My first visit to Mary's Mountain cookies. I just wanted to try one cookie and the server was so kind that she gave me oatmeal options, some caramel options and frosted cookie options. I then chose oatmeal butterscotch cookie. It was pretty huge almost the size of my hand. The taste itself was great. It was sweet for my personal preference but I thought it was a good cookie. I ended up paying about four dollars and it was pretty okay priced. I recommend if you like to try a cookie with milk or coffee it's a great option! read more

Mary’s Mountain Cookies - Oatmeal Scotchie - Bakeries Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

Dang good cookies. But a wide selection, and definitely not something you want to tackle every day. But these were good cookies. Staff were friendly and the counter was clean. We'll be back. read more

Mary’s Mountain Cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

Recently went back when my hubby and I were in the neighborhood having dinner across the street. We were so excited as Mary's cookies are always delicious. They had an awesome deal, but 6 and get 2 for free. I got the brookie, snickerdoodle and peanut butter. Hubby got all snickerdoodle. The extras we chose were chocolate chip and the turtle cookie. Holy moly were they all good. We put some in the freezer and they still tasted yummy after defrosting. My son LOVED his turtle. Snickerdoodle is a must try. Can't wait to go back. read more

I was walking on the Monon Trail and decided to stop into Mary Mountain's cookies on the way home to pick up a couple cookies. I had wanted to try this cookie place in Carmel,and I was impressed with the variety of cookies again in the shop. The ambiance is very nice and the cookie display was very impressive with a variety of flavors available to choose from to enjoy. I decided to go with the frosted Oreo cookie and the peanut butter cup dream cookie. The woman was very nice and professional behind the counter, and took care of my order. The cookies were wonderful! The frosted Oreo cookie had a little too much frosting, and not an Oreo taste to it, but it was still delicious. The peanut butter cup dream cookie was a party in my mouth. It tasted incredible and loved every bite I took out of the cookie. This is an excellent cookie place in Carmel and everyone should come experience Mary Mountain's cookies. They are terrific! read more

See all

Order a bag of cookies to go and brought them home for the kids. They didn't last long, which means they were excellent. Will be back for more in the near future. read more

Mary’s Mountain Cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

Mary and her Mountain Cookies are honestly my top 2 cookies that I have ever had! They have a wonderful display and many different cookie/ sweet treat options! I ALWAYS have to get an Oatmeal Scotchie - this is my all-time favorite cookie that they have here. They have a wide selection of wonderfully crafted cookies - from seasonal cookies to your classic Chocolate Chip. Also, if you haven't had their Brookie, then you are missing out! They also have Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches as well as Cookie Sandwiches with Icing in between. The staff are always super nice and each time you walk in, you are hit with a wall of fresh-baked cookie smell. If you are in downtown Carmel for any occasion, you must stop in and try this wonderful place! read more

Mary’s Mountain Cookies - Snickerdoodle Ice Cream Sandwich - Bakeries Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

Incredibly tasty and worth the money. A great alternative if you aren't in the mood for ice cream. The service was excellent and the staff was incredibly friendly. A great spot if you're looking for a sweet snack. read more

My son and I stopped in after his baseball game on Saturday. We both grabbed an ice cream sandwich. Made with two fresh cookies and a lot of ice cream. Highly recommend! read more

Mary’s Mountain Cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

Oh my the cookies are huge - and delicious!! There are so many selections. We even took some for our road trip home.

I went into this store because I heard that they have several gluten free cookie options, and they did not disappoint! They are stored in a cooler separate from the other cookies and individually wrapped. I was told that they were delicious as well! They have many normal cookies as well - and they are big. I got a selection to share and most of them were very yummy. (There was one that I didn't prefer.) This is a great place to go to please a crowd of mixed gluten free and not sensibilities. read more

I am amazed that I haven't heard more about this place.. the cookies are soooo good. they arent too sweet and stay fresh when you put them in the fridge they are a little more on the expensive side but the quality for the price is definitely equal. This will definitely be my new cookie place and beats the other franchise cookie brands out of the water! read more

My dog was getting her nails cut next door and I noticed they opened a Mary's Mountain Cookies here in Indy! It's a chain, they have them in Fort Collins, Colorado, where I used to live, and in the Western states. I walked in around 2:00 and 2 girls were waiting in line. I think someone called out from the back they would be right there. When the person came to help the girls, they weren't very friendly, just asked what flavors they wanted etc. I believe it was the owner. I was honestly turned off by the lack of service and excitement for customers coming into a new store. Everything looked great, but I honestly just left without buying anything. I may try coming back again another time, just today I was turned off, unfortunately. I'm sure it's amazing. read more

Mary’s Mountain Cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

See all

Randomly stumbled upon this shop on Main Street Carmel and I was happy to see a dessert shop that wasn't ice cream available! We were the only customers and the woman working was very attentive. I opted for the peanut butter bar cookie and the salted Carmel while my husband has the oatmeal raisin and Oreo cream cookie. The cookies where large and rich in flavor. Some of the icing seems a bit artificially sweet, but they were fine cookies. Because of their size, the cost was rather expensive, but no different than crumble cookies. It's a great option for Main Street! read more

See all

Love these cookies! They have gluten free options (yes - multiple options!) that are sooo good:). Staff is very friendly and prompt. Very clean. We love stopping in when we're in town for a sweet treat! read more

I was craving a snickerdoodle cookie and Mary's Mountain Cookies had been on my list to check out for a while so I knew this was a perfect opportunity! There is a huge variety of cookies; all looked delicious! They're HUGE! The snickerdoodle was moist and soft. My husband tried the chocolate chip cookie and said it wasn't his favorite but we plan to try other flavors when we're in the area. read more

I decided to stop in after walking by so many times! I got the snickerdoodle and frosted almond pumpkin cookie. The snickerdoodle was so soft and delicious. The sugar cookie had a good flavor and was soft but tasted a little artificial to me. I'd go back and try other flavors next time. read more

Mary’s Mountain Cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

See all

If you're in the mood for a big cookie, this is the place to get a big cookie. They have your classics: chocolate chip, snickerdoodle, sugar, peanut butter. But they also have some creative creations, like Oreo frosted cookies, cookies with chopped Reece's peanut butter cups on them, and -- my children's favorite -- s'mores cookies. My family loves everything s'mores, and we loved Mary's Mountain's s'mores cookie. It's a chewy chocolate chip cookie with fudge in the center and fudge drizzled on top, and big marshmallows and graham crackers on everything. It looks impressive and it tastes impressive. This Mary's Mountain Cookies location also has a refrigerated case with cookie dough in to-go cups. Cute! I'm not a cookie dough person, but that's a neat thing to have available to people who want that type of thing. Now is the part of my review where I talk about calories and nutrition, so if you're not interested in reading about how many calories are actually in a big cookie ... this is not for you. But for people who check nutrition information and count calories, you should know: Mary's Mountain Cookies lists their nutrition information on their website, which is great. But the calories listed per cookie are per ounce of cookie. Each cookie is around 6 ounces (I weighed them on a food scale!), so whatever calorie information is listed on their website, you will need to multiply that by at least six, per cookie. Just a head's up! It's a little deceiving because they don't let you know how big their cookies are, but they're big and they're 6x bigger than they're letting you know on their website. So basically, if you want to eat one serving of cookie: cut one cookie in half, then cut that half into thirds. That's one serving of cookie. Eating one-sixth of a cookie actually is not a problem, though, because Mary's cookies are very rich and sweet. A little bit goes a long way here. read more

My sweet tooth was raging after dinner on Main Street one night and I stopped in here... first thing I'd address that contributes to a 4 star is how early it closes. It doesn't get the after dinner rush at all. They've got plenty of cookies to select from and the ice cream sandwiches had me drooling. I got a chocolate chip and it was good! Slightly dry, but I'd for sure try again. Worth a try! I hope they expand on the hours, I want them to make it On Main Street! read more

WOW! I've been waiting for a new dessert spot on Main Street and boy did this place deliver! They have a huge selection of flavors with some really fun special ones. The cookies were about $4 each so a little pricey, but they're large and very filling. All the cookies were super soft and moist with a lot of flavor. The PB Cup was very sweet and the frosting was great. The M&M was my favorite. Check this place out! A wonderful addition to Carmel! read more

Mary’s Mountain Cookies - 3 cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

See all

Love love love these cookies! There is quite the selection! They are huge and tasty! Next time I want to try the edible dough and ice cream sandwich! read more

Best cookies in town! Fast and friendly service. If you are walking around the Carmel area, this is a great place to check out for a sweet treat. It is a small, quaint shop but has many options available. read more

Delicious selection of cookies and convenient location in downtown Carmel. P Lots of gluten few options also read more

Mary’s Mountain Cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

Second time I've came here and the hours on the door say they are supposed to be open and they are NOT. Call and confirm they are open before you waste your time riding around for parking and end up disappointed. read more

Delicious and freshly made cookies. Never disappointed with the quality and taste. Reasonably priced for the size of each cookie.

Ordered four cookies. S'mores, Frosted Sugar, Toffee, and Oreo. The cookies weren't good. They didn't taste freshly baked and the frosting on the Oreo and sugar wasn't good. I gave three stars because the owners were really sweet. The cookies are huge so I do feel they are priced well but if I were to describe them in one word I'd say underwhelming. read more

Stopped in on Saturday to check it out based upon the reviews. Wondering why it's rated so highly. Nowhere near the best cookies we've ever had. Tried peanut butter, snickerdoodle, Brooke and chocolate chip so far out of our purchase and can honestly say I'd never buy another of any of them. read more

These cookies were beyond! One of my best cookies yet in my lifetime. The people who worked there are very nice and we got our cookies fast. The scenery was very nice and happy inside! I recommend this place for people going into Carmel! read more

I was excited to try this new cookie shop. The location is great and I thought it would be fun to grab a couple of cookies to take home after a lunch out. First of all, there was a very large selection of cookies. It was difficult to decide which to order. I ordered the almond glaze and the salted caramel chip. The almond glaze cookie was a very thick cake like sugar cookie. It was soft, but I found it rather dry. The almond flavor was subtle. The cookie was not bad, but I would not get it again. I was excited to try the salted Carmel chip, but also found it disappointing. It was also soft, but rather dry and I didn't appreciated enough salt to justify the name salted Carmel. Again, the cookie wasn't bad, it just wasn't great. I may have just ordered poorly and maybe I would have had a different experience with a different cookie. I avoided the cookies with a lot of icing because I thought it would be too sweet, but maybe the icing is needed to cut the dry cookie. There were no evident COVID-19 precautions. No employees wore masks, nor were customers required. If all employees are vaccinated which is hopefully the case, I would encourage the business to post a sign that informs customers that all employees are vaccinated or unvaccinated employees will continue to wear masks. It's just unclear. There was also no attempt to keep hair from falling in the cookies. My cookies were bagged and a long hair was in with the cookies. I understand that this can happen, but keeping hair tied back could minimize this. Overall a disappointing experience, but I plan to give it another try with different cookie selections. read more

Mary’s Mountain Cookies - Salted Carmel - Bakeries Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

See all

I stop for cookies here when I'm on my bike rides in the area. I love the cookies here. They have some many different options and the cookies are huge. The folks in the shop are always nice and helpful. My favs are the sea salt caramel and the snickerdoodle. It's a small shop but they have ice cream and ice cream sandwiches as well. I also saw some gluten free options. My only complaint about this place is the packaging of the cookies. They come in plastic bags so if you buy several and don't plan on eating them right then, they are all crumpled up by the time you make it were you are going. They are so good though Im sure some folks don't mind but I'm big on presentation. I've tried twice to bring them home safely for others to try and they were not presentable. But if you are planning to eat them there, it's not a problem. read more

What a great addition to Carmel! Was excited to learn that this place opened on Main Street. They have a large selection of flavors which made it hard to narrow down! The cookies are large and about $4 each. The peanut butter cup cookie was outta this world! The cookie was moist, the frosting was incredible, and the peanut butter cup was abundant! Excited to try their other flavors soon! read more

See all

This new Main Street sweet spot is a must stop. For a man with a sweet tooth I stop by and grab a treat for post workout. My favorite cookie to-date is the salted Carmel cookie. Not only are the cookies reasonably priced, but delicious! If you like soft cookies and great selection, this is the spot! Not to mention customer service is very welcoming. read more

Mary’s Mountain Cookies - Mary's Mountain Cookies Carmel, IN - Bakeries Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

See all

Incredible cookies and extremely nice staff! We come to Carmel just for this place! Definitely recommend to all!

The cookies are to die for in the service was even better! Will definitely be getting these again. It is going to be my weekly stop.

Great cookies and way too close to where I live. They have bars and other sweets but the cookies are why I keep coming. read more

Delicious cookies. Wonderful service/location. Get the oatmeal raisin for sure!--there are limited special cookies depending on season also.

The cookies were soft and huge so that's a plus, but I wish the chocolate chip cookies had more chocolate chips! Overall, I'd say they have good cookies. read more

Showed up on Saturday at 2:40 PM. Closed. Posted hours clearly say should be open. No sign saying closed for an emergency or anything. Just closed for no apparent reason. read more

I love Mary Mountains Cookies, they're the absolute best thing ever. It's a staple in my friends and I's favorite places. Obviously, $4 for a cookie is pretty expensive, but it's so worth it. Every single cookie there is amazing. My personal favorite is their gingerbread cookie they get out during the Christmas season. I have and will continue to recommend this place to many people. read more

I was not a fan of these cookies. I felt that it was like biting into a stick of butter in terms of texture. The flavors were not great either. Also the packaging options were awful. They put the single cookie in a thin plastic bag and my cookie cracked into four pieces as I was holding it walking back to my car - which was a bummer because I bought it to give to my friend for her birthday. I went to try it again and bought an assortment of cookies which they put into one stack all on top of each other into a tall box. It was strange and then when I took them out they all crumbled on top of each other... cinnamon got onto my oreo icing and others combined like that. I will not be going back. read more

So delicious! I've tried several varieties and each one isn't Astor's than the last. Soft, not sickeningly sweet, and yummy.