[[HIGHLIGHT]]Brewery and tasting room with a full bar and five TVs. Plenty of tables and booths to sit at, plus an outdoor rooftop patio.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] We opted to be inside since winter is still happening. All the wait staff were excellent. They came by several times to make sure everything was okay. The food came out quick, although the pub wasn't busy. Oh yes, to the food. The squeeze and I shared an order of finger steaks and fries. It is our norm to split an order for lunch. The meat tasted good, nice and tender. Spices in the coating decent. The fries were crispy on the outside and fluffy inside. The dip for the finger steaks had a good amount of horseradish in it, wasn't overpowering but put heat into the bite. They did bring an extra plate, which was nice, and not to be charged for it is even better. They may have added some extra fries and fingers, don't know, but we were more than satisfied with the quality and quantity. Hippy Hopped Pale Ale had a nice taste of hops, kind of like a session IPA. The Mackinaw Red brew was oh so malty! [[HIGHLIGHT]]It was a little cool in there.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

See all

The service was fast and prompt but the bartender had the mouth of a sailor. The beer - the Overhung IPA was nothing special that made me think about having two. The pretzel was good, and the hot, spicy mustard was good. Good for a mid-day snack after skiing. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The place was kind of broken/trashy.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]We were sitting at the bar and noticed that the brewing supplies were a little gross. I thought brewers were clean?[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]The signs were not updated and had a make-shift feeling.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Sad to see what was once a great brewery is now trying to pick up its pieces. read more

We tried to give this place two tries because it was convenient. [[HIGHLIGHT]]First off, I realize it is Summer but it was HOT inside. AC looked like it was set to 67 but it was not on sooo...it was uncomfortable![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] The beer was ok, the service was slow. We ordered a couple sandwiches that were very dry. Adding condiments could not save the grilled chicken. It would have helped if I could have gotten a second beer but server was nowhere to be found. Seems like this is the norm in McCall. Second stop we tried sitting at the bar. Bartender was fast and friendly when we could hold his attention for 2 seconds. High energy but all over the place. read more

Inside out: decent location! [[HIGHLIGHT]]Inside gets very loud and crowded but that's fine. Fun decor![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Service: the people were so kind and friendly. I just gotta say we had every problem one could probably have. My friend has an onion allergy and they put onions on her food after asking for non, she asked for no coleslaw and they clearly had put it on her sandwich and scraped it off into a cup. She ordered mashed potatoes with gravy- got fries. They forgot her drink, and while they fixed it all and were so kind, it was still tiring when we were just hungry. I had a burger, it was good, and when they fixed her meal she enjoyed it- it just took a while to get there. I wanted to substitute a side and was given fries and charged full price for an additional side, which again they were willing to fix but my goodness at the end we just wanted to leave. The beer- excellent. Overall I'm sure it's not always like this. The staff were nice, we were hangry but tried not to be a pain about it, the food was good eventually, the beer was fabulous. I just can't say it was a five star experience but I would give them another try. read more

McCall Brewing Company - Posters - American Near Me - McCall, Idaho

My whole family loved our visit to McCall Brewing. Our waitress was the best! I needed my food gluten free. They were very knowledgeable and took good care of me. Highly recommend! read more

I will share a picture of our French fries that are old and saturated in grease...not eatable at all...the cook should be ashamed of him self for even serving such a thing...r order unfortunately was to go...but this is 2 out of 3 times that have been terrible. So this local won't be going back... I was hoping with new owners that it would of been a different experience read more

McCall Brewing Company - This is a picture of r old greasy fries that was served in 2 of r to go orders - American Near Me - McCall, Idaho

[[HIGHLIGHT]]Cozy little brew pub located in the heart of McCall.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] They have a great variety of beers available and the option to take some home too. I tried the Wobbily Man Smoked Scotch Ale and the Tangle Foot English Ale. Both were quite tasty and went down smooth. There's a good food menu too with pub grub. I ordered the bangers and mash. It was a very hearty portion and it paired nicely with my beer choices. The bratwurst was very flavorful. The place is crowded but the servers do their best to provide good table service. read more

McCall Brewing Company - American Near Me - McCall, Idaho

Went in and had some really good finger steaks and beer. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Kind of an old west saloon type place.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]Sat at the bar and BS with the patrons.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]Great place to meet a few people.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Have a great day. read more

[[HIGHLIGHT]]This place was sooo cold that the servers were bundled up.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]Between that and the rock hard booth seats, it was not a very good time.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]Owner needs to wake up and fix his heaters and try to make customer visits comfortable.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

[[HIGHLIGHT]]I really enjoyed the upstairs patio with a perfect view of downtown and the lake.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Ordered steak fingers which were cooked perfectly although a little on the skinnier side compared to some I had before. However, more than enough for me and my friend to share! read more

See all

Excellent selection of on-site beers available. Food selection seems somewhat limited and good for snacks maybe but the menu is more of a snack-like tribute to food. Seemed to be a little pricey too. I do go there for the beer and snacks. Staff is wonderful! read more

Service was great, and [[HIGHLIGHT]]I loved the atmosphere[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]], the food came at a great time the only thing is the food wasn't one in a million but pretty good for your average joe meal. read more

We love stopping into this place. I know it sounds funny but the bangers and mash are really good. This sauerkraut is excellent. They have a fun drink menu. We will be going back to this place quite often. read more

[[HIGHLIGHT]]Fantastic place with great beers.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] 2nd oldest in Idaho too. Great bartender too. Great burgers

What an utter disappointment and should've known better but took the benefit of the doubt and trusted my Yelpers! The only extra star was the ok service despite having to ask for every condiment to go with our food. Inside typical brewhouse vibe and was looking forward to trying it out. Now while they do have a good local beer selection we are taking a break from alcohol so we didn't try any. That might've been the high point. For food we started with the spicy wings. I asked for them crispy and well done. Out they came really fast and I knew from the get go they wouldn't be as ordered. Sure enough they were as expected gummy and not well done. Plus even though we asked for ranch and blue cheese we had to wait another 5 mins to get some. For food I had the KO burger which could've doubled as a hockey puck between 2 buns. It also lacked any seasoning at all on the patty. Plus the fries were right out of a frozen bag. My wife ordered the fish and chips and despite being next to one of the top 10 biggest fresh water lakes in Idaho this was the worst display of fish and chips. Tasted like frozen fish with some I am not sure what breading. For a brewer my how are these not beer battered? Same frozen tasteless fries as well. The fish was so inedible my wife didn't even eat it. This is a once and done place for me and very disappointing. In a town with very limited options for good place they have fallen to just that short! read more

See all

Go for the beer and skip anything on their menu. Ordered French onion soup which tasted like a watered down onion. We had to return the beef dip due to being so dry, and how does one mess up French fries. read more

This is my go to brewery to keep my kegerator stocked. Great beer, and great service - incredibly helpful.

McCall Brewing Company was a brewery I got to try out a little while ago in neighboring Idaho . I got the Say Whut Coconut Porter. I do really enjoy a good Coconut Porter and this one wasn't too bad. Dark and smooth in body this Porter does a good job with that. Also sweet and as I would hope with Coconut flavors made this porter fairly likeable for me. Not the best Coconut Porter I've ever had but definitely formidable and gets the job done nicely. read more

McCall Brewing Company - The tasty Say Whut Coconut Porter. - American Near Me - McCall, Idaho

We were visiting McCall and decided to stop in to eat at this restaurant. We got seated and everyone decided to use the restroom, as we had been on an ATV for a few hours. The waitress seemed impatient when only 2 people were seated and the others walked off to the restroom. We did give her our drink orders, but she kept showing up when not everyone was at the table. She did answer some questions that we had regarding the menu. My husband ordered the buger with fries. He said it was pretty good, but a bit decent. I ordered the tenders and fries. I thought that the tenders were pretty good, but some pieces were really hard. I still enjoyed them, and loved them with ranch. My FIL loved the onion rings that came with his meal and said they were super tasty. Overall, the food was pretty good and the service was alright. read more

See all

We came here for lunch on Saturday and had a couple beers and glasses of crappy champagne lol. (Noted for next time, skip the cooks champ). We were starving and ordered the bbq chicken sandwich and chicken tenders. The food was fine, nothing to brag about but it was a good meal and we cleared our plates. Service was good. Bill was pretty pricey spending $72 out the door with tip. read more

McCall Brewing Company - Chicken tenders - American Near Me - McCall, Idaho

See all

I can now say that I had a mimosa in a beer glass haha. Mimosa was good, cider was great, near looking place, friendly staff. My husband got to taste a couple of their beers and e took a bottle home. I think I would enjoy coming back it is a neat place and we felt comfortable there. read more

McCall Brewing Company - Mimosa in a beer glass - American Near Me - McCall, Idaho

See all

Food was average, beers and atmosphere were great!! They easily accommodated the large party I came with and we had a lovely rooftop table with a view of the town. I had the lemon ginger hefeweizen and thought is was pretty unique and good for someone who's not a hoppy beer fan. The beer cheese soup came out super fast and hot for one person but took a while for the other, maybe they had to make a new batch in between...? But anyway, we were there to try local brews and hang out so we weren't in a hurry! read more

McCall Brewing Company - Beer cheese soup - American Near Me - McCall, Idaho

See all

I highly recommend the Bangers & Mash! The Lemon Ginger Heff was yummy also. We will be back!

The food was great and the service was excellent. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Had a great view from the patio[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]]. Recommend you visit this place read more

McCall Brewing Company - American Near Me - McCall, Idaho

Came in on a wednesday afternoon with 2 plus hours before closing. We had 14 but stated we could be split up however they had tables and they refused to seat anyone. We asked for a table of 4 and they stated no and btw they weren't busy. read more

Two stars for the beer even though it was more expensive here than at other places in town. The Payette Dip sandwich was bland; even with mustard, ketchup and pickles I added, the taste did not improve. The Shepherds Pie was a bit better but the meat was so finely ground it looked like mush. Won't go back. read more

McCall Brewing Company - Special glasses for each brew - American Near Me - McCall, Idaho

I had only heard bad reviews of this place but decided to stop in just for a drink and maybe a snack when we first arrived in McCall since there are only 3 breweries. We went upstairs and were told to grab a table while the two people working seemed pretty frantic. It was Thursday around 3pm and the whole inside was empty but outside there were maybe 6-8 tables of people. I looked across from me and saw a guy drinking a beer flight and it looked good so I asked to order one as well. The tall white male server went over to grab me the paper to fill out which beers I want and after he walked away, he started talking shit - very loudly - to his female coworker in the upstairs server station about how "everyone kept ordering f%^*ing beer flights. " I worked in the service industry for many years and though I would've talked the same shit, I would've done it out of ear shot of customers. When he returned I opted for ordering just one beer instead so we could go ahead and leave. The beers were good but not worth the crappy service. The food menu honestly didn't look great so I'm glad we skipped out on that. We would not return. read more

McCall Brewing Company - Pale ale & kolsch - American Near Me - McCall, Idaho

Our server was amazing! She was so sweet! The beer was great, my favorite was the Lemon ginger Hefeweizen. The vibe was fun, it felt like an old school tavern! read more

McCall Brewing Company - $8 flight! - American Near Me - McCall, Idaho

See all

Stop here on our way to WA. We sat upstairs on the deck. It was a beautiful afternoon. Service was great. Food was good but the prices are higher than we have experienced at other places that have better food. I think our salad was close to $20. Ouch! Draft beer selection was great and we found some nice IPAs. A solid 4 star. read more

We are on vacation and love checking out local breweries. This place has a cozy, relaxed, mountain cabin vibe. Service was excellent start to finish. Very attentive and friendly staff. Food was ok, we just got some snacks. Don't order a Bloody Mary! They are good at what they do, coconut porter and IPA were delicious. We would totally come back. read more

If you are Gluten free or celiac , this isn't your place . They are not accommodating at all and there are hardly an options that have no gluten in them . Only the clams . It's great for fried food . I got the steak but couldn't have the gravy or fries or mashed potatoes and they put croutons on my very small side salad . You can get lettuce around your burger if you want - the meat is very good I ordered the skirt steak and I was great but just get the gravy on the side . The kids meal of fried chicken was huge . The fish and chips I was told were good - the sausage was bland . If you like fried food this is your place . read more

See all

Fast friendly service with a good choice on their menu. Food came out pretty quick and our server checked back a few times to make sure everything was to our liking (which it was). read more

We stopped here on our way to Boise from up north. They have many excellent options but we especially enjoyed the cheese soup and the Payette Dip sandwich. Service was friendly and attentive and the atmosphere in the restaurant is fun and matches the locality. Check it out next time you're in McCall! read more

We went to this place today for lunch on my wife's birthday. The restaurant is small, but it was completely packed. We ordered two sampler packets (flights) of beer. We enjoyed all of them. None of us are real IPA lovers, but everything we drank was good. We then ordered lunch. I had the pulled pork sandwich, and it was great. The portions were good, and the food was delicious. My wife had bratwurst with mashed potatoes, and said they were delicious. My father in law had clam chowder and said it was outstanding. My mother in law had a chicken sandwich with onion rings and she said the onion rings were the best she has ever had. My oldest daughter had the spinach salad and she said it was excellent. My youngest daughter had a veggie burger and she also said it was good. Our server was McKenna and she provided excellent service. She was so nice and attentive to us. She always made sure we had anything we needed. If you are ever in McCall, Idaho, I would recommend this restaurant. Next time we are there, I will do my best to go there. Thank you to the entire staff for an excellent experience. read more

3 stars is genuinely the correct rating for this restaurant. The setting is 5 stars. They have a lovely partially-shaded rooftop deck with views of the lake. The interior seating area is nice too. The food is 3-4 stars, on average. And the service is CONSISTENTLY 1-2 stars. So, every once in a while I am tempted to go back to McCall Brewing because of the deck and the decent food and beer selection. Yesterday we made our way to the rooftop deck. A waitress greeted us and said "you can sit anywhere you want, just don't move any tables or any umbrellas... Got it. We had a baby in a carrier with us and looked around and the only remaining shaded table had a couple of glasses sitting on it. It hadn't been cleared yet. So, we sat down and sat back to check out the menu until the waitress shows up to clean the table. We were sure to remain clear of the table to give them space to clean it. The same waitress showed up and had the nerve to say "hey guys, we prefer if you wait for us to clear tables before sitting down." Excuse me? We had already been told we could sit wherever we wanted, as long as we didn't move tables or umbrellas. It's not our fault that the servers aren't timely in cleaning tables, despite the fact that there were only a couple of occupied tables up there and two waitresses to cover them. And we had a child with us, necessitating some shade. We didn't need to be rudely admonished. Next she pointed to a water station where we could get our own waters (?????) That's a nice touch too... Our food came out relatively quickly and tasted OK. Our empty beers went unfilled. A smart server refills drinks to increase the tab and the tip, but not ours. So, basically this place is a mixed bag. If only the service was better, I'd probably stop by almost every weekend. But every time I go, I am so turned off by the insolent servers that it's usually a year or more before I forget how awful the servers are and give it another try. If you want to brave the incredibly ignorant servers, I recommend the Mackinaw Red beer. It's always delicious. Their sandwiches and burgers are usually pretty good. Their hummus is probably made from powder, skip that. read more

McCall Brewing Company - Nice view, but with empty glasses hoping for a refill. - American Near Me - McCall, Idaho

I just love this place! My favorite appetizer is the smoked meatballs! Their Overhung IPA is really freaking refreshing, probably one of the best IPA I have ever tasted...Servers and bartenders are so friendly and everything about their menu is great! read more

[[HIGHLIGHT]]The back patio was amazing.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]My guest and I were so happy with the experience.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] The only thing better than the ambiance was the service and staff. Disney ? And Bree were amazing. read more

The second oldest brewery in Idaho, McCall Brewing creates a big menu of craft beers and hard seltzers. Go for the flight tasting at first and trust effervescent bar manager "Disney" to curate your experience. This is both a local favorite and a hot pick for visitors. My favorite: Hippy Hopped, but their Hefeweizen is the popular winner. read more

McCall Brewing Company - American Near Me - McCall, Idaho

See all

Sitting at the restaurant now, we've already waited an hour since we ordered. The server is so unfriendly and rather curt. The lemon ginger ale was cool And refreshing. The jalapeño bottle caps were fair, too over fried for my taste. Asked the server, how much longer for the burger and were told it's going as fast as we can as we're in McCall. I now ordered 1 hr and 15 mins ago and still waiting for one burger. Hope it's better than the waiting time. read more

Stopped in for a snack and drink between lunch and dinner. We ordered the fish tacos and they were delicious. Perfect size to share and the jalapeño bottle caps were so good!! Yummy!!! The waitress was so nice and helpful. Perfect time to come when it was slow. read more

See all