I am amazed that so many people bag on fast food joints like McDonald's. First off, any place that has a dollar menu needs to give you pause in regard to how much actual beef is in that thawed out, frozen, particle board of a patty?... Any way, griping about FRESHNESS should not be apart of the conversation. - HA! 'And don't get me started on the meat quality of Taco Bell. One grade above, not suitable for human consumption... 'But that's why they have their hot sauce to help it along. - "Needs more ketchup."
In general, most fast food joints are going to be:
1. Cheap
2. Quick & convenient
3. Mass produced with just enough "quality" to sell off to the masses
However, most people will usually go for the first two, cheap & easy. If quality was a big concern, they'd be heading to The Habit, The Schwack, A's Burgers, Burger Lounge, Bad to the Bone, or Surf Riders Cafe. Although, the prices at MCD's are more than they used to be; you still can get a good deal on specials like the Filet-O-Fish Friday. ($2.50 - Reg: $4.79)
Which brings me to my recent side-by-side comparison: Wendy's Crispy Panko Fish Sandwich vs McDonald's Filet-O-Fish Sandwich
"Ding! Ding! Let's get this show started!"
McDonald's Filet-O-Fish: $4.79 (Special offer: $2.50 on Friday's @ most locations.)
Wendy's Crispy Panko Fish Sandwich: $4.29
*Offered for a limited time only; some locations may offer it all year around.
Photo - https://www.yelp.com/user_local_photos?select=IHAv4c5x47jhhVtvyQ6VZA&userid=O6EBodP3Fgu_n67efSKnBQ
Texture & Taste:
McD's Filet-O-Fish is not very crispy at all; moist. Wendy's Panko Crispy Sandwich is quite crispy which gives it a nice textural crunch. Wendy's fish filet is coated in a crispy panko breading; served with lettuce, a slice of American cheese, pickles and a creamy dill tartar sauce, served on a premium bun. (Photo note: The bun does not look as nice as McD's but I suspect there are less preservatives in it as well.) I did notice that there was a stronger fish flavor in the Panko Crispy Sandwich which was less prominent in the Filet-O-Fish. The Wendy's fish sandwich was also saltier in flavor which could have been toned down a bit. If I do return & order the Crispy Panko Fish Sandwich, I may try and request "very light" or "no salt"; if that's even an option.
Photo - https://www.yelp.com/user_local_photos?select=fsxOC92OC9zEY_6Ey2YjdQ&userid=O6EBodP3Fgu_n67efSKnBQ
Cheese and...:
Both sandwiches come with a slice of American Cheese BUT it is notable that McD's uses only a HALF-SLICE while Wendy's gives you an entire slice. Both come with tartar sauce; Wendy's actually adds pickles and lettuce to the sandwich in addition to sauce.
Photo - https://www.yelp.com/user_local_photos?select=538Zjs1zIXFkU6kivVcCCw&userid=O6EBodP3Fgu_n67efSKnBQ
Size:
McDonald's fish sandwich offers about 50% less Wendy's portion of fish.
Mcdonald's Fish Patty: 2.5" square
Wendy's Fish Patty: 3.75" square
Photo - https://www.yelp.com/user_local_photos?select=L_f61XQpm55BakloW8O1NA&userid=O6EBodP3Fgu_n67efSKnBQ
Fish:
McDonald's uses pollock for their Filet-O-Fish. Wendy's previously used cod for their sandwiches but has switched to Wild Alaskan Pollock. The Wild Alaskan Pollock comes from the world's largest certified sustainable fishery.
McDonald's Filet-O-Fish comparison rating: 3 Stars
The Filet-O-Fish: https://www.yelp.com/user_local_photos?select=ZbeVCVcTz7ak5EpITc1v0g&userid=O6EBodP3Fgu_n67efSKnBQ
Overall restaurant rating: 3 Stars
Conclusion: For about the same $$, Wendy's offers a bigger, better, fish sandwich. However, McDonald's offers Filet-O-Fish Friday which is the best value to get an inexpensive, fish sammie fix.
- Big Aloha!
Food: 3 (Overall)
Ambiance: n/a
Service: 3+
Value: 3 read more