Very disappointing. We have eaten there many times in the past 2 years and were always pleased with…read morethe food and service. My daughter was visiting and we chose the Herringbone for dinner on Tuesday before New Years Eve. I ordered the loaded potato soup and the tuna small plate. My daughter had the salad and the shrimp appetizer The soup arrived barely hot and watery. Her salad was fine Then came the tuna with a smear of avocado and corn relish. None of it was edible. The tuna was definitely not fresh . By contrast the shrimp dish was delicious. The waitress graciously offered a replacement but by then I had lost my appetite. I am hoping that this was an uncommon experience because we really liked it beforehand.

Waterfront dining, with great ambiance and decent food. Love the beer flight. The servers are…read moreattentive and polite. We came here for dinner with a family of four. I expected better from my tuna; it was difficult to eat and didn't taste fresh. Other reviews stated the same (please fix this issue as unfresh fish can cause stomach problems). Whomever manages raw fish there needs to up their game; this should be reliably fresh and taste amazing at a restaurant of this caliber. I would come for drinks and an appetizer instead. Chicken sliders are good. Salads are huge.

Our favorite stop on our travels to visit family! Good food, great location for cruising the shops…read moreafterward.

Patty melt didn't have cheese. I would have told the server had she come by and ask. Can't really…read moreblame her she was the only one working. Burger was a smash burger without much taste. Christian country music playing fairly loud.

Great burgers! Wonderful service and nice ambiance. Great cocktails as well!…read more I highly recommend it for a quick meal!

Rachael and Clayton have done an amazing job of "kicking up" the menuThe orange crush, nachos and…read moreBrussel sprouts were fantastic!

We made it before it closed. Only the drive-through was open. We ordered Pecan Delight. A…read morestrawberry with banana ( added fudge) and a vanilla milkshake. Everything was good

I had a gift certificate the Free and it was still good and the the owner told me should would not…read moretake it. You can believe my shock when they would not accept it. The restaurant in the past few years has gone down hill so you would think they would do anything they could to keep customers coming back but I guess they would rather just take advantage of them. By the way the place looked very dirty when I was in there!!! Do not go!!

I have eaten here many times and have always found the meals to fantastic! The food was prepared…read moreperfectly, the portions were generous, and the price was right. Probably my favorite go to in Edenton.

Permanently Closed as of March 2026. This is sad as there are very few places to eat here and some…read moreare closed on weekends due to private events.

Food was average. Took a long time to receive order. The price was high for quality of food and…read morethe vent above the table does not look sanitary

In retrospect, I wish we had chosen a different restaurant for one one dinner in Edenton…read more Unfortunately, the fried oyster sandwich was inedible- there were large pieces of oyster shell in the fried oyster. The roll was too large and dry- unsure why they selected this option. Ordered the broccoli head- unfortunately the sauce that accompanied it was gloppy and lacking flavor. When I ate almost nothing served to me, the server didn't inquire - since we won't be returning, i didn't circle back to all these issues. My husband was satisfied with his crab cakes, but be aware , they're more like pancakes. From the name of the restaurant, we thought there would be a water view- be aware- there's no water view.

I had the club sandwich and fries, and my wife had the chicken sandwich with pasta salad. The food…read morewas great and service was fantastic. The restaurant was very clean. Make sure to check out the lemon cake and cookies at the counter as they rock! Highly recommend and we will be back. Thanks again!

Amazing! The Oyster Bar is fantastic. The steamed and fried seafood are so delicious . We highly…read morerecommend this restaurant!

Pleasantly surprised definitely worth the drive. We stopped in for lunch on a Friday. I had a fish…read moreand shrimp platter and my wife had crabcake sandwich. Both were full of flavor and done to perfection. Service was good pricing was reasonable.

Great food, and service. Had the pizza and it was fantastic! Very reasonably priced with a nice…read moredrive from Edenton. The atmosphere was very nice and relaxing. Highly recommend!

I've been here for the first time in months of being here it was pretty nice of them to give me the…read morepleasure of getting a dipped cone and it actually looks like the one on the pictures

Dear DQ: we walked in road weary, hungry and tired... in desperate need of some food and time out…read moreof the car. Cashier 3333: you made our day... having such patience for my son who is ASD, and patiently explaining the menu to all of us. Your restaurant is super clean and the food was amazing: special note about the fries being so fresh!! Thank you for this experience