I love pizza. I am a pizza fanatic. I love this place's pizza. I've always had good customer service. Got my food on time. Never been a problem. I recommend this is a good pizza place for anybody visiting or those who live here. read more

Enjoyed our pizza slice and salad lunch today iatFabiano's in the old theatre of Newnan. Friendly and quick service, ambiance was fine. Salads - particularly the rocket or the spinach salads were excellent. Pizza slices are large and were delicious. All in all it seemed a touch overpriced yet the pi.- was very tasty! read more

If this is associated with The Alamo in Newnan....it is a complete dump. I ordered pizza and it looked like something that had been frozen since 1967 -- dry, tasteless, and barely edible. The place is filthy and feels like it's violating every health code in the book. Honestly, I wouldn't even tell a homeless person to eat here. This spot belongs on Bar Rescue. Avoid it. read more

Fabiano's Pizzeria - Pizza (barely) - Pizza Near Me - Newnan, Georgia

Being from NY it's pretty hard finding a great pizza place! Large pie was okay! It was cut in the shape of our pizzas at home which we liked! Pretty good for newnan pizza for sure!! Service was also sweet & simple! Dark/lounge type of ambiance! read more

Stopped in because we hadn't been in several years (12+). Started with garlic knots with cheese and a grande size pizza for a family of six (two being teenage boys). The garlic knots were fantastic and we couldn't stop eating them but didn't finish them as there were so many. The pizza was delicious, dough and toppings had great flavor and it was cooked perfectly. The craziest thing was we all had some pizza left on our plate and we only ate half the pizza. Will be back soon!!! read more

Fabiano's Pizzeria - This photo is actually a medium from when we went back a few days later. - Pizza Near Me - Newnan, Georgia

Love this place! Artsy, eclectic restaurant with friendly and personable staff. Pizza is so good! I'm originally from NJ, It's been a struggle to find a pizza place that serves a traditional crust and style I grew up on. Fabianos hits the mark! The size, the flavor, the sauce and most importantly foldable tender crust with mozzarella stretching across the table has me going back time and time again. Mouth watering yet?? The salads are literally piled high with fresh lettuce and veggies and delicious dressing choices- absolutely shareable! Fabianos is my favorite! read more

Delicious pizza, great service, and very cool atmosphere. It's been converted from an old theater. Price was decent. Only downside was that the pizza was very thin in the middle and could have used a few more minutes in the oven to make it a bit stiffer (easier to eat), I don't like having to use a fork. read more

Fabiano's Pizzeria - a half eaten pizza - Pizza Near Me - Newnan, Georgia

I ordered Fabiano's Pizza delivered to my hotel room thru Uber Eats on my trip to the Atlanta area in early March. I had just landed from my flight and traveling to the hotel, I was tired and hungry and had an early day the next day as I had to go to court. I decided to just order into the hotel, and some nice pizza sounded like the perfect meal. Especially since, I had seen the high ratings for this restaurant on yelp. I got two slices of pizza with pepperoni, bacon, and prosciutto as well as some wings delivered along with a drink. I have to say I didn't really enjoy the meal. The pizza was ok but I think the garlic taste was too overpowering... the wings were standard wings you could eat anywhere... and for $22.00... no don't feel like I got my money's worth. read more

Fabiano's Pizzeria - 8 Wings - Pizza Near Me - Newnan, Georgia

See all

We are from Dothan, AL and were On our way home from Atlanta where we had went for the weekend. We went back through Newnan to find somewhere for lunch. Needless to say, we found a whole lot more! We absolutely loved the food, the atmosphere and service! The garlic knots we're my favorite! We also loved the Quant little town of Newnan! My husband loved it so much, he said he wanted to retire here! He's gotta long way to go to retire though! If you are ever in Dothan AL, stop in and see us at Ray's Restaurant. We are a family owned business as well! read more

We tried out Fabiano's on a Sunday for lunch. This was partly to try someplace new, and partly because it was one of the few places open before noon in the area. We were able to park on a side street just around the corner from the restaurant. It might be more challenging at dinner time or on a weekday. The overall vibe here is 'Italian family' place with a bit of hipster aspirations (not in a bad way). They are also connected to a performance venue, which you can see off to the side of the dining area. We were seated promptly and our server was fairly attentive. We opted to each get a slice of pizza. We were, uncharacteristically, in the mood for tater tots also. They offered these in either a cup or a bowl. A cup sounded too meager for 2 people to split, so we went for the bowl. Don't think 'cereal', think 'salad'. There was no way we could finish this! The tots were good, though. The pizza slice seemed a bit plain, though it was large. I've notice that sometime at place that offer slices: they aren't representative of what a whole pie is like. The slice wasn't a bad lunch, but I'd be interested to get a whole pie and eat slices of it for comparison. I think we'll likely be back. read more

Some of the best pizza we have had outside of NYC or Chicago. We stopped in Newnan, GA ( south of Atlanta ) and needed to find some dinner. I read several reviews of pizza places, and we decided to give this place a try. We both were very happy that we chose Fabiano's in downtown Newnan. We did order the garlic knots, as an appetizer... hubby wanted cheese added, and this comes with pizza sauce. The knots were hot, fresh and tender ... a delicious flavor and just a slight crunch. Then, we ordered the meaty style 16 inch pizza . Their crust is so fresh and is hand made. The toppings tasted imported, the Italian sausage, pepperoni and other toppings blended very well with the fresh mozzarella cheese . We couldn't have asked for a more flavorful pizza. I ordered a salad, but only ate a portion of the Greek salad. Mama Mia ... this meal was one of our best finds.. this place was slightly retro, with booths and tables. We really love this place, and will return when we stay in Or pass through Newnan again! read more

See all

Great atmosphere to grab a slice of pizza and a salad but Fabiano's hardly puts any cheese on the pizza!!!! Do this one simple thing and I think you'll have more customers! read more

We were at Fabiano's for lunch and ordered a large supreme pizza. The crust was perfect, thin and crispy with soft edges. Toppings were good, but not many veggies, heavier on the meat. And I couldnt really find much sauce at all. I realize everyone's idea of good pizza is different, but this left something to be desired for our personal preference. read more

The only reason it's not 5 was slow service (salads arrived BEFORE flatware). This little gem is in the heart of the Newnan Square. The atmosphere reminds me of the Original Mellow Mushroom in Sandy Springs. Cool, eclectic vibe and food was great. Our waitress was great (but they were VERY BUSY). Greek Salad and Caesar was good. Cold beer, frosty glass. Hard to mess that up. Ordered the Supreme "Giant" and it was delicious! Definitely will return! I read more

Fabiano's Pizzeria - Supreme (giant) fed 3 adults. - Pizza Near Me - Newnan, Georgia

I ordered pepperoni pizza but it had cheese on it. I loved it anyways

My wife wanted to try somewhere new, so we decided to go to Fabiano's. When you walk in, it is a cozy hole in the wall restaurant. It's a casual kind of place where you can come as you are. The garlic knots were warm, fluffy balls of cooked dough. The texture is similar to a warm brownie that just came out of the oven. They come in a shallow bowl of garlic butter that is perfect to dip your pizza crust in. We noticed the menu stated that their meatballs were made in house, so we decided to give them a try. The meatballs taste like they are made with seasoned beef instead of your traditional beef/pork mixture. The flavor reminded me of a southern meatloaf. The amount of seasoning they used overpowered the meatball. Fabiano's has many toppings to choose from when ordering your pizza. You can order a 12,16, or 20 inch pizza. You also have the choice of ordering by the slice on most varieties they offer. When you order by the slice, the cheese pizza slices are prepped in the morning and toppings are added as you ordered them. The pizza had that wonderful soft crust. The simple cheese and sauce are not overpowering leaving the crust and the toppings to speak for themselves. read more

See all

I must say this is the first time I've been to this place. I love the building such a cool old theater. For the food, I wouldn't go out of your way, and the service I can't help but feel they were young adults playing restaurant. The menu at this location was a very limited. It was pizza or nothing. and it was nothing to write home about. As hard as I tried. I could not get into this place. The bartender kept saying saying we should go to the Douglasville location. They have a better menu. I should've took her advice and left. read more

Stopped here twice over the last three weeks they are ALWAYS out of the deer selection. Do they have a manager?? October Fest they have advertisements for German beer ....waitress says they are out ???? read more

First time eating here & it was great. I ordered the supreme pizza slice & my hubby ordered a Stromboli + a supreme pizza slice. It wasn't crowded & it was during lunch time. The waitress was nice & friendly. The only bad thing was the teeter tottering of the table. 2 supreme slices, stromboli, diet coke, sweet tea & 1 cider was all for $27.88. read more

Went to Karvelas but they had a wait so we walked up to Fabianos. We used to eat here all the time but felt the quality for price had gone down bc they were the only local pizza joint. It seems they have stepped up their quality game bc our dinner was fantastic. You have to enter on the Alamo side bc Covid. The hostess asked if we had a seating preference. I asked for somewhere quiet and a both. We got the front window on the Fabiano side, the best seat in the house. Our waitress, Brittney J, came over and took our drink orders. We went ahead and ordered the whole garlic knots with cheese... it's always been a favorite. We got our drinks and ordered a large pepperoni and sausage pizza and 10 chicken wings. I like how you can remove a topping from their specialty pizzas bc they are made fresh right when ordered but we just wanted those 2 toppings. Everything was delicious and we felt like we got what we paid for. The pizza was so tasty and the crust was perfect, it's been hit or miss in the past with way too much crust compared to where toppings start. The chicken wings were very good too. The garlic knots were scrumptious! The great service and food will make this our first choice next time! read more

Fabiano's Pizzeria - Sausage and pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Newnan, Georgia

See all

There pizza is very cheesy and there garlic nots are also cheesy. The service is really good. They are also very nice.

Omg! Best place ever. Whitney is a rockstar and Anya's lavender martinis are AMAZING!!!! I need you to come here. Please ask for Whitney she is incredible. I will definitely come back here. PS. Food is great also. read more

The food and service was 5 stars but the guy singing and playing guitar was so loud we wanted to leave. The place was empty and his voice was echoing and bounching off those walls. It was painful. We couldn't hear our family members talk. Won't go back on Sundays. read more

Cold chili , they were out of crackers, service is bad . We have tried several times thinking it was an off time.

This place is ridiculous! It isn't even themed Italian! It's so cold in that place. Hardly anyone there and they placed us in the bar area! They are slow and attentive. Don't have small pizzas only medium and large, the chili was not good at all! Didn't have saltines only club crackers and the calzone wasn't good. The place was trying to be more of a bar than a restaurant. Wish my wife and I had turned around when we went in. read more

We like to frequent this establishment on Tuesday nights for trivia with our favorite trivia host DJ Erok. The servers are super attentive (you will often find more than one helping you) and we often find sitting on the Alamo side to be more our style without the ruckus of children from the pizza side. My personal favorite pizza here is the Loaded Baked Potato pizza. It has a white sour cream based sauce, potatoes, bacon and loads of delicious cheese. If for some reason I'm not getting a whole pizza, I opt for a calzone or their yummy Greek salad. My husband can't get enough of their loaded tots and their Mighty Meaty pizza as the sausage they use has a nice kick of flavor. read more

We have ordered take out from here previously but our recent experience was not good. Not only did they get the topping selection wrong, it was probably the saltiest pizza we ever had. read more

This place is classic Newnan vibes. Their pizza is pretty good, if you dine in. It's pretty thin, so it can get soggy fast. Their menu selection is decent. If you're looking for an app, try to Garlic Knots or Pepperoni Knots!! read more

Great pizza 9 times out of 10. This is a solid choice for great pizza and fast, courteous service! Branching out and trying a spinach salad with buffalo chicken tenders today. It's really, really good! read more

Fabiano's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Newnan, Georgia

Best pizza spot in Newnan. Some really good original pies also, we had the Mexican pizza which I was made with chorizo sausage and chili peppers. They're pizza is thin and crispy just like I like it, the wait staff is friendly and on top of her game. Fabiano's also has great specials we were there on Wednesday where they have $2 PBR's and $6 pitchers of domestic. read more

See all

Terrible pizza - too expensive for what you get as a pizza. They took too long to bake a pizza that should be out in 10 mins and 45 mins later we were disappointed with a 23.00 pizza that didn't have the toppings that we were paying for 1 slice of chorizo on the special of night whole pizza. When I first moved here there was no pizza shop could not understand when where I am from there is a pizza shop on every block. I make my own dough and pizza it does not cost 23.00 but the taste, toppings, and crust are way better than this 23.00 pizza. I should open a shop? read more

Really good pizza! I like the thin crust and there's no yeast odor or taste to the pie dough. Ordered a slice with lots of toppings and a cup of the "Jerk Chili". I figured if Guy Fieri featured it on his food series Diners, Drive Ins, and Dives I'd probably like it, too. It was great! Going straight for the bowl of Jerk Chili next time, the cup portion is just a tease unless you're ordering a bunch more food. I've been coming here for lunch with friends on and off for years and I've never been disappointed by the food or service. read more

Best pizza in Newnan! We've been to Fabinano's many times and definitely the best pizza in Newnan. Wait staff always friendly and service prompt. Place can get crowded especially on Friday and Saturday put there is additional seating next door at the Alamo. read more

Excellent! Food came out hot & fresh. Always great drinks. My fav pizza place in town. Love this place and the hometown feel.

Fabiano's is a small joint on Newnan Square attached to The Alamo Bar. You wouldn't tell from the exterior or interior, but this place puts out the best pizza I've ever had. Everything is made to order and fresh. Service is good and never had a bad experience. They are local folk's with local pizazz. Very festive during holidays like New Years and Halloween. Appetizers are average - wings are good. If it's pizza you are looking for - this is the spot for you. As JJ would say "DY-NO-MITTTTTE" read more

Okay pizza. Usually underdone. On busy nights, expect the pizza to take up to 40 minutes to cook. They use the Wolfe Easy Bake Oven model with two 60 watt bulbs to really crank out the pies. By contrast, Antico in Atlanta is twice as good, and takes about three minutes to cook. read more

I asked around for the best slice of pizza in Newnan and was told to check out Fabiano's. The prices were off the chart for a simple slice of pizza and the wait was quite ridiculous. I proceeded forward and got a slice with a few things on it and a drink. Overall, it was one of the lamest slices of pizza of my life. The cheese was mediocre, the toppings were all canned and tasted as if they'd been added after the pizza was cooked, and the sauce--what sauce? The sauce was essentially non-existent. On a side note--the service was quick and our waiter was friendly. I just don't understand how it could be so crowded and highly recommended for such a lack in flavor and creativity. read more

Oh my goodness! Amazing pizza. Greek salad was woooooohoooo!!! Great environment. Awesome beer selection and the gin-based Hemingway cocktail is knock-your-socks-off delicious! We were here with a party of 10. They could not accommodate us in the main restaurant so they moved us to the Alamo next door. Lots of families and various different groups. Very kind, helpful and attentive. The server, Mari and manager were so friendly and provided us with a great experience! ***if you do nothing else, order the Olive Oil and Garlic Pizza. We added mushrooms and,... well,... I can't even talk about it. read more

We were filming a movie two stores down for this trendy little pizza place on the Newnan square. Instead of eating catering we decided we would finish out our work week with some Italian. About 12 of us went over at 6pm on a Sunday. The place was packed. Partial good news is that we went over at 530pm and gave them our order so that our food would be ready at 6 when we broke for lunch. At 630 were just getting our food. We order an assortment of menu items I can only really speak for the items I tried but crew had no complaints except for the wait. I ordered a pepperoni Stromboli which was of average size. There was a decent amount of cheese and pepperoni in it. The sauce on the side was pretty good. I did try the pepperoni rolls and cheese wedges that someone else ordered. Both were really good. They do serve alcohol and the bathrooms are clean. I can imagine that weekday lunch traffic would really limit the parking. read more

Fabiano's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Newnan, Georgia

Used to come here all the time, but then they started having issues with the wait times for carry out. I didn't know that 30 minutes in Fabiano time meant 60+ minutes in normal time. Was here nearby so we decided to give it another try. I Ordered at 5:32, was told 30 minutes. It's 6:25 and I'm still waiting. WTF? Do I walk through some discontinuity in the space-time continuum so that's time slows down? Food is ok, but not getting the timing right ruins it. Never again. read more