The buffet used to be amazing but that was before the original "new owners" took over. It's terrible now. NOT worth $10. There was hardly any pizza offered and what was there was old. They did not bring out any new even though we requested a simple pepperoni. The staff is so unfriendly. I miss the days of Brody. He was an amazing manager. read more

Went for the buffet which was great when Brody managed it a few years ago. He knew us by name, what we liked and made it without asking. Once he was let go and the 2 ladies took over its pathetic. Stopped in today to give them another try and it was awful. Barely anything on the buffet, guy running things was unfriendly. Requested a pepperoni pizza, never got it. Would have had a better meal at Subway for the $20 dollars. read more

My family really enjoys this place. They have a lot to offer besides pizza. They also have a buffet for lunch, that is very good. It is a good place to catch up with friends. The staff are very friendly and courteous. There isn't a lot of seating, but the pizza makes up for it! read more

You ever been at Subway and lost your appetite after seeing the shiny ham or watery vegetables and thought man I should've gotten pizza but then it's too late? Well not anymore! Just walk a good 15 feet past the register at Subway and you'll find a pizza buffet called Mama Nita's situated oddly in the back of the restaurant. Food: The pizza is actually pretty good, a lot better than you'd think for being in the back of a Subway. Except sometimes they run out if they get a big crowd and you can get stuck waiting for a while. -2 points. Service: The staff is incredibly nice, they are good people. +1 point. Ambience: As mentioned, it's in the back of a Subway, which is convenient when you give up on the Subway Jared diet and need to smash some pizza. read more

Easily my favorite pizza place in/around the Indianapolis area. The pizza itself is excellent, even when you're eating it cold the next day. The breadsticks have a nice garlic butter and parmesan flavor to them and are always really soft. Everything on the menu is reasonably-priced, especially when you take the good quality of the food into consideration. On top of that, the staff has always been nice in each of our previous experiences. I've honestly got nothing bad to say about them. I'd love it if they opened more locations around Indy, but if they don't, I'll happily continue going out of my way to get them. They're worth the trip. read more

Mama Nita's - Pepperoni pizza, cheese pizza, and breadsticks. We get our pizzas with light cheese. Some of its already eaten, of course. - Pizza Near Me - New Palestine, Indiana

Mana Nita's is a great place to eat pizza and salad with family. The place used to be better before the new owners but that's not saying much. I go this place once a week and have a good meal every time. The service is nice. It is connected to a subway though and I've learned the hard way to not use subways coke machines lol. The ambiance is nice with two tvs one normally with news and one with kid shows. read more

Got here right at 8:05pm and to my surprise, the cut off for the buffet is 8pm. We asked the person at the counter if it was possible to still get the buffet with what was left (there were still a few mostly full pizzas left!) and the cashier let us participate in the buffet - even at a discounted price! Although the quality was slightly lacking because the pizza was about to be tossed for the night, the flavor was still there! Such a great experience and I greatly appreciate the cashiers willingness to offer us the buffet after hours. I will certainly be returning! Sooo much food at a wonderful price! read more

Mama Nita's - Buffet - Pizza Near Me - New Palestine, Indiana

See all

I had a Groupon for $25.00 it only was good for a few weeks and didn't want to loose it so we drove to New Palestine. I read some reviews one said it was next to Subway. Well actually they are both in the same building. Mama Nita's has 7 booth that seat 4 so not much seating. There was a menu board that said all you can eat buffet $5.99 from 11:00 to 4:00. After 4:00 7:49. Kids 2 and under free Kids 10 and under $3.99. Seniors $6.49. Drinks $1.69 So I asked if they sold whole pizza he said yes and showed us a menu. Ok there was a lot of stuff on it. A lot of pizza-sandwiches-wings and other stuff. We ordered the buffet and a 12 inch Mediterranean pizza to go. On the buffet a small salad bar with about 12 different toppings bread sticks with cheese sauce and 6 different pizza. The pizza not bad for a pre-made crust. She to top it off you could pick a ice cream treat from the freezer. Ice cream sandwich-bomb pops or popsicles. If ever in New Palestine we would eat here again. read more

See all

First time here as I usually go to Mama Nita's in Greenfield. They kept the buffet fresh and asked if I had a special request. Not too many people eating Buffet but the carry out orders never stopped! There were as many as 8 people working & I mean working. Like a great oiled machine. Back to the food. No complaints here. Good Pizza Mama Nita. read more

Mama Nita's - Pizza Buffet - Pizza Near Me - New Palestine, Indiana

Pizza we had delivered was good. Service was good. Ambiance is ok when you use the buffet. read more

Great Italian sandwich! Simple atmosphere with some seating, but I got carryout. Will definitely be back.

We've eaten the buffet here several times and it's always been good plus they will put out fresh pizza of your choice if you want. Service is always good read more

The restaurant was filthy and the pizza was dry. It's super expensive for almost nothing. The freshest thing in that restaurant was the crow eating vomit in the parking lot. read more

I love this place so much! Very kind staff & deliciously made food in a timely manner! Though it's a bit pricey, it's worth the slurge.

Today I ordered a half taco salad and a full taco salad for pick-up. I have been ordering salads from them for many years, and they were always large, well put together salad. So, today we decided to order for the first time in a while. What a shock. The full salad was somewhat smaller than when we ordered before, but not significantly. But the "half salad" was a joke. It was probably not even a fourth the size of the full. The full salad was $9.99 and the half was $6.99. This is ridiculous. Rest assured this is the last time Mama Nitas will get any of my business and I would highly recommend thinking twice about ordering from here. read more

I discovered this awesome little pizza shop quite by accident. I was working in New Pal for a couple of days and at lunchtime my coworker started searching for a Subway. (No, not Subway AGAIN please!) Subs happen to be my coworker's favorite food group and she was driving. Sigh. HOWEVER, as she pulled into the Subway parking lot I saw a sign for Mama Nita's pizza buffet. Next door to Subway! I suggested (ok, demanded) that we check out this buffet. What a cool place! Several varieties of fresh, hot pizza, tasty breadsticks, soup and a fresh salad bar with a nice selection of ingredients. And ice cream for dessert, included with the buffet. The employees were very welcoming, friendly and helpful. They asked what kind of pizza I wanted and I told them I was vegetarian. They asked if there were any veggies I didn't like, and when I said I like all vegetables they made me a pizza that was loaded with veggies. Amazing service for a buffet! The ice cream treats were a nice extra. A freezer full of ice cream sandwiches, single-serve ice cream cups in different flavors as well as other treats! It was very convenient to grab an ice cream sandwich on my way out the door because we had to get back to work. I will definitely return to Mama Nita's the next time I happen to be in or near New Pal. read more

The best pizza Buffett around. They will ask for your favorite and add it to the Buffett. Great staff and budget friendly.

I don't want to give a low score but I had an off experience here. I went to the now closed Fishers location a number of times previously and never had an issue. This was my first time at this location. A suggestion: if you are going to load the buffet full of random, non-requested pizza, it would be a good idea to offer a variety of different types that will appeal to a wide customer base. When I went, there were 6 full pizzas on the buffet, all quite similar - mostly different combinations involving pepperoni and sausage. I think there was probably pepperoni and sausage, pepperoni sausage and hot peppers, sausage, pepperoni and bacon, and maybe a Supreme. I asked them if they can make a philly steak pizza, which is what I always had at the Fishers location. They said no, they can't make that for the buffet because it is too expensive. Ok...can you make just anything else besides what is here? Maybe ground beef and cheddar or anything. They said no, actually they can't make anything else because the buffet is totally full. I ended up eating a bunch of bread sticks and leaving. I'd suggest if you are going to fill the buffet, maybe put out a cheese pizza and a veggie pizza or something in addition to pepperoni and sausage this way there is some variety in case someone comes in who does not like pepperoni and sausage. The best part (for me anyway) of a buffet is variety. read more

Very small salad bar. It didn't tempt me. Many pizzas to choose from on the buffet. Some were hot, fresh and delicious, others cool and not so good. Very tasty breadsticks AND they had cheese for them! Ice cream bars for dessert, but no diet pop!! That's bad!! No diet pop? What about diabetics? Included in the buffet also is popsicles or ice cream bars. read more

Mama Nita's - Pizza Near Me - New Palestine, Indiana

I work in the area and decided to try a personal pan pizza ( sausage, pepperoni and banana peppers ) and it was soooo good and fresh . It was so good I came back today and tried the BBQ Chicken Pizza and i'm hooked . I rate this place 8/1O for sure ( would have been a 1O/1O but i don't like the sitting area or buffet setup ) , but i guess to go is always an option . read more

As we were eating our meal, a barefoot teenage boy came in Mama Nita's and spoke to the employee who was cleaning the buffet. Then the barefoot teen walked behind the counter and into the kitchen to chat with the employee. When he walked out, he stood in front of the buffet area and lifted his foot up to show the employee that he was barefoot. The employee just laughed along with the teen and he continued to walk around both in the pizza parlor and the Subway that is in the same store. The employees from both Mama Nita's and Subway seemed humored by it and no one asked him to leave or put shoes on. His feet were black with dirt on the bottom and we were so grossed out that we bagged up the rest of our meal and left. I think these two restaurants need some adult supervision. We won't be back. read more

Came for the lunch buffet, wasn't impressed with the pizza or the place itself. Everything was dirty, even the napkin holder was filthy. Pizza was very doughy with not much toppings. read more

Mama Nita's - Napkin holder is nasty - Pizza Near Me - New Palestine, Indiana

We ate their family of three on a Tuesday night. They had four pizzas that were hard and old plus pasta was just spaghetti that look like it had been sitting there all day staff was extremely friendly but food was lacking!! Would not eat there again in new Palestine read more

Yum! Always very pleased with the quality of pies at this establishment. My favorite pizza to order is the Veggie Special topped with fresh vegetables, but the sauce... delicious. Delivery was quick and the pizza was HOT. Friendly staff, will order again soon. read more

Best pizza spot in New Pal, and thats saying something since we have about 10 within a 3 mile radius. They have a solid variety on their menu with pastas, subs, and salads too. their baked ziti (pictured) is 10/10! great spot read more

Mama Nita's - Pizza Near Me - New Palestine, Indiana

First of all, the name is deceibing. More than pizza implies that there is more than pizza. There is not. The "buffet" is not my idea of a buffet. Salad and pizza do not make a buffet. The pizza was barely warm. It was dry and didn't have enough toppings. This doesn't make sense considering the staff seemed to be making items by hand, which is great. The question then becomes how long had the pizza in the "buffet" been sitting there? We will NOT be going back. read more

This is a nice small pizza shop with a lunch buffet, and it sort of shares some space with Subway. The staff is friendly and will make you a special pizza for the buffet if you ask them. The prices are pretty good, and they also serve subs, salads, and have ice cream. The taste is pretty good, above average, but not the best, but worth eating here. I recommend trying this place as it is good for a small town with limited choices. read more

A great dining option in New Palestine. The pizza buffet is affordable, fresh, and they'll make any type of pizza you request. The menu has several options besides pizza from wings, nachos, pasta, and subs. Once a year they offer 'buy one get one 1/2 off' on subs and that's a steal! Definitely worth stopping in or ordering to go. read more

Mama Nita's - alfredo pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Palestine, Indiana

See all

Greenfield, IN Location ...1st time visit, We come in, I'm to busy talking to be aware that I was actually *in the way* ... I move and make my way to the pizza buffet. I then noticed the employee and customers. The customer behind me had two children seated directly behind me. A mom, and a pair (male-female) seated across from the buffet, That lady was talking to the employee who seemed to be accommodating to whatever her request was. I devour and instantly fall in love with the pizza. It's a busy afternoon and it showed on the buffet and thru the employees. Again, second time, this lady stands at the end of the counter, to be noticed, until the employee noticed. They talked and he went in the back. Mind you it is busy, and I'm thinking the oven had pizzas in it already. BUT - I decide the guy she is with is an ass, because he snarled his nose at who I then thought was the lady alones kid. BUT - the employee talked to this lady again, again, walked in the back. I'm still diggen this pizza!! It's the best and I commented to my friend, if this shop is the husbands, he is winning the war on locations! It's fabulous. The lady comes back a third time to bug the employee, whatever now, she's getting on MY nerves. A few minutes later, her special request pizza is now up and being brought out and the lady that brought it out was AWESOME! She made us all aware, she has his back!! She announced this bitches (my word) Italian Sausage pizza is up and on the buffet. I had to think like this ... after three times buggin' ... I REALLY hope something, that won't get anyone in trouble at all 'special' happened to that lady's pizza. The three employees were already busy, great classy job of letting her know her special pizza was up. Great job employees and that pizza was fire and the whole buffet ~ on point ~ !! I'll definitely be back in as soon as I get myself moved in Greenfield! read more

Poor supervision-way too many employees working and no one knew what to do. Serval people in line as employees playing around. They clearly need someone to lead them. read more

It was a pretty good price for an all you can eat buffet with pizza, salad, and breadsticks. Wasn't very clean and the napkin dispenser had pizza sauce on it. The pizza wasn't bad, but wasn't that great. I would say I was a little disappointed. I would have to pass if asked to go there again. read more

Mama Nita's has had a few ownership changes since it started. The current team seems to have it right again. Because of Covid-19, we get carry-out. Food is always good, never skimpy. Really enjoy the Chicken Ranchero pizza. It's not your traditional pizza, but still a really good combination. Breadsticks are soft and good-sized. I have heard great things about their salads, so will have to try these, too. read more

The Greenfield location is awful. We have been here for over 30 minutes and have seen two pizzas and one order of breadsticks (totaling only eight breadsticks). Nobody is touching the second pizza, which appears to be bbq bacon. There are no breadsticks left; one pizza; and several people who have not had one bite of pizza or a breadstick from this PIZZA BUFFET. My family has at least had a few pieces, so we feel bad going up for any more pizza. I understand growing pains, but this is astoundingly bad. Don't open until you're actually ready for business. read more

It okay. Has a small building that is constantly crowded. Pizza is okay. Pizza bar has about 5 different types of pizza. Also the building is connected with subway. read more

Mama Nita's - Pizza Near Me - New Palestine, Indiana

It was my first visit. Had the lunch buffet. Very reasonably priced. My toddler (3) was very much welcomed and the manager went over the top offering any assistance. Will go back. Service was A++. PS: pizza was great. read more

Absolutely love this place. I can't believe my boyfriend has never brought me here before. Apparently, there is a risk of becoming morbidly obese because the food is so good. Everyone who works there is super friendly and greeted us the moment we walked in. They offered to make special pizza for us. All you can eat buffet includes drinks. The salad selection was perfect; much better than Subway next door. Sauces are great. Pizza was delicious. I loved everything. It's not fancy - styrofoam plates and plastic ware which was just fine with me. We left completely stuffed for less than twenty dollars total. read more

BEST PLACE IN NEWPAL HANDS DOWN You need to try this asap very friendly great food you think they have good pizza well their wings and sandwiches are even better 10/10 read more

This is an awesome local, unique pizza place. They have a buffet every day - they will ask you what kind of pizza you would like them to make for you. The buffet has a fresh, but small, salad bar, along with unlimited ice cream treats for dessert. Their pizza is some of my favorite pizza ever. The bread is sweet and soft, and the tomato sauce is also on the mild and sweet side. They have a great Barbeque chicken pizza, as well as a chicken cordon bleu and a cheeseburger pizza, amongst other specialty pizzas. Like Don said in his review, they keep the buffet stocked the entire time, regardless of how busy they are. Only downside is the seating is fairly limited. They have 2 tvs on, one with sports and one with cartoons for the kids. Highly recommended as a place for families. read more

Great little place to get pizza with friends or family. My wife and I love going here and eating the buffet. They fix a lot of different pizzas and basically whatever you ask for. read more

The best pizza buffet in Fishers! Great salad, many choices of breadsticks, cheesey sticks, pizza, desserts.. All at a very inexpensive cost! read more