I am a big sucker for their salads. I rarely order anything else from here. As for the salads, they are nice and fresh. A hefty portion of quality ingredients and the dressings are fabulous. I actually often divide the salads into 2 portions, because they are just so big... not that I am complaining. Service is quick and friendly here. The restaurant is nice and clean which is important to me. read more

McAlister's Deli - the interior of a restaurant - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Amazing food and service I ordered the 12 inch french dip and it was amazing will definitely come back again!

My sister and I stopped in for a mid afternoon late lunch. The restaurant was practically empty so service was super fast. No waiting to place our orders. The dining room was very clean and all tables were freshly cleaned. The dining room was cold, so cold I had to retrieve our morning jackets from the car. I ordered the Choose 2 option and chose the Classic Grilled Chicken on a Croissant sandwich with a cup of Broccoli Cheddar Soup. She ordered the same option of choosing 2 and went with the French Dip Sandwich and the Chicken Dumpling soup. We both enjoyed our meals. I thought my chicken sandwich had too much honey mustard. She really liked her dumpling soup. McAlister's serves really large soft drinks. I need two hands to manage one. read more

McAlister's Deli - French Dip and Chicken Dumpling soup - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

I had the chicken salad on a croissant. The croissant was more like a cracker instead of bread. The greens on the sandwich were brown and wilted. read more

I will never eat food from here again. This place is beyond gross and a huge disappointment. Something is very wrong with this restaurant. First of all, after my last negative review, as you can see, someone from Mcalister's acted concerned about my experience. They then messaged me and asked for my contact information for the store manager to contact me. No one ever did. That tells me this location does not care about nor take any pride in their establishment. Because it was so filthy, I decided I would not be returning. Last night, my husband calls and asks if I'd like him to pick up dinner. I said I wanted a salad from Mcalister's and figured he would go to the one that was near him at the time he called. Instead, he ended up going to this nasty location. As soon as I pulled my salad out of the bag, my heart sank. It looked a crazy mess and I could see large hunks of onion, not even chopped. The bowl also had quite a bit of empty space, which is not normal. It's usually so full with salad that you have to carefully mix in your dressing. I was able to dump my dressing in, replace the lid and shake it around. Usually the cup of dressing they give is the perfect amount. But because the salad was so scarce, it ended up being to much dressing. As I began eating, I realized that much of the lettuce was not good and a lot of the veggies looked old and gross. The lettuce even tasted bad, old and funky. I ended up getting sick shortly after eating what little bit of the salad I did. Do NOT eat here. I've instructed my husband to never get my salads from this location, ever again. It's filthy and they obviously have no quality standards in the least. The board of health needs to investigate. read more

McAlister's Deli - Pure laziness. - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Hadn't been in a while, but really wanted one of their spuds! We stopped in last night around 8pm, not too busy, but a small crowd still inside. I took some spud suggestions from a man named Chris who was not only helpful, but friendly! I believe I got the spud max.....? The meat on the potato wasn't overwhelming and I liked that! Shown in the photo- I ordered the pick/choose two. Chicken tortilla is my go to! Restaurant was clean and employees are constantly making their rounds to remove plates and refill drinks. I noticed they offer same day catering service as well! Last and most important (obviously) are their cookies! They are huge and come in a few different flavors. Always fresh! read more

McAlister's Deli - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

I've always gone to this location but recently they seem to be doing our orders wrong. I ordered a king club sadly my sandwich didn't have everything on it it's like they rushed through making it. I also ordered a BLT sandwich and requested to add cucumber and sadly they didn't add it. I've had a long day decided not to cook and pick something up really disappointed and sad I didn't get exactly what I ordered. As a college student I don't have that kind of money to spend on gas to go back and forth. read more

See all

Got back in town and wanted something light!! Hadn't seen my daughter in a week because i was out of town and this was what she wanted!! We sat in and ate! Our cashier that took our orders i didnt get her name but she was nice and attentive. Our food came out quick! And of course we ended our visit with a good ol' soft chocolate chip Thanks for the awesome customer service!! read more

McAlister's Deli - Dining in with my daughter - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Easy takeout experience with online ordering and easy pickup. Food was warm when we got it home and packaged securely. However, the pickle spears added were not included in the order. Everything looked and tasted good! read more

McAlister's Deli - Veggie Spud - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

I loved this place, and it was perfect for my family and I. My wife loved their salads, and my son loved the potatoes. The place was populated, and I still got my food quickly. The people who took my order seemed nice and patient. They seemed very professional and I was impressed. Thank you McAlisters for being so great! read more

Pretty great for a Friday lunch on the run. Much nicer than fast food or Panera, without breaking the wallet. read more

McAlister's Deli - 2 Southwest chicken salads with a baked potato (Spud on menu) and fresh black cherry lemonade - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

A friend wanted to join me to join her for dinner and suggested McAlister's Deli. I really didn't want to eat there, but I'm so glad I did! When we arrived the line was super long, but it moved pretty quickly. I order the half and half deal, but with my extras my total was around $13.00. I ordered the Broccoli Cheddar Soup in a Bread Bowl with a Chef Salad. It was the perfect combination for cold weather. The soup was good, but I really didn't like the actual bread. Next time, I would get the soup without the bread bowl. The salad was small but filling. All the topping were fresh and the ranch dressing was pretty tasty. The staff was really nice and accommodating. My friends sandwich was not made properly, but they quickly made another sandwich for her and apologized for the mix up. I really like this location and will come back to try more from their menu! Happy Eating! read more

McAlister's Deli - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Short curly haired employee about 4'9 came to bring my food and didn't know the name of the dish. Ruined my entire day. Please have your employees memorize the dish names. read more

I picked up a catering order for 30 people and was so impressed! Everything was fresh and included everything needed for no fuss lunch! Kudos to the staff! read more

I absolutely love this restaurant the customer service is great the food is great a lot of the time the line Is extremely long but today for some reason there were 3 cashiers which was perfect. They have a lot of items on the menu for all types of people I love fatty foods that's why I get the nachos (lol) they also have items for people who are on the Keto diet and people who just enjoy eating healthy, they have a section for outdoor setting which is nice for those nice sunny days and nights all in all it's a great place to dine. read more

McAlister's Deli - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Food - 2 stars Service - 5 stars If you like the food at McAlister's, this is a location to go. They push you through the line quickly, get you seated fast, and bring the food right to you. They come around to bring drink refills, provide extra help, and bus the tables. I ordered a baked potato with veggie chili. It had only a tiny dot of chili. I went up to see if they could provide more chili and someone was over to our table instantly with more than enough chili for my spud. The facilities are clean and well maintained. I want to like the food, really I do. They are so nice there, everything is clean, but the food is just so bland. The vegetarian chili was nearly tasteless. Usually veggie chili has a kick to make up for the lack of meat, but not this one. It was the beige wallpaper of chili. My friend had a salad and I tried her sherry shallot dressing. It was equally unflavorful. We went because my friend is vegan and I'm a vegetarian-in-progress. Their menu is fairly veggie friendly. It just really needs to amp up the blandness. read more

Went to pick up two sandwiches and two nacho baskets. Everyone was wearing a mask, EXCEPT the girl in the kitchen making the food(I guess technically she was wearing one but it was over her chin, not her nose or most of her mouth) .Also they forgot one of my sandwiches and I had to go back in, but the nice girl at the counter made that right. Really I was just upset that there is a mandate to wear masks, but the one person who really should be wearing on wasn't. read more

Great food. Love the southwest chicken avocado salad. Excellent. Great friendly service. Never get anything bad at any McAlisters

I have not been out of the house for two and a half years. I went out tonight to receive a haircut, an ice cream cone, and a meal at MacAllister's. Each stop was worse than the one before. I ordered two Rachel's with a change of condiments. Small servings of turkey, one slice of Provolone, and no mayo. The broccoli was fine. The cashier asked me three times if the broccoli was to go along with the sandwiches. Yes, of course. Then the salad was served on a plate with silverware. This was a TO GO order. My daughter had a similar experience. Her order was to go and they asked numerous times, "Is this to go also?" The food was for her and the boy. Why would half the food be a to go order and the other half a stay in order? I will stay home and order delivery online from now on. I have COPD and need to continue to wear a mask. It isn't worth the hastle read more

We love Rockville Mccalister's!! The people are super nice especially Haas Food is always good, hot and good portions Matt is doing a great jobmy husband eats there every day for lunch, he has been doing it for years. So it must be really good read more

My first impression of McAlister's long ago was so-so. Some hit or miss meals and I kinda forgot about them when I went off to college and there wasn't one nearby. When I moved to the west side after college, my husband's family was a big fan of the place, and I was definitely willing to give it another try (despite a blah experience on the north side around the same time). My love for McAlister's began then. I love this place, sooo many menu options and everything I have tried is very good. I'm mostly nowadays addicted to the Cobb Club, it is hard for me to eat something else, but occasionally I force myself to try something new. I crave their sweet tea so we make this a fairly regular visit. It loses one star due to a few messed up to-go orders and the occasional unfriendly staff member (but with how busy they can be, I can see why they get worn out). This location tends to be packed during peak times so we try to avoid those times if possible. I am sure my sweet tea craving will strike again soon...they even have little tea cup ornaments for sale during the holidays, I wonder how long I can resist picking one up... read more

McAlister's Deli - The tea that got me addicted to sweet tea. Staff is very nice about keeping it refilled too! - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

The menu has really changed over the years. I've been here more times than I can count. Everything on the menu is pretty decent, but nothing spectacular in my opinion. The quality is good, but it can get a bit pricey with all the options available. I haven't tried everything yet, but these are the items I'd recommend to try: 1) Basil Parmesan Chicken Panini 2) "Build Your Own Deli Sandwich" (Smoked Turkey on Croissant w/ Honey Mustard and ALL the veggie toppings)...It's nice that the bread and meat comes out warm while the veggies are still cold and crisp. 3) Side items-- Seasonal Fruit (seems sub-par these days, it used to be what I looked forward to as a side item) -- Mashed Potatoes & Gravy 4) French Dip (The gravy can be a bit salty for some.) 5) Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap 6) Pot Roast Spud 7) Soups -- Broccoli Cheddar -- Potato 8) Iced Tea Non-memorable menu items: 1) Side item -- Macaroni and Cheese (It tastes like a bad frozen dinner.) 2) Basil Parmesan Pizza Flat (Cardboard crust. What's worse was the cheese wasn't melted like it should be for a pizza.) 3) Lemonade read more

I want to give a huge shout out to the manager Mike!!! He went above and beyond today and personally delivered our food after door dash had delivered the wrong stuff. I've been going to this location for years and Mike is always engaging with guests and providing excellent customer service. Thank you so much Mike, McAllisters is lucky to have you!!! read more

We come here about once a week the food is great never had a bad meal but why we come is the staff very friendly. read more

See all

I gave visited locations in Gatlinburg TN, Vincennes, IN and now Avon/Danville, IN. The tea is good, but is not consistent between these 3 locations in regard to sweetness. The food is good, but quite expensive for a simple sandwich. Honestly, McDonald's sells their large teas for $1.00 and are just as good. Save your money. read more

I went for the first time and got a club and soups. I was so hungry it was the longest day because we were at the er all night. I got home and lived 23 minutes away and my sandwich was wrong I was so devastated and sad because I was just over the day. I called and talked to Maxwell and he was such a great guy, very understanding and replaced my order whenever I was ready to come back. So after the second visit. I'm hooked very great, fresh, I love it read more

I have never had a bad meal at McAlister's - at any of their locations! The best sandwiches and nothing tops their salads!! Great selections every day! Wonderful friendly service is the topper! read more

I LOVE MCALISTER'S! It's sort of like Panera but a little cheaper. I love the soups, salads, teas, EVERYTHING. There are so many different types of teas that I am determined to try all of them once summer rolls around again. This location in particular is great, because the staff is always so friendly. I'm sure all locations have great employees but this is one that I frequent often and the interactions between employee and customer are always great. read more

This is the ultimate place for lunch! The people are always friendly and the food is always hot and fresh. I'm obsessed with their tea so naturally I bought one of their refill cups and it's only $1 to refill it anytime at any location. That's half the price a drink normally is and as much as I go it was worth it. If you order anything at all it has to be the tortilla soup. I dream about it! read more

Dining in is great. Curbside took forever. Over 40 min for an order at 3:30

Try the grilled shrimp Caesar salad or pecan berry salad for $7.99 each.

I love MccAllisters! The tea is so good, both sweet and unsweetened. There is a good variety of soups and sandwiches. They have potatoes and pasta too, desserts as well. The muffuletta is my favorite sandwich. read more

See all

Definitely the biggest McAlister's I've been to recently. Although it was packed, service was very efficient and the food was great as usual. read more

This was our first trip here for dinner. It wasn't my first choice but I was pleasantly surprised. We had eight people which can cause problems but the staff was quick to accommodate us. We ordered and the food came out quickly. Everything was fresh and hot. The staff offered us refills on beverages and quickly took away finished plates. The iced tea was a big hit with most. I loved my veggie baked potato. Everyone liked the brownies. read more

McAlister's Deli - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Best sweet tea on earth!! Try it with peach. This is one of my favorite restaurants, and this location is the best of them all. The manager Brad and his staff are amazing! read more

I am a huge fan of McAlister's. I think the assortment of food is awesome, and it always tastes great. This particular location is always pretty busy during lunch on the weekdays so get there early! I am a fan of their salads and spuds, especially. And their gigantic waters are awesome. read more

I love the iced tea. The french dip is delicious, the taco salad, tuna sandwich and the spuds. It's a hard choice because I love so many things. The service is always wonderful at the Avon location and the remodel is really nice. read more

Came over to get myself a choose two. Good service; cashier was available and ready to take my order. Food was delicious.

McAlister's fun place to eat little expensive but I like the choices and they do have a really good baked potato with all the goodies on it and it's always nice in there it's a fancy read more

My family visits from KY and always want to eat at Mcalisters. Only complaint is there is too much food! Prices are very reasonable especially when you consider the amount and quality of the food. I can get a salad and baked potato combo with a tea for the same price as a Big Mac meal. Cheesecake has delicious toppings and the tea is absolutely the best. My husband always complains about tea from restaurants and he loves Mcalisters tea. The service is fast and friendly as well. I'm thankful I live so close! read more