious. We ordered pollo cancun, carne asada, and birria tacos to eat, and the food came out SO fast. It was well cooked and tasted delicious. I'd love to go back soon! read more

Mi Cerrito - Pollo Cancun - Mexican Near Me - Crestline, Ohio

See all

We are frequent customers of Mi Cerrito and we are always coming back for more! The restaurant has an amazing vibe and really gives you a big city, boutique Mexican restaurant feel with amazing artwork. We came at 5pm on Cinco de Mayo and sat down immediately. Our service was top notch and our food came out almost immediately after ordering. I always get some sort of taco when I come and the Cucos Locos are my all time favorite! The chicken is marinated and I love the slaw on top. My daughter is 15 months old and she had the Popeyes tacos in bowl form. She made quite a mess but she ate almost half of the bowl! She kept dropping her water and our waiter was so nice to pick it up. My husband got the fajita burrito. It is literally gigantic, has fresh vegetables, the meat is super flavorful and the queso on top is top notch! We will always be coming back for more! read more

See all

Item ordered was not same as internet menu They refused to fix it. Will not order from this establishment again. When ordering kept asking me to repeat and spell everything. When retuned home found item different from menu. read more

Mi Cerrito, I have been here once in Crestline and several times in Galion. The decorations are so full of color and give your eyes a lot to look at. I absolutely love the look of both locations. For our trip to Crestline, it was a big family gathering. There was at least 13 of us, if I am remembering correctly. The service was fast and all with a smile. Not a single complaint across 13 people with their food. Everyone with the same feedback. "It's so good!" If you're undecided, you should absolutely go here. By far the best food I have had in this area since moving down here nearly a decade ago. read more

Excellent chicken verde and shrimp tacos. The little lady who makes the guacamole was a pro. Two Chefs say Muy Bueno! read more

Loved going to the Delaware location when I lived there many years ago. Then I moved. My best friend moved away, too. She contacted me and said she found Pedro (Owner) at a new location less than 10 minutes from her new home. OMG! We stopped in on Halloween. Great vibes and great fun. Pedro himself made guacamole at our table, BFF and I shared a Raspberry frozen margarita. The food, drinks, friends and conversation was the best! Can't wait to go back! read more

Mi Cerrito - Pedro making us some tableside guacamole - Mexican Near Me - Crestline, Ohio

See all

Great local place. Food was good and prices were amazing. The decor is pretty cool too.

Yup. Five stars for a cool downtown, tiny-town Mexican restaurant with an urban vibe. Table side quac, great drinks, super food. We ordered basic and savored each bite! Worth the trip! read more

Mi Cerrito - Steak and Queso tacos - Mexican Near Me - Crestline, Ohio

See all

Shrimp tacos are amazing. These and their freshly made guacamole make visits there very pleasing.

Love the Taco menu. I like mine in a bowl The servers are always right on top of things and the food comes out of the kitchen hot and fresh Can not go wrong here read more

The food is delicious, fresh and plentiful. They have the best margaritas and salsa. The atmosphere is lively and arrive early for the best seats. Food and drinks are delivered in a timely manner. read more

The food is delicious! We have yet to have a bad meal here (we've tried many different things). The dishes burst with perfectly balanced flavors. I highly recommend the chillis. There is also a fresh guacamole option.... Someone will make it fresh at your table and you choose the amount of heat. Staff is always friendly. One server jokes around and always makes us laugh. The owner always comes around to make sure our food is perfect. We highly recommend this place! We eat here about once a week. read more

Mi Cerrito - Chips, salsa, and spicy ranch dip. - Mexican Near Me - Crestline, Ohio

See all

Love their fish tacos. Always good food and service. They do a great business in our little town

Solid Mexican food with good service, good prices and a cool atmosphere. Kitchen is generally quick, but it can get noisy inside if they're busy. read more

Best Mexican restaurant in Ohio! The birria tacos were so full of flavor! Best salsa I've had in a while. The atmosphere and staff were amazing! Definitely coming back! read more

This is such a unique place! Very spacious and wonderfully decorated; extremely friendly staff! If you want a unique Mexican restaurant experience, this is the place to be! Would highly recommend!! read more

Mi Cerrito - Cuco Loco Tacos and rice! - Mexican Near Me - Crestline, Ohio

Great food and drinks And a good atmosphere Impressive to see the quality has sustained after being open this long Always the go to spot in crestline read more

It's horrible food and even worse customer service. They messed up or order 3 times and the server was rude as can be.

Absolutely THE best! They have a menu more than any one person could ever need. Their drinks are spectacular. Excellent service and a stellar value for the food. I highly recommend! read more

Very good authentic Mexican styled food. It has a great atmosphere and staff are friendly! Best Mexican restaurant in the Richland county area! read more

Amazing place! Best Mexican food in the area. Staff is always so nice and polite. They take care of you from the moment you walk through the door. The food tastes amazing and always comes out hot and fresh read more

Great place in Crestline food and staff,Huge menu the ordinary Mexican fare and was told opening soon in Galion

This place is GREAT!! The Jumbo Shrimp Street Tacos are out of this world and I absolutely love their "white sauce" that comes with the chips! Be sure to say "Hi" to Clayton when you stop by!!! read more

Mi Cerrito - The Jumbo Shrimp Street Tacos are out of this world!!! - Mexican Near Me - Crestline, Ohio

Delicioso!!! I love the shrimp fajitas! My boyfriend always gets h to e fajita quesadilla!

The fish tacos are amazing. The guacamole and cheese are excellent. Great atmosphere. read more

Mi Cerrito - the interior of a restaurant - Mexican Near Me - Crestline, Ohio

See all

¡Me encantó esta comida! ¡Lo recogimos el viernes por la noche! ¡el pedido fue correcto, listo y delicioso! ¡No puedo esperar para regresar! read more

The vegetarian enchiladas with spinach stuffing are so outstanding! That's not the usual dish that you see on a Mexican menu, but their cuisine is so much more that what we see here in the states. Owners and staff are really nice. read more

My new all-time favorite Mexican restaurant. Super flavorful food from start to finish. And it's not the same typical Mexican food you find at most restaurants. The Mrs. got Mexican cheese steak tacos and I had the tacos al pastore. Both were FANTASTIC!!! Warm chips and salsa and they also came with a slightly spicy creamy dip I'd never had before. Not sure what it was but it was delicious. We will be back! read more

This place is awesome. Food was on point, had the fajitas, so good. The atmosphere was very cool. Impressive art work, incredibly clean and the staff was super polite even though it was late. Highly recommend. read more

Fantastic Mexican restaurant. Authentic and great atmosphere.

Husband and I decided to give this Mexican restaurant a try, from a friends recommendation. The food did Not disappoint! Atmosphere was cool, service was quick and friendly and the food was great! We will definitely drive the 40 minutes again! read more

Best Mexican food from Columbus to Cleveland. Nothing comes close in this area. Enjoy!

The shrimp tacos are life changing. The place is nearly decorated and very clean. Awesome little joint in Crestline, OH!

Great food, good prices, and beautiful facilities. Nothing here to dislike. Great staff as well.

Always friendly, always clean and fast. Always delicious. Sprites drinks are not skimpy.

This is first class Mexican food taken to the next level. It's a super clean restaurant with friendly staff.

Very nice restaurant. Food and service is excellent. Will definately go back soon. Highly recommend. It is beautiful on the inside (and out) They did a great job remodeling it. read more

Yea food was cold and service was crap. For the price you'd think that this wouldn't be the case but it was .

The Al Pastor Street Taco's are awesome. It's great to have an authentic Mexican restaurant close by. We were driving to Columbus or Akron for authentic Street Taco's. Very clean and nicely decorated. read more