Marcello's needs a new Review... Impromptu stop for lunch...specials galore. I opted for a regular-size ham and cheese boat. Came with fries and drink. My buddy got the two-slice special, cheese and mushrooms. Everything d-lish...the boats are great if you like hot subs. Tuna next.... Fries were huge portion and fresh out of the oil. I'd say give them another minute in the fryer. My buddy said the pizza was great! Menu is plentiful! We'll be back! read more

Ordered hot wings with extra sauce by didn't get any sauce. Called them they brought another order at no charge and the same thing no sauce. read more

Marcello's Pizza - Wings - Pizza Near Me - Red Lion, Pennsylvania

I'm a Roma's fan, but I remember the pizza at Marcellos being good. So, even though a large cheese pie at $15 bucks is insane, I decided to switch up. Never, ever again. Worst pizza I have ever had. And, what kind of creeps offer an $11 lunch special that is a 6 inch sub, fries and a drink? These people are gross. read more

Horrible pizza, poorly educated staff. Better pizza at 7/11. This place is truly aweful

Pizza was excelent done perfect and the right amount of sauce.The pizza had lots of cheese and very good. read more

Marcello's Pizza - 4-cheese pizza with bacon yummy - Pizza Near Me - Red Lion, Pennsylvania

Marcellos makes a good pizza and salads. Delivery is quick. I love their Caesar salad with shrimp.

Delicious special pizza with a great appetizer sampler. The person taking the order over the phone was polite and friendly. She asked good questions to confirm my order. Delivery was right on time! Have never been inside so I have no idea about the ambiance. read more

Would I was very impressed by how good was the pizza and the wings and the calzone from here I was up this way because we where looking to trade in my vehicle at apple Chevy of red lion and we where there for more then 4 hours on a empty stomach so we decided to get something to eat I was not in the mood for Chinese so we try this place and boy o boy was this a good choice good friendly staff and great food you can't ask for more the pizza was flaky crispy and it tasted very good we be stopping by soon read more

See all

Sadly this restaurant has declined quite a bit in the last few months. Not sure what has changed? Staffing or? Came in today to find the restaurant quite unkept with 3/4 tables dirty, no air conditioning, and no customers and no staff willing to make effort to clean up. I truly believe if you have time to lean, you have time clean! So sad to see this decline, this has been one of our go-too places for years. read more

Great New York style pizza and Stromboli. Delivery person was personable and food arrived hot and ready to enjoy.

Their pizza is my favorite. All their food is so much better than Roma's across the street. Tonight I ordered a sub for delivery they told me 45 minutes... I was like okay, well it's Friday night. But I kid you not that sub was at my front door in 15 minutes read more

The pizza is always fresh and the service can't be beat! I always enjoy my time at Marcello's.

So very disappointed in the food we received. The garlic bread was butter bread with cheese no taste. And the lasagna had not flavor. The sauce really was so bland I thought it came out or the can. Not sure what happened but the food was not the same as when we had been before. read more

Have eaten here several times. All the food we have received has been good. I especially like chicken fajita salad. The only thing is there is not much consistency. The first was great, the second so so and the third took forever to make. We had received our whole order minus the salad. The salad came when others at the table were finishing. I took the salad home and it was good but the chicken was tough. Just wish it had come with the rest of the meal. We will return return but I will try other menu items. Their pizza is good here. I really like their sauce. They offer luncheon specials. Wait service has always been great. Restaurant is clean. read more

Good food, affordable, and very kid friendly. There is room for small kids to move around if they get too antsy and/or impatient. The food is not made in peanut oil which we also like very much too. The staff is laid back and always kind. Great place. read more

Marcello's Pizza - This is the front of the restaurant. - Pizza Near Me - Red Lion, Pennsylvania

Best pizza in york for sure! I'm not sure why it only has 3 stars. People that work their are very nice and the prices are good as well for me. Only place I'll go for a good pizza! read more

Ok so I love this place. Me and my friends would hang out every Friday and we would order this. We were never disappointed. I personally like their Italian sub, pepperoni pizza, and cheeses sticks. It feels like a nice cozy family restaurant. You should definitely check it out for yourself. :) read more

Nice cheap tasting pizza. Decent variety of menu items. Good portion sizes. Contemporary interior along with 2 (i think) flat screens. Fast and friendly service. read more

The pizza at Marcello's is the best in the RL area. I have eaten at Marcello's many times and always have had excellent pizza. The sauce makes the pizza stand above all others. A bottle of red wine (BYOB) and the Hawaiian pizza make a relaxing and enjoyable dinner. read more

1st time we ordered, the food was good. 2nd time it was late, burnt, and not worth what we paid for it. Probably will not be ordering from there again. Better places around. read more

I've been going here for years. Very nice place with good food. I've tried several things on the menu from pizza to cheese steaks subs and pasta. All very good. read more

Ate here a while back never go back again, service was blah and so was the food had no taste was so bland did not enjoy. Step it up a knotch and maybe you'll get a better review. read more

I ordered pizza and fries online for an advanced order (45 minutes later). When I picked up my order I could tell the food was prepared too early. The pizza box was sweating underneath. I should've checked the food a little better but I had an antsy 2 yr old with me. When I got home 10 minutes later the pizza cheese had already hardened and the crust was soggy. Not only that but the veggie toppings tasted like the were either previously frozen or precooked. The fries weren't too bad but were also cold. I was very disappointed because the reviews are the reason I tried this place. I probably won't return again. read more

This is one of only two places within an hours drive that my children will eat the pizza. I think the pizza is great as well. The staff knows us as we are there about once a week because the food is good, its ready quickly, and a good price for the value. The wait staff has always been very friendly even handling both of my children whom have some mental health issues with grace and seeming to understand when its best to just ignore. The inside is starting to get a bit outdated and could use some freshening but its pretty clean. read more

The food here isn't bad, however the last two times I've placed a take out order here, my food was completely wrong. Last time it was an incorrect sub, this time it was an incorrect Stromboli. read more

Ordered carryout and I cannot drive there to return my sub. Got eggplant Parm sub not like any other that I have ordered from Marcellos. It was a grease bomb that needed to be dabbed with napkins before eating the eggplant. I get this dish often from Marcellos and other shops in the Red Lion Area. This is the worst sub that I have ever received in the entire Red Lion area. My hubby liked his steak sub though. read more

Normally i have nothing but good things to say about Marcello's but this evening my order was late, cold and none of the food was made the way i ordered it except the fries which would be pretty hard to screw up. Food was handed to me at the door not in a bag which would have helped keep the food warm as well. Certainly hope this is an anomaly or i'll take my business elsewhere. read more

I saw a sign in their window offering 20% off if you order online with a new app. I attempted to order online and the app did not work. I decided I would give the place a try and ask if they would honor the 20% off. The gentleman at the front desk said the app never works and turned to the manger and ask if they would still honor the 20% if I dined in. The manager was very rude and said no, I would need to order online to get the 20%. I explained the app did not work. There was no changing the managers mind. If they want locals to try this place they need to honor their deals. Didn't get to try this place and won't go dine with people that can't provide customer service. read more

Delicious pizza, light cheese as requested! Sauce is sweet, love it...reminds me of NY pizza My mild wings with bleu cheese was awesome too...thanks Marcello's! read more

I ENJOY...going to marcellos after I smoke...and have the giggles. WHEN I walk in the cook always stops what he,s doing like I might order something tricky...like a chit-ter-loin burrito...I never do. I always keep it simple and order something simple like the fried chicken wings stuffed with collard greens. read more