I ordered a greek gyro salad for lunch freshly made.... Delicious dressing .....it was excellent.....Highly recommend

This place is excellent. Everything I have ordered here is outstanding. The Baba Ganoush is the best I had in a long time. I highly recommend the Turkish Moussaka. They really put the love in their food. This is definitely a gem on Long Island. I would give the service here more than 5 stars. read more

Great food and great costumer service. The atmosphere is very roomy and you do not feel like you are on top of each other. Lots of parking if you come in the evening. The place is in between two business so I cannot speak on the parking situation during lunch hours. The food tastes great never have been disappointed. They have also a good variety of deserts. read more

This is the best restaurant for any kind of Mediterranean dish you could possibly desire everyone is wonderful and nice here definitely sit down and eat there!! Everything is filled with traditional ingredients and spices I recommend trying the lamb souvlaki with side of dolma!! Have a cup of Türk Kahvesi (Turkish coffee) before you leave. read more

Mediterranean Kitchen - Lamb souvlaki French fries Greeks salad - A white plate contains crinkle-cut fries and seasoned beef pieces, with a fork resting on the plate. The table also has a salad, a basket of bread with napkins, a small cup of dipping sauce, and a large glass of ice water. The setting appears to be inside a casual restaurant with wooden chairs and a stone wall in the background. - Turkish Near Me - Mastic, New York

This place is both a cafe and a store. Their gyros are excellent, as is their babaganoush. This is the best place for gyros in the area. Service was helpful and quick. They have improved the ambiance with covers on the booths. We got Turkish delight here too, and they had it in small packages as well as boxes, which was helpful. I'd recommend this place highly! read more

Fantastic! We ordered food for 7 people and each thing was better than the next! The food was super fresh and portions were large. There were no complaints. Hubby said this will be his new go to for Greek salad with many big chunks of kebab chicken. My favorites were the grape leaves, the shepard salad, greek salad, beans, the Adana kebob, and the custard dessert with the burnt sugar top. read more

See all

Delicious, authentic tasting Mediterranean meals, everything fresh and the staff is very friendly.

Past this place alot,first time in. Owners are actually Turkish. No matter, the food seems very good and fresh.we ordered 2 large Greek salads,one with lamb kabob the other with chicken. Lamb didn't taste like lamb more like steak,no matter it was very tender and tasty. The chicken was also very good. The dressings are pretty typical Greek dressing and the other is the white sauce with cucumber. It's like the gyro sauce. The spinach pie was really good but not flaky like the real Greek kind. I'm assuming this is a Turkish version. We ordered two,they were gone in no time. I will return and use this store again. There's other meals I want to try. I would say pricing is reasonable for the amount of food received. I will amend my review as I try different foods. I do recommend this place for you Mediterranean needs... read more

See all

This place used to be of my favorite places, even though the prices are high for the location. Decided to visit tonight for dinner, order a whole brazini (fish) with salad & rice, and ordered coffee However, the owner of the restaurant was the waitress training another waitress during rush hour, my coffee arrived SUPER late, salad and same late too, salad was mediocre, dressing tasted like white vinegar (horrible) once I was with soup & salad, was told they were out Branzini (fish) they offered a sea bass, which arrived like 45- 60 mns late, the chef was alone in the kitchen very overwhelmed with all the orders, my fish came out uncooked/ raw and the owner most fishy are like that... REALLY now, I was like WOW... I didn't no apology or was offered a different meal, they charged for everything and not even apology. I don't recommend this place, owner is nasty, rude & obnoxious... read more

Mediterranean Kitchen - Turkish Near Me - Mastic, New York

This is a local mom and pop family run establishment. The staff is super friendly and always happy to serve you the freshest and most delicious dishes. The price is very good for the portion you get. And the food is always top quality fresh and delicious. Make it a point to stop there and say hi and grab a bite to eat. read more

Mediterranean Kitchen - Grilled Salmon and veggies on bed of lettuce 5 - Turkish Near Me - Mastic, New York

Food was good service was good prices were fair other than drinks. Bottled drinks were priced very high otherwise I would have given 5 stars. read more

Cute little joint - very clean and super fast / I was getting my car looked at and decided to take a walk over to check it out - although they were training someone new the service was great and they got me my gyro at a discounted price very quickly and even added some extra fries - great deal definitely rexcommend and they have an awesome lunch special 9.95 for gyro fries and a drink read more

Tried this place a few years ago and wasn't thrilled so I stayed away. Last weekend figured I'd give it a try again and was pleasantly surprised. Wife and I had the Gyro Platters with Fries and had a Great Meal. Plenty of Meat vegetables and the Tziki Sauce was good too. Definitely going to be purchasing dinner from them again this weekend -- only this time we'll be purchasing an additional Gyro to split between us -- 1 1/2 Gyros each should hit the Spot. read more

Out on an impromptu day trip to Long Island and searched for a non-chain restaurant and decided to go here. Delightful, well-kept place. Absolutely delicious, quality food! Owners were wonderful, hardworking, attentive individuals. If I lived here, I would be a regular! And judging by the constant stream of people doing takeout, I'm sure they are quite popular! I don't do Yelp, much social media or reviews, but I needed to create an account just to leave this! read more

We decided to try their Greek salad with chicken and the veggie wrap. We are now addicted; it is so fresh and tasty! We were there last night and I dared to try the chicken lemon soup and it easily became a favorite. The ziki sauce is amazing and oh so fresh. The staff was very friendly, wore masks and did their best to remain 6 feet away. Give this place a try! read more

I live in Queens and when ever I go that way I have to stop by for Adana Durum sandwich. Combination of ground meat and zesty mix is amazing. If you never tried Adana Durum this is the place to try. They are fanatically clean. Negative comments about hygiene and masks are totally baseless. read more

My favorite place for Mediterranean take-out. Why? Everything is fresh, prepared to order and delicious. I especially like the gyro platter, deliciously juicy meat, grilled vegetables, and rice (white or red...I get both). Another favorite are the spinach pies. Great Greek salad as well. Friendly, quick service; fresh, hot tasty food, amazing desserts. What more would you want in a take-out place. read more

Great food and costumer service Food is always fresh keep up the good work guys the owner is super nice guy! read more

The food here is really good and so is the authenticity. However, I ordered over Door Dash, and when it arrived, I noticed I was missing one of the items I paid for. When I called to explain, they refused to resolve it and I could hear a man yelling to the woman speaking to me on the phone that I was a liar. So if you order from them and your order isn't correct, keep that in mind. read more

This is authentic Greek food. Staff very pleasant. Giro meat is a must have. Soups are amazing. read more

I keep trying this place because I want it to be good but it never is unfortunately. The tatziki is also slimey. read more

Mediterranean Kitchen - Gyro - Turkish Near Me - Mastic, New York

If I could give a zero I would. First of all in the middle of the biggest Covid infection rates ever no one is wearing a mask. Neither cook or cashier. All guests no masks. Food cold. Disgusting. Missing part of my order but yea let me go back in and get Covid. read more

If you are stuck in the cuisine desert of NY (Shirley/Mastic) and seeking lunch or dinner, I can safely say this is the best place to eat. I was very surprised by the quality of the food. Prices were very fair, and there is a small selection of Turkish groceries there as well. This place says "Greek and Turkish" cuisine, but it is pretty much the later, which is good! I suppose they have to put Greek and Gyro in their sign/menu to attract people in this area as there are not many interesting eats around, and many may not know what Turkish food is. Their gyro meat is well.. gyro meat and not like the juicy meat you get for turkish kebabs, but this is more than offset by their good chicken kebab and home bread. I had requested home bread and the woman was like ummm and goes to the chef, and she is like you are in luck, we have it today, we make it fresh. Fresh it was, and lucky I was, it was excellent and this is the furthest east I have had turkish home bread. read more

I've been eating here for YEARS!! Always consistently great food and friendly service! The gyro sandwich is massive and could easily feed 2 people. read more

I used to like going to Mediterranean Kitchen, but after my last visit, I will never go there again. I always thought they were very overpriced for what you got. Still, I would go there once every few months when the craving struck for a gyro. It was always sub-par. However, a few weeks ago, I had a few people over for a small birthday party and we decided to order Greek. My husband brought home the $80 worth of food (for 4 people, mind you) and it was just terrible. Everything was cold. They skimped on the meat in the gyros even when we had asked them and PAID FOR extra meat!!! The taziki sauce was watery and tasteless. I won't order from them or go there again. Looks like I'll have to start driving the extra 10 minutes and go down to Greek Bites. read more

Wanted to try something different so I ordered thr kofte kabobs (flat meatballs).....good choice to say the least. The five stars come from the food and the friendly atmosphere read more

Mediterranean Kitchen - Kofte kabobs (flat meatballs) soo good - Turkish Near Me - Mastic, New York

See all

Was a fan of this place for many years. Recently ordered falafel platter, and was so disappointed. Falafels had no taste, like grease patties, and tzatziki yogurt sauce was flavorless. I make better falafels at home, and mine have parsley in them, and my yogurt sauce at least tastes like the real deal. I was expecting a pita filled with falafels and since it was platter thought it wou have some other stuff on the side, instead, just these flat squashed falafels on bed of rice...and over priced as well (like $13.00). In NYC city (west side mid 90's) I get a platter with pita bread, falafels, salad, eggplant salad, babaganouch, lettuce, tomato, cucumber slices, olives, with tahini or tzatziki in a sit down restaurant for $11.95. The other dish ordered for the table was the gyro special...was not as good as we had remembered, and the fries were soggy...(just frozen fries). read more

Not the best turkish food I've ever had, however, it was very good. chicken kebab platter, with bulgur rice. greek salad was excellent as well. my date had the spinach pie, and he said it was great. read more

They make the best ziki sauce ! I've been coming back for years to order their chicken lemon soup and Greek salad.

My second time trying Mediterranean Kitchen and once again it was delicious. Had the Lamb Souvlaki Gyro (w/Pita Bread). The lamb was marinated and grilled perfectly. For dessert had the Pistachio Baklava which was so moist ate it with a spoon. By far the best place in the neighborhood for authentic cuisine! read more

I used to work in the area and was never really a fan of Mediterranean food. This place made me a believer. Gyros and kebabs are excellent, generous portions and delicious. Definitely worth a stop to check this place out. read more

Very small, cozy place located in Mastic. Don't let this small restaurant fool you, the food is freshly made and taste delicious! Yummy in my tummy!! :) would def recommend to anyone looking for a small spot yet healthier choice to eat. Enjoy! read more

Literally one of my favorite go to food places. I love the falafel platter with Ali's hot pepper. Best tzatziki sauce I've ever had. Never disappointed with anything I order. Authentic, beautiful food and such kind people. read more

The food here is actually really good but Fake crab meat in your seafood salad? Come on now how do you disrespect your menu like that???

Good food and love their chicken lemon soup. I would highly recommend this place . I have not been here since COVID but when I did stay in to eat I got great customer service and also clean place . My favorite is their Greek salad yum yum the best . read more

Right off, the counter person was very unwelcoming & curt. After my take-out salad was prepared, I asked the cook to please put the sliced lamb in another container since I didn't want the warm meat sitting on top of the salad & wilting it. The counter person then told me: It's not your order. But then she packed it up & gave it to me. I questioned her about this. She then said in a very hostile way: You're not allowed to talk to him. He doesn't speak any English. How bizarre is that?! I left without the food but with a very bad feeling about the place. I've never before had such a strange experience in a restaurant!! Wonder if the owners have any idea that this place is being run & represented by such an aggressive staff member. read more

Yummy ! A little expensive but what isn't these days. Quality of food is great. I got a Greek salad with chicken, dressing was good. My hubby got the kebab platter that comes w a side Greek salad. He finished every bite even the grilled vegetables. Good food , nice people. read more

They have great service, very good food. Free Turkish tea is always welcome and a nice selection of pantry items in the market they have.

Anytime I'm in the Port Jefferson area of Long Island, my friends and I like to eat at the Mediterranean Kitchen. The last time I was there, we ordered Iskender (grilled pita chips served with shredded lamb, tomato sauce and yogurt), and lamb souvlaki served on bulgur pilaf. We also ordered side dishes of hummus (mashed chickpeas), babaganoush (eggplant), tabouleh (salad made with bulgur wheat, herbs, tomatoes and more!), falafels (deep-fried, spiced ground chickpeas) and Greek salad. For dessert, we ordered a Portakal cake, an orange and cocoa cake with orange flavored icing. It was excellent with their Turkish tea. Everything was just so delicious! There is a section in the restaurant that displays products from Turkey, for sale. It ranges from food, trinkets, to other decorative items. After our meal, I went home with a very nice "evil eye" protection bracelet. The restaurant is cozy, the food is very good and reasonably-priced, and the staff is friendly. If you're looking for a delicious Turkish meal, you can find it, and more, at the Mediterranean Kitchen. read more

First time getting take out from this place. Food was good. Prices are a little high. The yogurt sauce is horrible. It's watered down.