GREAT people, prices, and food. We found Mandy's at the Fort Edward Farmer's market a few years back and fell in love. Of course, it was the finger rolls and pies! We're local hardworking people with "glamping" campsites sites on our land in Argyle. We laid low the past CoVid season. Now that we are out again, our fam of four returned to their store on Burgoyne. We have tried everything but the pizza so far, and this place is a family-pleaser. From awesome, GENEROUS SUBS made with fresh ingredients (hubby had a 6" turkey bacon that I wanted to wrestle him for!) to your basic hot dog, you can't go wrong here. Even their beverage selection was impressive. They have a few small tables inside and a few picnic tables outside, and all of the facility was nice and clean. We were served by a grown woman and younger lady, and although the first lady was all-business, she still had a sweet and fun demeanor. She had no problem letting my 11 yr old boy try the meat sauce to see if he liked it first (he did, most people would, it's like ketchup and ground beef). The hot dogs are served on perfectly toasted HOUSE MADE ROLLS. The younger employee ran outside while we were ordering and made sure the picnic area was ready without any prompting from anyone. (Thank you!) When we were done with our lunch, we all took advantage of the wonderful house-made PIES! My kids each got a mini, which is more than enough for anyone, and hubby spoiled us and got a very beautiful chocolate cream pie. EVERYTHING was great. It is so hard to get a satisfying experience anywhere anymore, but THIS PLACE shows it's possible. Mandy's is top-notch, with food made by people who care about the quality of the food and their customers. THANKS FOR CARING, Mandy's! My family of four will be back again and again. Also, I see they have BREAKFAST SAMMIES, and I BET they are terrific. I am also looking forward to trying out their salads. As a fantastic cook myself, it's hard to find anywhere I deem 'worthy." If you want sandwiches, hot dogs, and bread and pies, you can't beat Mandy's. Thank you so much for caring about the people who enjoy and spend their money at your business! We will be back. read more

Cold Meatball sub cheese not even melted pizza looked good but no ready slices ready for l

Every single time I go to Mandy's outstanding service family owned business for over 50 years. They bake and make all their own buns, cakes, pies, finger rolls. It's a staple in our community love the family love the atmosphere and the food. read more

Mandy's has been a family run business for as long as I can remember good quality food made quickly. Have expanded to do desserts and pastries as well. read more

Used to be the place to be haven't been in a long time it's changed most times they won't answer the phone to bad I used to love the pizza there for 40 years read more

Nice surprise from the spouse as I worked late Saturday - a usual delight turned sour quickly. As a pizza lover - I'm one who accepts a mediocre pie from time to time but this bland nightmare with an off tasting sauce and clearly canned s'rooms with a funky chemical taste had me trashing it and going for a PB&J. Kind of gotten used to Mandy's being catch as can - the quality of the product being driven by whoever's in the kitchen, but this was scary-bad. read more

A must-have. The best "works" hot dogs on this planet, no exaggeration. The finger rolls are amazing as well and perfect for picnics/BBQs. We stop here every time we pass by, and often come to buy the hotdogs and rolls in large numbers for parties (call ahead for big orders, they're great at having them ready on time). This will forever be my main go-to when I'm in the area. read more

If you're ever traveling far upstate and need to visit a legit pizzeria, Mandys is THE ONLY pizza and sub spot you should go to. This 5 star rating is taking a lot into account. The location is easy to get to. Prices are out of this world affordable. Food is made wildly fresh. Service is amazing behind the counter. There is extremely limited pizza options up here (besides cardboard Pizza Hut and Dominoes) so they deserve all the credit. My friends and I visit Fort Edward every year for the hot air balloon festival. Last year we decided to stop and get some pizza and sammies before heading back to NYC. It was the best decision we've made when it comes to food up here. We stopped here again this yr and it looks like Mandys is trending up. They've got (named) breakfast sandwiches available now. They (maybe always) have partnered with a bakery and get all their rolls n baked goods fresh from there, which was relieving to know. We ordered classic breakfast sandwiches (the Kylie) bacon egg n cheese & ordered a maple turkey bacon m cheese sub with Lett, toma, mayo. We all loved our food and will be back next year. Keep crushin it Mandys. read more

See all

Mixed review as the finger rolls were spectacular. Just as great as when I was a kid and went to another bakery for them. The pizza was subpar. I watched them make the crust so I know it was fresh but it tasted premade. The sauce and cheese were good. Nothing I'd go out of my way for. read more

Grown up on Mandy's Pizza and Subs, Home made Sub rolls and Hot Dogs rules are awesome.

We were on a long trip and wanted to get a nice lunch and use the bathroom. They have it marked out of order to keep non-locals from using the place. It was not welcoming to strangers read more

You can't go wrong with anything at Mandy's!! The Pizza, Hotdogs with its special sauce, Subs, and Finger Rolls ate the BEST around!! Mandy's bakes its own bread for its Subs & Hotdogs. They even make their own finger rolls from scratch. I now live in California & when I do come back to NY to visit this is always my 1st stop! read more

Their subs and finger rolls are the bomb. Every time I get a sub the rolls are so soft I never go anywhere else for a sub but Mandy's. And if I want something to go with my spaghetti at night or my goulash or anything Italian I go to Mandy's for their finger rolls they are the best. I've never had anything else of theirs but everybody talks about their hot dogs and their Pizza about how good they are one of these days I'm going to try them. You guys do an awesome job thank you. read more

Just bought a sub. So sad 1 tomatoe sliced in half. Very little lettuce onion 1 slice of meat on the second half of the sub. The bread is cheap. 8.50 for garbage read more

Their food is the best ! Recently flew back to upstate New York for my sisters funeral services. We even had Mandys cater the food for her celebration of life we held at the Barn. Whenever I am back in upstate I always have to stop by Mandys. One time I even ordered 4 dozen finger rolls and took them with me to Albany airport and passed them out on the airplane going back to California. No problems on the plane,everyone was extremely happy with Mandys finger rolls read more

Mandy's, a staple in Hudson Falls since I can remember. Love love love their finger rolls, they are a must have any gathering. Not to mention their subs. They always have plenty of rolls just stop in and get yours! read more

Sadly it's labeled as pizza and subs not "Mandy's Finger Rolls" we went here because the notoriety of their finger rolls and were definitely disappointed. We ordered a mushroom pizza and there was basically no sauce. Add to that the mushrooms were straight from a can (shockingly not terrible) however were covering the entire pizza. Finally, this is the first crust I could NOT eat due to tasting exactly like pizza hut pizza crust. Will not be returning. read more

Mandy's Pizza & Subs - We ordered a regular mushroom pizza. Looks like extra mushroom no sauce. Awful. - Pizza Near Me - Hudson Falls, New York

Pizza was flavorless and worse than forgettable. Just not good pizza. Had to get it home and do my best to doctor it with spices and red pepper flakes. Won't buy it again. Most lackluster pizza I've had in a long time. read more

Great pizza, hot dogs, and subs. Their secret to success is there homemade bread and rolls. Note: They now take credit/debit cards. They also finally deliver. Both major pluses in my book. read more

Grew up on their finger rolls, subs and pizza Local treasure

My previous review covered pizza and subs only. I had a few hot dogs here a couple of weeks ago and they were excellent. Different from the typical hot dog with meat sauce. Large, toasted rolls. Unique sauce. Based on the hot dogs, and continued good service, my overall rating goes up to four stars. read more

These are the best finger rolls I have ever had!! And the subs are really good too. People have been telling me to try this place for a few years but, I actually drove past by mistake and discovered where they were located. I will definitely be back for lunch and my business partner and I will also be using these finger rolls for catering at our restaurant. Yum. read more

Mandy's Pizza & Subs - Best finger rolls in the whole area - Pizza Near Me - Hudson Falls, New York

I just found out about this place and it is a real hidden gem! The rolls are amazing, Service is fast and friendly, and overall the food is great and inexpensive. read more

My fiancee and I just moved to the area and figured we would try some of the pizza and boneless chicken wings... We wish we hadn't! One of the boneless wings was hard as a rock and couldn't even be eaten! As for the pizza..,It was burnt around the edge of the crust and didn't taste like anything at all. The pizza muffins I make at home taste better! It's nice to know that some restaurants don't have quality high up on their agenda... Do yourself a favor and pass on this place. You'll be glad you did! read more

All their bread is homemade. Sub rolls, hot dog buns, finger rolls, etc. Good subs and awesome hot dogs, possibly the best ever! I heard they now deliver. Now all they need to do is start excepting plastic. Currently they're cash only. read more

Best sub and pizza we have had, very clean, fast service, would be going back, their prices are great, this place knows how to please someone, love the homemade bread, tried other places wasn't fond of it, this place it the best in town read more

I am 60 yes. Old and Mandy's still makes my meatball hot-subs ,so delicious they have been making me Hungary as long I I can remember. Thanks Gary.M. read more

I love there rolls. I order them every Thanksgiving. These sandwiches are the best around. You won't go wrong stopping in and picking up some good food. There pizza is to die for?? read more

The best buttery and warm rolls anywhere! Super tasty. We definitely enjoy getting hot dogs from Mandy's!

Amazing food,there famous for there hotdogs i grew up here and have ate mandys for a long time now we have mandys every thursday

Top quality food, kinda pricey but noone else makes breads like they do. Pizza compares to The Harvest. personaly i m not a sub guy so i dont care for the sub.,hot dogs are awesome the rolls to die for.And order finger rolls ahead at the holidays or you won't get any. read more

Mandy's is the best place to get hot dogs and pizza. Homemade rolls for the dogs mmm. Finger rolls are great to

This place is absolute top notch. Their pizza is legendary but second only to quite possibly the best hotdogs in the lower 48. Homemade everything and tasty. You won't be dissapointed read more

I'm new to Mandy's but I'm going to be a regular customer from now on. I've had their pizza, sausage and pepper subs and pepperoni bread. It doesn't get any better. The pepperoni bread is perfection - Not too heavy, not too greasy, not too spicy. Wish I'd started going there sooner - prices very reasonable, staff super friendly. Home made large and finger pies that I'm going to have to try for Christmas!! read more

It's been a while since we have been to Mandy's and we will be going there a lot more. I ordered a turkey sub and a sausage pizza for take out. It smelled so good driving home I almost couldn't wait, but I did and it was worth it. Outstanding pizza, covered with sausage and the most delicious crust. I'm writing this and I haven't even eaten the sub yet. That will probably have to be tomorrow's lunch. I ate too much pizza and I'm stuffed! Great stuff!! read more

Was at Mandy's today....love everything there already then I had a finger roll with white chocolate in it.....seriously??? It was so good I might have ate four more today!!!!!!! (I did). For sure my favorite pizza subs roll place ever!!!! read more

In my opinion, the pizza is over rated and the subs are under meated. Everything else there is amazing! Finger Rolls and Salads are killer and the homeade pickled sausages are beautiful. The hot dogs are very good, but make sure you get lots of toppings, otherwise the fresh baked rolls overshadow the dog itself. Definitely deserves it's long standing, quality reputation. read more

Thank you everyone for your wonderful comments! Those that know my husband, Gary, knows that he takes pride in his baking skills with the products that he makes everyday! It's customers like you that help keep us in business! Thank you for all of your support! read more