This rating is for an average: Wings a BIG 5.0! Pizza gets a 1.0 Wings should have skin so light and crispy it just vanishes when you eat it. Too many places serve wings with soggy, undercooked skin. Mozzeroni's does it right! That was a good thing, because... The pizza was basically inedible. Three bites and I gave up. The basic problem being it was way undercooked: soggy crust, glumpy cheese. I messaged them twice on this and got no response, so I thought I should post, both to warn about the pizza and recommend those wings! read more

I have had multiple different kinds of Pizza from this place. The staff are great. The delivery are awesome. The Pizza last but not least is incredible. My only place for the Village of Webster , NY. Thank everyone. read more

Bad pizza. Bad blue cheese. I can't believe how bad this pizza is. It was good ten years ago, now it tastes like bad gas station pizza. read more

I got out of work RAVENOUS. The thought of a delicious scrumptious magical pizza and wings came to me in a dream last night. All I wanted was to satisfy my taste buds. I decided to choose your restaurant as I see it everyday. When I got my wings there was 5 and then a tiny mini wing with no meat on it. I was saddened. Deeply. They tasted ok but they were all drumsticks. The pizza was oldly shaped. At time of check out it seemed as though the cashier was high on crack. He was shaking and his voice was very odd. The blue cheese was extremely yummy and that was really the only good part just like the rest of the reviews say. YIKES! Mark do better. read more

Marvin Mozzeroni's Pizza & Pasta - Mini tiny 1/2 Dozen Wings - Pizza Near Me - Webster, New York

First time trying here, we enjoyed it. It's ordered a La cart and they brought to the table for us even though it wasn't necessary. The food was hot, fresh, flavorful and portioned well. We had the Marvelicious pizza, with ham, chicken, cheese and sweet and sour sauce. Loaded chicken ranch fries were great. The kids got a chicken finger meal and a huge spaghetti dinner which filled us all. Staff was friendly, and inviting (as well as patient as we looked over menu). Made a point to thank them on way out for everything. Will be back again. read more

First home delivery from this location. The service was fast, delivered hot and was delicious! I will be ordering from here again often! read more

Marvin Mozzeroni's Pizza & Pasta - a pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Webster, New York

I was customer for over 19 years, long time ago it was the best pizza place. We used to order from this place 1-2 times per week and for all parties we had. I still remember when you only had the blue cheese in little containers and I remember speaking with the owner and saying you should put it in jars and which you guys ended up doing. Now this place became horrible, and pizza is so bad. Each time I order mushroom pizza (which I used to always get) it's being wet and raw. I already told them that , and they recommended to grill mushrooms separately. So some time it not that wet , but this time it's just probably gonna be the last time I will ever order from them pizza. First of all they grill mushrooms on the side and gave them separately to me wrap in foil instead of putting on the pizza and finishing baking together. But pizza even with out mushrooms came out still wet and raw, so I had to put those mushrooms on and finish baking it at home. After calling this place and telling my pizza is wet I was told it's probably because of the cheese they use. But it wasn't like that before 3-5 years ago. So for that price they charge and what you get now not worth it to order pizza here. There chicken wings still ok, and we love their blue cheese, but would not recommend theirs pizza's. read more

Great food at reasonable prices. I have tried so many items over the years, and they are all great. Pizza, subs, fries, sloppy plate (YUM!). And good people! I can honestly say if there is ever a problem they will resolve it. Go ahead, give 'em a call. read more

We live in Webster and within a 3 mile radius there are 13 pizza restaurants. Over the course on 5 months, we had a game night with Pizza trying out all 13 establishments. Marvin Mozzeroni's was the winner. read more

Great food! The food was delicious. Their Marvelicious pizza was great and their blue cheese is unlike any other. New owners are nice! I'll be back! read more

I have been hornswoggled by the other more advertised pizza places in Webster! Mozzeronis is my new ONLY place for this kind of take out in Webster! The other night we wanted some food and the 'other' shops were all closing and stopped raking delivery orders. My niece said let's try the place across from Noco. WELL! We got 2 subs and some wings... SO GOOD! 1st..Steak out. We totally requested to alter it...a lot. My partner has said this was the best sreak sub of her life. I got Big Bertha plain with nothing. Smothered with Frank's when it got here...PERFECTION! The wings were perfect also I am told by our 15 yr old wing Connoisseur! So tonight we did it again. 3 steak outs and a turkey sub. And she was right..The best steak sub ever!! And everyone was very nice, kind and accommodating. 5 STARS ALL DAY!! I would have posted a pic, but everything is gone!!! Good job, Mozzeronis!! read more

I've moved from MA to a Senior's Apartment building here in Webster. The neighbors are great and we often have building-wide meals to get together. When the meals include pizza, It has always been from Marks. Marks may be a Rochester tradition, but I'm not a fan. Anyway, I planned a pizza party a few months ago and decided to give Marvin Mozzeroni's a try. The Pizzas were delivered almost exactly on time, both still had their crispy bottom crust, and both were DELICIOUS! It's been pretty much decided that Marvin's will be our party pizza location from now on. Thank you for a great meal! read more

Excellent crispy slice. Super quick and good. Great stop for a fast lunch. Pizza is pretty underrated here. read more

Marvin Mozzeroni's Pizza & Pasta - Slice - Pizza Near Me - Webster, New York

Ordered 2 fish frys this evening based on good reviews. With tip, 42.00, take out. Fish was severely over cooked, actually black on bottom. Hard as a board, fries cold and soggy and Mac salad served in aluminum foil fashioned into some kind of cup. We didn't eat, and our dog wouldn't either Take it off your menu, you shouldn't be offering this garbage to the public. Yes-that bad! read more

I was in the mood for pasta and decided to try this place. And I was more than satisfied. Plenty of pasta and sauce for my order and I added 2 meatballs. Glad I did because the sauce was marinara, not meat sauce. They were good. I also ordered some garlic bread with cheese and it was very good. The salad that came with the pasta was just ok. I almost never give a 5 star rating because it would have to knock me off my feet. And this didn't but was very good nonetheless. read more

I found this to be enjoyable pizza! We ordered one personal pizza thin; two of the pizza teezers which are thin whole wheat appetizer pizzas; and one order of garlic Parmesan wings. The personal pizza was really flavorful. I ordered thin and I felt like the pizza was puffy like a pillow. So I'm not sure if something went wrong there? But it was really tasty. It was four pieces and I ate them all except the one piece my little son ate. He gobbled it up and this kid doesn't eat! I thought the chicken wings were pretty good. I only had one and I didn't long to have another. They were nothing to write home about but they're definitely better than Jeremiah's. I still think Donnellys has better wings though. (Both in Fairport) The little pizza appetizers were quite comical. They are so thin it's almost unbelievable. But they are very tasty. It's good for someone I think who is dieting who wants a pizza but doesn't want all the calories! Or if you want to order some of their other food but still have a taste of a pizza this would be a great option. Because when you eat it, it feels like you're really eating a pizza but it's thinner than a cracker! This place has parking in the back and also a seating area. It's a fun place and if I lived in town I'm sure I would go there at times. Check it out! Another note--I ordered the pick up through yelp pick up and I really liked it. I even put in my credit card and all I had to do was swing by and pick it up. They also had a delivery option. I was really impressed with that feature on yelp. The menu was just loaded with items. I'll be curious to check out some of the other items on their menu someday. read more

See all

Great service but the pizza was very average. Sauce was typical of all chain type places it just lacked everything. Other ingredients were just ok. read more

My organization used Marvin Mozzeroni's for an event and it was great! Easy to serve to lots of hungry people quickly because it's cut into perfect portion sizes. We look forward to working with them again! read more

We get pizza at Marvin's in Webster a couple times a month, and it's always great. Ample toppings, great sauce, perfectly done, with a great crispy crust. There are lots of pizza options in Webster, but Marvin's really has no peers. The owner, Mark, always insists on perfection, and he delivers. If you want a great pizza, go to Marvin's, you'll be really glad you did. read more

Most of my experience with Mozzeroni's has been with delivery but my family keeps asking for more. The sauce is on the sweet side, but the combination of pepperoni and sauce have a satisfying but minor bit of spicy heat. Vegetable toppings are decent but nothing special. My family prefers the pizza when ordered as a sheet. The crust is puffier and the amount of sauce makes for an overall more flavorful pizza. My wife and I love the way they cook their wings. Most places don't seem to cook the wings at a high enough temperature so you end up with rubbery wings and/or overdone meat. We've had consistently crispy wings with juicy meat and not to mention hot to the touch delivery from Mozzeroni's. The "buffalo" wings are a nice flavor that many might need to acquire a taste for as it isn't the typical orange sauce, but my wife and I can't get enough of the barbecue wings. It's a barbecue sauce that is similar to the Masterpiece brand sauce (it may even be that brand) and when the wings arrive hot and crispy there's no better wing I can think of. Service experiences have been good to excellent for the most part. A couple of downsides: The delivery person will want to rub an impression of your credit card onto a receipt which is awkward and slow (they used to carry old-style machines to do this). Also, the blue cheese dip that comes with the wings is diluted with milk or just very bland. We don't even crack it open anymore. If you enjoy trying different pizza and wing places, don't miss this one. Try the sheet and some barbecue wings. read more

Overall one of the worst pizza experiences I have had in Rochester. Started poorly with the incorrect initial charge, even though I reminded her as she was typing in my order I had a coupon, showed it to her and she still rung it up without it. Only when I pointed out the total on my slip was $8 higher than it should have been did she say, "right you have a coupon or something?" She wasn't even listening. Then on a busy night with a lot of foot traffic my family simple order of large pepperoni pizza cut in smaller pieces should have been out within 15-20 minutes. Instead my cousin who walked in 15 after me ordered a large pepperoni and hers was done in less than 10. Where was mine? When I asked they said it has about 4 minutes to go. 10 minutes later they went in the back and couldn't find my slip. But assured me another 4. 30 minutes later, the pizza was done and not cut in small pieces. Ok, irritating as can be, but the attitude on why my take out was double the length as everyone else's? "Oh we are busy, can't you see that?" Not quite the customer service I anticipated after the multitude of error... Now the actual pizza? I would have rather had cold dominos from my college days, or a frozen Tony's pizza than this cardboard garbage. Drown the pie in blue cheese and it might be redeemable. In fact, the blue cheese was the only redeeming quality about my wasted $24. Oh except the bottled Aquafina was pretty good. Don't waste your money. There are better quality and better service establishments within Webster. Gross. On both fronts. read more

Friday night pizza night. We have not had good service from two other pizza places in the village of Webster so went to Mozzeronis. It didn't disappoint. Takeout order was on time hot and what we consider the definition of Upstate New York pizza -saucy and thick crust.Sauce was thick and not too sweet. crust flavorful and not chewy. Hot wings were hot but not too. They even were still a little crispy which is hard to find by the time you get order home. Big points from us for that. The gentleman that answered the phone used my name and remarked that I had not been there since 2010. Yet it did not deter him from giving very friendly service to me on the phone and when my husband picked it up. We have found our neighborhood go to pizza place. Can prob find similar pizza and wings around but people make the difference! read more

I came in for one of the lunch specials -- boneless wings and a slice of pizza ($5.99 excluding drink). The wings were good, however the pizza was pretty bad. I don't know if this is indicative of how the whole pizzas are or not, but the pepperoni slice that I received was overdone and pretty tasteless. I'll try somewhere else next time. read more

I had the Marvin's steakout hoagie and it was seriously the best sandwich I have EVER had. I would eat that for breakfast lunch and dinner until I die. Please never take that off the menu. They did change the gluten free crust lately and its not as good as it used to be. Otherwise awesome staff and incredible (gluten) hoagies read more

We have been buying pizza and hoagies from Mozzeroni's for over 2 years now, and I have to say the crew there does an outstanding job. We are always greeted in a friendly manner, or food is always hot and delicious, and after ordering from them almost once a week, I can only recall one time there was a small error on our order. We are always happy with the quality of our pizza and wings, even on busier nights. Great job! I recommend everyone gives them a try! read more

I am a resident of Delaware and was visiting a friend who lives off of Oxford. I am writing a review about the Oxford location. I got a small pizza and it was so greasy and disgusting. I waisted my money! It was by far the worst pizza, I have ever had. Please, please, if you are reading this you'd be better off with a bowl of cereal to feed your late night cravings! Nik read more

Love, love, love these guys and gals! I'm so happy they are on GrubHub now. I've ordered from them several times and each time the transaction was flawless. They have a great menu, great food, very competitive pricing, and extremely friendly people. I've tried their pizza, wings, hoagies and several sides. Everything was delivered hot and delicious. Count me a very satisfied customer! read more

My rating is really more a 3.5. The best way I can describe Mozzeroni's is that it's good not great. Don't get me wrong I enjoy it, and I do go here occasionally. It's not terrible by any means but it's not the best. I will say though that the wings are awesome, and the NY style pizza is really good as well. read more

I moved from out of town to the neighborhood a year ago. Being a young man i knew i needed to find a new pizza joint. I love Italian and "Marvin's" at this location specifically always delivers on quality, professionalism, and overall on great attitudes. The first time i walked in I explained I was new in town and more importantly asked how was the food? The young man behind the counter was honest and said the food is great and I saw he took an honest pride on what he did and the quality speaks for itself. (The whole staff has always shown this trait.) To this day Marvin Mozzeroni's is always my first choice on takeout.(Especially this location, They have always met my harsh standards and I always feel satisfied with my purchase. Keep up the great work guys! read more

Mozzeroni you get 5 stars...Why? Because you listened to your customers and made things better. My previous review listed some reasons for discontent with Mozzeronis. A short time later i was contacted by the staff who informed me they would be making changes to their ordering system... Low and behold they did! So five stars for fixing a mistake and making good on your promise. It's hard to find that kind of service in today's world. read more

Have never had anything but great pizza and Wings from here. It is my go to place in Webster. Shocked to see poor reviews. Keep up the great pizza read more

The food is always consistently great. Love the calzones, flat breads and chicken fingers. The wing sauce is awesome. I would have given 5 stars had i not been treated so poorly after calling the store to let them know my order was wrong. It wasn't a big deal, they brought subs instead of calzones. I ordered through the website so not sure how my order was messed up, but when i called to let them know i was made to feel that it was my fault some how. Not ordering from here again. read more

10/10 recommend. When you order online you can add special delivery instructions and they truly come through. Asked them to send their cutest delivery boy and write a pick up line on the box and they did not fail to make my night. read more

Marvin Mozzeroni's Pizza & Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Webster, New York

See all

THE PASTA DINNER WAS AMAZING!!! I ordered on grub hub, the food came fast I was very happy and surprised to find that the salad that comes with the pasta dinner was much bigger than all these other dinners and pizza shops. Not only that but the pasta dinner came with this amazing bread with butter on it must have been home made so good!! I feel the price honestly is reasonable for the amount and quality of the food as well. Menu is HUGE I cannot wait to order again this weekend!!! Only suggestion is there hot dogs on the menu should be token down in price just a little bit but it was still delicious!!!! LOVE THERE FOOD! read more

Best meatball sub I have had in a long time. Awesome customer service, too! My husband and I frequent this location bc of it.

Absolutely great food every time and the delivery staff is wonderful! Thank you so much for your service to Ontario!!

I normally buy my wings from the Philly Cheesesteak restaurant on Long Pond Road. I was in Webster and had a coupon for Mozzeroni's. Their menu advertises a dozen Jumbo Wings for $12.49. They were tiny. I weighed them when I got home and they were 18 ounces. That works out to over $11 per pound. Go to Philly Cheesesteak restaurant for your wings. They know what the word Jumbo means. read more

Best pizza & wings ever! Subs are HUGE.... especially the gourmet subs. Staff is ALWAYS so friendly & Ive noticed that this place is cleaner than most any place Ive gone to. I cannot say enough good about this place. If you are looking great, QUALITY food, definitely give them a try! read more

Decided to give this place a try one night while suffering through working a 16 hour night shift. The pizza is good, and their seafood is delicious. Servings are huge so make sure you have an appetite! The online ordering is great too because I can place an order for a future time and I can run out on my break knowing the food will be done. read more

The pizza was good, but there Webster website is misleading. They list a medium pizza as $9.99, but the charge is really $12.99. They should correct their website. read more