My daughter and I were visiting Dickinson College and found this place on 4/4/18. My daughter had the manicotti and really liked it. I ordered the penne vodka with no prosciutto or tomatoes. It looked sooo good but tasted not right. I should have said something. Wondering if the cream was bad or if they use something different in it that I'm not used to. Cute place and really wanted to like it. read more

I usually pick up from Marcello's 2-3 times a month. I had been very pleased with their service and food quality. On Sept 1st, Saturday evening around 10;30 pm, I stopped and ordered a med cheese pizza. I also ordered a piece chocolate cake, to go. When I got home, I was very disappointed with the pizza, not the same quality I was used to from Marcello's. Pizza was not even round, did not fit in box properly. Sauce and cheese was kinda just thrown on the dough. Didn't even cover the pizza dough evenly. I was surprised, not in a good way. Hopefully It was just a rare bad pizza from Marcello's and the next one will be back up to their standards which had always been very, very good! read more

I have only been here two times but it is the best sub and frys i have ever had and a great lunch deal

Just do not get injured there. They will not help pay expenses for doctor, etc. Since February 2018, I am still in pain and will be the rest of my life. I sat on a broken chair. read more

We drove through Carlisle Pa and I am so glad we did because it was so yummy- try the White bruschetta with shrimp and clams- great lasagna and pizza - plus the staff was so nice! I loved the salad with Italian roasted peppers and pickles on it- great food read more

Everything was delicious, fresh and well prepared. Attentive staff. Can't wait to come back!

Best Italian in Carlisle hands-down. Delicious red-sauce, checkered-tablecloth, family-owned, Italian-American food. Generous portions Fair Prices Attentive and competent servers. BYOB. A bit out of the way from the center of town but you will be glad you went. read more

After a disappointing catering experience with Marcello's, I implore you to consider one of the many other Italian options in Carlisle prior to securing Marcello's for your next event. There were many red flags (to include the owner "lost" the paperwork outlining our menu after our initial meeting, after meeting number 2 with the owner to outline the same menu the cost increased $2/person, the food was delivered late to the venue and our guests arrived prior to the food's delivery, during a telephone call that we initiated to receive reassurance that the food was indeed being delivered despite being late an employee hung up on me after he was told that their service was unacceptable, and finally when the food was delivered the final cost was increased another $3/person) and no apologies were offered. Ever. Taking responsibility and a simple apology can soften the edges when errors occur, but unprofessionalism and irresponsibility in a small town can quickly damage a restaurant's reputation. Ciao, Marcello's! read more

We stayed at the Marriott residence Inn last night and ordered for delivery. We got the eggplant rollatini which was excellent! Also a large pepperoni pizza that was excellent as well. They said it would be 45 minutes but it came much faster. read more

Mediocre. Came here when I was new to the area and didn't know of any other places. Now that I have found more (better) places to dine, I will not come here again. read more

Had a lunch for 20 ladies here. Everything turned out wonderfully. I recommend letting Alfredo, Dylan and the rest of the crew take care of everything for you! The wait staff was friendly and even though we ordered and paid separately for all our meals, it was efficient and the food was wonderful!! Thanks Marcellos!!! read more

My co-worker was showing me her amazing Greek Chicken Salad that she got there, the other day, so since I was in the area, I thought I would pick one up for myself. I called in my order, mentioning my co-worker bragging about this salad. I got there in 10 minutes, and it was ready. Again, I mentioned my co-worker loving this salad. I get to work and there are no olives. I show my co-worker and she's shocked because hers is usually smothered with them. It tasted like a Caesar salad to me (dressing was more a Caesar dressing), but it did have feta cheese, tons of chicken, red onion and tomato. So I called to see if they may have accidentally made the wrong salad. He said they were probably buried under the lettuce. Uh...no they're not. After a minute of talking to someone, he let me know that they are out of kalamata olives today. Nice...how about a discount on my salad, or at least tell me that when I call in...or even when I come in to pick it up? Not very good customer service. read more

Tonight my husband and I ordered lasagna, eggplant rollatini (appetizer portion) and the seafood misto to go. The entrees come with a salad and garlic bread. All three items were very good especially the seafood misto with spicy marinara. The seafood dish had quite a lot of seafood and the portions for all the dishes were quite large. Definitely try the eggplant rollatini! I've never had this type of dish prepared this way and was pleasantly surprised.I'd also like to point out to the management that we were disappointed that we were overcharged for our order and still believe we didn't get the correct credit after I went back in to dispute the charge. I never saw an itemized receipt so I'm not sure why the total amount was higher then what is listed for the items on the website. Since we were traveling with a puppy we didn't have time to go back and get it solved correctly. All in all I think it was just a mistake and if we lived here we would return and I recommend you trying this place out if your traveling in the area. I would also probably rate this restaurant higher if we had a better experience! read more

OMG...this place is a must! Everything is so good. Garlic bread,eggplant ,pasta,salad....all we tried was exceptional. People are very friendly. bYOB though,so if you wish to partake ,bring it with you. Can't say enough good about it,we will definitely be back! read more

Very clean and good service. Would come back. Large portions. The chicken parm was very good

Great pizza and dinners. Have used them for catering as well and the reviews were great! The ravioli are always fantastic and the calzones are perfect every time. Pizza can be hit or miss if you like it done a specific way but that really depends on the night and how busy they are. Still always wonderful. The cheese fries are also fantastic. Had the baked ziti and chicken parm catered for a party and it was all gone. My guests loved it. Highly recommend this place. Especially good for a nice Italian dinner without the work. read more

They have amazing bolis. My family loves their bacon chicken ranch boli. Always friendly, fast service, amazing food, and they also have a sit down area. read more

We were in the area for a soccer tournament. The owner was so accommodating in working with us to organize a team dinner on a Saturday night. We had 50+ people and he had us sitting in a separate area with plenty of attention from the friendly wait staff. The food was really good and very plentiful. We also loved that it is BYOB! We will definitely go there again the next time we are in town...the owner and staff gave us a wonderful experience! read more

Our new favorite restaurant in Carlisle! With a family with varied age ranges, finding someplace that will suit everyone is never easy! This restaurant has it all - "dressed up" dinners for adults and kid friendly meals for the kids. My husband had the eggplant ptarmigan which was amazing! I had a chicken dish that had mushrooms and artichokes and capers and it was to die for! The kids had pizza and chicken fingers.... ALL of it was amazing! The portions are HUGE (you have been warned) and we ended up taking home dinner for tomorrow night as well! We also took home a piece of their homemade cheesecake..... Well worth the splurge! Overall ---- a GREAT, family friendly restaurant! To top it all off, the staff was amazingly accomadating and SO friendly! I HIGHLY recommend this restaurant! read more

The eggplant Parmesan is amazing! The pizza is delicious! You can not go wrong here! We have tries all different kinds of their dishes over the years and have never had a bad meal! The owner is friendly and helpful, as is all of the staff! This restaurant is a sure thing! read more

Ordered two large cheese pizzas and the cheese slid right off the soggy crust . Grease laid on the pizza needed a paper towel to soak up. Think twice before you order a pizza at this place needless to say the only place for this pizza was in the trash can . Not happy! read more

Traditional Italian food. Great place for a quick and tasty lunch. Mussels in white wine sauce is my favorite dinner appetizer. BYOB option makes it easy on the wallet! read more

The place was crowded and we ordered a pizza to go. The pizza was hot, burnt, and way too salty. Very disappointed and now my husband has no interest to return. :( read more

BEST pizza around without question. The chicken bacon ranch sub is to. die. for. Service is amazing and they are SO friendly. Great family atmosphere! read more

I ordered the Lasagna, but when it came out it wasn't anything that resembled Lasagna. It was a bowl of cheese with some meat, tomato sauce but not one piece of pasta in it. A normal plate of lasagna would have layers of pasta, cheese and meat but this was just not good. After about 10 bits of nothing but cheese I quit eating to for fear I would clog my arteries. If that is Italian food then I must be missing something. Never again. read more

This is a great sit down family Italian restaurant! The food is fantastic!!! Huge servings, we always leave with enough for a meal the next day. Some of our favorites are Chicken Alfredo, Veal Marsala, and many seafood dishes. Staff is very friendly! This is our favorite family hangout and a must when extended family comes to visit. On days when we don't want to eat in or we have friends over, we order take out, usually pizza and cheese steaks which are equally as awesome! Prices are affordable for our family of five and they have a great Sunday pizza special plus their cannolis are probably the best we have ever had! We even had our son's confirmation party there. Can't say enough good things about this place. read more

I don't know what everyone else sees in this place. I went in with my Grand daughter today. I ordered a personal pepperoni pizza for her.( There was no pre-baked for a slice). I ordered a slice of white pre-baked for myself. Then I ordered a cheese steak and a salad to go. So let me say there was no greeting. It was a young kid and he asked me, Do you know what you want? So I ordered. When they called out my order, I went to the counter to pick it up. It was on a hot pie plate with nothing under it to carry it to the table. My slice was not even hot! I don't think they even attempted to heat it up.The pepperoni pizza crust was limp and it was greasy, My grand daughter commented on it.. There were no plates to put a slice on, not even paper! No utensils at all. So we muddled through our meal using LOTS of napkins. So I went up to ask for a box for the left over pizza and tell him we were ready to leave. He handed me a box and grabbed my take out from the counter behind him. When I got home I was wondering why the bag was all wet. He had the sandwich and the salad under the heat lamp. The salad was all wet and wilted, the cheese on top of it was melted. I couldn't believe it! There is no way I will ever go there again! Horrible service, dirty place, totally unacceptable! To many places to eat Italian food than to put up with that crap. read more