This review is based solely on their ice cream cake, as I have not been to their store.
A few days ago, we celebrated a co-workers birthday at the office. The office's birthday committee decided to switch things up a bit and instead of getting a traditional cake, they opted for an ice cream cake. I had never had their I cream, much less their cake. In fact, tbh, I hadn't heard of Maggie Moo's before. I am well aware of them now. The cake was delicious. The bottom layer was chocolate; the top layer was vanilla ice cream. The coating was chocolate and to top things off whipped cream and Oreos. I actually liked this ice cream cake more than Baskin Robbins.
Next time somebody asks where to get good ice cream cakes, I'll point them here, or to one of their other three locations. This one is in San Juan, but they have one in Guaynabo, Dorado, and Humacao (all have Yelp pages).
I'm reserving the 5th star for when I visit the physical location and try their ice cream. read more