Made a pilgrimage to this old school market after seeing the place featured on Brooklyn Bites. There's a limited selection of produce -- some well priced, but berries were pricey.The packaged meats were a pretty good value. I thought a rack of baby back ribs was excellent, but a quartered chicken was sloppily butchered. Steaks from the butcher were very good and also well priced. The prepared foods were not that visually appealing, although a cavatelli salad with broccoli was fresh and better than expected. Service was friendly and efficient throughout. I'd definitely shop here if I lived nearby, but it wasn't worth the trip from Westchester. I'll stick with Paisanos! read more

Meat Supreme - Nicely marbled strip steaks. - Caterers Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

All the ingredients for the perfect Italian sandwich is right here. Including a delicious bread. read more

See all

gotta rave about this awesome store I stumbled upon! Seriously, if you're craving authentic Italian flavors, this is the place to be. From the moment you walk in, the aroma of cured meats and simmering sauces hits you like a warm hug. They have everything from hand-rolled sausages to imported cheeses, and don't even get me started on their selection of olive oils and balsamic vinegars! But what really sets this place apart is the incredible service. There's this guy Chris who works there, and he's an absolute legend. Super friendly, always ready with a recommendation, and knows his stuff inside and out. I was trying to decide between a few different prosciutto options, and he guided me through each one with such expertise. Ended up with the perfect cut for my sandwich! Honestly, this store is a gem. Great products, reasonable prices, and a staff that goes above and beyond. And Chris, you're the man! If you're looking for a taste of Italy, do yourself a favor and check this place out. You won't be disappointed. read more

I'd rate Meat Supreme there and a half stars. Came on a Saturday morning to pick up side dishes for a party. They have a great variety of cold sides. All the dishes were good and I didn't have any complaints. Their seafood salad was a hit. Pricing was reasonable, and service was quick and helpful. read more

Catered from meat supreme for Thanksgiving. The turkey was moist and delicious. Delivery was perfect with the delivery person taking the time to check each item and he made sure everything was correct. I would order from them again read more

Came here today to pick up some deli meats from their deli counter and of course some of their fresh baked breads (got 2 loafs of Italian bread). I got sandwich fixings and extra bread for when I make my beef stew dinner tonight. They always have great customer service here. Friendly staff always. Great attitude and delicious food. Some items can be pricy but always great quality. read more

See all

Me to girl behind meat counter: "Do you have guanciale?" Girl gives me a frown: "What?" I explained what it is and what it's for, she said, "No, we don't have it." Me to girl behind the register: "Do you know if this place have guanciale?" Girl furrows her brows: "Huh?" I tell her what I told the other girl, she went, "Ask one of the service guys." Oookay, let me turn 180 and go back to the corner to see if there is a guy, any guy that know what the hell guanciale is in this meat store. I found one Italian-looking man by the raw meat area and prayed that he knows what I'm seeking. Ah, finally, he knew exactly what I was hunting for and didn't gawk at me like I'm a psycho looking for a made-up meat product with a fake name! Unfortunately, he said he didn't have it in the store that day because a little old nonna bought all they had for Easter so I'm out of luck. He says to come back after the weekend when their delivery guy make their dropoff and he'll take care of my meaty needs. I showed up today, dude wasn't there, instead it there was a Latino by that area. Me to aforementioned new man: "Do you have guanciale today?" He stares at me blankly. Dammit. I told him the story. He goes, "We have pancetta." Goddammit bro, they're not the same! (exits the store like a failure) read more

I drive from the eastern end Sheepshead Bay to shop here. The deli department is aces. They still cook their own roast beef, top round, roast pork, prepare their own friend foods, & do a great job of it. The counter people are NICE & actually slice all meats perfectly, nice & thin. The pasta & other salads are great. Bleieve it or not, there seems to be no other store left in this end of Brooklyn that performs on the same level. read more

The butcher with glasses started ti shut the store down 10 minutes before the schedule says...no emergency...no reason...soo I ask politely " don't you guys close at 5?" He says " yea and?" Well sir it's not 5 yet..and he was soo disrespectful...he has gotten way to comfortable in his position for the Long time he has been working there...I asked if the owner knows he speaks like that to customers and he smugly said " yea tell him tomorrow " don't shop here..nasty people..and mouse.poop on the products read more

Meat, chicken selection is in abundance and fresh. A beautiful selection of freshly made salads cold cuts and various cheeses is sliced to order. Prices are a little high but worth every penny. They take phone orders for delivery in a timely fashion. Avenue U location is pristine clean, cashiers and other workers are very nice and helpful. Freshly made Italian breads and rolls every few hours. They offer catered dishes for large gatherings, corporate & private parties. read more

So before I begin, let me say that I read a couple of reviews here that were totally unfair, the best of the unfair was one that gave 1 star for not being vegan! Hello... the store name is MEAT Supreme. OK,, so I have been shopping here for a few weeks and was always satisfied with their selection of meats, cold cuts, breads (so good) and home made prepared foods. So when it was time to have a July 4th BBQ, I headed over to place an order. I received amazing 1:1 customer service and was guided through their BBQ menu and offered suggestions and alternatives. No hard sell and very patient. I asked for the delivery on the 4th and voila!! Delivered at 10 am. The food order was perfect. Everything packaged so that all I had to do was take it to the grill. Now comes the kudos. EVERYTHING WAS DELICIOUS! My guests loved the marinaded chicken and steaks. The sausages were obviously made in the store and so meaty and tasty. I was more than happy with everything, Not to rush the summer, but we have already decided on who is catering our Labor Day BBQ. Thanks guys for everything. Ya did good. read more

I have absolutely no idea why I entered this shop. I was hoping they would have at least some sort of frozen vegan food items but nope. They got plant based milks tho. ...and that's about it. read more

their apple crumble pie so good and fresh , apples perfectly sweet and not sour, crumble sweet and flaky and not dry read more

Meat Supreme - apple crumble( where apple pie and coffee crumb marry) best of both worlds - Caterers Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I will never come in here again. I use to shop here like twice a week but never again. I came in to purchase two sirloin steaks for dinner. Was a little hesitant about spending $7.99 especially since they were boneless but I did it anyway. I brought them home and started to prepare to cook them. As I opened the packages one of the steaks wasn't even an inch thick the second wasn't even sirloin it was a skirt steak and it smelled completely sour. I had to throw it out. I am appalled that a place that is suppose to be known for their meat has thrown out all standards and sold a product that is inedible. Despite the fact that their cashiers are very rude I was willing to look past all of that for a good product, but they couldn't even provide that I will never come here again read more

I've been a customer of Meats Supreme for many many years and I've never had anything less than a 5***** experience but earlier this afternoon the staff managed to outdo themselves. I was buying some cold cuts at the deli counter and noticed that Vito (the deli guy) was gonna throw out some end pieces of the eye round roast beef. I told Vito how much I loved these end pieces and finished my order. While waiting to check out, Vito took the time to wrap up a bunch of end pieces and stepped out from the deli section to personally hand deliver the end pieces to me at no charge. I just had to share my pleasant experiences with Meats Supreme and their warm, friendly, and professional staff. With this awful pandemic gripping the world, these guys and gals put their own health, safety and lives on the line to serve their customers to which they deserve high praise. Meats Supreme put their customers first and its much appreciated by this writer. Keep up your great work guys. I'll be seeing you in a couple of days. PS: I'd be remiss if I didn't extoll the virtues of manager Joe at the gourmet premium steak section. Joe has that old school mentally and way about him and makes me feel like an MVP when I shop there. Joe and his talented crew catered my retirement part 8 and 1/2 years ago and their staff left no stone unturned. Oh, did I say that their food is always fresh and delicious and so much better than outstanding? Love you guys. read more

Beautiful corner shop located on Avenue U with plenty of great meats (Shocker) and other groceries. They have fresh breads and a variety of sides like macaroni,potato and german potato salad. I love to go in, grab a roll and hand it to them, they then work the magic on it by adding the meats,cheeses and other toppings I request. Great workers that always seem to be in a good mood and willing to help you out if you need it. Check it out and get a great lunch for a reasonable price. They sell 3-6 foot heroes and also cater for parties. Around Christmas they also put together holiday meals if you are like me and prefer to down some wine or Guinness with family, instead of schlepping over a hot stove all day. Check out the meat supreme website for other locations around Brooklyn for all your butcher, seafood and deli needs. read more

Rude cashiers, great deli guys. Awesome selection of meats, sandwiches cuts, and cheeses. Meat Supreme has a really local Brooklyn feel. I would rate this place 4 stars, if only their teenage cashiers weren't so snippy. It's small but it'll suit your needs. read more

The difference between this Meat Supreme and the others in the nearby area is at this specific location they have a bread baker on site. You can get freshly baked straight out of the oven Italian bread that you cannot get at any of the other Meat Supreme locations. Just be careful when you are buying the bread. When I say hot, I literally mean just came out of the oven you WILL get burned. There are two kinds. With or without sesame seeds. If a whole loaf of Italian bread is too much bread, there are smaller loaves as well. On certain days of the week, you can find specific items. Lard bread can be found on Fridays/Saturdays (Don't quote me.) Their deli has a huge selection of cold cuts and salads. My favorite salad is the apple salad which is not available all the time. When if is available, it sells out fast. It has apples, grapes, walnuts, blue cheese, spinach, with a balsamic vinaigrette. The apple salad and some fresh bread makes a great lunch. The deli counter staff and catering staff are great. I gave it four out of five stars because I feel when you're waiting in line to pay, the young cashier staff should be more attentive and more vocal to inform customers that they're ready for the next person. read more

My sorority in Brooklyn uses Meat Supreme from time to time and we have always loved the food and service. When planning a retirement lunch for my office manager, I decided to try them out....my office is in the Wall Street area and the prices of catering near the office are ridiculous...First Joe and Michael were professionals....they worked to make the price for the meal fair....So glad I stuck with Brooklyn business......got the delivery for a 12 noon at 9 am...idea for us since we had time to make sure the food was piping hot for the guests who raved about the food...delicious and plentiful... we will be back again!! read more

I've always loved shopping here they make amazing hot food and all salads are fresh and delicious. The other reviews are not even accurate!! I have never seen a roach or rudeness from any employee. it's a family own and run business and I am even a new employee. So far all of the workers are great and the bosses r amazing. So I felt it unfair all of the negative reviews!!! read more

I get ALL of my meats and deli items from Meats Supreme. My boyfriend and I moved into the Gravesend area 5 months ago and the broker who found us the apartment highly suggested Meats Supreme for groceries and meat. Their Italian sausage is outstanding! They have a great assortment of cold cuts and cheeses. Their sides are really good too..try the cranberry, apple, and walnut salad and their couscous salad. Everything they sell is good quality and priced well. Defiantly love this place. read more

Meat Supreme now has rainbow bagels... Seriously best day ever! read more

Meat Supreme - MEAT SUPREME NOW HAS RAINBOW BAGELS #THEREISAGOD - Caterers Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This is my husbands favorite supermarket because they have a lot of his favorite Italian items that remind him of home HOWEVER we won't be shopping here anymore because the cashiers think its appropriate to trash talk customers in Spanish, in front of them! I have never wanted to punch someone in the face so badly in my life. Please teach your staff some manners. Or teach them to not assume that an Italian female doesn't speak Spanish. Idiotas! read more

I havent been here in a bit but Im going to make it back here soon. Almost all of their prepared food Ive had was good. The spiral looking sausage was good as well and Ive had their T-bone steak and that was good too. I live quite a ways from here but I used to have a reason to come to this neighborhood... I no longer have one but this place has given me a reason. read more

I was craving a sandwich so bad and I just walked in here by chance. MAN, THIS IS GOING TO BE MY GO-TO SPOT! My sandwich was so bomb. It hit the spot. I couldn't make up my mind to decide which sandwich to get. The deli guy, I think his name was Pete, was amazing. He recommended the best combo and hooked me up! I'll be going back for more sandwiches by Pete. So helpful and friendly, he'll know exactly what to make you. I'll be back soon read more

This is a great place to go! Has some awesome sandwiches, food is displayed right out there for you so grab and go, or you can order a nice sandwich/salad for yourself at the counter. Fast, helpful and reliable service from the cashiers and the cooks there. Go here about twice a week and it's an awesome place to get some food! I definitely recommend going here. read more

Apparently my statement about this place got deleted so I'll write it as many times if I could....this place is disgusting and have ROACHES!!! I went to buy lard bread and a roach fell from it another time a cashier saw one crawling by her station and she was freaked out she even told me they were infested and that they need to jump over to get out what a horrible business..some of the cashiers are also rude as hell and talk to eachother and curse like there's no tomorrow while customers are waiting and they also stuff their face...I wouldn't reccomend this place to anybody they r disgusting and infested read more

Meats Supreme's meat quality is lower than neighborhood Key Food's. And the prices are higher. So, why do they call themselves Meats Supreme? I go there once a year, just to see the selection and prices....and the question I ask myself after I exit the store... WTF? read more

I went back there today having not shopped in MS for a while, and I bought a pre packed linguine w/white clam sauce. It sucked. All I tasted was red pepper flakes and JARRED garlic. For this high priced dish I paid for garlic from a jar and an overabundance of parsley. This neighborhood needs a supermarket to knock them off the block. read more

OMG, this Italian Pork Store, Deli, catering just started making pizza. They gave samples to us and I have never tasted pizza this good. It was old school pizza from back in the day. I was in the store, while customers were tasting the samples and all I heard was, I will take 2 pies, half a pie, and so on. Excellent sauce, crust and the whole package. So you can shop and eat at the same time. I like any store that offers samples of their food. I will definetly go back for a slice or two or maybe a whole pie. You know of course they have to have the freshest ingredients, They make their own Mozzerella. read more

I come to Meats Supreme all the time, even from when I was a child. They sell dairy products, snacks, and fresh sliced meats on the daily! Don't forget about the fresh baguettes that come straight from the oven every hour! Meats Supreme never fails to disappoint me. I'm deducting a star due to the prices, that are a bit higher than most places. read more

Been shopping there for a very long time. Even though the meat prices were too high, my family went there at least 3 times a week for sandwiches. Today was the end of this. I ordered a basic turkey and cheese on a roll, went to the register and when told that it was $7.50 plus tax, I finally said enough. Never paid more then $5 plus tax there before. They even had the audacity to make a bogus statement about how the $5 sandwich was only a recent sale item. For years, that was the price. Now they even weigh the meat and cheese before putting it on roll. I watch as they put a little tuna in a container to weigh it before making a sandwich. I go one block up and get a larger sandwich for $5. Supreme also wants $8.50 if you want a stingy sandwich on a hero. Bye bye Meat Supreme. You just lost my family. read more

My grandmother lives in the area and I've come in here several times over the years to help her with her grocery shopping. This place has a great meat selection and lots of fresh bread they have delivered on a daily basis. They also a great deli department with every deli meat and cheese you can think of. Their macaroni and potato salad is one of the best I've had. read more

They have some nice meats but it's not real butcher quality. Still, I love their mini burgers, and the chicken sausage. They make some nice ready made meals and salads. It's not cheap though. Especially the produce. My son wanted an apple and it was like $3+. Pretty horrific. There is a produce place down the street on the other side of W 6th that is better. Also the staff can be pretty annoying. The cashiers can be totally rude. They are always talking to each other, and sometimes they don't even acknowledge you at all. There is a pork store down the block near W 7th and they are much nicer but they don't have the selection. They do have amazing olives though! Lol. All in all, Meat Supreme is a good place to grab tonight's dinner on the run, and maybe tomorrow's. read more

This place has the best fresh baked Italian bread and fresh mozzarella anywhere in Brooklyn

The deli guys here can be really rude. I once went in there in buy some cold cuts and some guy had the nerve to act like he didn't hear me because I mispronounced one of the names of the cold cuts. Give me a break! Other times these guys will ask you your order multiple times rather than just getting you your cold cuts. Then when you do finally get what you ordered, chances are they got something wrong. This place needs to get it together! read more

Awesome deli guys, neat supermarket but don't ever work there not worth it! Cashier needs improvement they're always in a bad mood! lol The food is a bit pricey but it's worth it, make sure u order the rice balls hot and fresh. Best call in the morning :D read more

This place made the best hero sandwich I have ever tasted. The staff was friendly and a custom made my sandwich to order, I got everything I wanted on it and it was made to perfection. I had a pastrami made from Boar's head brand meat topped with Dijon mustard, mayonnaise, tomatoes, roasted red peppers and shredded provolone cheese. Outstanding! I also got me a small bowl of Orso pasta with chopped olives, cranberries, Arugala and drizzled with olive oil. Also very good. The price seems a little much for me, the hero itself was $14 and with a soda and the pasta it was $16 total. But that sandwich was so good and it made two meals, I am going to go back and get me another one. read more

this place is awesome, I love this deli department, they have so many different kinds of cold cuts and cheese, so many options to choose from it becomes hard to decide. the variety of meat is also great for the prices marked, always fully stocked too.i also love the Italian bread that they sell for ridiculously low prices. you can also find good salads here, olive oils, pastas, basically anything Italian lol this store gets crowded on weekends, lines tend to get crazy here so beware! read more

Been coming here since I was a child. The butcher's knew my family and me and were always very personable and friendly. I have never had a issue shopping here. Even now as an adult I chose to shop here as the quality of meats and catered goods is always a hit. I have gotten my friends addicted to their tuna salad lol. Anyway this is my favorite local deli and butcher shop. read more