Matt's has surprisingly good pizza. It also is friendly and has a laid back vibe. You can chat it up without anyone rushing you. Definitely a five star " hole in the wall"". Ron read more

Nice traditional pizza with good flavour in the sauce. Thin crust or regular seem en point and thankfully they let you put your own little extras so if you like it plain they don't ruin it with parm or chili flakes. Yay. Inside could use better lighting but it's ok. Outside is my go to sitting but that might depend on the weather. Great for takeout. read more

Mindy sat me immediately and took care of me. The lunch special by the slice is for any pizza including the specialty pizzas for $1.00 more. I convinced myself that I needed a small pizza and a small salad which is not small at all! () so I'd have leftovers! I thoroughly enjoyed the Greek Pizza and look forward to trying the others options. Good pizza. Definitely recommend. Bring your cash if you hate the 3% surcharge for credit cards. Do not penalize your server for it! I tipped extra because of it. read more

See all

Great pizza, very good service, small town experience, here are the 85 characters to finish this post

Matt's small town pizza is incredible because they have great service and the pizza is fresh with great flavor and toppings. Best pizza in our area! read more

Great pizza and great service! Enjoy the small town vibes and genuine hospitality. Will definitely come back!

Matts is a great little spot. Staff is always friendly and the pizza and chef salad it's great!

Great lunch pizza special. Love the thin crust pizza. Good location. Wish they were open Sunday, but I understand.

Never had a bad experience in the years I've been ordering for here! Food is always fresh and quick. Wings/pizza are our go tos and very good. The service makes you feel right at home. read more

Thin pizza but it was still undercooked. Have good flavor but it needs to be more krispy if it going to be a thin pie . My opinion

6/11/2022 First visit Loved the location. Wish golf cart paths connected from PTC. Old, quirky bldgs are my fav. Service was quick and friendly. Drinks were icy (important in GA summer). 3 small pizzas=1 All Meat, 1 The California, and 1 Potato. All were yummy, but the 3 of us voted The California as best, it was a rare find of balanced flavors. Well done. Also had some onion rings which were very tasty and separated properly when bitten (no messy crumbling or stringy onion). Sorry no pics, was too hungry, next time. read more

Matt's Smalltown Pizza - The California - Pizza Near Me - Senoia, Georgia

We came out here as part of the big zombie tour put together by The Atlanta Movie Tours https://atlantamovietours.com/ It's really well done and worth every penny esp if you are a Walking Dead fan. When we came this place and one other place were the only ones open so we came on in here. The pizza were really good but I thought our waitress had bit of an attitude problem-probably since a group of tour people just walked it...but to be honest no one knew this town existed before the Walking Dead so I don't know why some people would be against it...anyway, better than average pizza with okay service. read more

Matt's Smalltown Pizza - a pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Senoia, Georgia

Love their pizza! They are very generous with the toppings and you actually get extra cheese when you order it. Never disappointed!

Stopped in on a whim while looking around Senoia. So glad we did! Lunch special was around $5 for a specialty slice and a huge drink. We got taco pizza and Buffalo chicken pizza. Thin and crunchy crust. Such huge slices, one is plenty! The waitress was very attentive and nice. Gave her a large tip and she gave us drinks to go. I can't wait to visit the quaint city of Senoia again and get another slice. read more

Matt's Smalltown Pizza - Pizza slice - Pizza Near Me - Senoia, Georgia

Absolutely loved this restaurant! The ambience is warm and cozy, the service was so welcoming, friendly, and quick and the food was even better! We had a medium pizza with some beer and it was delicious! We will definitely be back the next time we're in town! read more

A group of us decided on getting pizza for dinner since some relatives of ours highly recommended this place. We ordered two large pizzas to go. We drove about 20 minutes from Fayetteville and see where this place was at, which was located on the Main Street of Senoia along with other cute small eateries and shops to check out. When we got back about a half hour after picking it up, the pizza was still fresh. There was half pepperoni and half cheese on one pie and I think there was sausage and onions on another. I didn't get to take pictures since it was all snatched up pretty quickly when it was placed on the table. Overall, the pizza was alright. I found it to be just like any other pizza I've had before. The slices were bigger than a normal size and it did the duty after having two of them. If I make it to the area again, I would definitely dine in and try some other things they have to offer. read more

Really good pizza with quick service! It always tastes very, very fresh!! I recommend for a good piece of pizza!

Everything cooked when ordered (pizza) so be patient. Good choices. Good salads. We've eaten here several times over the years. Clean and family friendly read more

Had a terrible experience here last night "Friday". We went in to dine in and the host told us it would be 30min wait. She said if we ordered take out it would be faster. So we decided to order out. She said she would text us when our order was ready. We walked around, about an hour went by. We decided to go back to restaurant. Our pizza wasn't ready. However she said our mozzarella sticks were ready.... They had been sitting behind the counter. After 10mins my husband asked for the mozzarella sticks. They were cold and not cooked well at all! Another 15mins goes by and they bring us our 2 pizzas. She said "oh sorry we forgot your salad" Same host. So we waited for the salad another 15mins. We left with everything an hour and a half later! The pizzas were gross and cold. SO frustrating!!! We live in senoia and we come here often. My son also goes here often. Such a frustrating experience and waste of money last night! read more

BEST pizza in the area!! We tried this pizza a few years back, and we were so impressed thst we came back 3 times in a week! The crust is perfectly crisp on the edges with that soft chew in the middle! The ingredients are FRESH!! And the customer service is always good! Year in, year out, they have been CONSTANTLY GREAT!! As long as they are in business, we will be eating/getting our pizza from here! Also, they make a great GF pizza crust! For those who need GF. :) read more

The Supreme Pizza is our favorite! Always great with lots of toppings and the crust is awesome! And you cannot beat their greek salad! And they deliver!!! read more

The pizzas and cheese sticks are our favorites. Only thing that could have made it even better last night was getting the pizza to our table right out of the oven. Our cheese sticks came out that way, hot to touch, my favorite way. May request the next pizza that way too. Service is always good and love having them in our town. No need to search for great pizzas. read more

The service is so slow. We waited 45 + minutes for our food. This is our first time at this location

Great crust. We always double the toppings because they are fairly light, otherwise great.

Every single time I order from this place, my order is significantly wrong. If you call and tell them they will basically tell you "oh well". Been eating here for 10+ years but done spending my money when they genuinely do not care about steady business. Wish I could give 0 stars. read more

We really love the pizza here. We have always ordered pickup and they're pretty good about having it ready on time. This is a great value for the money. read more

The food at Matt's is great and the staff are so attentive. I love eating there. Never been disappointed by my meal there.

Matt's pizza is our favorite local pizza place! You literally can't go wrong! They have one of the coolest selections of delicious specialty pizzas and also have the best calzones I've ever had! Their pizza-style cheese sticks are a must as well! read more

Matt's Smalltown Pizza - We love Matt's pizza! They have an awesome menu including specialty pizzas and their calzones are absolutely amazing! - Pizza Near Me - Senoia, Georgia

Love this place. Never been inside but their delivery is always on point. Love supporting local eateries!

Food: 7/10 Service: 6/10 Atmosphere: 8/10 Matt's is a great spot for slice pie. It's not like FiDi or midtown NYC, but it's the best place on the south side of Atlanta, to my knowledge. The location is in a really cool old building with beautiful old brick work, albeit a small venue. There are a few innovative pizzas, like the Cuban, which are must try! While the service can be spotty, it's the perfect place to stop if you're visiting Senoia and need a quick relief from all the zombies! read more

See all

My family and I come here a good bit and have minimal complaints. The food is always pretty good! The buffalo pizza and supreme pizza are two of my favorites. Sometimes the pizza can be a little greasy, but nothing a napkin dab can't fix. Another favorite of mine is the calzone- so good and enough to have leftovers the next day! Others that I love- Cobb salad and the fried pickles. The Cobb salad can be split or leftovers if you get the large portion! Overall, pretty good place, the customer service could improve. I recommend to others. read more

Matt's Smalltown Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Senoia, Georgia

This cute little pizza place is located near the Main Street of Senoia. I came here to grab a bite before my Walking Dead tour began. I was seated pretty quickly but it did take the server a bit of time to head over. I ended up ordering the lunch special; a slice of pizza and a drink for like $5. It was a nice sized slice! Be sure to leave time for your food, especially if you have time constraints; 30 min was barely enough time for me to get my slice and run to my tour around the corner. read more

We love all of their pizzas, but especially the apocalyptic pie!!!! It is awesome for parties and a crowd. The thing is huge and you just can't go wrong with a giant pizza. We have tried so many pizza flavors, but the Taco Pizza, and Potato Pizza are stand outs for our fam. We've tried lots of other things and have not been disappointed, they do a great job and the food is memorable. Give them a visit if you're nearby! read more

First time we ate here I was not a fan (extreme upset stomach), but I decided to give them a second try about a year later, it surprised me as it was better than I remembered but still extremely mediocre. There's not very many choices in a small town like Senoia for delivery so I guess you get what you get. read more

I have tried Matt's for both lunch and dinner. Both times, the pizza was quite good and the restaurant wasn't packed. My visits were on a weeknight (maybe a Thursday?) and on a Saturday around 11:30 a.m. Parking was easier during the week; I just parked on the main street and walked around the corner. On Saturday, I had to use a dirt/gravel lot diagonally across from Matt's. Also, map software shows Matt's on Main Street, while it is actually around the corner on a side street. It is only about one storefront off Main, though. Just beware if you are just following Google Maps. Service was attentive. They appear to have some sort of salad bar, though I did not make use of it. There was a steady stream of parties (families, tourists in town for film tours, etc.). The pizza tasted fresh; I'm sure we'll be back. Recommended. read more

Do not visit Senoia on a Monday. Walking dead, indeed; nothing is open. Nothing except Matt's Small Town Pizza and a couple of other shops. The Yelp location is incorrect, by the way. No telling when they'll fix it. Matt's is on the north side of Seavy Street, about halfway between Main and Barnes. Country music. Lester loves his dawg. Bubba shot his momma. Mabel-Sue swore to her baby daughter never to drink again, and later that day drove into a bridge trying to avoid crashing into a drunk driver. Two small dining rooms. Not really any good seats for one or two people to sit. Pull the door shut behind you - no one in Senoia has installed hydraulic door closers. Were you raised in a barn? Oh... sorry. I didn't know. Look, I said I'm sorry. How was I to know your deddy died in a barn fire after the cat knocked over a lantern? Why not write a song about it? Oh... Really? Carrie Underwood, you say? It was #1? I don't know about Georgia, but back home Pizza Inn was fairly common until, despite being voted the #1 pizza chain in the US in the early '90s, they began to close most locations as they shifted heavily toward fat-American-style dining. In the mid-80s, Pizza Inn introduced me to taco pizza. I've yet to have one that I like as much. Super-thin crust, ground beef, shredded cheddar and lettuce, tomato. Even salsa way back in the day. The place wasn't very good, but I always returned for taco pizza. Matt's has taco pizza. It's not bad. The crust is too thick, and it falls apart, requiring a knife and fork (which I absolutely hate to use with pizza). They use red onions, which should be chosen only for appropriate recipes. This is not one of them. The grape tomatoes could use some ripening. They bake the pizza with cheese on it, whereas they should instead only sprinkle cheese after it's baked. The jalapeños aren't spicy at all. Otherwise, a good attempt. A slice is about $5 with tax. Given the size and ingredients, it's worth about $2.75. I didn't know this before ordering, but I'm letting you know in case you'd like to negotiate a fair price out of Ruby-Lee or Reba-Mae. I'd be cautious ordering most non-pizza items. All of the appetizers are frozen, mass-produced stuff (or so I was told). They have wings, sandwiches, calzone and pasta dishes, as well. The wings aren't a bad price, but I haven't seen or tried them. They offer a tiny salad bar, but it looked pretty pathetic when I came in late for lunch. Everything was empty or nearly so. Be prepared to listen to a few tourists talking about zombies and a certain AMC soap opera that should've been called "The Undead and The Restless" throughout your meal. And shut the fucking door. Overall, 5/10. read more

Matt's Smalltown Pizza - Taco Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Senoia, Georgia

The pizza was delicious! The onion rings, too! We ordered the Apocalyptic Pizza and it fed 4 adults, 4 kids, and we still took home leftovers!! The crust was perfectly thin and chewy. Service was excellent! We will definitely be back! read more

Have visited twice. The interior is charming, and it's a great location. The young woman who greeted us was very friendly and welcoming. On both visits, however, the servers never smiled - or if they did, it was forced. This area is full of genuinely warm people, not sure why the place has servers that are bordering on surly. Everything on the top of the pizza is right. It looks good, the cheese is good, the outer crust is browned. I think the oven's just not hot enough. The bottom crust is soggy, even with just a topping of cheese. It could also just be not kneading the dough well enough to windowpane point for gluten development, but something's just off. I'd make a point of coming here regularly with friendlier service and a crisper bottom crust. read more

Matt's Smalltown Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Senoia, Georgia

2 hour wait for pick up. Unacceptable. Very rude on phone. This is the second time we were unable to get pizza there.

Excellent Caesar salad and small pizza. The small salad is big enough for 2 people. Fresh romaine and plenty of cheese and crotons. Did not disappoint. The pizza crust is very tasty and the topping options are endless. Prices are extremely reasonable. Best part, they sell by the slice, or small, medium, large or extra large. Fantastic! I appreciate that they have outdoor seating for us with our small dog. read more