I tried this pizza place 15 years ago. Back then, I wasn't a fan. Decided to grab a large cheese pie today. And I am so glad I did. The place has new owners and I don't know what they changed, but the large cheese pizza was absolutely amazing. It was like grabbing a slice at my favorite NYC Pizza Joint. I grew up in NYC. The customer service was stellar and the pizza was great. read more

How did we not know this place has been here for over 7-8 years? Kind of on a weird spot next to the Krogers on lower Fayetteville rd. New neighbor told us about it. Excellent pizza! We got the "Choice Special" and wings. Wings were "ok" but the pizza was great! read more

Peoples Choice pizza - Choice special ....excellent - Pizza Near Me - Newnan, Georgia

This was my first visit. I ordered 4 bone-in wings and an 8" personal pizza and paid $22.93. The food was good. However, I think it was a bit over-priced for the portions I received. (4 wings for $9.74?--no fries or anything, just 4 wings!) I've received more food for the same price at other places and the service was satisfactory. I only placed my order to go, so I wasn't able to see much past the to-go order counter. I did see the DPH posting a score of "B" on the wall though. I only went to this place because it was opened before the others I preferred and I had never been here before. I'm not sure I would ever make a special effort to come to this place again. read more

Peoples Choice pizza - Receipt of purchase of 1-8-inch personal pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Newnan, Georgia

See all

Haven't eaten here in about 3 years. Even worse than I remember. I gave it one last chance but it was burnt and had so many bubbles in the crust that there were pools of cheese over half the pizza and thin garbage for the outer half. The wings are much smaller too, not worth the money. Would not recommend to anyone with tastebuds. Made a yelp account because the google reviews must have been paid for. read more

By far the WORST food I've had anywhere. I attached the picture of their so called White Pizza. There was no olive oil, no garlic and absolutely NO RICOTTA. what we received was a hours old cheese pizza with no sauce. Salad was delivered soaked in dressing. WTF even does that!? The chicken Caesar wrap seemed to have been put through the dishwasher before being packaged. The Stromboli looked great. But tasted like cardboard. I've had better pizza in middle school on Fridays. I don't know who's eating this food that loves it. But, you should definitely see a doctor to have your tastebuds reevaluated read more

Peoples Choice pizza - Famous White 12" - Pizza Near Me - Newnan, Georgia

When I first got to the area a little over two years ago, this was my favorite pizza spot. I was disappointed when they stopped making the New England style pizza, but the normal was still solid. I don't know what happened over the last year, but my last six orders, no matter how simple, have been made wrong or poorly. When they remake the order, it's worse than the original. The price for what you get has gotten much worse as well, the toppings seem to be a mild suggestion now. Until something changes, avoid and spend your money elsewhere. read more

Love their pizza better than any of the other pizza places in Newnan! Always ready on time hot and delicious!! Crust is perfect and they don't put too much sauce on the pizza!! And the staff is super friendly and helpful read more

Do not order from this place especially if you are expecting a gluten-free pizza. I ordered one regular pepperoni and one gluten-free pepperoni. My daughter picked them up and the employee was very rude to her and ignored her when she asked for ranch. When she got the pizzas home we opened them both up, nothing marked on either box, and they both looked the same. No way to tell if one was gluten-free or not. Someone with a gluten-free allergy cannot just assume. I called the store to ask them if there was any identifying markers or how am I supposed to tell which one is gluten. They told me that I shouldn't have ordered the same toppings and there was no way to tell and there was nothing they could do. "Maybe you just shouldn't eat it then". I asked for a refund for the gluten-free and I was told he didn't know how to do that. I have no words for the unprofessionalism and lack of care that this business showed. Food is expensive enough and when you don't want to make dinner after a long week of work this was extremely disappointing!! Look at the pictures and tell me if you can see a difference..... Shameful. read more

Peoples Choice pizza - Which one would you think was gluten free? Nothing on either box to identify them. - Pizza Near Me - Newnan, Georgia

See all

Cook the Stromboli at least to melt the cheese, or as I suppose to continue cooking it at home? Wings were good though read more

Peoples Choice pizza - Uncooked Stromboli - Medium or ham sub - Pizza Near Me - Newnan, Georgia

Pizza : arrived cold and looked like it's a day old; Cardboard crust, dry lacking sauce and cheese. Ordered half pepperoni and charged as whole topping. Cheese steak: Basic, cheese and "steak" that was dry and over cooked. Bread to roll ratio ... HIGH...pathetically filled with fluffy boring roll. First time and last time. Save your money! Probably better at the corner gas station . read more

Peoples Choice pizza - Dry, lacking and overcharged - Pizza Near Me - Newnan, Georgia

We aren't from here and so choosing a good spot seemed tricky. People's Choice Pizza was great though! The woman that took our delivery order over the phone was awesome and the delivery guy was on time and nice. We enjoyed our food. I would say their pricing is fair and their food is good. Crispy chicken sandwich was delicious. Try it. Fresh cut fries were good. Original pan cheese pizza was good a bit harder crust then preferred but we enjoyed it! Oh and that pizza sauce was pretty tasty We would order again. read more

See all

The food was great. I just wish that their portions were a little more. I definitely would recommend.

Topping were delicious and fresh. Everything portioned just right. The maranira sauce was so good. Besides the great tasting pizza..the customer service was exceptional with excellence. My husband is hard to win over..when it comes to take out. He said Oh Yeah..this is some good pizza. read more

so I just went into this place was trying to order pizza the young man with curly hair was on the phone so I sat down and waited he said nothing to me then later after the call disappeared to the back telling the lady that was in the back about the call as she's complaining about that customer only tipping her 21 cents after waiting for 20 mins just to order and getting no help or anyone saying anything to me I decided to walk out at 7:45pm lack of customer service and bad business to complain about other customers while you have customers in store. company is not recommended at all. read more

I used to order from here all the time. Lately it's been going down hill! Order before last was wrong order and had to bring them back. Manager said they would put a credit on my account to make up for it. Wasn't done. Ordered tonight for delivery and received the tiniest little wings I've ever seen! See photos. Called the store and asked to speak to the manager. She was really of NO HELP and said they received a bad batch of wings. Really?! A bad batch that's what you tell a paying customer?! She said you should have received extra wings because of the small size...we received 1 extra teeny tiny wing! Needless to say...we are DONE ordering from People's Choice! read more

See all

Great food and service. I would recommend taking the family lunch or dinner during your work day or on the weekend .

I had a good experience. I realized they are a bit expensive while online ordering but I went ahead and made my order. For 5 people we spent $80.00 including delivery and tip. So be prepared to spend some money. The food is good. We ordered wings, sandwich, salads, and bread sticks. I can't complain about the food, although the "grilled" chicken caesar salad wasn't really grilled at the restaurant.... They delivered pretty far out. That was good for us considering we're limited in delivery options. The order was correct. Phone operator and Driver were friendly and helpful. Overall, we would order from them again. read more

Ok, here goes. I don't usually write reviews in any way for anything. I will give it the stars it asks for fairly when prompted. S0, here, is the exception. I am from NY originally. I know what good pizza is. In Newnan, mind you, this is the closest you will find. Being extremely strict on my grading. Which would include food, delivery time, staff, etc. I give People's Choice a 94%. Don't knock them because of a 94%. This is the the best I have found, for multiple reasons, in this area. Also, Let me give a shout out to my favorite delivery guy who I have had the pleasure to have met, Ethan. Ethan is my preferred delivery guy. Good people, good food, timely, and kind. Thanks, M. Callahan read more

Used to be good. Not so much now. Cardboard pizza. Cold fries. Brown salad. 79 health score

GREAT PIZZA! We have been ordering from People's Choice now for a year. The Pizza is great and NY Style. Great Sauce and fresh ingredients. fast delivery and even had one that was wrong pizza, but Theresa made it right and in 30 minutes we had a new one. good Customer Service, thanks Peoples Choice! read more

This pizza is nasty smh I called placed my order and it took 2 hours to deliver a cold pizza. I didn't Complain but it just wasn't right for me. Try some of the local pizzas tbh read more

Small hole in the wall pizza joint. We have tried a lot of there specialty pizzas. The hamburger pizza and lasagna pizza are our favorites. They always give a generous portion of toppings including cheese. Great little place for delivery you should try it. read more

We really enjoyed our pizza!!! Generous toppings and delicious cheese. We ordered for delivery. It arrived quickly and hot!

A little pricey, but delivery is quick and the pizza is really good. They use a good amount of cheese and sauce and the crust is the perfect texture. Only reason for 4 stars is because of price. Food was delicious. read more

As a born and breed New Yorker, I really like this place. The pizza is pretty good and I like the hot sandwiches. The delivery times can be pretty lengthy, I usually order on a Friday or Saturday, but to be expected when you are dealing with decent food. read more

This place either needs to be shut down or to fire the entire staff including the manager and rehire people that are not nasty and rude to the customer. It was about a week ago, when I ordered a pizza, I went back to my car and I checked it, the pizza looked okay, but they only gave me 3 MOZZARELLA STICKS, really. I went back in and told them there were only 3 in there they only made me 4, and the cashier jerk took the originals back instead of letting me keep them, I WILL NEVER EAT THERE AGAIN, and I will tell everyone I know not to eat there either. read more

Pretty good pizza Great customer service fast delivery- for free faster pick-up give it a try you won't be disappointed read more

Okay, I don't know how you feel about thick pizzas with thick crusts, but if you are a fan then you should love the Lasgana Pizza. The mixes of cheese and the meatballs on this pie are divine. Get it with extra sauce, the mess is worth it. They make a good thin crust pizza too and the rest of the menu has a little bit for any appetite or mood. The chicken fingers with fries are a whole meal or a great appetizer. They are entirely pick-up or delivery and in the Kroger lot so you can order dinner, do some quick shopping (pick up a dessert) and then grab your meal to be the hero when you get home. read more

By far the worst customer service. Charlie the heavy set one was very rude. Hung up the phone when we asked why would she put two different order fries in the same box ( without acknowledging the customer before hand ) her response was because they was saving on packaging ( sounds poor of a business ) saying they didn't have enough pasta so asked if we wanted cheese to replace the pasta and wouldn't discount the order. We threw out the whole order and got dominos will be no next time coming here read more

Always my goto pizza place since they opened. Always delicious and fresh made when ordered. They send out coupons they give you info on specials over the phone have a website to order online and even offer FREE delivery. Can't go wrong! Any issues they are always quick to rectify. If you've been debating on them just STOP. Pick up the phone and place your order for my favorite NY Style crust!! read more

Got to order pizza from this place by accident but gave it a chance because I called the wrong place. They both had the gourmet pizza and both vegetarian! That's when the similarities end. The pizza crust was plain maybe frozen. The menu said broccoli, none to be found. Sorry, will never make the wrong call again. Go to the other shopping mail across the street for a far better crust with all the toppings included or order from here before midnight if you have the munchies. Best yet go into the supermarket to get your frozen pizza for half the price to take care of the munchies... read more

Peoples Choice pizza - a pizza menu - Pizza Near Me - Newnan, Georgia

Just moved into the area and ordered a chicken Parmesan sub and a large pepperoni pizza. Thought it was a bit pricey but when I took my first bite ohhh my!! Best pizza I have had in a longgg time! read more

I love this place. The lemon pepper wings are the bomb. I got the girls at work addicted to the lasagna pizza. It tastes like lasagna without the noodles. The marinara is mouth watering! The prices are reasonable. There have been a couple of times I ordered Greek salad and when i opened it it didn't even fill the container. Recently ordered the tuna salad and was very pleased. Fried Mozz, poppers, potato skins, Tuna sub & meatball subs are awesome. Last couple of times I ordered dessert it wasn't really a whole Piece of cake. Like someone ate the bottom layer off. So I don't really order it anymore. But this Is my go to pizza place. Service is always great! Love that I can order online and pay online. Keep up the good work PC! read more

Peoples Choice pizza - Lasagna Pizza. Heavenly. Perfect amounts of ricotta, sauce, meatballs, spices, cheese...amazing. One of the best pizzas I've tasted!! - Pizza Near Me - Newnan, Georgia

See all

My first time ordering a philly steak sandwich. I did add sautéed onions, mushrooms and peppers to it. It was absolutely delicious. I usually order the Italian grinder but the Philly was incredible. A side of onion rings was worth the 2.95 and they were yummy. Website says a 30 minute delivery time and as in the past it was exactly 30 minutes or slightly less which is great compared to other local pizza places that take alot longer. The 2 liters are ice cold. Peoples choice is a great go to place for delivery or takeout. read more

Lemon pepper wings are a cut above the rest, though Peoples Choice can be a bit pricey I can say it's always a treat to have these wings. Lunch specials are always helpful so I'm glad they offer deals here and there! read more

Ordered from them last night. As usual, food was on point and delivery time was exactly what they stated. Delivery driver was very pleasant as well. Will order again in the future. read more

Best thing this place has going is free delivery and calzones. If you like freezer to fryer then you'll enjoy it, unless you want your order correct.... read more

Best white sauce pizza I've ever had. Weeping with joy right now. I downloaded yelp just to post this.

Best pizza, salads, wraps, and wings in NEWNAN and GA. Everyone is always wishing they lived closer to me once they try it. I get plenty of house guests now though. LOL read more

I ordered delivery to my son's work in order for him to bring to me. We usually have never had a problem in the past, however this time it was not good at all. The calzone had chopped up hotdogs (should have been sausage - real Italian sausage) very little cheese and only two pieces of onion and pepper. The chef's salad was lacking as well. There was no bread included (which it advertises) and although fresh, it was mostly bagged spring mix with very few other ingredients. The wings were good, however there was no celery nor the ranch dressing that was requested. Had the order been opened at delivery, these things could have been rectified by sending the delivery person back for the missing items. As it was, the lack of attention to detail has turned me off from this pizza place. read more