Jay at the front desk was very nice. He gave me multiple options with varying price levels for tires. I made an appointment online for same day very easily and then came back that afternoon to get the tires which was very convenient. read more

Mavis Discount Tire - New tire! - Auto Repair Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

Having a breakdown is one thing, but having it on Easter weekend with two kids is the mother of all issues and I am so grateful to Jay and his team for getting me in the shop immediately and communicating with me throughout the process when I had to leave the car in their care. Jay promised that he'd stay until the car of fixed since there were parts that needed to get to the shop, which slowed down the work for a bit, and he's a man of his word. I greatly appreciate his time; he and his crew saved my family trip for Easter. read more

Just had front tires installed on my wife's new BMW X7 and they stretched the front rims so bad I may have to sue they want even help me and they had no clue how to reset the oil light and now we are driving around with that on and on top of it I was told they had no one qualified to do the alignment so we are driving around unaligned as well. I hope that all there locations are as torrid as Deer Park NY read more

Most honest and friendly auto center around! Went in to have our car pre-checked for passing an inspection. They were very honest and more than willing to assist. I was told the car is passable and to come back the next day when an inspector is available. Since I waited the day before, they got me in right away and completed the inspection. read more

Mavis Bay Shore, which borders Oconee Estates, has proven to be a highly disruptive neighbor. Employees at this location frequently play excessively loud music with heavy bass that causes nearby homes and windows to vibrate. In addition, air horns are sounded throughout the day, creating further disturbance. Such noise levels are unnecessary for the normal operation of a tire shop. My neighbors and I have repeatedly contacted the business to request that the music, bass, and air horns be reduced or discontinued. Unfortunately, the manager has been consistently rude and unresponsive to these concerns. read more

Honest guys. Good work. Pete is the man. Great to have them in Bay Shore. Hard to get 85 characters. read more

The staff members are so courteous and professional. What a nice group of guys. Great service.

Watch out! Mavis Store in East Islip has a blonde manager that is trapping customers with Failing inspections . I have a 3 year old leases car and she failed my inspection for tire threads and wipers. read more

Top notch guys here - I bring my car here for all services needed. They're extremely honest, thorough, and deliver a great product. Highly recommend. Pricing is competitive and usually cheaper than most other places. Can't go wrong. read more

My tire pressure light came on on my way home from work I called at 5 pm and asked if I could have it looked at wasn't expecting a yes since it was almost closing. Scott said yes of course come on down. Got there Chris was so nice! Told me prob nothing to worry about, filled all my tires and just asked me to do a positive review! They got that from me! Was so grateful they took me last minute! read more

You get what you pay for. I was a regular at the Mavis tire on main Street in Bayshore for years. But after extreme staff changes and service that has gone down hill significantly, I had to leave and write a review. The last two times I paid for service on my truck, the "mechanic" they used was a young man who was actually learning on the job. Big mistake when dealing with a $46K Toyota 4 Runner TRD off road. Simple tasks. Oil change? Well he left the seal off and it leaked oil for a week. Tire rotation? Simple right? Well the same guy stripped the lug right off. Add to learning on the fly, he needed a translator. Avoid this Mavis on main street in Bayshore. The Mavis tire on sunrise Hwy in Bayshore is way more professional. And better staffed. read more

Horrible. Do not bring your car here. My car is currently in the shop after receiving an "oil change" from them. The oil change I received from them was them actually not changing it at all as my mechanic now is telling me that the oil level was extremely low and dirty. Con artists. read more

Very happy with service provided. Jared was very professional and courteous. Will definitely go back in the future. read more

Horribly unprofessional and rude- the guy with the beard at the front desk specifically. I will never be back and make sure my family and friends dont make the mistake of using them. Have had good experience with other mavis' in the past read more

Got a flat in middle of afternoon I was able to get tired filled on side of road to make it to this location Thought it was gonna be a $500 tire was in and out in 15 minutes with $34 plugged tire. Made my day!! I could not Believe it was that quick was preparing for all day with no car. read more

The manager Chris was such a great help and the mechanic Kevin did a great work. He knows what he's doing. Definitely going back !

Went their on a Saturday in October for tiers on my van all four. Got their early at 9 am . Ot busy at all. Took 3 hours to get them put on. Here is the kick, they play games with each other in the service shop like little girls, they put my lug nuts on backwards, to which when I am getting brakes down a month later can't get the lug nuts off , the mechanic broke some of the lug nuts off just to get the tire off. To which I have to have new roaders on , so instead of just brake shoes now I am into this fix for 1100.00. would never go back, people check you cars and trucks.nthey hire the most uneducated , street thugs who are brain dead read more

Worst place ever. Called me 2 hours in advance for me to sit around and the mechanic picked up lunch in my vehicle.

Don't waste your time to go there or go back as a second time.customer service is zero.no smile. Don't look at you as a customer. If you are the shop owner and reading this. You need to fire some of your employees for sure. I called for your tire shop and got a 12 pm appointment for alignment And end up my car was seating in the car lot until 2 pm. I seen your employee was just taking a break again and again. My turtle run faster than them. Never got the job done and told me I need a pair of tie rod end that was frozen. And I need to make an appointment to come back. I spent over 3 hrs at the shop and just give me a 5 seconds answer. I don't think I will ever come back to this shop and I don't think anyone should go there since the employees don't even welcome any customer. If I can give zero star or feedback . I would! read more

I did not have an appointment and called this store and asked if they could check my car out for a long trip. They took me right in. Recommended an oil change and tire rotation. Topped off all my fluids. Set all my tire pressures and finished even before the time they stated. Excellent communication and a joy to come to Mavis. I will be back . read more

It's like the third time i used this shop. Had an alignment done and it was: a) Affordable b) done in under an hour c) accurate... car does not pull to one side anymore Really nothing but positive things to say. read more

quick and easy for an oil change! Time was as estimated. Got me in the same day I called!

I am making a diminished value claim for the damage they did to my car. The work was so bad it had to be torn out by Volkswagen and the only thing Mavis can say is they fired the technician who did the work. I want the work refunded in full and the repair at VW and the diagnostic fees. In addition to the time waste. Looking into a class action suit read more

I am very sorry to see that Mavis no longer stores records from 2014. I purchased 4 rotors and brakes for my car in latter 2014. To find yesterday that I need rotors again because they are rusty. Really? Look at the rims. Please google rusty rims and safety/ braking ability. Need that sale so bad. Soon to lose me and my 6 cars since 1994 as a customer. Since you guys went to Sunday openings its been downhill for me. read more

If I could I would give them 0 stars. My mother got 2 new tires about a month ago. A few days ago she got a nail in her tire that could not be plugged. My boyfriend took my moms car to this store since my mother had insurance on the tires. The guy Jeff ignored my boyfriend for 15 minutes before he offered help. He was told he had to wait awhile until the car can be looked at. After an hour he came up to my boyfriend and told him the tire wasn't new and he'd have to pay full price for a new one. My boyfriend took him out to the car and showed him the tire was not old. Jeff told him he has to get a tire from another store and to come back Wednesday at 1pm. Today I called to make sure the tire was in. That's when Jeff informed me they get tires in on thursdays and he had no idea what I was talking about ordering my mom a tire. That's when my boyfriend got on the phone to remind him of their conversation. He then causally said oh I forgot what day it was it's tomorrow. I never said I'd get the tire the next day. I called customer service to make a complaint and was told the manager would call me right away. Well I'm still waiting. My mother has been a customer for over 20 years and she gets treated like this. From now on we will be going else where for our car needs. No one contacted me yesterday nor today. And so that you know I will never go to Mavis again. Especially what happened today. read more

Absolutely terrible customer service , needed a plug for a slow leak in my truck 3 hour wait ! The staff is terrible they didn't even know what truck was mine and couldn't find my number to call me . Hence the long wait BECAUSE THEY NEVER STARTED IT read more

Had an appointment was told even though I had an appointment and showed up first I would have to leave it til atleast the next day, for an oil change and inspection? Wtf! Guy wasn't even responding why he didn't atleast call me since they had my appointment for a week! So after calling Mavis corporate and got a nice girl ensuring me I would get a call within 48 hours still nothing!! Avoid this Mavis for sure and Mavis in general ! They don't care about loyal customers. Found a guy who did it on the spot in North Babylon K.K auto great guys in and out!! read more

I have a nail in my tire - a very slow leak. Call Mavis - sure we'll fix it... Come on over. I'm there in a flash but they have no idea who I am. "We're very busy and understaffed" says Dylan the manager blaming the "call center." Come back later, come back tomorrow just don't expect a quick fix... I start making preparations to leave the car when he comes up with a new one. "Your car goes too fast, we don't repair those tires. It's company policy." I give up. I know when I am fighting with a functionary and not a person with a mind of his own. The next day I take the car to a professional shop where for a few dollars it is repaired and is deemed to be good as new. Thanks again Mavis for your help. (Imagine if this was a real emergency.} read more

I am a healthcare worker at the hospital down the road. I was leaving work and my tire pressure light came on. There was a nail in my tire and I needed it plugged up so I could make it home since I live 30 min away. I also had to pick up my baby at daycare and didn't feel safe driving on the parkway with a flat. This place was the first tire place I saw. I waited 10 min before the man at the front desk even acknowledged me. I told him I work at the hospital and I just left work and need my tire plugged so I can make it home and pick up my baby. He said "all his guys are very busy and didn't have their lunch breaks yet, he closes in two hours and can't do it today" . I again said please I need to pick up my baby and get home and would appreciate it if he could help me out quick. He again said no and told me to go to another tire place that's probably only 5 min away. I went to another place and the man working there was happy to help me, it took him 5 min to take out the nail and plug up my tire. Go to HC Auto and tires on 5th Ave, don't waste your time here. read more

I'm not one for yelp reviews but Eric at Mavis in East Islip is such a genuine guy. Came here about two weeks about and thought for sure I needed new brakes. He checked them out, and told me I didn't need them. From my own personally experience every opportunity mechanics have to make some money they take it. He was so genuine and honest. Today I came back for two new tires, and Eric offered me the best tires in my price range, discounted them and everything took under an hour! Shoutout to Mavis in EI for honest and hardworking workers, they will certainly have my business from now on. read more

I have had pretty solid experiences at other Mavis locations, but I live closest to this one, and it is absolutely horrible. They are liars and thieves! My drivers side door was damaged and the wheel rim rubs against it and it makes a popping sound upon opening. It was fine when I got there and it never sat in the parking lot, heck I saw it almost. I waited there while they were changing oil and heard the lift coming down. They lied to me straight to my face and this was a small job that would've taken no more than 15 mins. I've spent thousands at Mavis in the past. They try to upset everything and give you parts you don't need. Really rude, shady people. Go elsewhere. read more

8 am appt...on time...porky little dude at counter...10 mins of typing to check me in...guy in front already had a fit...show up at 6pm, porky dude says its being dome now...ask what time...he says now...we leave...40 mins later car done...its now 7pm DONT WASTE YOUR TIME read more

Had a pretty nail wedged into my tire so I went to get it patched up. They said they would have it done before close and they'd call. Went back there before they close and was told they haven't even gotten to it yet. I dropped my vehicle off 5 hours ago... for a 15 minute job! Ridiculous. read more

I really want to give zero stars but it's not an option. I brought my car in for a slow leak in the rear drivers side tire. When I received my car back every time I turn the wheel to the left it squeaks. Brought the car back to Mavis only to be told the car is fine there's nothing wrong. The car did not squeak when we originally brought it in, so clearly there's something wrong now. Not sure why all 4 tires were removed to begin with. We only wanted the slow leak to be fixed. The car is a 2017 with 15,000 miles on it. I'm so disappointed in my experience at the Mavis Tire on Montauk hwy in Bay Shore, NY. I will NEVER recommend them or go there again. Very incompetent. read more

The honor the lower price I had from tire rack and were able to accommodate me although they had a lot of cars. Greg is best.

I originally purchased four new tires from Mavis late 2018. I also purchased an extended warranty with the tires. The other day, my tire pressure light went off. Yesterday, I stopped at this location (where I originally purchased the tires), to see if they could take a quick look. I was turned away from the front desk clerk for them being too busy and was told to come back the following day, today. I was fine with that. I then also made an appointment online for the following day at this location to secure my spot. Today I walked in and the same desk clerk said he couldn't help me at all. He told me rudely to go to another location..even though he himself told me to come back today. I also told him I made an appointment for this specific location. It didn't matter to him. Horrible customer service. Do not recommend this location. read more

2 hours and $35 to remove a screw and patch a simple flat. This was after I came in 3 hours earlier to ask when would be a better/faster time to come in. Never again. read more

Go to HC Auto tire on 5th Ave (going northbound after the train tracks) or another Mavis if you need something more than free air. I really wanted to be patient with them since I came to the staff needing help replacing my tire (one of my tires was just on the verge of popping, according to one of the mechanics). I waited about 1.5 hours just to have to wait more to get help. Ultimately I had to go to HC auto to get the help I need. I want to support Mavis since they weren't blatantly rude. But if your job is solely to help customers and their tires, you should probably prioritize and not forget the customer over your lunch break. 1.5 out of 5 stars read more

TL;DR - Took advantage of someone who doesn't know cars, charge $350 for a $150 part(at most after searched the market) and then claim he already gave discount because "part department" said it would been $630. Also can't come up with paper work for the part invoice or reason for why the part needed to be swapped (lower control arm) after a standard inspection. Threw paper work at my mother and told her to get out of the store. I would absolutely not recommend this shop unless you like to be ripped off on standard maintenance and then have them throw you out the door. My mother had her car serviced there for a while, recently she showed me a receipt on one of her standard inspections. She got an inspection, changed out a signal bulb, replaced both front lower control arms, and an alignment done. I could not think of a reason why this would be needed under a standard maintenance and inspection, and my mother told me they didn't give her a reason why, she just paid for it(she doesn't know cars at all). They charged a total of $450 for the LCA job with $350 for parts alone. I understand shops make some money on parts, but after doing searching, i found out at most the parts are about $150 total, not to mention the cheapest pair of LCA are only $45 new, its obscured. I was outraged and decided to have my mother go back to the shop to get an explanation for this work done, and have me talk to the store manager greg over the phone (I live out of town). So Greg picked up and i explained my concerns to him, his attitude was good at first, then it turned for the worse after i inquired about the LCA. He started throwing numbers at me saying how he always took care of my mother's car and always gave her discounts. I asked him why the LCA need to be replaced and if there are records, he told me paperwork are submitted to corporate and he doesn't have it. I ask if there is an invoice for these parts, he told me there is no way for him to get it because everything goes to corporate(which i think is BS, because shipping will have paper work with an invoice attached). He told me he can call the parts department and have them find out how much they are, and later came back with $315 each and keep saying how he already gave my mother a discount. With the part number he gave me, i checked out a standard price(GM no longer make these since saturn is gone), the most expensive was $150 for BOTH sides. I get shops charge a little more on parts, but at over 100% increase? its highway robbery. Especially taking advantage of someone who clearly doesn't know what is going on. After getting nowhere with the guy, i got off the phone. He then threw the receipt paper work back at my mother and told her not to bring her car here any more and get out of the store. Its guys like these that give legitimate mechanics and shops a bad name and i'd absolutely advise people to take their business elsewhere. read more

I've had multiple services done here and i've always been satisfied. Good prices, quick service, and friendly employees.