Super cute cake shop!! I stopped bc I was recommend by a friend to taste their banana pudding! Glad…read moreI stopped. I love the building/decor and desserts! I picked up banana pudding, their dirt cake version and two unicorn cupcakes for my kids. They loved it! I'm giving it 4 stars only bc the girl checking us out didn't seem to know much about the items while I was asking questions.

Best bakery around!! I needed to find some sugar free cupcakes for my dads birthday so I was…read morecalling around to different bakeries in the San angelo area and no one offers them.. So when I called Carters they informed me that they indeed make them fresh I was so excited. It was a last minuet order and they still managed to accommodate me, I was so thankful because I was ordering all the way from California. They had them delivered on my Dads birthday .. he was just over the Moon. Both of my parents couldn't believe they were sugar free.. THEY WERE DELICIOUS!!!! I just wanted to give the shop a huge thank you for such great customer service and for making these cupcakes so delicious..

10/10 coffee and bakery items!!! I've never stopped here but I have stopped at numerous other…read morecoffee shops in town while working and this is by far the BEST! First of all, cutest name ever! All of the bakery items are extremely fresh, homemade, and crave worthy! Something that I absolutely loved here is that the iced coffee has 4 shots of espresso. Majority of other locations I have to add atleast one extra shot to my coffee or it tastes overly sweet or watery. This coffee is PERFECT! I will always return here when I visit for work!!

The food is always changing which I love. I do think their pastries are amazing. Their muffins are…read morealways perfect, their desserts are phenomenal. One complaint I have is that croissants are always burnt. Never one time have they been cooked at the right level. They want to make sure the inside is cooked but the outside isn't golden it's always dark and over crispy. Today I had a scone but the ratio of toppings to dough was off a bit. Perhaps oven temperature? There isn't enough space for customers to maneuver and while they do have a microwave for you to heat up food that isn't heated through it's a cheapo Hamilton one from Walmart. It would make a big difference in customer service for them to upgrade to a higher wattage microwave that is maybe professional grade. Both for the staff behind the counter and the one available to customers. Simple fix that I think would help the line move quicker. Staff are always courteous and kind.

First, everyone already knows the cakes are delicious! And I'm talking every flavor! But, are you a…read moremember of the email club? It's free to join, and membership means free cake! Every so often, you will get an email coupon for BOGO free! That means cake for you AND your spouse, or kid, or BFF, or whoever is lucky that day! Personal favorite? I'd have to go with red velvet, or white chocolate raspberry. YUM! Not a member? Sign up!

This location has the best customer service and freshest of cakes. I've visited different…read morelocations across the nation, and THIS location has been theeeee best! #AboveAndBeyond #BestEFFORT #Friendly #FreshAndTasty

The strawberry cupcake: frosting is nothing special, not too sweet, but a little too much for the…read moresize. The cupcake itself tastes artificial. The red velvet: frosting is better than the strawberry's, nice classic cream cheese frosting. The cupcake itself has good flavor but wonder how long it has been there because tastes a little dry. Banana cupcake: Best of the three. I would say come early because when we got there around 5:00PM, there wasn't a lot left. Person who served us was nice and patient when my fiance and I were making our decision on the limited selection. Location isn't best for them: we had never seen the shop before until I looked up direction to Cakes in A Cup and we pulled up to the store front. Not much to attract people except that store. Oh and they have more than cupcakes. They have ice cream and also cookies I think...

Ok, so to be fair San Angelo doesn't really have much to offer in the way of cupcakery's that have…read morean actual storefront - so kudos for someone trying to venture out. I'll start with the good: - decent variety of flavors - two sizes - not too too pricey - takes custom orders - easy to order by phone - pretty decorations on cupcakes Now the needs-improvement: _ #1: MOVE LOCATIONS. They are not in a prime spot, but that could be overlooked. The real problem is the neighboring a nail salon and the chemical smells completely overpower the bakery smell to the point of nausea. I don't know how the girls bake in there with that smell. Move, move move!! - cupcakes were dry - website is outdated (I tried submitting a contact form and never heard back from anyone - was told they don't have access to the website since they bought the company from old owner. I HIGHLY recommend they either gain access or ask the previous owner to shut the site down) - it has flavors and pricing they no longer carry so it's misleading. - photos on website are prettier (and different) that what you get when you order - seemed like every cupcake was pretty much an iced and decorated version of banana bread, chocolate or vanilla (obviously with the exception of the strawberry or red velvet). It's not awful but I have experienced (MUCH) better cupcakes (and actually from this cupcakery BEFORE it was sold to the current owners). I don't think it's a total failure and with a few adjustments they could probably make some improvements for the better. Truth be told. if I needed cupcakes in the near future, I would look for other options before I tried them again just to see if this town has something a little better to offer.

Crumbl cookie who? Today we went and tried Sugar High Bake Shop San Angelo and oh my gosh. These…read moreare the best dang cookies i've ever had! We also got the Cookies & Cream milkshake which was also so dang good! These are fresh and massive! We will definitely be back! Stop by or order on doordash! It's 100% worth it.

Sugar Rush had a "Share it to Win it" facebook contest, and I won. The cake balls I received were…read moregorgeous and tasted wonderful! I'd recommend Sugar Rush anytime!

Super cute, great stop in Rising Star Texas. Good coffee and Pastry's to keep you going on your…read moreroad trip.

Best cupcakes ever. Many distinctive flavors and presentations, all of it quality. 1000x better…read morethan grocery store stuff. Just be sure to get them before they run out!

Stopped by here when we were passing through Brownwood! I can say it's one of the best decisions…read moreI've made all day! SUPER yummy sandwiches and they came out really quick! Lunch is only $7 and it comes with sandwich, drink, chips, and a CUPCAKE! Owner is super sweet also she introduced herself to us while we were eating! And free wifi who doesn't love that!

1/29/2026 we ran across this bakery by accident and we were greeted as soon as we stepped inside…read more They have a variety of both baked goods and chocolates to choose from. We picked up the apple pie after looking over the other items. The owner said they are in the early discussions of baking bread to include sourdough items. We can't wait for the fresh baked bread. As far as our apple pie, it's delicious! Apples are fresh with a bit sweet and sour tasting and with a fresh crisp bite not like that soft mushy texture like you get with store boughten pies baked who knows where and shipped in. The store is clean, bright, smells like a bakery and easily accessible with parking right out front.

Great assortment of cookies, cupcakes, pies, and cakes. The Texas Chews and Princess Squares were…read moreamazing! Cant wait to return and try more things!!