Grinders are awesome and the lunch time special price is very inexpensive. The staff is always very friendly

I love Mancinos in Columbus. Food is good, prices are great. Employees are nice. But if I could change one thing, in my opinion, the music is a little too loud. Its sometimes hard to hear my friends talking. But overall one of my favorites! read more

Got a large cheese pizza and breadsticks. I did enjoy the breadsticks as they weren't just bread like a lot of other pizza places. They actually had seasonings and things on them. The pizza was pretty good as well. Not the greatest ever, but definitely not the worst. The service was okay. Just average service. The restaurant itself was also okay. Just your average place. I'll definitely go again and try more at some point. read more

Mancino's Pizza & Grinders - Large cheese pizza from Mancino's in Columbus, Indiana. - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Indiana

small business, best sandwich in town, wonderful family environment, impeccable customer service. dope claw machine for big kids

let me start off with the experience was absolutely terrible,they were Very racist's towards me. I was told I couldn't even get food because I was black and wasn't even able to get a drink or any kind of service.wouldn't recommend this place at all if you are African American read more

I think one of the best places in town the food is great staff could be a little more friendly I've always eaten it at home so really don't know about the inside dinning read more

Tried two of the grinders. The Italian grinder was very good but the meatball grinder was horrible. Despite the name it doesn't actually have meatBALLs but instead has super dried out shaved slices of meatballs. Cooking it this was just leads to nasty, flavorless dry meat and a terrible sandwich. Loaded fries were even worse as I'm pretty sure they just out frozen fries in a pan, covered them with cheese and bacon pieces, and baked them. But not enough to actually cook them... just enough to thaw them. read more

Horrible sandwiches, just got to Penn Station across the street! I went here for the first time recently and instantly regretted the meal after 2 bites of my grinder. The deli meat in my sandwich seemed waxy and almost like you'd expect from the oscar meyer boxes. For the money you are way better off going to Penn Station or swinging by a Jimmy Johns! read more

Mancino's Pizza & Grinders - Roast Beef Trio Grinder - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Indiana

awful place, tried to eat here on my birthday. Given the complete wrong order and the very rude assistant manager Betty told me the only way to make things right was drive 45 minutes back to the store and explain. do not recommend read more

Only pizza place will order from now. Never have we not gotten fresh hot food. The delivery driver is very polite. They've never gotten our order wrong nor have the ever forgotten anything. I have absolutely fell for their bredsticks. If you've never been you MUST GO! GREAT GREAT people and food for the price. read more

See all

I've been eating at Mancino's for over 25 years and I still think they have THE best grinders in central Indiana!

Meatball sub bread tasted doughy and undercooked. It didn't feel like it was going to stay together. I got the loaded fries, which were missing their bacon, and unseasoned; they also tasted as though they had been cooked by being placed into the oven, frozen, with the cheese on them. Also, the baked onion rings were nothing but doughy batter, which, again, was flavorless. Overall, an incredibly disappointing experience, one I will be unlikely to repeat. read more

Now this place is home in my family, when we want a sandwich night we usually go here buy a whole lot of Italian grinders, the ham and cheese grinders and that will be our whole meal for night.. (we fight over the Italian grinders) great place!! read more

Food took forever and one family that came in way after us got there's way before us.

This pace is amazingly good! It takes a little bit to get your orders, yet the wait is well worth it. From Grinder (sandwiches) to Pizza these guys rock. I had a 1/2 grinder, Onion Rings and a coke - there number one lunch deal, and could barely get through it. The BBQ chicken grinder was excellent. A place to definitely check out!! read more

Amazing Sandwiches!! Great Friendly Customer Services. Very Clean bathrooms and clean dining areas.

Went there and ordered a taco pizza, and it was terrible and very greasy had so much hot sause you couldn't even taste the cheese or the meat. You can be rest assured we won't be back. ZERO STARS read more

Food is good place is a little dirty staff looks depressed and unwelcoming food is a 10 out of 10

Stopped in for a quick to go lunch and waited.... waited..... and waited some more. The cashier process was quick - 1 person ahead of me, then boom, got to order. 2 minutes, perfect. Cashier said "about 10 minutes for your food" - boom, fine with me. I'll be eating quickly. Cashier called the name of the lady who ordered ahead of me and it was right on the "10 minute" window. Cool, I'm next...... Then the wait. and more wait. Heard the name of the person after me and thought, ok, I should be next. Nope. Heard another name. Nope, not me. Ok, at 23 minutes, walked up and said do you have my Steak Grinder? Staff looks on the pickup rack and there it is - been sitting there for awhile. As for the food quality. Hhhmm. Hard to tell since it wasnt super fresh. Its a unique way to serve a grinder/hero/sub/sandwich with the bread sliced all the way though. The steak grinder could have used some more sauce or something as it was pretty dry. The veggies were minimal - mine didnt even come with the green peppers that were stated on the menu. The mushrooms were from a can - you can just tell the processed 'shrooms from fresh ones and they werent that good. How hard would it be to convert to fresh? The establishment - your typical 1970's pizza parlor with tables and chairs, some high / bar style, some low style. Nothing too impressive but more light and bright than many pizza joints in town. Would I go back? If I was to order and watch my food like a hawk, most likely. Would I order the Steak Grinder again? Nope. P.S. "Has TV" - sure, there is a small flat screen (32" maybe?) in the far upper corner of the seating area. On a bright sunny day, dont expect to see much from across the bar! read more

I'm new to Columbus and remembered Mancinos in Anderson and it's been a long time. So glad I did! It's hard to beat a sandwich from Mancinos. I had the Italian Grinder and it was spectacular. Also had an order of wings and they were equally spectacular! I ordered online and the order was complete and was ready at the time the website told me it would be ready and the staff was friendly and efficient when I picked the order up. I may have found a new tradition for Monday nights. Football & Mancino's.! read more

We always make a point to stop at Mancino's when we come home to visit family. Love the classic Italian pizzas, grinders, breadsticks, calzones, & appetizers. Our family loves this place! read more

Mancino's is the best! I am from out of town and tried their grinders with my then-boyfriend. Every time my now-husband and I come back to town we have to stop at mancino's. 100% recommend. read more

Excellent pizza!! We ordered Mancino's pride and the veggie (add pepperoni!!) and they were delicious. Also ordered two side salads to share. read more

See all

Decent food at decent prices. They make a great pizza, but I go for grinders, calzones & salads. They're best avoided when they can be expected to be busy, but you could say that about most places. One thing I really like about Mancino's - they do have a table outside. read more

Great pizza. Awesome staff. Definitely worth the wait for your food. My favorite from here has to be the taco grinder.... so good.

This place is pretty delicious. There wasn't anything I tried that had disappointed me. I always go here for a good sub rather than Jimmy Johns, Subway, or Penn Station, but that's just my preference. Customer service is always nice and it's also convenient that I can order online through Yelp. My favorites would be the Italian grinder and the calzones. And if you sign up for their text alerts, you get a free order of garlic cheesy bread. Overall, good food for a good price. read more

I have very little if any negative comments about this restaurant! The pizza is excellent, it has a very unique flavor and the crust is the perfect balance between crispy and soft--the outside is crunchy but the inside is perfect! The garlic cheese bread is a cheesy, greasy basket of perfection. If I could eat just that all day I would. I've had almost everything on the menu and I have very few things I don't like. Top 3 items I'd have to say are 1) the garlic cheese bread 2) any type of pizza--but the BBQ chicken is a must have. and 3) pizza grinder--the menu one is pepperoni but you can make it any type you'd like. I like to make mine Hawaiian! As a heads up, Friday nights are CRAZY, so be prepared for that if you go then. Also: Yes, It is typically staffed with younger people, highschool and college aged people but, don't let that deter you! Young people can work just as hard if you let them! Overall, this family owned pizza place is worth the search (it's tucked away and easily passed by!) and the wait. In fact, I think I'll go this weekend! read more

Wish I could five negative stars. Staff was very disrespectful and just rude. Missing. Half of order called and nothing but thats not our fault. Didn't call for excuses but results. And again staff and management very disrespectful and incompetent. Will never go back. read more

We love this place! Great grinders, and pretty good pizzas. I like the salads too, but rarely get them. They daily lunch specials wrote in their chalk board inside restaurant. They also have a "text club". Where on your first text u get free garlic cheesy bread. then after that about every two-three weeks they send you additional deals. They also have kids meals, and they are reasonably priced. I usually get the mancinos club. But there are enough options to make everyone in your party happy! read more

See all

Grinders had very little meat. One was literally cold to the touch, cheese was only partially melted. Took back to counter, they "ran it through the oven" second time. STILL COLD when I got it. Took it back and got refund. What is so hard to get a sandwich hot? Lost a customer! read more

I always seem to forget about Mancino's since it is tucked away in the middle of a strip mall, but every time I have it, I'm reminded of how great it is! The cheese bread is so crusty and delicious on their homemade (I believe) bread. The sandwiches/grinders are also on that bread, and are so fresh and filling that I always have leftovers. However, my favorite from there are the calzones. I'm able to get my own personal serving of pizza-like goodness with whatever I want in it and the cheese and bread/crust really make it stand apart from other pizza joints. The freshness here is top notch! read more

Their subs and pizza'a are quite good, just picked up a medium pizza today near their closing time and they gave me a semi cooked one, soggy base. Toppings are microscopic, have to cook in oven at home before eating :( Very disappointed. read more

Their grinders are some of the best around! I'm obsessed with their chicken bacon ranch grinder; it is so tasty!! Delicious!

Horrible customer service Got my carry out order wrong, had to drive clear across Town to pick up the right sandwich, while everyone else's dinner was ruined. Didn't even offer a discount. Shameful. read more

This place is a must eat! The sandwiches here are always delicious and the service is always amazing. There is a reason I still come back here over places like Jimmy John's and Penn station. It's hard to find another sandwich and pizza place that is this good! read more

I'm a regular here for lunch - pizza and grinders. Grinders are toasted subs with a variety of meats and veggies - they have a ton of choices surely something for everyone - and you can customize as needed. I like the chicken grinder - the bread is great and I like the melty cheese. They offer a personal sized pizza for lunch and I usually get sausage. Sometimes we go with the lunch pizza special which includes a large three topping pizza and garlic cheese bread. Split this with 3-4 people for a good lunch. I usually get sausage, pepperoni, and black olives. The garlic cheese bread is wonderful. Only complaint is they use canned mushrooms and I prefer fresh. There's always service with a smile and a pretty stable workforce, which I figure is a sign of a well run place. read more

Mancino's is a small chain (or group of franchises), which to my knowledge, is found in the midwest. There was one in Findlay, OH where I went to college and there's also one in Carmel, IN. I love the pizza. When working nearby, I was excited that I'd be able to go pick one up on my lunch hour. I asked for my pizza to be ready at 12:10 and when I arrived (at exactly 12:10), it was piping hot and ready for me. Crust is hand-tossed, sauce is nicely flavored with herbs, and the cheese is super melty. I ordered an 8" personal pan with ham, then bought 2 of their monster soft & gooey chocolate chip cookies, and my total (including tax) was $6.15. What a bargain! I REALLY enjoyed that pizza. Nothing can come close to a hand-tossed pie in my opinion. They WILL deliver to businesses in the immediate area but not homes. Hear that Cummins? They'll deliver to you! When I went in at noon on a Saturday to pick up my pizza the place was pretty full, but the tables were still being cleaned quickly. You order at the counter and then they'll bring your pizza out to you. Not all that easy to see from the street, this business is in the same strip mall as Best Buy and PetCo. I've had the calzones and grinders at the Findlay location...I'll bet they're just as awesome in Columbus. read more

When I'm in the mood for a huge hot sandwich, or a great pizza, this is the place I go. The grinders here are a-maz-ing, and the their selection of grinders (see website) is as big as the grinders themselves. The pizza is amoung the best in Columbus...fresh hand-tossed dough, lots of cheese, quality ingredients. French fries and onion rings are decent, but are clearly bought frozen/premade, so they don't feel/taste quite as good as the rest of the food. Very busy during lunch hours, but even so the wait for your food is never very long. Staff is always friendly, and the dining area is always clean. Highly recommended! read more

Mancino's Pizza & Grinders - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Indiana

Mancinos was awesome as always! Thank you for the wonderful service and food!!!! Your team is always spot on for our family!

My dad used to bring home a Mancinos grinder regularly for dinner when I was younger. It was always a special treat for us kids. After my recent visit I understand why he made it a habit... affordable and delicious! I enjoyed an Italian grinder, 9". I love that the bread is made in-house, it's so good! The service was friendly but didn't "wow" me, that's why I only rated 4 stars. Could be a potential 5 star though! read more