Mianjah & Liam were super helpful and sweet! The customer in front of us kept suggesting they help us first because he wasn't sure what he wanted but Liam insisted on helping the man & offered samples. Mianjah came right over to us & made us feel welcomed. read more

When in san marco area..... If you need a dessert go to mayday. Good service. Good selection. And something always new to try. Always fresh with the ice cream. read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Double scoops. And the let you sample so you know exactly what you want - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

See all

While staying at a nearby hotel we got a hankering for some ice cream and found this place on Yelp. The parking lot was pretty filled, mostly by adjacent restaurants that share the lot, but we found a stall in the back 40. The two employees working inside were quite friendly and offered us taste tests of the assortment of ice creams they had displayed. The interior was clean and organized. We both elected to try the 6-pack, smaller scoops on a tray. Some we tried were fantastic and others were just so-so. We were provided a frequent customer card, which they stamped, and informed that there were Mayday Ice Cream franchises across Central Florida. We may use the card down the road, but I can't see us filling it up anytime soon to get that free one in the end. We'll see. Overall the ice cream was good, but not necessarily great. read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

See all

Stopped by after a fun field trip to the fair with my daughter, and we decided to end the adventure with ice cream because that's what great days deserve! We found ourselves at Mayday Ice Cream, and it did not disappoint. Such a fun, family-friendly spot with great vibes and even better flavors. The staff were kind and welcoming, even coming by to check in and see which flavor my kid liked best a small gesture that made a big impression. They also have a great outdoor seating area, set up with shade and heating lamps perfect for enjoying a day out no matter the weather. The area's perfect too you've got La Nopalera and Panera Bread right next door, so you can grab lunch, then top it off with some amazing ice cream. For the grown-ups, don't skip the Gillespie's Bourbon Pecan rich, creamy, and a little indulgent in all the right ways. My daughter went for The Wingman two scoops of Coffee & Donuts with Chocolate a winning combo! They also offer an ice cream flight (yes, a flight!) with six mini scoops perfect if you want to get chocolaty wasted in style. Can't wait to come back and work my way through the rest of the menu! read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Pricey, But Worth It for the Flavor and Vibe The ice cream was delicious super creamy and packed with flavor. Definitely hit the spot! It was a bit on the pricey side, which is the only reason I'm giving 4 instead of 5 stars. The staff were two young teens who brought a lot of energy and spunk to the experience. They were fun, upbeat, and added a great vibe to the visit. All in all, a tasty treat with a lively little team behind the counter! read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Outside - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

See all

I stopped by Mayday after a Mexican dinner n cut door. Found an amazing ice cream flavor called Lavender Melange. It was truly amazing. It cleansed my palate after the flavorful dinner. It's been a while since I've visited Mayday. Service was great & ambiance was relaxed, though busy. Sorry forgot to take photos. Ice cream looked like it was vanilla. I know I'll be back just for the Lavender sweetness. read more

See all

Interesting and delicious ice cream options in a great location in the historic San Marco. Despite that I was unsure which flavor to have and had to try a lot of them, the service was very kind and wanted me to have a great experience. I will definitely come more often, the place offers a lot a light and is very inviting. read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Aviator scoop plus blueberry scoop - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

This Mayday Ice Cream location is in San Marco and you can't miss it! I spotted this biz when we were visiting Aardolf Brewing Company and I knew I had to stop by. I always get ice cream when it's cold so it was kismet that we were right by here. Parking was easy with a lot in the back. This location has a cool architecture, it kind of looks like a lil house on its own. We were able to sample some flavors and I ended up sharing a small scoop with my partner. I got my usual- the aviator with their homemade sprinkles. A great Mayday location! read more

See all

Totally get the sampler. Worth the price and you get to try 6 scoops.... They have gluten free and nondairy options my read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Sampler - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

They have so many different flavors to try out! My favorite was the olive oil and rosemary. It was so good! The guy at the counter was really nice and let us try as many flavors as we wanted. The portion size is huge and I feel like you get your money's worth! read more

What an amazing experience I just had. This is the best ice cream in the world. My friend and I just shared a"flight" which is 6 small scoops of ice cream. We couldn't decide on one flavor so we each could pick 3 and it was so much fun read more

A creative, cutesy little ice cream shop in San Marco? Yes, please! Stopped in on a Thursday night and saw lots of people enjoying Mayday both inside and outside. Shoutout to the one girl working, she managed to not rush anyone and always served up a smile. I felt very welcomed and didn't mind the 10 minute wait to order at all for this reason. I tried the Brown Butter Chocolate Chip Cookie ($5.75 for a scoop) and oh was it good. It managed to strike the perfect chord between sweet and warm, and I was very happy with my choice. They also let you try samples too if you're stuck between a few flavors! Also, the sprinkles and galettes (like a waffle cone cookie almost) are free!!! My only recommendation is that there be a flavor card for each kind of ice cream, because there were plenty with no name and I wasn't sure what they even were. The sweet employee asked if we had been before and gave us a punch card when we said we had not. After a certain amount of purchases, you can get any scoop-able ice creams for free, including their flight of 6 mini scoops! Definitely will be back and craving it now after writing this review! read more

See all

This a wonderful little neighborhood shop. The perfect place to stop with the kids for an after school treat. The employees are always pleasant and you are able to sample as many flavors as you'd like. It's bright and clean inside and outside there's a quaint brick courtyard with plenty of seating and room for the kids to run around a bit after their ice cream. They have an excellent assortment of flavors that's sure to please even the most discriminating palate. read more

See all

Delicious ice cream with homemade sprinkles, sugar cones, waffle cones & more! Has a wide variety of ice cream, including dairy free and liquor infused (21+ only). Their services always excellent and the establishment is always clean. They have an outdoor pavilion to sit at or you can eat indoors. read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Scoop of chocolate ice cream and whipped cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

My friend and I stopped here for dessert one evening and I'm so glad we did! The shop is super cute, with lots of ice cream esc decor. It also smells sweet and sugary time you hit the door, super enticing! I tried the blueberry toast crunch and it was very creamy and delish. I always just get one scoop and it was a nice serving size. The woman behind the counter was quite nice and patient as we tried a few flavors bedroom picking our fav. Looking forward to another visit the next time I'm in town. read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Pumpkin decor contest - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Whenever I travel I have to try ice cream shoppes that we don't have at home. Mayday did not disappoint. There were so many flavors to choose from - and they let you sample them because it's that hard to decide! I was even more impressed when I discovered that an ice cream flight was an option so I didn't have to choose! I ended up with a few booze flavors and some family friendly options. I was dreamy about this the remainder of the trip. read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

See all

Best ice cream hands down. The waffle cones are made fresh like the ice cream! Make sure to grab a pint Togo!

Just recently tried out Mayday in San Marco and really enjoyed! I was pleasantly surprised at both the number of original and staple flavors, as well as seasonal ones. The staff was kind in letting us try out as many samples as we wanted (which we took advantage of), and gave us generous helpings! The ambiance too was inviting, although it's a chain, it still has that small ice cream shop vibe which was fun - so certainly recommend! read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Mint Monster - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

I dont have much a of a sweet tooth for candy or baked goods... but for ice cream, thats a different story. I do not go out for ice cream often, so when i do, i splurge. I went with the 6 mini scoop flight. I cannot recall all the flavors, but some of the highlights were the banana pudding, queen salted caramel, coffee and donuts, cookie crush, parent trap and bourbon pecan. It was just delicious. Service was excellent. Unlimited sampling ;). Will be back again in the future. read more

See all

my first time there 8/13/25. it was cute. the gentleman was extremely friendly. he is a amazing and total what you'd expect walking into an ice cream shop, major points for that! energy ++ friendly +++ engaging +++ don't go here for your regular flavor ice cream. i made that mistake. so i'll give it another shot. read more

If I could give more stars, I would. The ice cream is amazing, the staff are engaging and friendly. I came in, emotionally distressed, and they helped me the minute they were free, provided comfort and offered to help me find a job. They are amazing. I was a regular, and due to unfortunate circumstances, I don't think I will be able to finish my stamp card, but I absolutely love the people, the ice cream, and the atmosphere. It's soothing, fun, and the people are amazing. read more

Always a great time getting ice cream at Mayday. You can't beat the flavors and the service is top notch. Thank you Paige and Zach for the friendly service! read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Pilot scoop of the Lavender Melange - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Arguably THE BEST cookies and cream ice cream I have ever had. EVER. Came here on a whim after eating at V Pizza so I was already full and didn't even want dessert. But that ice cream, I tried a sample, and it blew me away. Mayday is crazy good and they are the same company as Hyppo Gourmet Ice Pops. The standout again at Mayday, aside from the ice cream, is their pastel color house-made sprinkles they offer for any ice cream you buy. The sprinkles were a delicious vanilla sugar flavor, and I instantly wants more sprinkles. Cannot recommend this place enough, skip eating a practical meal and just have some of their ice cream! @Mayday, please bring your cookies and cream ice cream to Orlando!!! read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Oh damn it's so good. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

See all

The best ice cream place around, they are constantly updating their menu and have rotating options of flavors. Definitely recommend the coffee and donuts! read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Some of the best small batch ice cream you will ever have is it May Day Ice Cream. Friendly, out going service. Zach had great recommendations that matched our tastes. I would highly recommend it to everyone. read more

After a lovely dinner with my girlfriend, we decided to go to Mayday Ice cream to satisfy our hunger for dessert. I must say that I'm so glad we went because the ice cream hit the spot in so many ways. I ordered the Blueberry Toast Crunch and it was amazing. Literally tasted like CinnamonToast Crunch cereal but in ice cream form. I got two scoops with the cookie on the side and that completed my heavenly dessert. While my girlfriend, ordered the Pink Mint Sorbet. She said hers was delightful. I would have to agree with her because she finished hers way before I finished my cone. The waffle cones really gave it that dessert set up and with the cookie it was a nice extra added to the ice cream cone. Their are many flavors I got to sample so Her and I will be back for more flavors! read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

See all

This is a nice spot, but the shopping center it's in is a little weird in terms of parking, with a lot of very aggressive signage all around telling you what not to do. It is an open, glassy shop next to some railroad tracks. They have an impressive flavor selection. I went with their version of mint chip, called mint madness, as well as a vegan chocolate almond milk flavor. The mint flavor had all sorts of mint leaves and cookies thrown in there, but my feeling was that more is not better and I would have preferred to have a less complicated flavor. The almond milk one was the slightest bit grainy in texture, but robust in flavor. Both were good, many others would also have been good. The price for two scoops was quite high, and I wasn't that blown away, but I'm not saying it isn't good. read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

My favorite place for ice cream! We always take our out of town friends to here when they come visit! We've been going since 2018 since we moved here and they all collectively agree that it's one of the best ice cream places! The shop is always so clean, bright, cute, and I love the ice cream shop like aesthetics on the walls. The customer service has always been hit or miss. Sometimes they're really great or other times, they're really average or meh. But none of the time, I've gotten really rude service. What I love about this ice cream shop is that they don't have the usual, traditional flavors like chocolate, vanilla, strawberry, etc. They elevate their flavors and make them all in house. They have flavors such as the raja honey (honey with jasmine tea), parent trap (oreos and peanut butter, an ode to the Parent Trap movie), banana pudding (made with actual real bananas and not the artificial flavoring and nilla wafers), coffee and donuts (coffee ice cream with bits of glazed donuts), blueberry toast crunch (blueberry flavored ice cream with cinnamon crunch cereal bits and swirls of the blueberry jam?), key lime pie (with pie crust in it too), cookies and creme overload (cookies and creme but made with a load of oreos), and also alcohol flavored ice cream like bourbon pecan (made with buffalo trace liquor) and watermelon melon sorbet (made with vodka). They have a wide variety of flavors that will satisfy anyone! Their flavors change often so make sure you check out the menu on their Instagram page or their website. They offer sprinkles and a homemade waffle cookie with your ice cream. You can get one scoop, two scoops, or a flight of mini scoops. GET THE SPRINKLES!!!! They make it in house and it's not your traditional sprinkles that are overly sweet and hard and crunchy. Their sprinkles are not too sweet, a nice consistency and texture and very pretty!!! They add a great crunch with your ice cream. The waffle cookie is delicious too and it reminds me of the stoop waffles but not filled. My go to is always a scoop of their ice cream with a waffle cone. They make their cones in house too! I tried the pretzel cone but wasn't a fan as it was salty and too hard for me. I got the banana pudding with a waffle cone last night and it hit the stop! You can taste the chunks of banana and the distinct taste of a traditional banana pudding. The nilla crackers weren't soggy at all and still maintained it's crunchy texture. I was literally eating banana pudding in ice cream form and it made me so happy! Come by and try some of the best ice cream ever! You won't be disappointed. read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Banana pudding ice cream with homemade sprinkles, waffle cookie, and waffle cone. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

I stopped in this evening and had a scoop of the Queen Salted Carmel - SO delicious!!

This is my favorite ice cream place for three reasons 1. The location - beautifully nestled between Panera and La Nopalera in San Marco, the outside is just so lovely at night with all the string lights. Perfect for a summer day 2. The flavors - I don't know about you but I love trying different flavors of ice cream. Love the alcoholic options too if you as me ;) 3. The service - top notch. I find that a majority of the workers are quite young yet so polite! I love their bright smiles Mayday ice cream overall has great, quality ice cream! read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Blackberry Earl Grey Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

This ice cream shop was a pleasant little surprise I happened upon while walking around the area. It is located in an artsy/historical area with a few other restaurants and has nice surroundings to enjoy your ice cream outdoors. You can also opt to dine indoors as well. The ice cream is hand made and full of flavor. Andrew assisted me with trying out quite a few. My favorite flavor was the lavender ice cream. It was full of fresh lavender flavor and aroma! I was so impressed that I asked if it could be shipped and sure enough it can be! Zack helped me with the information on how to order and ship my new favorite ice cream flavor! Mayday Ice Cream is a must try! I hope you enjoy as much as I did! read more

Did it take me almost 5 years to try out Mayday Ice cream after moving to Jacksonville? Yes, it did. Now I wish I had visited sooner. The location in San Marco is super cute inside and out. Their ice cream is creamy and delicious. Don't forget to try the boozy flavors they offer. You won't be disappointed. It was almost $6 for a scoop of ice cream ,on the pricey side, when you can get a gallon for the same price at a grocery store. But there is not a substitute when supporting a local business. They also have ice cream flights for those of us who hate having to pick one flavor! Definitely a must try in San Marco. read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Cookie crush - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

I recently moved to Jacksonville with my wife, and I am quite happy that Mayday Ice Cream is just a short drive away. It's the best ice cream shop I've been to in Jacksonville so far. Great ice cream, immaculately clean shop, and an always friendly and helpful staff. On my most recent visit, my wife and I took my mother who was visiting us from out of town. We stopped in on a Friday night in a brief moment when no one else was in the shop and had the full attention of the staff. My mom ordered a single scoop waffle cone (which is really at least two huge scoops) and had two flavors that she loved (bourbon pecan and caramel apple pie) while my wife and I went for the six flavor ice cream flight comprised of six mini scoops. If you're into variety, the ice cream flight is the way to go (it's about $9, but totally worth it when you're splitting it). The caramel apple pie, cookie crush, and straight strawberry were standouts for me, while my wife was all about Session Chocolate, which is a wonderfully rich ice cream that punches you in the face with chocolateness. Mayday Ice Cream's prices are on the higher end ($5 for a single scoop cone, $9 for the ice cream flight) but the value is totally there. Serving sizes are large, the quality of the ice cream is high, and the shop is amazingly maintained in a nice area of town. If it's a pleasant night, there's a nice courtyard to hang out in, too. Is there cheaper ice cream out there that's also good? Sure. But I've been to my share of hipster ice cream shops that charge the same or more and are nowhere near the experience of Mayday. If you're in the San Marco area and in the mood for high quality ice cream, Mayday is worth the visit. read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Ice cream cup - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Was recommended this place but overall it was pretty disappointing - we ordered a couple of pints off Uber Eats (the aviator and key lime pie) overall nothing stellar - maybe in the future we'll try a few other flavors. read more

The best ice cream in town! Paige and Zach were so lovely and made sure that we all got exactly what we wanted!

Good variety of flavors, great service and good ice cream. Ordered the flight, which comes with 6 flavors of your choice; selected cookie crush, parent trap, the aviator, coffee+donuts, straight strawberry and queen salted caramel. While they were all good, parent trap, the aviator and queen salted caramel were my favorite. read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Flavors are not listed in order. Cookie Crush, Parent Trap, The Aviator, Coffee+Donuts, Straight Strawberry and Queen Salted Caramel - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

During COVID, they're not even cleaning tables between customers. The virus is considered "heavy", so if someone with COVID breathes over the table while they are eating, guess where it falls? That's right. On the table. I love the ice cream here, but please DO BETTER to keep customers safe. I won't be back here until I know things changed. read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Tucked in the San Marco Train Station - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

See all

Some of the most unique flavors of ice cream! The banana pudding ice cream was fantastic as well as the strawberry lemon! The rest of are party had coffee and had nothing bad to say! The staff was friendly and it was nice and clean inside for it being so busy! read more

See all

Such a quaint ice cream parlor for a bright and bustling plaza in the heart of San Marco. When I'm craving a sweet treat or meeting up with friends. This is my go to spot. The zesty mural of Mandarin oranges in the shop is a refreshing sight to complement the full freezer of flavors. I love sampling different ones every time I stop by but my favorite one is the aviator, a soft and fluffy Nutella chocolate, laced with Biscoff crumbs. The staff always seem to be smiling, having a pep in every sprinkle they decorate their scoops with. read more

See all

It's a parent trap is the best flavor around, don't even waste your time trying all the flavors, trust me! If you do want to taste them all, go right ahead they are are patient and did allow me to try so many but I kept coming back to parent trap, I think that's the right name, it's a peanut butter ice cream with chocolate and man it was just a dream of an ice cream flavor, it's a good thing I am pretty far from this place or I would be a regular. Cute shop and has ample seating inside and outside. 10 stars all around. read more

Mayday Ice Cream - Entrance - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida