1. Mathis House

    0

    Toms River, NJ

    Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Mathis House

    4.4 (83 reviews)
    Closed • 11:00 am - 5:00 pm

    About Mathis House

    Loading...

    Read the full summary in the app

    Order Mathis House Takeout or Delivery

    Mathis House Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    Portfolio From The Business

    Sponsored

    Recommended Reviews - Mathis House

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    One version of a vegan/ gluten free platter (options vary)
    Atira L.

    Leaving a review for the Mathis House is past due for me. I found this place doing a Google search for "hot tea" in Toms River. I called them and expected them to say that they had no vegan or gluten-free options. But the owner, Vicki, answered the phone and told me they had vegan and gluten-free tea service, including scones, sandwiches, desserts, and more. I was shocked! My mom and I went there for lunch about a week later. Our waitress was so knowledgeable about the house and the food options and she answered all of our questions. That was the beginning of a long history of coming to the Mathis House. I have since brought groups of friends ranging from five to twenty. We have attended a few Afternoon Teas, including the holiday sessions; Cinco de Mayo, and a Masquerade Murder Mystery. I recently celebrated my birthday there. My favorite thing about the house is how we can view the lovely decorations. The house is decorated to reflect every season. Plus, I love how vintage and classy the atmosphere feels. A visit to the Mathis House is always an enjoyable time!

    Afternoon 5-course tea, preceded by a small salad and cup of soup
    Grace G.

    Lovely afternoon tea. Small salad, delicious cup of soup with croutons (we had carrot coconut) and a nice presentation of tea sandwiches, scones, dessert. The soup, scones, and tea sandwiches were amazing. The dessert was lovely, perhaps not as imaginative as other afternoon teas but still very lovely. They don't rush you which is so nice. You can wander the first and second floor of the mansion to view the other tea rooms, retail shopping, and even peek at some of the bedrooms if they're open at the time.

    Entrance sign
    Jessi S.

    My husband and I had a wonderful one night stay at the Mathis House at the end of September. We had a party to attend down in Toms River and we wanted to also celebrate our 10 year anniversary so I was looking for a nice place to stay the evening. Someone recommended the Mathis House and I am so glad they did! What a cute bed and breakfast! We arrived around 3:00 to check in and we stayed in the room, Lady Genevieve. It was a very cute Parisian themed room with a queen bed, a small TV, a cute vanity, and a smallish bathroom. We were brought up to the room by the hostess down in the tea room. She explained to us there are snacks upstairs by the rooms and a Keurig coffee maker. She also warned us that the house is quite old, so it takes time for the shower to heat up. To be honest, I didn't feel like it took that long at all, and everything was perfect. The bed was comfortable, the room was clean, temperature was perfect, and the included breakfast in the morning just really hit the spot! Breakfast was at 9:30 downstairs in the tea room (which was so cute and decorated for Fall). I had a coffee and an orange juice. The breakfast spread was absolutely delicious. The waitress brought out a board of all the most amazing breakfast foods. We got cinnamon raison french toast, sausage and cheese frittatas, bacon, fresh fruit, and orange / cranberry scones. It was all to die for. So so good. And the scone? Top notch! I felt full, but not overly full. It was the perfect amount for the both of us and it was such a nice way to end an enjoyable stay at the Mathis House.

    Salad with raspberry vinaigrette dressing.
    Althea A.

    I went to this place today with a group of 15 people for their tea experience. The food was delicious along with the three different teas that they served with soup, salad, sandwiches, & desserts. I definitely will try this place again.

    Ric T.

    What a nice Victorian B&B tight in the heart of Tom's River. As their ad says "The Lixury of Today, the Coziness of Yesterday ". I did not stay here but since I was in the area , I was curious. You can book small gatherings like a moderate-sized party ie anniversaries, birthdays, corporate and tea. Very " English" if you get my point. There are five bedrooms in this three-story Victorian home. I believe the rates are mentioned in their website. They also sell on the third floor seasonal items such as Christmas & Thanksgiving tchotchkes with gift baskets. This is also a nice romantic getaway for those of that ilk.

    Salad in a tea cup
    Monica C.

    first time ever going here , place was amazing , Awesome Design & details! it was for a bridal shower with at least 35 guests! each table had about 4 to 5 ladies ! Now upon arrival 11:00 am ( time listed ) each table had 3 pots of different teas to try ! Table were set nicely accordingly to the tea Theme out table did not have Sugar cube bowl on it and we couldn't drink our hot tea until we received sugar! Now our salads were being served , our table which was middle of the room were last to receive a tea cup of salad which was very fresh and delicious, Our choice of soup was served next , again last to be served . But what was disappointing was having to hear about how this place came to light ! Now normally it would have been okay to stop eating and listen to the tour guild tell his tale but we were only there for 2 hours ( again bridal shower ) When the story was over we were then served the 3 tiers of finger sandwiches which were Egg salad on cut in half croissant ! Cucumber & scallions cream cheese, little tuna salad and a turkey & cheese ! bottom shelf , only small half per person was offered . second level had just one blue berry scone per person! they were soft and very sweet! Top shelf of the tier was sweets little bite size pieces of marble cakes , 2 straw berries covered in chocolate ( 4 ppl at table ) a few mini cupcakes ! The hostess was asked by several guest to please put the Air Conditioner on it was very hot out that day we were all sweating that also ruined the experience !! Would I go again ? Yes but never in August' !

    5 course tea party
    Lane H.

    I have lived in Toms River for 10 years and point honestly did not know this place existed until two weeks ago. It is such a pleasant time. I think that is the best way to describe it. Everyone in the staff is so kind and knowledgeable about the tea. They take photos for you which was nice. There's also a little gift shop where you can purchase teas or even local goods. They have hats to wear to fit in the tea vibe. Realllly enjoyed it.

    One of the sitting rooms in the Victorian home
    Sal V.

    Charming! ! . Go back in time to the Victorian era and enjoy a traditional tea from vintage tea cup and teapot with tasty little finger sandwiches and scones. Choice of teas are phenomenal. Service was pleasant and educational. Price fixe was perfect. Take your daughter or granddaughter they'll love it

    Main course & dessert (lunch)
    Ashlee B.

    Excellent customer service!! I absolutely loved the place. Exactly what I was looking for. My sister & I were worried we'd be over dressed but felt like we fit right in with the vibe. I was expecting to feel a little hungry after but oh my gosh the food was delicious & I was stuffed!! Be sure to take a look upstairs too, super cute!! I got the raspberry (I think) lemon tea. To die for. Next time I'm wearing a derby hat

    Scones

    See all

    13 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    12 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Beautiful house, comfortable rooms, large porch. Owners are friendly and accommodating. Delicious breakfast.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 3 of 3

    Ask the Community - Mathis House

    Can we purchase tea and tea sandwiches without staying over night?

    Yes

    View All 3 Questions

    Review Highlights - Mathis House

    “I have lived in Toms River for 10 years and point honestly did not know this place existed until two weeks ago.”

    Mentioned in 7 reviews

    Read more highlights

    You might also consider

    Clarion Hotel & Conference Center - Room 121

    Clarion Hotel & Conference Center

    3.3(55 reviews)
    2.2 mi
    •$$

    We have been staying at the Clarion on our annual vacation for the past 4 years. Multiple times…read moreduring some years. June 2026 changed everything. Our room was on the second floor. At about 9pm, during a heavy rain, there was a leak from our bathroom ceiling. Called the front desk to change rooms. Two minutes later, I was at the front desk, an older blonde lady arrived 10 minutes later carrying free food from a banquet room party. Extremely rude, asked me "what do you want?" The washing machines have a sign that say coins available at the front desk. Around 7pm I went to the front desk, remember open 24/7, the desk was empty. I went into the bar to wait. The brown haired lady working the front desk was in the bar. Not for a quick coke, she was sitting in the bar for 40 minutes, with her back to the front desk, chatting away like she was off work. Never knew she was working until a customer started tapping on the counter and she eventually, turned around and headed to the front desk. The $10 continental breakfast is significantly worse than last year. Scrambled eggs, sausage links, and French toast. Bagels that were cut half way through. A scary guy watched us eat as we were the only two in the eating area. It's $10, you could have got a better breakfast at Wawa for cheaper. After the first day, we did. Housekeeping, was more focused on cleaning the empty rooms. We used housecleaning once in our 7 day stay. They didn't finish our room until 5pm. We waited in the hallway for 20 minutes until they finished. Only one housekeeper working that day on our floor. Boogie nights are Wednesday, Friday, and Saturday. Good luck sleeping if your room is above the bar. Let's not forget the constant hum of the ac units on the roof. I cut my stay by one day because of the service. Bottom line, the Clarion in Toms River used to be a nice place to stay. New management made changes that caused me to seek other arrangements. I will say, there are two people worth mentioning. Both on the day crew. An older gentleman and a brunette lady. Both highly professional and customer service oriented. If I were to stay at the Clarion again, it would be because of these two. Great job to them.

    We have held many events at the Clarion, and they always provide good service and good food at a…read morefair price they are quick to accommodate us even with last minute requests, and the staff is a pleasure to deal with

    Photos
    Clarion Hotel & Conference Center
    Clarion Hotel & Conference Center - Room 121

    Room 121

    Clarion Hotel & Conference Center

    See all

    Inn At Laurita Winery - Early morning view from the balcony...

    Inn At Laurita Winery

    3.8(24 reviews)
    18.3 mi
    •$$$

    I don't like to give bad reviews but I'm baffled at not being able to get ahold of a business to…read morebook a stay. I had my in laws try to stay here for my son's baptism. They called multiple times and left voicemails, of which were never returned. My mom who is local had to drive over to see what was going on and she was given an email to book (because apparently they are off during the day???) The email provided was incorrect and bounced. This would have been so helpful to stay here to take my in laws to and from the baptism which is local so now we are having to book towns over. I really hope they can figure this out because the business just lost out on a 2 night booking.

    We were greeted by Kayla and she showed us around. The inn was very clean. We stayed here two…read morenights. Our room was great. The bathroom was very big with a nice size shower and a tub. There is a room upstairs that we played cards in for hours. Snacks were always available and plentiful. Breakfast good both days. Hot food was warm and well cooked. There was also a large bowl of fruit and some nice baked items. The inn is surprisingly large but quaint. We met many other guests and even hung out with them. We went to the food truck festival at the winery and John the general manager offered to drive us and bring us back. We met Darcie his wife who was always working in the garden and they looked beautiful. My only complaint is they didn't come in the room and give us fresh towels but we made a call to the inn keeper and she promptly showed up with clean towels. I found it weird they don't check when you stay a few days. We will definitely stay here again and enjoy the winery.

    Photos
    Inn At Laurita Winery - Waiting for us upon entering our room for the first time...

    Waiting for us upon entering our room for the first time...

    Inn At Laurita Winery
    Inn At Laurita Winery

    See all

    Mathis House - bedbreakfast - Updated October 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...